MMP in action

I think we are about to see MMP in action again. National has called for the law & order select committee to hold an inquiry into the Corrections Department.

This would probably never happen under FPP but with a minority government it can. A check of the membership of the committee and there are three Labour MPs, three National MPs and NZF’s Ron Mark. Now I can’t see a scenario where Ron will not want an inquiry, so we will probably get one. Good.

Greens attack Labour

Brash backs Independent Justice Panel

Fires erupt across country

National Radio Politics

For those who like listening to the weekly politics discussion on National Radio’s Nine to Noon show it is now on Mondays at 11.05 am. First show of the year is today.

UPDATE: Heh when Hooton said Clark’s spending summer holidays skiing in Norway would invite comparisons to Narnia’s Wicked Witch Queen it was hilarious to hear the reactions from the others as they tried to work out how to respond. The line I liked best though was the Cullen’s economic policies are to blame as we always have winter and Christmas in the form of tax relief never arrives!

West Wing Cancelled

Empire Drinking Game

I blogged last week on the Empire TV mini-series and how to put it kindly it had some mild departures from known history.

Or to put it less kindly it was like a very bad spin-off of Star Wars.

However being masochistic I will be watching it again tonight (9.30 pm on One) to see how it goes. But DG has made an excellent suggestion that we have a drinking game to go with it.

The drinking game is simple. Every time there is a scene which looks or sounds like it could be from a Star Wars movie then you consume.

So references to the power of the senate get a drink, scenes showing Octavianus sneaking around hooded like a jedi get a drink, battle scenes with jedi type moves etc etc.

Should make the evening far more pleasant!

UPDATE: Oh my God. A black Roman general!!!! This is like having a white guy play Martin Luther King. The Romans did not in 44 BC have black generals to put it mildly.

Also Octavian never had the Senate trying to kill him he never pretended to be a slave and never became a gladiator!!! Last episode at least had some factual accuracy such as well Caesar did die. This one seems to be total myth.

UPDATE2: Brutus becomes Pontifex Maximus!!! Ahem that was Lepidus – Brutus was never chief priest. And I also don’t think Cassius would pash Brutus’ mother as he was married to her daughter!

Canadian Dirty Tricks

I used to think the US had the worst dirty tricks in politics but Canada seems to be setting new lows. I think it shows how bad it is when one party stays in power for so long.

In Saskatoon-Wanuskewin (great name eh) the Conservative candidate was taking part in a televised live candidate’s forum. One of the callers accused Maurice Vellacott, a former pastor, of sexually assaulted a former parish secretary.

Vallacott demanded that the TV station give him the called ID number of the caller. They did so and the call originated from the local Liberal Party Campaign Office!!! Incredible!

The Liberal candidate has said yes the call came from his office but has denied knowledge and said that a member of the public may have snuck in and made the call. This sort of claim would lack credibility at the best of times but when it emerges the caller waited on hold for 12 minutes to make the defamatory allegation, well it speaks for itself.

And to make it worse someone has sworn an affidavit that they recognised the voice as being a George Laliberte who is a well-known associate of the Liberal candidate. Oh and upon being informed it is one of his long standing associates the Liberal Candidate said “but I just think that volunteers do things out of anger and frustration sometimes that you can’t control. Mr. Vellacott is the kind of person who generates extreme responses to his extreme positions”. So you see it is all still the Conservative Party’s fault his associate phoned up the TV show!!!

I can’t imagine how corrupt or desperate one would have to be (let alone stupid) to spend 12 minutes waiting on a phone calling from your campaign office, to accuse an opponent of sexual assault.

On related news, while I do disapprove of Wikipedia vandalism, I did have to laugh at the insertion of an image of the Hindenberg Disaster on the Canadian Liberal Party Page.

Mind you the latest polls have the gap narrowing to 7%, and FPP elections often have real surprises, so election night will still be very tense for all I am sure.

Norwegian Madness

Just remember the next time someone holds up Scandinavia as the ideal society this law highlighted by Lindsay Mitchell.

The law requires a minimum 40% female composition of public company boards. The Minister has threatened to dissolve any company which does not comply. I can think of nothing more insulting to female board directors (and I am on a company board with three exceptionally skilled female directors) than this sort of law where you would never know if you were appointed on merit or just to stop the Government from dissolving the company.

The law was actually introduced by the former Conservative Government. I knew a few of their MPs so will have to give them grief when I next see them.

Spy Stations

It amazes me that despite the events of September 11 there is no change in the attitude of some people towards western intelligence gathering.

In this case I refer to Keith Locke. One would think a so called peace party like the Greens would support intelligence gathering, as it saves lives and helps prevent terrorist attacks. In Sydney, in London, in Europe it all keeps people alive.

But no Locke calls NZ playing our part in intelligence gathering as a “cancerous cell”. He has called for Waikopai to be closed many times.

I usually avoid the easy cheap shots, but I really have to ask if Keith Locke is so concerned about governments collecting intelligence on citizens what was his view then of the USSR which instituted spying and monitoring of itz citizens to a level unparalled in human history.

Well back in 1980 of course he was supporting their invasion of Afghanistan.

Now yes I know he now says he was wrong. Good. He was. He is however equally wrong again this time and in fact never has someone been so wrong so often as Keith Locke on foreign affairs and defence. Hence of course he is the Green’s spokesperson on it.

Island Bay Marine Reserve

I grew up in Island Bay and lived there for around 20 years. It will always be home to me, despite having lived in Thorndon for over a decade. It is a lovely place to live, and a great place to bring up a family.

So it is with interest I read the Dom Post story on the proposed marine reserve.

As a general rule I think marine reserves are a great thing. In the late 90s a fairly large number were established.

However I do has misgivings over the proposed location of this one. The Italian fishing families are a huge part of the community of Island Bay. It would be a huge shame to push them out of the area, especially as the marine reserve won’t even allow them to land their catches from further out in Island Bay.

As Tony Muollo says: “It would be sad to lose Island Bay’s iconic fishing fleet”

Poor Lib Dems

The UK Lib Dems are having a torrid time. New Conservative Leader David Cameron is draining off their support and their Leader resigned after concealing his alcoholism for many years.

Then their House of Lords Leader revealed he was an alcoholic also (or had been) and finally today one of their leadership contenders has resigned from the front bench after his use of rent boys was exposed.

They seem to be doing a re-run of the Tories in the 90s!

Sometimes it’s good to be a journalist

Spiritual Healing

Sigh. $1.3 million a year on Maori spiritual healing and the like.

There is of course no evaluation of their effectiveness.

I wonder if a wine club could get $1.3 million for wine drinking on the basis of it being traditional French healing 🙂

Excuses

Briar Dravitski defends her actions in having sex with a 13 year old by claiming he came on to her when she was drunk and he wasn’t her first.

I am trying to imagine the odium a 23 year old man would attract for claiming the 13 year old girl he slept with was “experienced” and basically took advantage of him.

She also claims she thought that the 13 year old (four days earlier he was still 12) was 17.

The Crimes Act actually has some pretty sensible provisions for dealing with mistaken ages. It used to say if you were aged up to 21 then you could use as a defence you thought they were over 16.

The recent changes still allow a defence of assumed age and indeed allow it for someone of any age but it makes it tougher. Section 134A of the Crimes Act requires you to have taken reasonable steps to find out whether the young person concerned was of or over the age of 16 years.

I don’t think we have any case law yet on what will be deemed reasonable steps but at a minimum it would require actually asking them their age. If you met them on licensed premises that could be deemed a reasonable belief but the Act suggests some sort of active rather than passive action to check age so probably not.

What Winston wants to hear

Blog Posts

Don stories

The Dom Post has an interview with Don Brash, where he talks about plans for this year, polls and his future etc.

Also Fran O’Sullivan writes on why her money is on Don staying where he is.

I concur with her conclusion that Don will remain leader “unless or until the political polls turn on either National or him.”

People I think forget that while National didn’t quite get to form a Government, its share of the popular vote was the highest since 1990.

Misleading Headline 2

Okay this one is serious!

You see “Jails boss rejects idea of using ex-crims as guards” and you assume it means what it says – that ex-crims can not become prison guards.

Instead upon reading the article one discovers that in fact it says no such thing. It says:

* a previous conviction would not automatically preclude someone being employed as a prison officer
* those who had served a term of imprisonment would generally not be considered

So in fact the policy is that convicted criminals can become prison guards if they were not sent to prison themself, and even if they had been to prison the policy has the weasel words “generally not be considered”.

Considering that one can sometimes run up a dozen offences before actually winning a jail term, I am not greatky reassured. The corruption in the prison service is already massive, so why would you make it even worse by hiring convicted criminals as guards.

Misleading Headline 1

Currency Wars

I always find it amusing when I read of spats between Michael Cullen and John Key on currency issues.

For I always reflect on what jobs both men held before becoming MPs.

Dr Cullen was a history lecturer. They have tenure which means a job for life regardless of whether you are correct or not in what you say or do.

Mr Key was head of global foreign exchange for Merrill Lynch. If he got it wrong on currency he could lose tens or hundreds of millions of dollars for his employer an clients. If he got it seriously wrong he would be sacked and unemployable in that industry.

So not a hard decision for me, about who’s side I’m on!

Miscarriages of Justice

Retired Judge Sir Thomas Thorp has called for an independent authority to be set up to identify miscarriages of justice.

I concur that this would be an exzcellent move.

I find it interesting that Sir Thomas has concluded David Bain’s conviction for the murder of his parents and siblings was safe but that he had misgivings about Peter Ellis’ conviction. That is very much my views also.

A further story on this issue is here.

Telecommunications Review

Like several other industry bodies, InternetNZ is preparing a position paper on the NZ telecommunications framework and regulatory environment, which will go to the Minister by 31 January.

InternetNZ is keen to have input from interested stakeholders, who have empathy with InternetNZ’s broad philosophy of an open and uncapturable Internet for NZ, on the position paper so it reflects as wide-spread a consensus as possible. To this end consultation/discussion meetings have been arranged in Wellington, Auckland and Christchurch. If you are interested in attending one of these meetings, and would like a copy of the paper just let me know on [email protected]

The meetings are scheduled as follows:

Wellington
Wednesday 25 January at 6.00pm
InternetNZ, 9th Floor, Exchange Place
5 – 7 Willeston Street

Auckland
Thursday 26 January at 6.00pm
Marlborough Room 2
Sky City Convention Centre

Christchurch
Monday 30 January
Venue and time TBC

The paper covers, at a high level, issues such as local loop unbundling, community broadband networks, potential role of BCL in developing a broadband network, a wholesale/retail split for Telecom, Commerce Commission investigations, and a national fibre network.

Steve Crow

Being interviewed this afternoon by TVNZ about the latest Steve Crow venture. Mr Crow became (in)famous a few years ago for his plan to include a live birth as part of an adult video.

So why am I being interviewed? Heh let’s not spoil the fun and people can watch TV One tonight, but keep the speculation clean 🙂

UPDATE: Heh during the interview they wanted me to bring up on the computer screen next to me Crow’s website. My response was that I think that would be a very bad idea 🙂

Latham strikes again

Before you read the latest Latham news, please do remember that this is the man whom Australian Labor tried to get elected Prime Minister.

UPDATE: It gets better. Mad Mark screamed at the photographer that he was a pedophile, assaulted him but best of all despite smashing the camera into 100 pieces did not damage the memory card and they are still going to publish the photos. Also weye witness accounts here.