Wellingtonians have more fun

Sutton’s 6,500 majority all gone

Jim Sutton holds Aoraki with a majority of 6,453 which should normally be as safe as houses.

However he is trailing National’s Jo Goodhew by 6% according to a Timaru Herald poll. And after probing undecided voters the margin expands to 11% which is landslide territory.

The combination of a very effective and hard-working candidate, and an incumbent MP who is seen to have last touch, can overturn the biggest majority.

Very surprised to see that 30% of respondents named the motorcade incident (which did happen locally) as a factor in how they would vote. As I have said before it is not so much the speeding itself, but the trying to sheet all the blame onto the Police drivers.

Almost neck and neck

Today’s Fairfax poll has Labour 1 ahead of National, almost neck and neck. This is taken before the 1st debate which will help Labour a wee bit, but it shows how tight the race still is.

The seats on this poll would be:

Labour 52
National 51
Green 7
NZ First 7
United 2
Maori 1
Progressive 1

To get to 61 seats Labour would need a four way coalition of Labour/Progressive/Greens and either United or Maori Party.

Reading at 180 km/hr

The NZ Herald was sceptical of the PM’s claims that while her car was moving at 180 km/hr she was so busy reading papers that she didn’t notice the speed.

So they sent out a journalist to try it for themselves. Read the amusing conclusions here.

Thanks for the precedent

Thanks to the precedent set in the TV3 case, Destiny are now threatening TVNZ with court action if they are not included in a debate between the Labour Party and Maori Party candidates.

I now await a lawsuit against my blog for not giving equal airtime to NZ First.

0800 DON BRASH

Labour have set up a parody phone line on 0800 366 272 (0800 Don Brash). I find this sort of stuff quite amusing and in fact for a while my voice mail on my mobile was a Labour Party hotline which gave people options to cover up forgeries etc. Some tosser complained to Parliament about it, and despite me owning the phone, I got forced to change it as my ddi diverted to my mobile.

Now Labour may change their message often so I encourage people to phone it regularly in case it varies. Also the voice quality appears much better from mobile phones. I imagine one could even have your PC dial in, and record the message so you can listen to it when you get home.

Now I am sure no-one will make unnecessary calls just because they are free. Because Helen and Trevor has assured us that students will not take up free loans of money just because they are free, and they of course are never wrong.

ACT Billboards found to be illegal under the Electoral Act

The story is not online yet (actually it is on Scoop I’ve found) but a spy reports that the Chief Electoral Officer has ruled ACT’s billboard are illegal under the Electoral Act, and they face a fine of up to $3,000 if they are not removed.

ACT are amending the billboards to comply.

TV3 Debate Ruling Online

The TV3 Debate Judgement is now online.

While many reasons are given for the decision, significant reliance appears to have been placed on what I believe to be an incorrect interpretation of the margin of error.

Paragraph 15 says “in such polls margins of error are often considerably larger than the margins separating the smaller parties”

In paragraph 37 it says “one poll result, especially where the margin of error exceeds the total percentage of votes of some parties and well exceeds the difference between the parties is no rational basis on which to base any such decision.”

This is quite wrong as the gap between Progressive and ACT does not exceed the margin of error for those parties.

Paragraph 40 says “basing its decision on a single poll where a margin of error was 3.1% and the differential in support of 0.2% between an invited party leader and an uninvited party leader, TV3 is acting unreasonably and arbitrarily.”

And again this is the wrong margin of error being quoted.

The above paragraphs are quoting the applicant’s submissions. The Judge himself agrees in paragraph 44 saying “It is clearly established that a single poll with small percentages and high levels of error provides little or no guidance on actual relative electoral support.”

Again I assert that the difference between ACT and Progressive in the poll is significant as the margin of error is in fact less than a quarter of the 3.1% quoted.

And finally in paragraph 45 the Judge says “The error rate well exceeds even the difference between the fifth and eighth parties” which is totally incorrect.

While I believe the bigger issue for TV3 and the media is the whole issue of should a court second guess editorial judgement, the errors made with relation to the margin of error also provide a sound basis to appeal. I would be happy to assist them with any appeal on that point.

Keith Ng on Debate

Lots of views on who did best in the debate. Keith Ng has some useful perspectives having been up there.

General consensus seems to be that Dunne is good at saying worm friendly words, but that this is unlikely to work as it did last time, because last time he was an unknown.

I found interesting how strongly the worm reacted to the labelling the Government as interfering busy body etc. You see Keith is right in that trying to convince people the country is stuffed is a difficult job. But a lot of voters seem to think the country is doing okay, but that the Government really pisses them off. This in my opinion is the underlying sentiment that is still somewhat of a sleeping giant – the interfering Government.

Judicial Ruling Criticised

The NZ Herald is absolutely scathing of Justice Young’s ruling on the TV 3 Debate. They comment

Likewise, the ruling implies that every time Mr Anderton, or any other MP, expresses a view during a parliamentary debate, the media will be obliged to report it.

It is good to see that despite the debate having happened, TV3 are looking to appeal. There are huge principles at stake here.

Ten types of men

Cathy describes for us, the ten types of men. Hopefully she will follow this up with the ten types of women.

Not sure which of the categories I would fall into. Probably a bit of (3) and (5).

On a similiar topic Rob Hosking has an amusing tale of a night out.

TV3 Debate

Well watched the debate. It went as well as could be expected with eight participants. Not sure how useful it will be to anyone undecided though.

I thought the worm was a bit unfair on Tariana, where there seem to be considerable hostility regardless of what she said.

The ones I am really looking forward to is the Brash vs Clark ones where they can actually debate each other properly.

Guantanamo Bay & Harry Potter

Very amused to read that the most popular book amongst prisoners at Guantanamo Bay are Harry Potter books. How is that for universal appeal!

Also noted in same story that 1,800 copies of the Koran have been provided. This is a useful context to the allegation that possibly on one occassion someone may have mistreated the Koran there. Hardly a gulag.

Sir Ron Trotter Dinner

I was privilged to be a guest of the Business Roundtable at Te Papa on Tuesday night for the annual Sir Ron Trotter dinner. It was a lovely night, and I’ll blog in a seperate post the social side of it.

The guest speaker was Professor Tyler Cowen of George Mason University. His topic was “The future of culture in a globalised world”. Tyler also is the co-author of highly popular and respected Marginal Revolution economics blog.

I won’t attempt to give a full summary of what Tyler said (I will link to his notes if put online) but I will cover his main issue:

It was the concern of some that globalisation is bad for culture as we may become a McWorld with one (American) culture. Tyler pointed out that so called national culture is invariably already a synthesis of culture from dozens of places.

He also made the point that the greatest growth for culture historically has been times of globalisation such as the 19th century while when you look at a period of deglobalisation such as the fall of the Roman Empire, the impact on culture was devastating.

I especially liked the idea of talking about the fall of the Roman Empire as deglobalisation. It is a good way to look at things.

There was also mention made of the role of the Internet in promoting culture and allowing greater exposure to other cultures. All that led to his conclusion that globalisation is a friend not a foe of culture – a conclusion it was hard not to share.

Did the Judge understand margins of error?

I was concerned when I heard the arguments in court yesterday that the TV3 poll had a margin of error of 3.2%, and that this is greater than the difference between the result of 1.6%, 1.4% and 0.4% (being ACT, United and Progressive respectively).

I was even more concerned that the Judge said “It [TV3] had based its decision on a single opinion poll — which expert testimony had said had a margin of error greater than the margins between the smaller parties.”

You see the fundamental mistake is that the 3.2% margin of error is a maximum one which applies for a sample of 1,000 for a result of 50%. It means with 95% confidence the true result is between 46.8% and 53.2%. But if the result is less than 50%, then the margin of error shrinks. This is crucial.

The actual margin of error, and 95% confidence interval for each party is:

ACT 1.6% = 0.8% moe = range of 0.8% to 2.4%

United 1.4% = 0.7% moe = range of 0.7% to 2.1%

Progressive 0.4% = 0.4% moe = range of 0.0% to 0.8%

Now one can also calculate the probability that one party is actually ahead of another party. There is a calculator (excel) linked here.

The probability ACT is ahead of United Future is 64.3%. The probability ACT is ahead of Progressive is 99.7% and probability United is ahead of Progressive is 99.1%.

Therefore any decision to allow Progressive into the debate, on the basis of the margin of error, is highly flawed. There is only a 0.3% chance (at 95% confidence) that they have more support than ACT.

I look forward to seeing the court record (if there is a way to see it) to find out whether it was made clear to the Judge that the 3.2% margin of error quoted had not relevance to the issue. The relevant margins of error range from 0.4% to 0.8%.

Judge rules against TV3

To my great surprise Justice Ron Young has ruled against TV3, and ruled they must allow both Peter Dunne and Jim Anderton into the Leader’s Debate tonight. This means the time available for the other six leaders will shrink from seven minutes to five minutes.

I think it is a blow against media freedom to have editorial judgement cast aside in this way. WIll you next have a Judge tell the media how much time each leader gets, whether Clark and Brash are allow to answer more questions, whether a time limit on answers is arbitrary or not.

As I joked at a debate today between Mark and Marian, when it was asked who would speak first – “Let’s get a court order to decide”.

Naughty ACT

ACT have put up a billboard in Wellington Central which has made the news.

Now I have no problem at all with ACT saying give your party vote to ACT, and give National the candidate vote – especially in Wellington Central:-)

But where the problem lies, is that it is difficult to tell who authorised the billboard. Plus you really should not use an trademarked logo without permission. If the billboard said at the top “ACT says” and didn’t use the logo then I suspect no fuss. Of course ACT wants people to give your party vote to ACT, just as National wants people to give their party vote to National. The problem is people may think if they just see it as they go past that National is endorsing a call for people to give their party vote to ACT, which obviously would never happen (well if they were at 4.9999% in the polls I could be tempted).

Anyway I think the ACT people are actually very happy with the publicity the billboard has got from the complaint, so maybe it was all a cunning plan? šŸ™‚

An interview with Cathy

Economic Trouble Ahead?

G-Man points out that almost every economic indicator known to man is looking like it will head in the wrong direction.

I haven’t checked every indicator myself, but certainly have been following that most of them are not looking good.

The changing story

The bigotry of Christian Heritage

Christian Heritage have put out a press release saying “Don’t rely on National for Family Values”.

To support their argument they cite from NBR:

Chris Finlayson is a lawyer placed at no.27 on the National party list (likely to get into Parliament). He is open about his homosexuality and says “It is not an issue as far as I am concerned, nor is it an issue for the leader or president”

and Leader Ewen McQueen concludes that National was not going to be a standard bearer for Christian/family values in New Zealand.

Okay where do I start. The sheer bigotry of attacking a party because it has a gay candidate. This puts the lie to their claim they hate the sin not the sinner crap. They think it is bad to have MPs who happen to be gay. Shame.

Then there is the irony that Chris is actually in court at the moment defending two Catholic institutions in a law suit. Chris is a committed Christian and Catholic. Do Christian Heritage even check before they open their mouth, or do they think all gays are ‘deviant atheists’ who want to destroy the traditional family blah blah blah?

Again ironically Chris actually did not support civil unions because he thought they would undermine marriage. Chris has said ” I

Let us in or else

Peter Dunne and Jim Anderton are trying to get the High Court to force TV3 to allow them onto tomorrow’s TV debate.

First of all I do actually agree that the decision to just take the six top polling parties is silly when there is only a 0.2% difference. I have agreed with Frog that it should be 4 or 7 leaders there, and Peter Dunne is hard done by.

I don’t think there is any case for Anderton to be there. Most polls have Progressive at 0.1%, Destony rank highers in polls than them, and they are almost indistinguishable from Labour.

But regardless of my and others views on who should be there, TV3 is a private company. I think its is appalling to have MPs try and get a court to order a TV stations on a matter of editorial judgement. It is the start of a very slippery slope, and if the Court interferes it will set an appalling precedent.

I hope it can be confirmed that no taxpayers funds are going towards this court action.

Good Stuff

NZ Herald on National’s Immigration Policy

Russell and others on the left have been using selective quotes to try and portray National’s immigration stance as close to NZ First. I suppose they have to say that.

I recommend people read Don’s full speech (credit to Russell who links to it). It is very pro-immigration, but anti some of the current policies. And yes you can be one and not the other. Those arguing that are often the same who argued Don was a racist for his Orewa speech.

The NZ Herald editorial has labelled National’s policy as rational and am improvement on Labour’s knee-jerk reactions and piecemeal change. It does not agree with every aspect but overall is positive.

Harry Potter Discussion

There has been heaps of posts to the Harry Potter Book Seven thread including someone posting their own versions of the first few chapters. Almost everyone posting there is not a regular to the blog so I wondered where they were coming from, and checked to find I am the 2nd highest hit on Google for “Harry Potter Book Seven”!

I enjoy the Harry Potter discussions as much as the political ones so I may start posting regular Harry Potter threads, to keep the debate going. Can’t wait for the film of Book Four at the end of the year.