Jail I hope

I’ve found very creepy the case of the ex-undercover policeman who was charged with threatening to kill Prime Minister Helen Clark.

Over the years I’ve seen many death threats (and even had a couple myself) against MPs, but one involving a former police officer would be more unsettling than most.

I hope the Court gives the man a jail term, as I think there has to be a very clear message that threats of the nature he made have no part in NZ.

Nonsense statistics

I’m annoyed with this article in the Press, repeating some invented figures by Cullen, trying to guess what National’ tax relief and extra spending may total.

They claims it may be $7.5 billion. Yet do not specify whether this is per year, over three years or ten years. The article is meaningless due to this failure alone.

They invent a figure of 3% reduction in all four tax rates. They also assume it would all happen in the first year. They include in backdating income threshold adjustments to 1999 *on top of* tax rate reductions.

They have $2.1 in petrol tax into roads over six years, and cost $1 billion for seven new prisons (as if they would all be need in a couple of years which is crap). They also have $720 million to abolish carbon tax over three years.

So we have figures expressed as annual, as over three years, six years and over a decade, all together in the same article. This is just, to be blunt, shoddy. You can’t even refute it, because you can’t understand the basis for their claims.

If they showed all their calculations as average annual cost over the first three years, then maybe one could debate it.

As for the overall claims, that is simply scare mongering. Don Brash is probably the most fiscally responsible MP in Parliament. He’d sooner spend twelve weeks on Survivor or Treasure Island, than run a Government which has an operating deficit.

Labour is desperate to panic National into showing its hand too early. Over the next four weeks they will make wilder and wilder claims about what National is promising. They will claim $10, $15, $20 billion of tax relief and spending. They will claim interest rates will double. In fact they will probably claim the sky will fall in also.

Comparing the Stories

It’s interesting to compare the NZ Herald and Dom Post stories on yesterday’s personal attacks in Parliament.

I think the Herald story has represented the situation much fairer. It mentions the frequency and context of the attacks on Nick Smith:

Yesterday’s jousting was triggered when Foreign Affairs and Trade Minister Phil Goff told National MP Nick Smith to “take his medication” after interjecting while the minister spoke.

The Government has frequently insulted Dr Smith with the suggestion, perceived as a reference to the stress leave he was put on by National in the wake of the leadership coup against former leader Bill English.

It also gives a much more detailed account of what happened.

In the Dom Post story, it almost looks like Nick Smith was the instigator. Instead of factually reporting that they had been yelling out “take you medicine” at him for months, they merely reported that he claimed he had been provoked by a campaign of personal abuse by the Government.

I should point out that sub-editors often chop a story about, so this is no criticism of the reporters concerned.

I should also point out that I think it is unfortunate (but understandable) that Nick responded in quite the way he did. He was absolutely right to call the House’s attention to the incredibly nasty campaign that Labour had been waging, but he would have been better to not name specific Labour MPs as examples that National had left alone. He would have been best to just say generally that National has never made issue out of the private alcohol issues certain Labour MPs have had.

But reacting in anger is understandable, faced with what Goff and Mallard had been doing. And the creep of the week award has to go to Phil Goff who with a smirk on his face said that his repeated comments to Nick to “take his medicine” were something he would say to any MP interjecting. Everyone knows that is not the case.

Anyway the whole issue is pretty distasteful, and hopefully the publicity from all this will stop such comments in the future. As I said yesterday, I’m all for a robust, even aggressive, debating chamber. But there are limits, and they have been breached too often in recent times.

Apple Protest March

Orchardists marched on Wellington yesterday to protest that the Government was only referring the Australian ban on NZ apples to a committee, rather than to a formal dispute procedure. What they find especially galling is that they know that the chance of winning, if a formal dispute is advocated, is even higher than the chance that George Hawkins will ever be Prime Minister.

So knowing we have a great case, which we are guaranteed to win, they are understandably upset the Government is refusing to stand up for them.

After marching on Parliament they also marched to the Australian High Commission, which happens to be next door to where I live. The irony is that the Commission staff were really looking forward to the protest, because they had been told a box of NZ apples was going to be handed over. Said staff were very keen on the idea of free yummy apples for a couple of weeks 🙂

Getting geekier

While I have a pretty good operational understanding of the Internet, I am by no means a ‘techo’. Some of the people at InternetNZ are literally real experts in their areas, as they make their living from being able to keep portions of the Internet running.

So in all my years with InternetNZ, I have been on admin cmtes, legal cmtes, international cmtes, policy cmtes, constitutional cmtes, executive cmtes but the one committee I have never been on (for good reason) is the technical committee.

However I am having a brief spell as the Acting President, and the President is ex officio a member of every committee and task force. So today I am taking part in my first (and possibly last) meeting of the Technical Committee.

I did ask everyone to speak slowly for my benefit 🙂

Very nasty

For some weeks and months as I have watched question time, I have been very disquieted by the way certain Labour MPs always interject “take your medicine” when Nick Smith is interjecting.

Now let’s be blunt. This is Labour referring to the fact that Nick took some stress leave during his brief tenure as Deputy Leader. They do not say this to any other MP – only to Nick.

Now National has been very gentlemanly over the years about not capitalising on shall we say health issues of Labour MPs. There was an incident about a Labour Spokesperson in the 1990s which National left alone. Mark Peck’s problems were also treated with sympathy, as should be the case. This is in total contrast to what Labour are doing.

What Labour has been doing in the House is downright nasty, and they should be ashamed of themselves. I’m the last person to say the House should not be full of robust debate, and merciless for gaffes etc. But insinuating this stuff is just pathetic.

Spinning the Polls

Some more ACT Billboards

Welcome Tim

A big welcome to Tim Barnett who becomes the first Labour MP to blog (Tamihere’s did not count as the only one he did himself got the blog deleted for being defamatory)

Tim is one of my favourite Labour MPs. Now that may be a bit like saying Jawbreaker is one of my favourite killer pitbull terriers, but hey all things are relative 🙂

I look forward to his blog, and will add it to my blogroll.

Taxpayer Funded Advertising

Yay someone else remembered

Even John Armstrong in the Herald was saying no-one could recall a PM being evicted before, but NZPA’s Ian Llewellyn confirms I am not imagining things by saying “It brought back memories of another Labour prime minister David Lange and Opposition leader Jim Bolger both being removed in 1987, the pair leaving the House arm-in-arm.”

My recollection also is that Lange and Bolger thought it was hilarious they got evicted simulteanously.

60% increase in fleeing Kiwis

NZ First Treaty Policy

NZ First has released its Treaty of Waitangi policy, and for once I have to say not too much I disagree with.

If National does end up in a coalition with NZ First, this is one area where Peters may be useful because to be blunt a Maori MP can say things like ‘while appropriate in some cases, powhiri had become “costly token gestures, with a rent-a-kaumatua to cheapen both the integrity of the Maori involved and often cause discomfort for those who have to sit through it”.’ without being called a racist.

Personally I usually enjoy having a Maori dimension to conferences. I absolutely love the Maori version of the National Anthem. But sometimes one almost gets blackmailed into having a powhiri for any public event, and as Peters says they become token gestures.

I’m also not quite as extreme as to say one should abolish all education for Government employees on the Treaty. There is a happy medium between the current gravy train, and saying the Treaty is of no consequence at all for Government. But I’d say 90% of it is unnecessary.

Flu Vaccine

Had my flu vaccine yesterday, which meant was a bit queasy for a few hours, and had a sore arm. But definitely worth it as I really can not afford to be seriously sick until after the election!

Even happier as I read today that three kids have died from the flu so far this year. How tragic.

The vaccine takes two weeks to work, and I am off overseas in 16 days, so got it just in time!

Batman Begins

Saw Batman Begins last night with Disease Girl and really really liked it. Definitely the best of the series.

They did everything well. The plot actually worked, the romance angle was minimal – not soppy (Katie Holmes very hot though), the casting was good etc.

The batmobile absolutely rocked. Think more a fast moving tank than the traditional batmobile. Also loved the scene where Bruce Wayne overcomes his fear of bats and is surrounded in the cave with thousands of them flying all around him. The scene worked well.

My other favourite scene was where Bruce Wayne is on the town with two lovely models. The restaurant manager informs him that the fountain is not actually designed for swimming, and furthermore his two (very drunk) companions do not seem to have any swimwear (in birthday suits IIRC). He then buys the hotel and jumps in to join them 🙂

Overall a very enjoyable and well made movie. Not a brilliant movie, but a very good one. Afterwards had the usual good meal at Big Thumb.

I must be getting old

TVNZ are saying this is the first time in living memory of the oldest press gallery reporters that a PM has been kicked out of the house.

However I can recall David Lange being booted out as PM. I wasn’t at Parliament then but remember it happening when I was a uni student. I’m not that old!

St Molesworth: Top 10 thinnest books of 2005

St Molesworth’s Top 10 thinnest books of 2005:

Highlgihts include:

2. The Care and Management of Domestic Animals by John Tamihere.

6. Good Island Food by Lana Coc Croft.

8. Probing Parliamentary Questions by Diane Yates.

9. The Burden of Fame by Martin Gallagher.

10. Good things about David Cunliffe by Clayton Cosgrove.

Ahmed Zaoui

The NZ Herald has details of the Supreme Court decision on Ahmed Zaoui.

Frog has some excellent analysis of the pros and cons for Zaoui. No Right Turn has also gone into good detail, with his major concern being that Winston may be Immigration Minister when a decision is made.

Personally I think Zaoui will not have the security risk certificate upheld by the Inspector-General. This is because of the new threshold to deport which is “the person in question must be thought on reasonable grounds to pose a serious threat to the security of New Zealand; the threat must be based on objectively reasonable grounds and the threatened harm must be substantial.”

I beleive Zaoui had been supportive of terrorist activity in Europe, and that the criminal convictions against him were justified. However that does not mean he poses a substantial and serious threat to NZ directly. Our physical isolation, lack of support networks for any such activity, plus the fact he is so well known that he would be unable to do anything covertly, all add up to a very hard task to say he poses a serious threat to NZ directly.

So my pick is the certificate will not be upheld. And unless I am mistaken the Minister only gets discretion if it it is upheld (ie they can still decline to deport) but they do not have discretion if it is not upheld. Not 100% sure on that last point though.

ACT Billboards

Out!

Heh heh Speaker Margaret Wilson just evicted the Prime Minister from the House for disorderly behaviour!

This is pretty rare. I do recall in the 1980s that David Lange and then Opp Ldr Jim Bolger both got kicked out of the house. They were reputed to have cracked uop laughing the moment they were out.

Not that I think there is anything wrong with the occassional disorderly behaviour, as long as not up to the Mallard level.

UPDATE: Heh, heh. I had been thinking of commenting that one would never see Don Brash ejected, but just as well I didn’t as he also got kicked out a minute ago. They are lively today!

Middle East News

OBERAC vs Cash Surplus

Keith Ng has done some useful research for his blog.

Keith has looked at what Dr Cullen said when the OBERAC was introduced in 2001:

“the OBERAC, which may be regarded as the measure of the underlying surplus…”

He also points out that the cash surplus was not mentioned in his 2000, 2001, 2002, 2003 or 2004 budget speeches. Only in 2005, when he needed to try and con people into thinking there was no room for significant tax relief, did it appear in a budget speech. Anyone who trys to argue that capital expenditure should be funded out of operating surpluses, is intellectualy dishonest in my opinion.

Keith, not known for his advocacy for the centre-right (on the basis he blogs at Public Address :-), basically says the same thing:

It’s baffling. Not only is it just a load of shit, it’s an load of shit that politically negates the work he’s done over the past five years. It obscures his true, reasonable, honestly impressive objectives and replaces it with an unbelievable and unbelieved lie that would serve little purpose even if it was believed.

Incidentially I disagree with Keith on the issue of large surpluses needed for future superannuation, but we’ll debate that another day.

The scare campaign begins

Heard the PM on radio saying how she would try to portray tax cuts as resulting in the spending cuts of the early 1990s.

Pretty desperate stuff, but as some may fall for it, let’s make clear the difference:

In 1990 National inherited a government which had been running Enron style books. The ‘public’ surplus turned out to be a $5 billion projected deficit. Spending cuts were needed to keep the country from bankruptcy. Incidentially they worked, the budget got balanced, and the economy grew from 1991 until the Asian Crisis. National also passed the Fiscal Responsibility Act to ensure that no Government could ever do what Labour had done and use the cash accounts to portray the overall health of the economy.

In 2005 rather than a $5 billion deficit, we have what looks to be an $8 billion surplus. This is possibly the largest surplus as a % of GDP in the world. It is certainly many times higher than Australia (which is also offering tax relief). One can offer significant tax relief, and still have a surplus. Labour would claim there is no money for tax relief even if the surplus was $20 billion.

So trying to equate tax cuts when faced with an $8 billion surplus, with necessitating the expenditure cuts of 1990/91 which was due to a $5 billion deficit is dishonest on many levels.

Having said that a National Government will of course cut out wasteful spending in areas where this can be done without affecting desirable services. In fact any responsible Government should be doing this. And anyone who thinks there is no waste, has been in a different country for the last few years.

Big News in the Herald

Dave Crampton from Big News has a column in the NZ Herald on the issue of smacking of children.

It is an excellent piece and I agree with Dave that “What is needed is reasoned debate on what constitutes reasonable force, or what constitutes assault in terms of physical discipline”.

Personally I can be persuaded to amend or remove Section 59 as a step towards lessening child abuse, but it does seem the real motivation for some is to use this as a proxy to campaign against smacking children at all, and equating smacking with child abuse is daft. The vast majority of parents know what is best for their child, and that may include smacking them if for example they try to run accross the road by themselves. The law should protect the children from the small minority of families who are abused, but should not be used to equate smacking with abuse.

Fisking Che Guevara

Peter Calder in the NZ Herald writes about the outrage from some on the left after he effectively fisked the romantic legend of Che Guevara and Cuba, pointing out that the former became a “Stalinist revolutionary thug who summarily executed dissenters; who founded the forced labour camps that would later hold dissidents, homosexuals and people with Aids; who ached for the Cuban Missile Crisis to escalate into purifying nuclear holocaust; who abandoned the revolution because he thought Castro was a sissy; and who died in Bolivia organising a peasant revolution that failed to enlist the support of so much as a single Bolivian peasant”.

What I find most interesting is the email sent to Calder which expressed surprise that “a journalist with liberal credentials” would write what he wrote. He notes the comment reveals an assumption that runs through his critics