Green co-leader

Well we are in the last few days of the contest for co-leader of the Green Party, who has a Y chromosome. Incidentally do they test the candidates for eligibility or just take their word for it?

I watched the four candidates on Agenda, as Joe Hendren did.

I agree with the NZ Herald that Mike Ward is effectively out of the race. A nice guy, but no longer a leader.

Dave Clendon has handled himself okay, and if Nandor was not in the contest I suspect he would poll close to Russel Norman in a two way race. But with two “front-runners” he has never made the impact needed to be considered on his merits.

So that leaves Nandor and Russel. Now I’ll take a punt here and say that I think Nandor should be elected, but predict Russel will.

The reasons I think the Greens should go with Nandor, is that he is the safest option for them, and when on 5.3% you don’t want to risk losing 0.4%. Nandor has noticeably picked up his game since losing his seat, and then returning as Rod Donald’s replacement. He has the skills and resources that come from being an MP, and also for my money has the right strategy on emphasising the environmental brand over the social justice brand (where other parties compete).

This is not to say Russel Norman will do a bad job if elected. He seems very articulate and competent and importantly has good working relationships with other key players. However if he is made Leader he will struggle a bit with not being in Parliament, while one of the failed contenders is. He may get over-shadowed by Nandor even if he is elected Leader.

So why do I think Russel Norman is more likely than Nandor to win? Because the Greens are using STV (as they should) to elect the co-leader.

Nandor is well known after seven years as an MP to the Green party faithful who vote. They would have made a decision on whether to see him as leader or not and will rank him either first or last.

So I think Nandor will have the most votes on the first ballot, but unless he gets a majority, then Ward and Clendon will drop out and almost all of their votes will go to Norman, with Norman beating Nandor on the final ballot.

Now bear in mind I am not exactly a Green Party insider, so I may be totally wrong and they will declare Mike Ward leader by consensus!

I await the announcement with interest. Anyone know when it is due at the weekend?

England does not equal Britain

Just like it annoys me when media use “web” instead of “Internet” it also annoys me when people refer to the United Kingdom as England.

In this NZPA story on Pitcairn Island, the lead paragraph says “The Privy Council will decide if England has legal jurisdiction over the remote islands.”

Umm no they won’t. Well not unless they are about to overturn the 1707 Act of Union between England and Scotland.

In 1790 when Pitcairn was settled by the Bounty crew, the country then in existence was the “United Kingdom of Great Britain”. In 1800 it became the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Ireland, and then in 1922 changed to be the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland.

Pedants may ask what about Wales? Well they were never merged/unified with England, they were conquered 🙂

Wales went from being a Kingdom to a Principality in 1284 through the Statute of Rhuddlan, and in 1535 the Laws in Wales Act 1535 annexed Wales to the legal system of England.

Anyway back to my main point, England does not exist as a sovereign country since 1707, well except in some sporting contests.

Tree Chopping

Okay I don’t subscribe to the notion that you have an inviolable right to do whatever you want on your property. I’m comfortable with not being able to build a 100 foot high fence as it may block your neighbour’s views. I’m also comfortable that if you have an ancient native tree – you know 200 years old or so, that it may have heritage protection.

But prosecuting Alice Presley because she cut down an exotic tree on her own property seems like bureaucracy gone mad. Especially that said tree had been causing problems with the power lines.

But the problem is Auckland City Council have passed a bylaw that basically says any tree over eight metres tall belongs to them, and you need their permission to cut it down. Ridiculous.

New All Black Haka

Must See Video

Crikey has a video of a news anchor asking an officer in East Timor if he feels safe, with all the armed soldiers behind him. He replies yes he does, but not because of the soliders there as her stage manager placed them there, not him 🙂

Hilarious.

The part Jordan left off

Jordan has a graph up comparing Real GDP between Australia and NZ from 1977 to 1998. He uses this to blame everything on the nasty right wing reforms and says the more sensible policies of the last few years have closed the gap.

Now let’s look at the three periods in turn – pre 1984, 1985 – 1999 and 2000 onwards.

Jordan shows a similar GDP growth up to 1984. So does this mean he thinks Muldoon was right? Does he hanker for the days of the state setting wages, prices, rents and interest rates? The days of import controls and subsidies?

Then we have 1984 – 1999. It always amuses me as people try to treat this as one period with one Government. There were in fact two, arguably three Governments in that time with very different policies.

Yes from 1984 to 1990 GDP slipped relative to Australia. Well Labour was in power then and sure they did some things right, they also did a fair bit wrong. Then National came into office in late 1990 and by 1992 you see the GDP growth start up and looking much the same rate as Australia. Kept this up until 1996 when we got hit by the Asian crisis and Winston.

But anyway that isn’t even the main thing I wanted to touch on. I was intrigued by why the graph stopped in 1998. Jordan says he hasn’t had time to update it. Well it took me a few minutes but below we see Real GDP, seasonally adjusted, from March 2000 to December 2005. They both start from a base of 100 in March 2000.

GDP.JPG

Oh yes one can see how well Dr Cullen is closing that gap. Now remember Jordan said “The more sensible policies since have led us to slightly catch up in terms of growth – particularly over the past five years.”

Yeah Right.

UPDATE: The Australian line looks to be based on nominal, not real, GDP which makes the current graph invalid. It was meant to be real GDP but somehow grabbed the wrong data series. WIll do an updated post later with the corrected figures.

$50 Xtra refunds?

Bruce Simpson suggests that Telecom are obliged to refund $50, not $3.25 for their recent Xtra outage. He quotes from their standard terms and conditions:

“If you are still without a Telecom service because of a fault in any of these things more than 24 hours after you tell us about the fault, or if we miss an arranged visit, call us on 120. You can choose either a credit to your Telecom account of one month’s worth of your Telecom residential line rental or $50 worth of PhoneCards”

Does Xtra count as a Telecom service?

New Helengrad definition

New Kiwi Blog

Ana Samways and partner Steven Shaw have launched a new blog – Spare Room.

There is some great content on there. The video of TV bloopers such as the news anchor asking the weathergirl if she is “warm and wet as well” – hilarious.

Also personal stuff such as ten reasons Ana’s OE stunk.

They have three seperate rooms you can browse or subscribe to – the Spare Room homepage (humour, opinion and ex-pat contributions), The Lounge (covering the likes of film, TV and music) and CoolFinder (a catalogue of art/design/fashion/gadgets we think are both cool and affordable).

I also enjoy the self-deprecating humour where Ana tells how she was once enthusiastically described to her brother overseas as a

Sensible NZers

63% of NZers don’t believe Michael Cullen, when he says tax cuts are unaffordable. This is pleasing, even though the figure should be 95% as all but the most partisan pundits say it is obvious you can afford tax cuts with a $9 billion surplus.

Our beloved PM of course disagrees and attacks the polling company. Now it is true Colmar Brunton does tend to have National 2% or so more favourable than other polls, but when you have 63% stating a view, that can’t be explained away by such variances.

The Dom Post gets one thing wrong in its story. They claim:

The poll also debunked National claims that thousands would flood across the Tasman after tax cuts in Australia. Only 17 per cent said they were considering shifting.

The last time I checked 17% of four million is around 680,000.

A Principled Act

National shows it is fully ready to make right the accidental election broadcasting over-spending, which has left broadcasters out of pocket. Leader Don Brash has submitted a bill to amend the Broadcasting Act which will allow the Electoral Commission to pay the $110,000 to the five broadcasters and in turn be paid by National.

I expect this bill could be introduced with unanimous leave of the House and passed through all stages under urgency.

It will also no doubt serve as the starkest of comparisons for ethical behaviour compared to Labour who over-spent by $418,000, broke their word to the Chief Electoral Officer, and refues to acknowlegde any wrongdoing whatsoever.

Draft Submission on Size of Parliament Bill

Like No Right Turn, I’m planning to put in a submission against the bill to reduce the size of Parliament to 120 MPs.

My current draft is below. Feedback is welcome from people on it.

SUBMISSION TO
Justice and Electoral Committee

REGARDING
Electoral (Reduction in Number of Members of Parliament) Amendment Bill>

FROM
David Farrar
Thorndon
Wellington

1. This submission respectfully asks the Justice and Electoral Committee Secretariat to recommend to the House that the Electoral (Reduction in Number of Members of Parliament) Amendment Bill not proceed.

2. I would like to appear before the Committee to speak to my submission.

3. I only represent myself in this matter.

4. For over 10 years I have been professionally involved in electoral issues, including the Electoral Act, electoral boundaries, electoral administration, and analysis of election results. I consider myself highly knowledgeable on electoral systems, and specifically the New Zealand electoral system.

5. The major reason I oppose this Bill is because reducing the size of the House of Representatives to 100 MPs, as outlined in the Bill, will over time break the MMP electoral system.

6. Other reasons for opposition are
a. The size of the House is small amongst countries of our population size.
b. It would allow the Executive to dominate the House more easily.
c. It would reduce the number of MPs available for Ministerial roles.
d. A compromise to reduce the probability of overhang may see the size of Electorates increase.
e. Parties would have fewer List MPs, and this would lead to a less diverse Parliament.
f. The Royal Commission on the Electoral System recommended a House size of 120, preferably as much as 140.
g. Expected Cost Savings would be relatively small.

7. Overhang

8. The number of electorates is basically governed by the relative populations of the South and North Islands. The Maori option also has some effect but the general rule is that if the North Island population grows faster than the South Island population, then the number of electorates will increase after every census.

9. The number of seats grew, due to this uneven population growth, from 80 in 1966 to 99 in 1993.

10. Under MMP the number of electorate seats increased from 65 in 1996 to 67 in 1999 and 69 in 2002.

11. The number of electorates is recalculated after each five-yearly census. Using the medium growth assumptions of Stats NZ, I project the following number of electorates in the next 20 years:
2006: 71
2011: 73
2016: 74
2021: 76
2026: 77

12. If however the South Island followed a low growth path and the North Island a high growth path then the no of seats would be:
2006: 73
2011: 78
2016: 82
2021: 86
2026: 90

13. I think this clearly demonstrates that any reduction to 100 MPs, as proposed in the Bill, would be unsustainable as there will not be enough List MPs to allocate to parties to prevent over-hang.

14. In the 2002 election Labour got 41.3% of the vote, which in a 100 MP house meant they should have 43 seats. However they won 45 electorate seats so in 2002 they would have had an overhand of two MPs.

15. We have already seen over-hang for the first time in the 2005 election with the Maori Party having one more seat than its share of the vote would normally entitle it to. Over-hang is generally seen as undesirable as it makes The House less proportional, and proportionality was a major rationale of MMP.

16. Size of the House compared to overseas Parliaments

17. Some people assert that the size of the House making up the NZ Parliament is large compared to other countries. I have gathered data from all 30 OECD countries, and the eight countries expected to join the OECD in 2007.

18. The results are set out in the table below:

house size.JPG

19. The size of the NZ Parliament, per 100,000 residents is ranked 17th out of 38, or just about dead centre.

20. In absolute terms the size of Parliament at 120 is 30th= out of 38. Our population is also ranked 30th out of 38.

21. However even this simple comparison is somewhat unfair to NZ. Because very large countries always have a very low MP to population ratio, and very small countries a relatively high ratio. This reflects that there is a maximum and minimum size for a Parliament, for it to be an effective law maker.

22. If the US wanted a ratio equal to NZ, it would need a Congress of 9,000 representatives and Senators. Likewise for Iceland to have the same ratio as NZ, it would have a Parliament of only nine MPs.

23. Therefore the best comparison for NZ, is to look at countries of a similar population. Now of the seven countries with a smaller population than NZ, none of them have a lower MP to population ratio..

24. If we take countries with a population of between four million and ten million, we find NZ has the smallest Parliament and is ranked 9th out of 11 for ratio of MPs to population.

25. Therefore I conclude that overall NZ has a small Parliament relative to countries of our size

26. It is also worth noting that NZ is one of the few countries with no provincial or state governments. This puts NZ in an even more favourable position.

27. Executive domination of the House

28. One of the good features of MMP has been the increased role for and importance of the House. The days of not having the House meet for six months, and then just rubber stamping legislation are long gone.

29. The Executive in recent years has tended to number 26 (currently 29). In a 120 member House 61 votes are needed to pass legislation. If Cabinet decides on an issue, all Ministers are obliged to support it at the Government Caucus meeting. Reducing the House by 20 members will make it almost inevitable that the Executive will form a majority of the Government Caucus.

30. No of MPs available for the Executive

31. The size of the Executive, has grown significantly over the years. It is currently 29 which is an all time record. A century ago it was only seven.

32. A new Government has to fill the Executive roles, two or three of the four Speakerships, and perhaps eight to ten of the 18 Select Committee Chairmanships. This is a total of around 40 roles.

33. Even with a 120 MP House, a new Government often will have only around 40

ACT on Campus lookalikes

Generation XY has noticed how smiliar some ACT on Campus people look to celebrities.

They see Gavin Middleton as Wayne Knight who played Newman on Seinfeld.

Mike Collins as as Ed O’Neill, better known as Al Bundy.

Clint Heine as Paul Giamatti from Cinderella Man.

And finally, pictured below. Helen Simpson as the teen heart-throb Mischa Barton from The O.C. Good detective work!

helen_simpson_mischa_barton.jpg

Hypocritical Greens

Once upon a time the Greens were known as a party of principle. They would say if they thought something was wrong, regardless of party. They would refuse to vote for urgency motions without good reason etc.

Now after months and months of saying nothing at all about Labour’s deliberate $450,000 overspending, they suddenly jump up and down to protest on behalf of broadcasters that National’s GST error is unfair.

Since National voluntarily disclosed the mistake, it has been known that it was the broadcasters left out of pocket. National in fact tried to pay them, but this would further breach the Act, so for the Greens months later to suddenly demand they pay the broadcasters back is bizarre.

What should have happened of course, is for the Police to charge National over the GST error. Because while it was a genuine error, it did result in an advantage of $112,500 (around 1/4 of the Labour over-spend). However with the Police determined not to charge Labour for a much more serious offence, they could hardly then charge National. The correct decision would have been to charge both.

I find it hilarious the Greens are also demanding that National deduct the $112,500 off its 2008 election budget. I now await them also demanding that Labour deduct $420,000 off its 2008 budget. Their failure to do so, indicates the rank hypocrisy at work here.

Less bangs for the buck

In the current broadband debate there has been many comments on whether NZ broadband packages compare favourably with other OECD countries, but a real lack of hard data.

To help correct this, InternetNZ last month commissioned Wairua Research to do a study. In early May they examined 2586 broadband packages from 388 ISPs over 26 OECD countries.

As reported in the Dominion Post, New Zealand offerings on average rank 22nd out of the 26 countries. And before the changes made in April, we would have been last.

On price alone, NZ now ranks quite well. But on performance issues such as speeds and data caps we are well behind overseas countries. We also have far less variety of offerings than many countries.

The full report is available as a pdf (250k) – around 60 pages.

I’ve also included INZ’s press release after the break.
Continue reading »

Tana’s handbag

One News Poll

One News had a Colmar Brunton poll tonight. I missed it and their website is unresponsive but I am informed results are approx:

National 47% (+2)
Labour 38% (-4)
Green 5% (-2)
NZ First 4% (+2)
Maori 3% (+1)

The 9% gap might be seen as optimistic as other polls tend to be less favourable to National, but the key thing is the trend, and this shows the gap growing 6% since the last poll at the end of March.

This makes sense with the negative reaction to the budget. Once upon a time budgets were meant to help, not harm, the Government!

An election based on those results, and with no change in electorate seats would see:

National 61
Labour 49
Green 6
Maori 4
ACT 1
United 1
Progressive 1

Total 123

A National-ACT or National-United Government would have a majority 62/123 seats.

Casual Sex Fridays

You need to apply for the $3 credit

Most people know about the Xtra outages which lasted for three to four days. They have said there will be a 4 day credit, which is equal to around $3.50 for most Xtra users.

Now a friend has just shown me the e-mail from Xtra which says you have to fill in an online form and apply for the refund!!!

Now time is money, and people will not want to spend ten minutes finding their phone bill, and copying over the exact account holder name, the account number, plus phone and e-mail just to get back less than $4.

Surely Telecom could just apply the refund to all broadband accounts, or even as a compromise allow people to apply for it with just their username and password (which you don’t need to look up generally).

This is just going to offend more of their own customers I suspect.

A peaceful Sunday

Spent some of this morning helping construct sandcastles at Scorching Bay. Mu Uncle and Aunt are visiting from Australia so we went to brunch at Chocolate Fish Cafe with my brother sis-in-law and my niece Sabine who is now 2 1/2.

Somehow Sabine got to build the sandcastle, my brother got to dig the moat while my job was to fill the bucket up with water. This required me to go up to the sea, hold the bucket down, and as the tide comes in let it fill the bucket up right until the point where I am about to get soaked, and then I jump backwards. Luckily I managed this with only the odd damp toe.

My apartment block has a power outage from 10 am to 1 pm, so I’m now sitting in Starbucks with a very large coffee, and the laptop finishing some reports and blogging. I love wireless Internet!

Was going to see The Davinci Code this afternoon but all sold out. Never mind – I am enjoying a relatively quiet Sunday.

Maia defends Infanticide

Maia defends Infanticide, saying:

But if a woman feels like she has no other choice but to wrap her baby up in a rubbish bag, I’m still on her side and will not judge her. I think the mother is more important than a new-born baby.

I’m staggered by such a view. Because this is not talking about the life of the mother (she has sucessfully given birth) vs the life of the child. Maia is saying it is more important that a mother can decide not to be a mother, than the life of the child.

I wonder whether she even has time limits for up until what age one can kill your baby? One week, one month, one year?

At the end of the day it all seems to be part of a world-view where no woman can ever be judged to do anything wrong, because she is oppressed. Every allegation of rape must be taken as correct, every bad thing done by a woman is not the fault of the woman, but of society. Obviously a world-view which is not my own.

If people comment on this issue, I would ask them to be restrained with their language.

The Everest Debate

Up until now I had not blogged on the Everest debate, partly because my view was somewhere between the two camps of “There was nothing one could do” and “Inglis should have tried anyway”.

However the SST editorial on the issue, pretty much reflects my own views.

It is wrong to single out Inglis; he could not have saved Sharp by himself. But it is also wrong to exempt him from blame. Inglis, and the 39 other mountaineers who did not stop to help the British climber, made the wrong decision.

And later:

Inglis, to his credit, sensed there was a problem. He stopped, radioed for advice, and seems to have worried about whether he was doing the right thing. A sherpa offered aid. But who knows what could have been done if all those passing mountaineers had shown solidarity with David Sharp?

A dry talent pool

Matthew Hooton, in the SST, labels Parekura Horomia as “possibly the most incompetent person ever to have held a ministerial warrant in New Zealand”. He may be right, but for my money George Hawkins was definitely a contender also.

Hooton goes on to conclude that Labour’s lack of talent comes from the fact they have used their party list to protect incumbent MPs, ranking them all at the top for the last few elections. You do this to avoid short-term pain, but it causes long-term pain.

National has had a varied record over the years in regards to does it protect MPs by placing them high on the List. In 1996 and 1999 the Government had majorities of one, so National couldn’t afford to upset an MP with a low list ranking as they could bring down the Government. There was no formal decision to place all MPs in winnable spots but that is just the way it turned out.

In 2002 then President Michelle Boag made it very clear there would be no list protection for some MPs, and effectively encouraged electorate challenges also. This did result in gaining new MPs such as Don Brash, John Key and Judith Collins but caused a huge amount of friction and resentment in the Caucus and wider party.

In 2005, for the first time, National puts all of its 25 MPs seeking re-election in the top 30 spots. The rationale was that clearly National was going to get at least 40 MPs, so as there was no question of being able to get some new talent into Parliament why go out of the way to offend some MPs by having them receive lowish rankings?

Many were concerned that this may set a bad precedent for the future, and it was seen as a one off. It will be most interesting to observe what approach National takes at the next election. I believe it is essential to avoid the problems that Labour has with its lack of talent, and not have incumbent MPs given protected positions on the list.

Of course ten of the new MPs, got there by winning seats off Labour (or Winston) so they will be hoping not to have to rely on a list ranking to get back in.

Treasury forecasts of Surpluses

As even the most ardent Labourite finds it difficult to argue that tax cuts are not affordable with a $9b surplus (well not with keeping a straight face) they often point to the forceasted surplus for the out years and exclaim that it is going to shrink to $3.5b, so hence tax cuts are not affordable.

Leaving aside for one second the fact that Dr Cullen can make the out year forecast surplus be anything he wants by changing the level of unallocated future expenditure (which is a massive $9.9b slush fund over three years), we should look at whether surpluses turn out larger or smaller than forecast.

Taking the OBERAC, the underlying surplus, I have examined every OBERAC projection and outcomes for the years 2001 – 2010, as reported in the DEFUs and BEFUs since 2000.

In the 2000 BEFU the OBERAC for 2002/03 was forecast as $2.7b. It turned out to be $5.6b.

The 2000 BEFU forecast the 2003/04 OBERAC to be $3.2b. It was $6.6b.

The 2001 BEFU forecast the 2004/05 OBERAC to be $3.6b. It was $8.8b

The 2002 BEFU forecast the 2005/06 OBERAC to be $4.2b. It looks to be $7.0b

So next time a Labourite claims future surpluses will not be large enough for tax cuts, just think yeah right!

Treasury forecasts of Surpluses

As even the most ardent Labourite finds it difficult to argue that tax cuts are not affordable with a $9b surplus (well not with keeping a straight face) they often point to the forceasted surplus for the out years and exclaim that it is going to shrink to $3.5b, so hence tax cuts are not affordable.

Leaving aside for one second the fact that Dr Cullen can make the out year forecast surplus be anything he wants by changing the level of unallocated future expenditure (which is a massive $9.9b slush fund over three years), we should look at whether surpluses turn out larger or smaller than forecast.

Taking the OBERAC, the underlying surplus, I have examined every OBERAC projection and outcomes for the years 2001 – 2010, as reported in the DEFUs and BEFUs since 2000.

In the 2000 BEFU the OBERAC for 2002/03 was forecast as $2.7b. It turned out to be $5.6b.

The 2000 BEFU forecast the 2003/04 OBERAC to be $3.2b. It was $6.6b.

The 2001 BEFU forecast the 2004/05 OBERAC to be $3.6b. It was $8.8b

The 2002 BEFU forecast the 2005/06 OBERAC to be $4.2b. It looks to be $7.0b

So next time a Labourite claims future surpluses will not be large enough for tax cuts, just think yeah right!