Tim Grosser

I am delighted to hear the news that Tim Grosser will be a National MP after the election. Tim spoke to a Young Nats conference in the early to mid 90s on GATT/WTO issues (he was our chief negotiator) and everyone there was hugely impressed with him.

Grosser has had a great reputation, and was no small player in some of the multi-lateral trade deals which were worth billions to NZ. This man is a very very talented person, who has achieved great things for NZ.

It is appalling to have Labour’s Jim Sutton accuse such a loyal civil srervant of betrayal, simply for deciding to stand for Parliament. As No Right Turn points out, this is hypocrisy when you consider the huge number of civil servants which stand for Labour.

In fact Sutton’s reaction displays the arrogance all too common with this Government. We see this with Clark also – that not backing the *Labour* Government is somehow unpatriotic.

If Jim Sutton really cared about putting NZ ahead of partisan politics, then he would allow Tim Grosser to continue the work he is doing until the day he has to stand down (20 – 27 days before the election).

Beijing

Despite conference, have managed to head into Beijing on Friday and Saturday night. On Friday four of us slipped away after the official conference dinner.

We went to Tiamannen Square and looked around there. Large is the word that comes to mind. The square, the buildings etc. I looked for tank tread marks but they seem to have all been claned up 🙂

After taking the taxi to the square, we then decided to take the subway home. A good plan except for the minor detail that we got off one stop too early. And while on the map it looked to be only one block away, their blocks are around 45 minutes walk. We then decided to go to a local bar to recover. The beer was around 3 yuan, or NZ 50c. Nice.

Beijing is a huge city – three times as many people live there than in all of NZ – 13 million residents. It is not a greatly attractive city, but still somewhat impressive. As big as Beijing is, it is daunting to think the capital city is only 1% of the total population.

On Saturday night wqe were all sick of hotel food, so we turned down the free dinner at the Asia Hotel, and went into town for food. I had been warned that China does not have three or four course meals, but ten to twleve courses, and this was true. You never leave hungry.

After dinner the group of us (a Kenyan, an Indonesian, a Swiss, a Malaysian and a Canadian) went shopping. We had been advised that you should haggle on prices. I did reasonably well getting two silk ties for 25 yuan (NZ$4) which started at 150 yuan each. Also got some leather shoes for 100 yuan (NZ$16) which started at 550 yuan. So have done my bit for free trade.

While out shopping was approached by a young (as in looked 18) girl who asked if I spoke English and would I like a drink somewhere. I assumed it was a solicitation and started saying that I had to meet friends in 20 minutes. Somewhat bemused when she said it won’t take that long. I inquired further, and eventually disocovered that she is learning English at Beijing University, and that it is quite common for students to just want to talk to foreigners to improve their language skills. So we drank tea for 20 minutes and just chatted. Felt somewhat guilty for assuming she was a prostitute, but there are quite a few of them around also.

Talking of night-time activities, I noted with amusement that in China not only do you have to register at the hotel, any guest who wants to visit you in your room, they must leave by 11 pm. Just like being back in a university hostel 🙂

Star Wars breaks records

It is somehow fitting that the final Star Wars movie has become the first movie in history to sell US$50m in a single day.

I wanted to find a cinema in Beijing to watch it, but no surprise none are in English.

Peter Matcalfe has done a useful and funny review of it. I can’t link to it at present, but he is listed on the main links on the right.

Kiwis Fleeing

The net migration to Australia increased by a massive 59% last year. It was 11,387 and is now 18,186. I can’t recall such a huge increase for many years.

The Dom Post has a story on this. The Government’s only response is “They go up and down.”

The lies start

Wow that did not take long. Having mucked up its own budget so badly, Labour are now telling lies about what National will do.

In the Dominion Post, Dr Cullen says “National can’t propose large-scale tax cuts without large-scale expenditure decrease at the same time”. This is absolute lies of course. First of all one could for example deliver $6 billion of tax cuts over three years without even touching expenditure. It is simply known as a smaller surplus. And you know both this year and next year it is going to be $8 billion or so.

And *even* if National did propose different levels of expenditure to Labour (which I hope they will), then even then it will not be expenditure cuts but merely a slower level of future expenditure increases. And considering the appaling quality of so much of the extra spending to date under Labour, this would be a good thing as one may end up getting better results.

A great disaster

Day II in China

I got absolutely fleeced at the Airport on Thursday. As I was walking to the taxi stand, a local saw gullible foreigner and said he can arrange taxi. They had a proper kiosk where we checked hotel on map. The cost was 400 yuan (NZ$70) which I thought was a bit steep, but agreed. Only later I realise this was massively over-priced. As a comparison a one day tour to the Great Wall costs only 260 yuan (NZ$40).

You do notice the Internet censorship. All blogspot.com is blocked which is annoying, however I can still view most of them through my bloglines viewer. Other large blog hosts are fine though. The top 20 hits for Dalai Lama in Google all come up as non existent if you try to go through to them.

However on the other hand I did enjoy reading the local paper which called on countries to commit to free trade. Also the media do criticize the Government in some areas, just never on anything major. And just to prove some things are universal, the major story was the screening of the third Star Wars movie, with quotes from fans.

Freiday was 1st day of the meetings with the All-China Youth Federation and Government. Met the Vice-Chairman of the National People

A strategic blunder

For a couple of years my biggest worry, in a partisan sense, was that Labour would introduce significant tax relief in this budget. If they had done so, it would have made it very difficult to campaign against a Government which was saying “Hey we are spending more in core areas, and also running the economy well enough to give you some of your taxes back”.

But Labour have made what I consider to be a strategic blunder. They should have either introduced significant tax relief, or they should have stuck to their guns on making no changes. But by having their President allude to a deep dark secret, and have it turn into a miniscule amount which you have to wait three years for, they have over-promised and under-delivered.

Making people wait three years, when you have an $8B surplus is basically insulting.

The original version of this post had links to ten different editorials and articles all saying much the same thing. But the bloody filters here blocked it, and I lost it all. Suffice to say I have never seen such all-round negativity in terms of budget coverage as with this one.

The ball is firmly with John Key and co to come up with an affordable and realistic alternative.

Wellington Airport

Jordan has blogged (no I can not link to it, as he is banned in China) his frustration at the constantly (closed 14 times in four months) fog-closed Wellington Airport. It is more than a minor nuisance, as one of the participants from NZ to this meeting, Jacinda, has been unable to attend at all as the closures meant she would not be able to get here until after it was half over.

No easy answer as the airport can not be extended enough to allow the equipment to land in the fog. Perhaps we could build one next to the inner-city bypass, while we have the demolition gear already there 🙂

Benson-Pope Inquiry

Tertiary Changes

The changes for tertiary students are so small (even smaller than the so called tax cuts) that they barely come to $15 million/year.

It is interesting that the Government is raising the income threshold for which students can earn money, but not raising the parental income threshold. Was chatting about this issue with a group of students two weeks ago as to what they would prefer.

Almost all of them said an increase in the parental threshold, as they don’t want to be working so many hours that their studies are affected.

Just think – one could almost abolish parental means testing all together, with the money that has been funnelled into sub-degree courses which students don’t even have to turn up to.

Sir Humphrey in NZ Herald

The Budget

Okay am now in China, which is rather appropriate considering Labour’s latest budget.

Looking at the key facts for taxpayers, we now have the 11% of people earning over $60,000 paying 48% of income tax. The top 3% pay 25%.

Next year’s surplus is projected to be a whopping $6.7 billion. And remember that Treasury normally under-estimate by $2 billion or so, thus still looking to over-tax by almost $10 billion.

The so called tax adjustments are so small, and not coming in until, get this, 2008. Something is better than nothing, but as John Key said this is squandering a once in a generation chance to make significant reductions in tax. I mean waiting three years for such a piddling adjustment is almost insulting when you look at the forecast surpluses.

Tax revenue is forecast to reach $54.3B under Labour. This is a huge 78% increase over three terms, if they get the chance. Under National it increased only around 3% a year, as surplus funds were returned.

More analysis later.

Annoying Things III

Around an hour after take-off remembering there was one crucial file you forgot to e-mail before you left, and that your company needs it around five hours before you land.

Nine hours of mild panic including seeing if one could call from the plane (Air NZ not that advanced) and then learning that one very intelligent staff member worked out the file was missing, and needed, and just recreated it herself. Initiative is a wonderful thing.

Annoying Things II

Airport Lounge PCs which have Net Nanny installed. This one allowed me to view my blog, but when I tried to post anything it fatally crashed IE – three times!

Anyway that was Auckland. Now at HK Airport having had a great 12 hours here. HK Airport thank God has wireless so one can use your own laptop.

Have quite a few photos taken, but forgot the cord to download them so will probably only blog them when back.

Annoying Things I

High up the list are airports which show on ther LCD screens a final boarding call for an aircraft, and then when you get there you find that in fact the plane has not even landed yet!!!

I waited for a boarding call, and when none came, but the screen changed to final call, I ran (not a pretty sight) to the gate to find the plane is not even on the ground and delayed for an hour or so.

Complained to Air NZ staff, who agreed it was very bad, but that the airport company controlled the displays, and they had no ability to get them to correct their information. They said it was such a hassle for them they would rather switch the displays off in the lounges.

Letter to AIAL will be sent on my return!

Cathy – if you are reading this, I may be late arriving at HK. Generally though on longer distances they can make up the time.

Finally some blood from the stone

After taking an extra $50 billion in tax over the last few years from us, Dr Cullen may give a tiny bit of it back on Thursday it seems.

This is good of course, but sad it has taken such huge surpluses and pressure to get even a small adjustment. Plus of course everyone knows he would rather keep it all, but their polls and focus groups said it was a vulnerable area for them.

Age of Allegations

I was somewhat surprised to hear the PM on Newstalk ZB suggesting the alleagtions against David Benson-Pope are not credible because they were not made at the time, 20 years ago.

Using that as a precedent then the Police should ignore all historical accusations of rape, child abuse etc.

Bloggus Interruptus

I fly out early tomorrow to the People’s Republic of China (via Hong Kong) for a workshop. Will be fairly busy, so blogging will probably be at reduced volumes. Also there is a chance my blog may be ruled subversive by the Chinese government filters so if there are no updates at all, then that will probably be the reason.

Another golden handshake

Digital Strategy

I attended the launch of the Government’s Digital Strategy yesterday, in the Beehive Foyer. It was a real who’s who of the industry with Telecom’s Theresa Gattung and all the other prominent players there.

I think the IT/Comms area is one where the Government is doing a pretty good job, and the digital strategy, unlike some other documents, actually delivers some very useful initiatives such as $24 million for regional open access broadband networks. Yes I am sceptical in certain areas of the value of the state spending money, but I see stuff like this as core infrastructure, just as important as roads.

The Dom Post has a good focus on what is called cash for Mush!

Also good to see the Government no longer talking about getting better access to broadband, which technically starts at 256 Kb/s but fast broadband of 5 Mb/s or more. There is a big difference between the two. As Citylink says 5 Mb/sec is still not what some would consider fast, but it is a great step forward. Incidentally InternetNZ’s long-term vision is 1 Gb/s access to every house! Talking of InternetNZ their statement on the strategy is here.

David Cunliffe has done well to get the funding for the strategy, and in producing a final strategy significantly tighter than last year’s draft strategy, showing they listened to the feedback.

And to prove he walks the walk, not just talks the talk, he mentioned to me at the launch he does read this blog. And later that day a dreaded ninth floor staffer quoted my own words back to me re something I had blogged that morning. I just hope that H1 and H2 do not use the Internet 🙂

What do we call this scandal?

Is it called bullygate or popegate? 🙂

Anyway onto more serious analysis of the problems facing Mr Benson-Pope. And they are quite grave. As TV3 said yesterday he faces allegations which may not just end his ministerial career, but even force him from Parliament. Not for his discipline methods in the 1980s, but for the fact he has denied them categorically both inside and outside the House.

It is possible of course the allegations are untrue, but five different accusers is a huge number, and I understand more are coming forward by the day. And these are not teenagers but adults in their 30s. According to the NZ Herald one of the men making the accusations is a Labour Party supporter.

It was incredibly foolish of David Benson-Pope to deny categorically the allegations (assuming they are true), considering how many witnesses there must have been. I have some sympathy for an ex-teacher being judged today off disciplinary methods of 20 years ago. If he had just said that he will not get into details, but regrets if any of his ex pupils felt his disciplinary methods were inappropriate, then the issue may be over. But like with Colin Moyle the denials are now the issue.

Peter Metcalfe makes the point that the Government has known of these allegations for months (they have in fact been around since 2000), and did nothing at all to investigate it. In hindsight a bad move.

Sir Humphrey has a wonderful parody of the alleged activities concerning tennis balls had taken place at Abu Grabib Prison.

No Right Turn says the allegations are of sadistic behaviour, well beyond what was acceptable under the law. I agree that hitting a student in the face is clearly unlawful, but some of the other allegations may fall into the inappropriate rather than illegal category. Thus I am uncertain this is simply a matter for the Police.

My sympathy goes out to the staff in Mr Benson-Pope’s ministerial office. These situations are always doubly difficult for the staff, as they are loyal to their boss who risks losing his job, but of course many of their jobs are at risk also if he is sacked.

David Benson-Pope

Student March & Protest

VUWSA President Jeremy is encouraging Victoria students to come and join the protest march on Tuesday, to demand an end to fee increases and a decent pay increase for university staff. Never mind that the two demands are almost contradictory!

Second year student Anna disagrees and expresses shall we say more than mild disapproval at her fellow students demanding more free money from the Government.

Anna’s advice for her fellow students includes:

* We don’t need more wanky university students who lazed around sipping their subsidised by student union cheap coffee discussing how evil right wingers are and how communism just needed to be given a chance.

* Why don’t we give everyone who leaves high school $50,000 to do as they please? Why should only university students get that kind of money?

* How many university students volunteer? And no, I don’t mean putting up posters saying “Save the mucus produced by slugs attached to the spotted green Baloogo plant which only grows on the left side of shady trees in north Peru”.

She concludes by saying “Instead of going to Parliament and presenting ‘a list of your demands’ how about you go help out at a rest home for an afternoon, help kids with their homework, visit volunteer Wellington. When you are actually contributing to society in a healthy way, not by throwing up in the Cuba Mall fountain, then the government should look at whether you need more money put your way.”