Organ Donation Bills

As I have previously blogged, I find it offensive that a decision to be an organ donor can be vetoed by your family. The good news is there is a bill by Jackie Blue and Andy Tookey to stop other people over-riding your decisions with your organs. Andy Tookey appeared yesterday at the Health Select Committee with his daughter Katie who is five and may need a liver transplant in the next few years.

Sadly the Government also has a bill which specifically legislates for your wishes to be over-riden by others on “spiritual or cultural grounds”. This is awful because it means your partner’s or family’s spirtual beliefs get to trump your own ones. You may tick to be an organ donor and your partner may belong to a religion that doesn’t support organ donation. So if you die, your religious beliefs are ignored, and your partner’s ones over-ride your own.

Commissioners wanted

It appears the Government is having considerable difficulty in recruiting new Telecommunications and Electricity Commissioners.

It is not surprising that there is a lack of victims volunteers. The Electricity Commissioner was dumped and claimed massive interference by the Government in his job, while the Telecommunications Commissioner got savaged by the PM last year.

If you have independent regulators, you need to let them be independent and not have Ministers as back seat drivers.

Such a modest chap

Such a contrite modest chap, that Taito. From Hansard today:

Hon Bill English: Has Phil Goff ever discussed with the Prime Minister the fact that he visited Phillip Field’s house in Samoa, met people who fitted—

Taito Phillip Field: I raise a point of order, Madam Speaker. Only a few minutes ago it was pointed out to Mr Bill English that my name is Taito Phillip Field.

Madam SPEAKER: That is true.

Taito Phillip Field: He continues to ignore what is required of him in this House.

I actually wonder whether it is required to use a foreign title in the House? Also interesting the arrogance demanding it be used. I doubt Michael Cullen demands he be referred to as Dr Michael Cullen.

Also Field seems to have attended the John Tamihere school of political management, which is to attack your accusers:

Taito Phillip Field: Can I ask the Prime Minister whether she is aware that Mr Keith Williams, at the time he approached me, did not disclose to me that he was illegally employing Mr Sunan Siriwan; that by his own admission, Mr Williams is an unrepentant, unreformed alcoholic and is a witness entirely without credibility; and that he attempted to use his letter of 3 August 2005 as a form of blackmail prior to an election?

CYFSWatch Blog publishes MP death threat

They are literally their own worst enemies. I find it sad that such poor judgement lets down what is actually a worthwhile cause.

The NZ Herald has the story of the threat, and the reaction.

Not only does CYFSWatch solicit Bradford’s residential address, they then try to blackmail her by saying they will not publish the address if she withdraws her bill. That is outraegous and I suspect illegal.

The actual threat is here. I am now linking to it, because I want people to be able to see how repugnant the posts are. Their exact words:

I would like the opportunity to drive my fist straight into her face as hard as I can, hopefully breaking her nose or jaw in the process. As she is lying on the ground, blood and mucous pouring profusely from her nose and mouth, I would then give her a light smack on her substantial arse, and ask her “Now Sue, is the difference a little more clearer to you?”.

This is just repulsive stuff, and goes so far across the line that Google should close the blog down. Criticism is one thing. Publishing explicit accounts of desired violence against an MP, soliciting their home address and then trying to blackmail them to drop a bill or they publish it, is quite another.

Going to be very close

Sue Bradford’s anti-smacking bill has passed the second reading by 70 votes to 51. The breakdown by party was:

Labour 49-0
National 6-42
NZ First 3-4
Greens 6-0
Maori 4-0
United 1-2
ACT 0-2
Prog 1-0
Field 0-1

But it could be very very close when the Borrows amendment is considered. I understand the six National MPs who voted for the bill will vote for the amendment. That changes it to 64-57.

Now it all comes down to the NZ First and United Future MPs who voted in favour. Peter Dunne, Brian Donnelly, Doug Woolerton and Barbara Stewart. If all four of them vote for the Borrows amendment then it is 60-61 or rather the amendment passes 61-60.

Bradford is saying she will withdraw the bill if the amendment is passed, but that’s an expected threat.

Bowling the Government down

If you want to try out the new Wellington inner city bowing complex, and also help bring about a change of government, you can do so this Sunday. Details are:

Venue: The Lanes, 234 – 238 Wakefield Street
Start: 2.30 pm, Sunday 25 February
Cost: $35 a ticket for 2 games (teams competition format) and pizza. Cash bar for drinks.

Tickets from Carl Bates 021 522 837 ([email protected]) or Nick Muir 021 688 674 or [email protected]

Should be a fun afternoon.

Tony Milne on conspiracy teaching

Tony Milne attacks me for criticising Kirsty Gillon for her teaching of whackjob conspiracy theories, on the basis that she has a positive rating on ratemyteacher.com.

Now just think about this logic. It doesn’t matter that she may be teaching falsehoods, promoting anti-semitic lies, suggesting the US Government mass murdered its own citizens on Sept 11, so long as she has a good rating on ratemyteacher.com.

Never mind that her teaching was condemned by the Dean of Education at Auckland University and the New Zealand History Teachers Association. Hey what would they know – she has a good ratemyteacher.com rating. I mean that is scientific and valid and objective isn’t it.

But on the positive side we should look forward to Tony becoming Minister of Education one day. Because Labour have always argued against performance pay for teachers – arguing that there is no objective way to assess teacher performance. Well that is no longer the case, as we will expect Tony to campaign on paying teachers bonuses based on their ratemyteacher.com rating.

McMahon vs The Don

An amusing twist to the normal professional wrestling scripts. They’ve written in a feud between WWE owner Vince McMahon and Donald Trump. Both billionaires will nominate a wrestler to compete, and the loser (who I predict will be McMahon) will have to shave all his hair off. I predict massive ratings.

Fiji Dictator sets 2010 election date

It must be fun being a dictator. You can set election dates at yoru whim without any reference to a constutition or laws.

The Fijian DIctator is refusing to hold elections until 2010, despite an independent group funding they could be held in 12 to 18 months.

NZ should continue with full sanctions until at least after the elections.

Goff to jump out of a plane

Working around kiwiblog technical issues

As people will have noticed, there are a few technical issues with Kiwiblog at the moment. Some of them can be worked around.

1) Front Page not refreshing

The front page is meant to rebuild itself to reflect every new post (and comment). However sometimes new posts are not appearing for some hours as the system gets so busy. Now the posts are actually on the blog, just not appearing on the front page. So if you are desperate to see the latest material, you can look for it by clicking on the permalink of the latest post showing on the front page. Then when that post comes up, look on the right hand side where it shows the previous and next posts. If it shows a next post then you can click on it to access it.

2) Comments Spam

I’ve been waiting several weeks for the hosting provider to install the anti-spam “are you human” test. This will stop 99% of the spam getting through. I’m currently spending well over an hour a day deleting spam. Until this is fixed though the script which shows the ten most recent commented threads is not as useful as possible.

3) Permalinks not working

Due to server performance issues, sometimes a new post doesn’t complete correctly. It appears on the front page, but the permalink page with the comments on it wasn’t established. I need to manually go in and rebuild the page and that depends on me being at my laptop. So if the permalink page isn’t there, just check back in a couple of hours and it should be.

How did that happen

Had an InternetNZ meeting in Auckland last night. Before I went in I haerd NZ were 44/4 so it looked all over, especially considering a target of 346.

Got back to the hotel at 11 pm or so and on MSN everyone is talking about the game. I am puzzled as there is no way one can recover from 44/4 and beat a target of 346. Hell we were looking to struggle to make 100.

But TV3 had highlights and indeed we did make 350 to win the game. Amazing. Some stats from Cricinfo:

* New Zealand’s total of 350 for 9 is the second-highest in a successful run-chase after South Africa’s 438 for 9 in Johannesburg.

* Craig McMillan’s 67-ball century is the fastest by a New Zealander in ODIs

* The 26 sixes blasted in this match – 16 by Australia and 10 by New Zealand – equals the record for most number of sixes in a game.

* The 165-run stand between Craig McMillan and Brendon McCullum is the joint highest for the sixth wicket in one-day internationals.

I am so loving cricket at the moment. Winning helps!

The banning smacking bill second reading

The bill to ban parents smacking their kids will go through second reading this evening fairly comfortably, but the real battle will be at the committee of the whole stage when amendments are considered.

The amendment by Chester Borrows is to redefine limit reasonable force as a defence if “it causes or contributes materially to harm that is more than transitory and trifling”.

The Borrows amendment sets the bar about as low as you can set it, without having any bar at all. I’m amazed so many MPs are set to vote to specifically include parental discipline which is trifling and transitory as a criminal offence. Every MP who votes against the Borrows amendment is voting in favour of criminalising smacking.

The current law is not satisfactory. Bradford’s bill, as it stands, is equally unsatisfactory. The Borrows amendment is a sensible compromise which is a win-win for parents and children.

The stinking proxy

I think Labour have miscalculated by taking Field’s proxy vote, and the stench of his vote will continue to cause them harm.

It’s one thing for Field to decide to still vote for the Government. No-one can stop him doing that, and he was elected on a platform of supporting the Government.

But it is quite another thing for the Labour Whips to be casting his proxy vote for him when he is not there, away from Parliament on full pay. There was around an hour of points or order yesterday on the legality of this. It was of course ruled legal, but was sucessful in drawing publicity to the fact that Labour have accepted his proxy.

John Armstrong writes on how what was godo news is starting to turn bad:

An arrangement extremely convenient in restoring the Government’s majority now has the look of utter expedience.

How can Labour justify accepting the proxy vote of someone whom it has just slung out of its caucus? How can it rely on the vote of someone whose behaviour has been described by the Prime Minister as immoral and unethical?

Indeed.

Anderton praises Berlin Wall supporter

Jim Anderton lauds the late Wolfgang Rosenberg as an unsung hero of New Zealand.

Liberty Scott points out that Rosenberg was a champion of the Stalinist Berlin Wall and and also for good measure the evil North Korean regime.

It seems the Berlin Wall was needed so that well educated intelligent east Germans could stay to rebuild the country and socialism, instead of being selfish and wanting to enjoy a better life.

And North Korea is a wonderful place as they have no traffic congestion it seems.

As Liberty Scott points out the tragedy of Rosenburg’s life is he fled from the evil of the Nazis but ended up supporting regimes almost as repressive and evil.

Teaching conspiracies

The HoS had a story on complaints against a Takapuna Grammar teacher who has been promoting conspiracy theories to her students. The teacher is Kirsty Gillion, wife of former Alliance MP Grant Gillon.

Her teaching included:

* The Apollo Moon landing was an elaborate hoax filmed in Area 51
* Astronaut Neil Armstrong was a fictitious character invented to deceive the masses
* The number of Jews killed in the Holocaust had been exaggerated
* A commercial airliner did not crash into the Pentagon during the September 11 attack
* Alien life forms were living on Earth.

I know which school will be having a drop in enrolments next year. This makes them look nuts.

Hat Tip: Whale Oil

Unsecured Wireless Internet

If you are at a hotel, or similar public place, and your laptop detects an unsecured (no password needed) wireless signal, what do you do or would you do?

(a) Try and work out where it is coming from, and let them know it is unsecured so they can fix it

(b) Don’t use it at all, or notify anyone

(c) Ask the hotel if it is theirs, and if so use it, otherwise don’t use it

(d) Connect to it and use it for your normal browsing and e-mail

(e) Connect to it and start downloading 350 MB television shows so you don’t go over your normal data cap at home

Answers in comments please.

Anyone can be a police officer!

The Government is desperate to not break its promise of 1,000 extra police. Now instead of paying Police more in order to increase recruitment, they have been lowering standards one by one:

First they increased the maximum age for recruits.

Then they reduced the minimum height eligibility.

Then they relaxed the bans on criminals becoming police officers.

Now they have gone one better and even those who fail basic training are being allowed to go on the beat.

Most of those failing, are failing the English language requirements. Rather crucial I would have said.

The most persecuted religious minority

The Herald reports on the most persecuted religious group of 2006. They were:

* referred to as a “weird cult” several times by Helen Clark

* called “the Christian version of the Taleban” by David Parker

* and incited by Labour MP Georgina Beyer to be “dragged out of the country”.

No need to guess who they are.

On the other hand they should lay off the private detectives to put it mildly.

Partially list SOEs

I am 100% in favour of Rob Cameron’s proposal to allow minority non-voting equity into SOEs. The disciplines of being listed on the stock exchange would improve SOE performance significantly I am sure. It would also give the stock exchange a new lease of life.

Of course I would also be 100% in favour of selling most SOEs outright, but I accept there is little political will for that. It’s a pity as I believe ownership by the Government actually interferes with the legitimate regulatory role of the Government.

As an example I doubt the Government would have passed the telecommunications regulation it did, if it actually owned Telecom. It would have tried to deal with it by backdoor suggestions to Directors etc.

One just has to look at electricity as an example. The Government owned Transpower so when Transpower got into a fight with the regulator, the Government sacked the regulator. That wouldn’t have happened if Transpower was privately owned.

I have a dream programme

Great to read in the Herald about the I have a dream programme set up by millionaire entrepreneur Scott Gilmour to give better opportunities to disadvantaged children. They work with and support selected kids right through school and will even pay for their tertiary education if they choose to go on.

I wonder if Maharey sneeringly refers to this as “Tory charity” also.

In the same story, over 80% of people in a Colmar Brunton New News poll disagree with the PM and said there is an underclass problem, and furthermore 60% said it had got worse under Clark and only 9% said it had got better. Also neither National nor Labour were seen to have the right policies to help low-income New Zealanders.

Incidentially I don’t think the issues around the “underclass” are only related to being low income. There are many low income who are doing relatively fine, and there will be some of higher incomes who are in the underclass (God we need a better word than that).

Burtons’s impeccable behaviour

The parents of murdered man Karl Kuchenbecker say they blame the Parole Board for his killing by Graeme Burton.

Burton of course has primary blame, but in this case I think the Parole Board do have some blame.

Of course the Parole Board does not have ESP and can not be 100% accurate in regards to who will or will not reoffend. To expect 100% accuracy is silly.

But the case of Burton is one they should have foreseen. Everyone who knows Burton says he was unstable and highly likely to reoffend. Either the Parole Board ignored the evidence, or the system is so faulty they don’t get the information they need. Instead they got told Burton had impeccable behaviour.

Mom and Dad now homophobic terms!

Good God.

The National Health Service in Scotland has told doctors and nurses to avoid using the terms ‘mom’ and ‘dad’ as the terms could be offensive to homosexual couples with children!!!

As part of their “zero-tolerance policy to discriminatory language” they recommend when talking to children to consider using ‘parents‘, ‘carers’ or ‘guardians’ rather than ‘mother’ or ‘father‘.

They also rule as unacceptable the terms ‘husband’, ‘wife’ and ‘marriage’ as they exclude lesbian, gay and bisexual people. Instead, health care workers should use the terms ‘partners’ and ‘next of kin’.

How long until someone tries this on here?

Hat Tip: Family First

Tolerance vs Respect

Simon Collins reports in the NZ Herald that in the debate over the draft National Statement on Religious Diversity, some non-Christian religions want more than “tolerance” of their faiths, but respect.

I would fight tooth and nail against that. Tolerance is exactly the right word. You earn respect, you don’t demand it, and to be honest the state has no business trying to tell me I should respect some or all religions.

I do not respect the Church of Scientology for example. I think they are mostly fruit loops. So why should I have to respect them. I suspect the PM may not be that keen on respecting the Exclusive Brethren either. Actually I think she fails the tolerance test also 🙂

My fear over this draft statement is it will end up being an attack on free speech, and be used to shield religions from legitimate criticism. We should all keep a watching eye on where this goes.

Cheaper Eden Park upgrade confirmed

The Government has confirmed a cheaper upgrade of Eden Park for the 2011 World Cup, with 50,000 permanent seats, and at least 10,000 temporary seats.

On balance this is probably the best decision, as I blogged last week. It is a pity there wasn’t more advance planning so that options like Carlaw or North Harbour could have been properly evaluated.

I do note however that last week the TV leaked story (which came from the Government) talked of a $50 to $100 million cost for the cheaper option. This $190 million cost is a lot more than that and the full permanent 60,000 seat option is only double instead of triple that.

But how often will Eden Park have more than 50,000 people wanting to attend?

The interesting detail for me, is who pays for it. How much will ratepayers and taxpayers be putting in, as opposed to NZRFU etc?