Colin James on the Government

The Colin James article today is a must read.

He sums up brillantly what has caused the Government’s problems:

Competence is a matter of management. Who managed NCEA into a mess? Trevor Mallard. Who managed tertiary education into a mess of wasted money? Steve Maharey …

Who managed immigration into a vote factory for Peters? Lianne Dalziel and Paul Swain.

Who managed hospital waiting lists into Neverland? Annette King. …

Who managed tax into a losing issue? Michael Cullen.

James also highlights the improved performance of National.

The u-turns have started

Labour have started the u-turns. They have now agreed to two amendments to the RMA which they have oppossed for six years. Still leaves a long way to go with the RMA, but significant that they are starting to move on issues of concern such as the RMA and the wananaga.

Pity they did nothing for six years, and only now listen a few weeks before an election.

How long will it be until they announce that they will bring forward their 67 cent a week tax cut to next year instead of 2008?

PM right on NZ First super promises

The PM is correct in saying the promise by NZ First to boost superannuation payments to 72.5 per cent of the average wage is a bad thing.

The current superannuation scheme is already the most generous in the world. It is barely sustainable into the future with an ageing population. Promising to increase payemnts even further is the height of irresponsibility, as it will in fact increase the chance of requiring major changes in the future.

NBR vs DPF

NBR did one of their better piss-takes of me last week. As part of a collection of e-mails paying tribute to Graham Kelly, they included:

David P Farrar: Though we never met, I was – I now realise – one of Graham Kelly’s most trusted friends. Unfortunately, his big mouth sometimes let him down and there was even a hint of sneaking arrogance in his public pronouncements. Now if you’ll excuse me, I must get back to my weblog, where I am in the middle of giving my frank opinion on a sub judice criminal matter that no one else in New Zealand except me is allowed to publish commentary on.

Consensus of said friends is I deserved that one. Incidentially people used to comment to me when I got a mention in NBR. Now they only comment when I don’t get a mention!! Personally I’m still waiting for them to realise Russell is a much more fun target again 🙂

Coffee

Pod has become my regular coffee place. Parlty because it has great coffee and great food, but also because it is within 2 blocks of InternetNZ, National HQ, Curia’s office and Mark’s campaign office. In other words in my neck of town.

I met Desperate Gorgeous Jewish Housewife there for coffee this afternoon. A 15 minute catch up went on for over an hour, as we cheerfully discussed how to best control the media and the banking system.

After just ten minutes of talking DGJH displayed her psychological training as we discussed the wasteland known as my previous relationships and proclaimed “I know your type, you need women who dominate you”. I didn’t take this as an offer, as DGJH had rejected my two offers to date of marriage (something to do with having a current husband). I probably should also refrain from marriage offers to people I’ve yet to meet!

DGJH also said I should do more within the Jewish community. The fact I am technically not Jewish (just of Jewish descent) did not seem to be an barrier to her enthusiasm. I was deemed Jewish enough though for us to swap highly offensive Jewish jokes.

Anyway a very pleasant catchup, and nice to have a new friend. Just hope me claiming her as a friend doesn’t end up as being newsworthy for NBR!

ACT Billboards

Once again you know the billboards are great when other parties build on them.

I have to say I like this ACT one a lot. It is very cheeky but nicely reinforces National’s message, while also differentiating ACT.

If the debate ends up being between National and ACT over how much tax cuts, and how soon, then we have all won.

One News Poll on Tax

One News had a Colmar Brunton poll on tax.

With regard to Labour’s miserly budget tax changes, 13% say this made them more likely to vote National, and 7% more likely to vote Labour. That is a net 6% gain for National, which sounds about right with what we see in the polls.

I’m not quite sure how they worded the question, but they also reported that 51% said tax cuts could be funded through eliminating government waste, and 49% [42% actually] I think said from surpluses.

The surpluses are certainly what will fund the majority of any tax relief, in my opinion. But if getting rid of waste can get a few less dollars a week taken off taxpayers, all the better.

Amazing!

******* Telecom

Blog has been down most of the day, due to major Telecom outage. A lot of Internet stuff has been down also.

UPDATE: If an MP has a spare question slot in Parliament tomorrow, they may want to ask if the outage today disabled the home monitoring service for those on home detention?

How to stop youth drinking

In Virginia they are getting tough on youth drinking. A couple who served alcohol at their son’s 16th birthday were sentenced to eight years in prison. The appeal court has reduced this to *only* 27 months.

National Review Online is appalled.

Well if they bring in those laws here. Miss Ten will be on lemonade until she is 21 🙂

Kyoto Responsibility

Certain commentators from the left said I “should be ashamed of myself” for calling for Hodgson to go over the Kyoto blunder.

I did wonder if I was being too harsh ascribing blame at the Ministerial level. But then I read the Press editorial this morning:

“For this [support for withdrawing from Kyoto] the Government has only itself to blame, or, more accurately, Pete Hodgson, the Energy Minister. It was his responsibility to get the calculations right. Not only did he fail to do so but he advocated our participation in the convention, largely, on the carbon credits coming our way.”

But it gets better, and goes on to call him an incompetent Minister:

“In a democracy more demanding of ministerial accountability, Hodgson would today be on the back benches. He is slowly shifting from the energy portfolio to health, but that Cabinet responsibility is even more politically sensitive and complex than is energy. Hodgson’s record gives no confidence that he can be relied on.

Further, his whole administration of the energy portfolio cannot be relied on. If he made so monumental a mistake with the carbon credits, what other mistakes has he made with ensuring the nation’s energy supplies? His performance needs an independent and high powered audit.

With an election approaching and growing concerns about its performance, the Government is unlikely to open one of its senior ministers to scrutiny. But it must move to re-establish confidence in Kyoto. The issues impact heavily on New Zealand’s future prosperity and cannot be left in the control of an incompetent minister. “

Well should the Press be ashamed of itself also?

What do we want?

Student activists traditionally chant:

“What do we want?”
“Free Education”
“When do we want it?”
“Now”

The Fairfax poll suggests the chant going around the land is:

“What do we want?”
“Tax Cuts”
“When do we want it?”
“Now”

Now only do 75% of NZers want tax cuts, so do 67% of Labour voters. Now Labour is planning a scare campaign that tax cuts means cuts in public services (in fact can be funded out of surpluses alone) but even if they do mean a cut in public services, you still have over half in favour.

Now a poll in April only had 28% of people supporting tax cuts, so the magnitude of the Government’s budget own goal is becoming clear.

Yum

One Network News Poll June 2005

Tonight’s One Network News/CB Poll continues the trend of all the other polls showing Labour has gone downhill since the budget.

Party vote results are:

National 43% (+6)
Lab 41% (-3)
Maori 2% (nc)
ACT 2% (nc)
NZF 7% (-1)
United 1% (nc)
Green 3% (-1)

Now on these poll results, and assuming no electorate seats change hands, Parliament would be:

National 55 (+28)
Labour 52 (+1)
NZ First 9 (-4)
Maori 3 (+2)
United 1 (-7)
Progressive 1 (-1)
Green 0 (-9)
ACT 0 (-9)

Total 121 (+1)

Potential Governments would be:

Nat/NZF 64 seats
Lab/NZF 61 seats

No Government could be formed without NZ First.

If the Maori Party wins more than 3 electorate seats, or the Greens do make 5%, then Labour would need one of those parties, *as well as* NZ First to form a Government.

Kiwi Carnival #1

Kyoto continued

Search Terms

So far in June the top ten search terms are:

1 schapelle corby
2 diversity
3 car crash
4 david farrar
5 penguins
6 kiwiblog
7 excellent
8 penguin
9 graham capill
10 stag party

Around 8,000 people a month are accessing it via search engine keywords. SOme of the more amusing ones are:

lipstick party (32 hits)
police porn (29 hits)
tomatina (29 hits)
miss universe (24 hits)
chicks with guns (12 hits)
dart vader nooooooo (9 hits)
ding dong the witch is dead (8 hits)
queef (8 hits)
jenna bush (7 hits)
penguin sex (6 hits)
10 reasons why sex is good (2 hits)
emily braunstein (2 hits)
frank kitts park swings and slide photos (2 hits)
how to score a girl (2 hits)
orgasms while breastfeeding (2 hits)
rebecca loos pig download (2 hits)
all men are rapists
can i be forced to work with someone who has slandered me
dpf stories mothers and daughters
famous people who were born september 11th
popular and competent helen clark victim of my own success
sex in iran
the fucking great wall of china

The Tipping Point

Elite Artists

The SST has a story on Merilyn Tweedie’s refusal to talk to media, despite receiving $500,000 of taxpayer funding.

Painter Grahame Sydney has defended this, saying “Tweedie had no obligation to explain herself or her work” and “The public isn’t in this equation”.

If that is so, can we have our $500,000 back please as we are not part of this equation.

Tamihere issue not quite dead

I think Tamihere will be out of Parliament in a few months, so am not that interested in the latest updates on the Waipareira Trust, but can’t fail to note the HOS story which shows “he or his family got benefits of at least $9500 from the account” , which $20,000 of the stolen $100,000 was paid into.

Remember Helen and Michael say that all the allegations were false, and Tamihere did nothing wrong. People I hope will make up their own minds.

Nuclear Ships Ban

The nuclear ships ban is in some ways a relic. If someone got up today and proposed such a ban they would be laughed at, because the reality is that no US ships have nuclear missiles anymore (except the attack subs which would not visit) and almost no ships even have nuclear power (the exception being once again the subs, and also some aircraft carriers which are most unlikely to visit). It’s a bit like wanting a ban on hydrogen filled blimps.

The Herald on Sunday has results of a “private” poll which shows 62% of NZers support US ships being able to visit, as long as they are not nuclear armed. Now I think the questions were slightly leading and the actual situation is closer to 50/50.

Now some people want the CR parties to campaign to amend the legislation, so that if they win office the law will be changed. They assume this would be welcomed by the United States.

In my opinion they are wrong and I base this on many discussions with various US officials over the years. They certainly very much want NZ to amend the legislation, but they don’t want the law changing backwards and forwards every six years as Governments change from CR to CL and vice-versa. And they especially do not want the NZ/US relationship being a controversial partisan election issue every three years. This would actually damage the relationship more than the current situation.

If one wants a permament solution to the silly stand-off on this issue, then one is going to need to get Labour to agree to amending the law. Now this is not as impossible as some might think, as a number of Labour MPs agree the ban on nuclear-powered ships is stupid, if for no other reason than the fact there are almost no nuclear-powered ships left to ban.

Incidentially the solutions are not just in the hands of NZ. As I said previously, both countries need to compromise on this issue – as it is silly having a stand off on what is basically a symbolic law only.

Barking Mad

This post by Bren, persuaded me to go visit Brian Tamaki’s website which is at the modestly styled bishoptamaki.org.nz.

Now I don’t know where to start. Perhaps with calling the media a modern day witchcraft. Now I’ve certainly heard one or two of the female press gallery reporters referred to as bitches, but never as witches.

Then he declares we have an evil government. I am more charitable and prefer to think of them as merely misguided. But Bishop Tamaki declares they are evil because not all of their MPs would swear on the bible, and one even swore on the Koran. Well I am not the greatest fan of Islam around, but I actually liked the fact that Ashrad Choudary swore on the Koran as a nice reflection of a diverse society.

Tamaki attacks Peter Dunne for voting for the Homosexual Law Reform Bill in 1986. So I presume he wants people to be jailed for homosexual activity, as was the case before the law changed.

He is coming to Wellington (actually Lower Hutt) on 8 July. What a pity I will be overseas as would love to go along and ask some questions.

Borowitz Report

Coalition Options

The Fairfax poll has 68% saying they want coalition preferences known before the election. This is somewhat naive as such things really do depend on how much vote each party gets. A major factor in 1996 in NZ First choosing National over Labour was that NZ First/National could form a two-party majority while with Labour would have needed the Alliance.

But we do know a fair bit already about who might go with whom. Let’s review:

ACT: Would only support National

Green: Would only support Labour

Maori: 90% likely to support Labour, 10% chance could support National

Progressive: Would only support Labour

Destiny: Shudder

United Future: Claims it will negotiate first with largest party. If all other things are equal I would say 80% likely to support National.

NZ First: This is the big one which people want to know. I put him at 75% likely to support Labour. My rationale is below:

1) Claiming Policy Wins

There is a strong incentive for Peters to choose to keep the incumbent party in Government, as he did in 1996. The reason for this is he can then claim credit for any new policies or initiatives such as extra police.

However if you go in with current Opposition parties, then it is much harder to distinguish what are

Dom Post on Tax Cuts

The Dom Post sums things up well:

The worst mistake is misreading the public mood on tax cuts, compounded by a blunder over the Budget strategy.

That strategy, which even the Government now acknowledges was flawed, allowed expectations of cuts to build up and then delivered what most voters would have rightly considered a joke