Bitten by the Frog

I knew that as sure as the sun would rise this morning, that Frog Blog would not let my comments on their Auckland transport policy go unanswered. I was just surprised it took them so long to respond, but guess they had to calm down first after I labelled them enemies of public transport 🙂

Now Frog has helpfully clarified that the Greens don’t actually propose to rip up the existing roads, just basically prevent any new ones being built. Oh yay.

They give examples of overseas cities of similar population which have much better public transport than Auckland, but this ignores the fact Auckland is so spread out geographically. As I said I am a fan of public transport but the figures I keep seeing for Auckland are spending billions of dollars for something which will only cut road numbers by a couple of percent. Again my message is you need both more roads and public transport, not just public transport.

Finally Frog says they don’t like my Wellington example (calling it a red herring) of the $410 million package which will result in only 100 less motorists a day. I am sure they don’t like it. But the Wellington Regional Council has the expertise in public transport (and in fact are very pro public transport) so I don’t think it is fair to call their assumptions “patently ridiculous” just because the conclusions are crippling to your own argument.

Another smear blog

Another smear Brash blog has been set up, and this one has managed to go so far that both the Greens Frog and No Right Turn have condemned it.

Indeed the contest of ideas is what this election should be about. People are getting distinct choices – tax relief vs interest free money for students etc. In many elections the policy differences have been blurred. Not so this campaign.

The nose gets bigger

Helen Clark’s claim to have been so engrossed talking to Jim Sutton (always an unlikely story) that she failed to notice the speed, the lights or the sirens of her convoy has been shout out of the water by the testimony from Officer Clinton Vallender who has stated under oath that Clark congratulated him for the “heroic drive”.

I think it is shameful that these officers have been left out to hang by the PM when it is clear they did not make the decision about making the 4.50 pm flight but the PM and her staff did. The Police advised there was a 5.40 pm flight and it was the PM’s press secretary who after consulting the PM said to make the 4.50 pm flight.

Tax Cuts vs Free Interest

ACT has a calculator (excel file) which shows that their tax cuts would allow students to pay off their loans far quicker than under Labour.

Also once the loan is paid off, you get to keep the benefits of lower tax for the rest of your life, unlike Labour which will keep taxing you to fund every scheme they can possibly think up.

Now ACT’s tax policy is not going to happen, but there is a very valid point that students and graduates should not assume that they will pay their loans off faster with Labour, or be better off, than if they vote for a party which will deliver tax relief.

Dating Stories

Not much of an audit

The Dom Post reports that up to 42% of Pipi money may have been paid to Donna Awatere-Huata or her associates.

But the amazing thing is an Accountant wrote a report stating no funds had been misused, and he did this on the basis of being so impressed with Doona’s explanations. He provided this report without seeing full accounts, minutes and invoices, which he asked for.

I know this wasn’t a full audit, but all the same, rather shocking laxness for a qualified accountant.

Peter Ellis

The Justice Select Committee has reported back on the Peter Ellis petition. Regretably it has not recommended an inquiry, but it has made some useful suggested law changes which should help prevent a repeat.

The full 56 page report is here.

The report includes a summary of Lynley’s Hood book by the Parliamentary Library. Well worth a read.

The issue is not dead though. If there is a National-led Government, Don Brash has confirmed there would be a full independent inquiry with sufficient powers to get to the bottom of the issue.

Horse and Carriage

Maurice Williamson has said that he is “surprised the Greens haven’t advocated a return to horse and carriage as our main mode of transport” in response to the Greens call for the funding for Auckland’s motorways to be moved into public transport.

I am actually a fan of public transport, where population density and grography make it workable. Ironically the biggest enemy of public transport is the Greens (and yes I am serious) because they persist with the madness that public transport is an *alternative* to roads. They are not. They are complementary. By pushing it as an alternative to roads, they almost doom its chance of sucess.

Let’s use a local example. The Government is looking at five packages for Wellington. One of those packages is a $410 million investment into primarily public transport. Now guess how many less cars a day it is predicted this investment would lead to? 100!!! Yes that is right $410 million will only result in 100 less cars a day on Wellington roads. It would be cheaper to buy 100 motorists a helicopter each and tell them to fly to work.

Now this is not a case to never invest in public transport, but one has to be very clear about your thinking. If you think spending on public transport will make even a small small dent in traffic congestion, then you are wrong. It will make public transport more pleasant and useful for those who use it, but it will not lead to any significant reduction in traffic congestion.

Clark voted for Marshall

An interesting revelation from Helen Clark that she never voted for David Lange to become Labour Leader, but voted for the far left Russell Marshall (described by Lange as shallow, shabby and endlessly self-seeking).

God knows what would have happened to NZ if Marshall had become Leader as Clark wanted. Either there would have been a fourth Muldoon Term (shudder) or a Marshall led Labour Government which probably would have concluded that the problem was not enough state intervention. I mean after all the Government only decided the prices of every good and service sold, the wage rate for every person and the interest rate for every transaction.

Well done Labour

Today’s Letter

Was very pleased to read in today’s Letter from Prebble that a brother of the Sgt Roy Prebble killed in WWII has been located. Allan Prebble was too young to go to war, but lost both his brothers in it. It reminds you of the huge sacrifices made by that generation.

The letter also has a thought provoking piece on Islam pointing out that “the Koran is like a pick-and-mix selection. If you want peace you can find peaceable verses. If you want war, you can find bellicose verses

False rape complaints

I had always wondered about the incidence of false rape complaints – wondering if was significant – ie over 10%.

Fairly shocked to see in the NZ Herald an estimate that 60% to 80% of complaints are false.

Such false complaints are a lose-lose for all concerned.

* They discourage actual rape victims from complaining, because of the climate of suspicion that the false complaints generate
* They can destroy a guy’s life, even if later found to be false
* They can destroy the girl’s life if it is widely known she made a false complaint
* They tie up a huge amount of police time better spent on actual crimes

It would be interesting to know if there were any official figures to back up the 60% to 80% estimate. Also whether there is any breakdown between false allegations against a non identified person, and a false accusation against a specific person (which in my opinion is worse).

Rape is a horrific crime, and frankly if I was ever to subscribe to vigilante justice, I’d be most likely to do it to someone who raped one of my close female friends. I’d quite happily throw them in a shark infested harbour.

False accusations trivialise actual rape victims. While sometimes the accuser has psychological problems which need counselling not prison, I do wonder if the relatively low level of prosecutions for such false accusations has led to a climate of acceptability?

A moderate immigration policy

One of the lamentable side-effects of NZ First’s posturing against immigration, and especially against non white immigrants, is how difficult it has made it to disagree with Labour’s immigration policies, yet not be seen to be aligning yourself with the xenophobia of NZ First.

The current immigration service has to be in a competition with Corrections, NZQA and TEC for most dysfunctional agency. Let’s not even mention the “lie in unison” scandal.

I have a fundamental belief that immigration is a good thing for NZ. However it does pose challenges – especially if the rate of immigration outstrips the ability of infrastructure to cope.

And while immigration admittance should be blind to race, it should not be blind to their ability to contribute to New Zealand, and become New Zealanders.

The NZ Herald reports that the thrust of National’s immigration policy will be a four year probationary period for new migrants. This means they can be deported if they break the law.

It seems a sensible solution to me. It will put an end to the endless NZ First horror stories about crimes committed by recent immigrants, which just serve to wind up ill-will against all immigrants. And it will not affect the vast majority of immigrants who settle down and contribute positively to NZ.

A fascinating poll

Tonight’s TVNZ Colmar Brunton Poll is fascinating.

Labour is up 6% to 45% – something they will feel pleased with.

However National is only down 1% to 41%. Labour have taken 3% off the Greens and 2% off NZ First.

This is the second poll to show the Greens well below the 5% mark. It is far too early to make predictions, but it is well known that the strongest support for the Greens has been the under 30s and students, and Labour’s student loans policy has obviously attracted a lot of that vote.

Just as ACT claims their possible demise is due to National stealing their policy, it would indeed be an irony if the same applied to the Greens and Labour.

So on this poll NZ First would hold the balance of power. The minor parties have never polled lower (however this poll often is harder on them than other polls) and you would have two large parties, one minor party with seven MPs and three parties with an MP each (Progressive, Maori and United).

It will be interesting to see how other polls paint the picture.

Pay up Nandor!

Valedictories

Lange on Clark

Fascinating extracts from David Lange’s autobiography in the SST and HOS.

Lange says that Helen Clark did not oppose the flat tax proposal – only Michael Cullen did. He explains that Roger Douglas “bought Clark off by promising her supply in her housing portfolio” and “She responded by putting her head down. I do not remember her buying into any fight we ever had in Cabinet. She was by her own account a survivor: as long as her paddock had a good sole of grass the firestorm could consume the rest.”

Such a principled person, Lange portrays.

Also an interesting conversation with the man Helen Clark has designated as one of our 20 greatest living New Zealanders:

Lange recalls how when he first arrived in Parliament, Jonathan Hunt told him of the free air travel to which he was entitled, specifically how one could join the Invercargill Public Library and fly down to get out books and return them.

No wonder the taxis fares got so large with that attitude!

The Maori Seats

Quite a bit of recent poll activity here. I’m going to summarise the polls in each of the seven seats going from north to south:

Te Tai Tokerau – Samuels behind by 16% in July. In April led by 34%. Despite the trend normally being all important, I believe Samuels is toast with a 16% deficit. The 34% lead was always inflated.

Tamaki Makaurau – Tamihere behind by 2% in July Marae Digipoll. Was 36% behind in April and a July Maori TV TNS poll has Tamihere 38% behind. This is too close to call as the different results are too far apart to be reconciled without knowing sampling methods. I suspect Marae Digipoll does a standalone poll while Maori TV TNS ask the questions as part of an omnibus poll on many issues, as their sample is collected over six weeks. I put more weight on Marae Digipoll.

Personally I hope Tamihere is re-elected as he causes far more problems for Labour than he does for anyone else.

Tainui – Mahuta behind by 4% in July Maori TV TNS Poll but 22% ahead in August Marae Digipoll. She was ahead by 15% in April Marae Digipoll. Too close to call.

It is ironic that Labour attacked the April Marae Digipolls as “snake oil”, because they are now consistently showing Labour far better off than Maori TV TNS polls are.

Te Tai Hauauru – Tariana ahead by 60% in July Maori TV TNS poll. In April 48% with Marae Digipoll. She is home and hosed.

Waiariki – Mita Ririnui behind by 24% in July Maori TV TNS poll. Was 15% behind in April Marae Digipoll. He is gone bar a miracle (but back on list).

Ikaroa-Rawhiti – Horomia ahead by 7% in July Maori TV TNS poll and also ahead by 7% in April Marae Digipoll. Horomia looks fairly safe but margin of error is high at 6.7% (not 5% as Maori TV claims here) so not certain.

Te Tai Tonga – Mahara Okeroa behind by 23% in April Marae Digipoll. Best to wait to see more up to date results but MP win is likely.

So overall state of play is Maori Party look highly likely to win Te Tai Tokerau, Te Tai Hauauru, Waiariki and Te Tai Tonga.

Tamaki Makaurau and Tainui have somewhat contradictory results.

Labour ahead in Ikaroa-Rawhiti.

So Maori Party at this stage look like they will win four seats, on a good day win six, and on a very very good day sweep all seven. Best case for Labour appears to be holding onto three out of seven.

Somewhat Disappointing

I have to be honest and say that I do find National’s defence policy somewhat disappointing.

I never expected a pledge to reinstate the air combat wing, as I knew it was near impossible to do after all the pilots have gone off overseas. Building a new new wing from scratch would be incredibly difficult. It was possible in 2002 after just two years, but five years after it was abolished it just is not possible to turn the clock back.

But what is disappointing is no specifics around funding increases. Spending at 0.9% of GDP is dangerously low (Australia is double that at almost 2.0%) and I would have liked to have seen a pledge to increase it by 0.1% a year over six years so by 2011 we are at 1.5% of GDP.

Islamic vs Islamist

Andrew Falloon points out how that Winston Peters appears not to know the huge difference between Islamic and Islamist.

Islamic is basically a term for all Muslims.

Islamist is a set of conservative political ideologies which hold that Islam is not only a religion, but also a political system that governs the legal, economic and social imperatives of the state. The goal of Islamism is to re-shape the state by implementing a conservative formulation of Islamic law.

More on Speeding Case

AUSA President

I see on ACT on Campus that a Dan Bidios has been elected AUSA President over Young Labour President Conor Roberts.

Commisserations to Conor, whom almost everyone has only good things to say about.

What I find interesting is that both the 2005 President and 2006 President seem to have significant involvement in religious groups, and wonder whether there is a common theme that the religious groups have got organised and are now a significant voting force in AUSA politics?

McCully on NZQA Report

The Taxathon

Around a million “taxathon” pamphlets are going out this weekend. The front page is below and Aaron has all four pages on his site.

I love the pamphlet – pissed myself laughing reading it the first time, and am sure it will strike a chord with many.

The NZ Herald also has a story on the pamphlet.

taxathon.jpg

Michael Laws Watch