Hubbard: children killing gays

Auckland Mayor Dick Hubbard has revealed more of his true colours by writing a letter against the Civil Union Bill, where one of his grounds was that children of gay couples were more likely to be murdered.

Boy am I glad to be in Wellington where our last three Mayors have been tolerant on this issue, representing the city generally. Fran Wilde credentials are well known. Mark Blumsky, as Mayor, was a vice-patron of the local gay business group and Kerry Prendergast is going to be a celebrant of civil unions.

And in Auckland – the city meant to be even more socially liberal than Wellington, they have managed to replace John Banks as Mayor with possibly one of the few men even more conserative on moral issues. Jesus at this rate they’ll be electing Brian Tamaki in 2007.

UPDATE: Nick Venter in the Dominion Post highlights this is a broken promise also., having said before his election “I have no problem with the Civil Union Bill.”. Yeah no problems with it, except that those nasty gays will murder their children. What a plonker. He has just become a one term Mayor I predict.

Civil Unions Bill Party

Greatly enjoyed the celebration party for the Civil Unions Bill, sorry Act. I think I drank even more than at the National Caucus bash the night before!

As I entered Parliament again I discovered Parliamentary Security read my blog, as they were keen to discuss exactly how I borrowed a swipe card to show someone around yesterday, and whose card it was. I reassured them that I did not do anything inappropriate with it, and would never misbehave after eight years working there.

Then entering the Grand Hall found my name wasn’t on the “list” but luckily Ramon (Tim Barnett’s partner) recognised me and got me through.

There were 150+ people there and it was just so positive and happy. As some speakers remarked this was not about abstracts but about real people in real relationships, and one can not underestimate how important today was to so many people. They were hugging, kissing, dancing and just celbrating how glad they are to be in a liberal tolerant country like NZ.

I won’t try and summarise all the speeches as there were too many. Fran Wilde was MC for the night and we had speeches from David Benson Pope, the two organisers of the campaign (can”t recall names), Clem Simich, Jonathan Hunt, Moana Mackey, Matt Robson, Chris Carter, Lianne Dalziel and Tim Barnett.

Clem got an absolutely huge round of support and gave a stunning speech on why he supported the CUB, what it means to families etc. I have never been more proud of Clem Simich than during his speech tonight, and if National win the next election he will be a superb Speaker. Matt Robson even offered to sign him up as a Progressive MP as they need to expand 🙂

I was also surprised, yet very pleased, when Clem mentioned Katherine Rich’s name and there was loud sustained applause. A lot of people appreciated how staunch she has been on this issue.

The biggest round of applause was for Tim Barnett (actually I think Tony his secretary may have got even more cheers!). Tim played a huge role in managing the numbers for the bill. I was very impressed when I met with him last week to discuss suitable MPs to lobby and twice during the meeting he had updates on moving MPs from one column to another, definites probables, possibles and no hopes etc. It was a nice example of how a professional political campaign should be run (I have done similiar for candidate selections).

If Peter Brown had 10% of the skills Tim has, the Euthanasia bill would have got past at least first reading.

As I said, it was a great celebration party. It was really nice being a very small part of helping something positive happen, rather than oppossing something negative.

Well I can’t see too many typos so I’ll post this now. Of course I am fairly pissed so I may have missed a few 🙂

Ahmed Zaoui gets bail

As was widely expected Ahmed Zaoui has been granted bail by the Supreme Court.

Not clear at this point whether it is to Mangere Refugee Centre which the Crown did not oppose or the Dominican Friars which the Crown did.

I don’t think it is a bad thing he has bail. Two years was far too long a period of time to keep someone in prison while resolving his status. Having said that I would still rather he is not given residency here.

UPDATE: I have been told he is bailed to Mangere. Was joked that if anything will scare him off overseas, living there should do it 🙂

UPDATE2: Seems my source is wrong (you’re sacked) and it is to the Dominican Friars. Boy that is a real slap to the Government – effectively saying you have no case at all.

Civil Unions Bill third reading debate

It will be interesting to see whom the parties put up to speak on the final reading, to see if it varies from second reading. Some parties may split their spots as happend last time.

Debate due to start in a few minutes.

And we are off at 3.18 p.m. The Minister David Benson-Ppoe (L) kicks off. Civil Unions take away nothing from people, and gives some people a new choice.

No 2 Bill English (N) says this is a case of horse before cart where civil unions are being created without knowing what rights they will get from the companion bill. Legislating a ceremony and certificate only – is a legal mess. Plus does not believe stats should be absolutely neutral on every relationship. Companion bill may force defactos into relationship rights they do not want.

No 3 Tim Barnett (L). Thanked Michael Wallmannsberger and CUB support team. Taken swipes at Turia, Franks, Worth. Quotes from letter about gay couple together for 50 years. For 45 years no celebration of relationship and for 40 years worried about being arrested so had second bed in house as defence.

No 4/1 Winston Peters (NZF) talking about how fundamental (sic) homosexuals are against this bill as to deliver what Tim Barnett claims they should just amend the marriage act. Says it is duplicity and not give equality. Now on about asset sales!!! Peters concludes saying that denying a referendum is denying homosexuals chance to have their relationships supported by the community and people should vote against Labour for denying them a vote.

No 4/2 Dail Jones (NZF) says marriage is only between a man and a woman for purpose of having children. This bill is present to the coterie of homosexuals and lesbians who surround Helen Clark. Would vote in line with referendum result.

No 5 Stephen Franks (A) this is a deliberate piece of wedge politics. Is an empty bill with a never defined concept. Would have got 75% support for removal of disabilities against a minority. I wanted to support the bill, but this has no substance. Worried about impact on free speech for those who argue homosexuality is wrong. He disagrees with them but will fight for them.

No 6 Nandor Tancozs (G) says people are against because they see it as gay marriage, or will weaken marriage or it is not needed. Is not gay marriage

CUB Photos

Just popped down to Parliament to see the yes and no camps. It was a bit of a carnival with the yes people having a huge stereo system and dancing in celebration. The choice of songs (to do with in love and getting married) is no doubt designed to annoy the no camp.

Photos below:
Continue reading »

Alliance membership doubles

Asher has joined the Alliance, to keep Spanner company 🙂

More seriously I would regard it as a bad thing if the Alliance is not around. I’d like there to be a party of the hard left which doesn’t have the anti science hysteria of the Greens. Just as it is useful to have a party to the right of National.

A damn good party

National had their year end caucus party last night and as always it was a great event. There were a huge number of former staff there and I actually ran out of time to catch up to everyone. Most of the old team from when we were in Government last were there.

It is of course Chatham House rules but within that I can share some experiences as most of them just make me look foolish:

* Had an ACT person ask me if the girl I was talking to was:
a) my wife
b) my daughter
c) my colleague
d) an employee of mine
e) a friend

I responded three out of five were correct, without specifiying which three!

* Strong rumour about a change of job for a former colleague, which has been confirmed and should be public soon.

* Was asked to do a quick tour of Parliament for someone who had not seen it before. Did not let the fact I no longer work there get in the way and borrowed a swipe card. Got nervous when a security guard asked us to stop, but in fact the only issue was my tourist was walking around in bare feet and had to put her heels back on. She also set a record by being the only person in the last ten years (and I have done many tours) who correctly identified the montrosity of a scuplture on the ground floor as representing essence of women, rather than a dinosaur tooth wich most take it to be. Turns out art history is good for something after all!

* Had many many people mention my blog to me, all claiming to love it and read it regularly. Funniest comment was one person saying they thought Miss Ten was beautiful and would love to meet her, and me pointing out that she actually works for him!!! He had been on a leave of absence and the change in hair colour had confused him.

* Just as I did last time, I did a case of mistaken identity and with the same person!! But in reality I didn’t. This time I did know who she was, but she thought I was still confusing her with someone else, and then I thought I was also because of what she had said, until I finally realised I wasn’t. End result is I looked like an absolute dick and seem to have a genetic disability that makes me act retarded in front of pretty blond women.

* Reached agreement with former colleagues that the men’s caucus mailing list needs to be re-established. Don’t ask if you don’t know what it is. And no Belinda, you still are not allowed to subscribe!

* Tried to congratulate all those MPs who had voted for the CUB, but everytime I was, another MP who had voted against joined us.

* Ran into the (very pleasant and attractive) Dom Post reporter who did the big feature on blogging. Introduced her to all my friends as the reporter who wrote the blog story – am sure in hindsight this is not what she wants her career summarised as.

* Rodney complained that my version of the filming in the Backbencher made him look bad. I agreed it does, and that this was preferable to making me look bad. He suggested that as I had asked if the cameras were working I was aware of them. I concede this point.

All in all a really enjoyable night, finished up by a quiet drink at the Backbencher afterwards. Glad they are only every six months, as free alcohol is not good on a regular basis!

CUB Vote

Well the vote is today and a few development but nothing which should change the outcome.

Very pleased to see Deborah Coddington now supporting the bill. Better a late convert than none at all. Deborah does seem to have a history though of initially being against liberal legislation and then being persauded of its merits. Good to see lobbying works.

It has been interesting getting feedback from various MPs about the issue. I know many MPs who are voting against and are not at all homophobic. There are valid reason to vote against, even if I do not agree with them. However the anti-CUB debate has been characterised by such extreme statements from some people, that to be frank they make even those voting with them embarrassed. In fact I suspect if it were a secret ballot, there would now be more than 70 MPs voting in favour, as the way the anti-CUB campaign has conducted itself has been to be honest almost embarrassing, and people want to dissociate themselves from the symbolism of what a defeat would mean.

The infleunce of friends and family on how MPs vote has been interesting as related in this article. Brian Donnelly’s speech was verespecially moving.

I’ll blog this at length one day in another post, but having casual everyday contact with gay people has a huge effect on how people see issues such as this. I know my views on issues such as this have changed 100% from when I was younger and didn’t know any (openly) gay people

Almost everyone under 40 has been in a workplace where one or more colleagues are openly gay, had gay friends, and hence under 40s generally don’t see what all the fuss is.

The third and final reading should start at around 3 p.m. and I’ll live blog it again, rather than actually be at Parliament watching. I suspect there will be a big party afterwards to celebrate!

Four weeks holiday

National has announced that it will not repeal the extra week’s leave (which would be electorally suicidal) but will give people the choice of taking it, or cashing it in.

I like this compromise.

The reality for businesses is that wage rates were going to adjust anyway to take account of the extra week. Sure those in current jobs would not take a pay cut, but it would affect future payrises and job offers.

Giving people the choice of taking the 4th week or cashing it up recognises this.

Enforcing the alcohol pucrhase age

An interesting article on how eight liquot outlets who sold alcohol to a 17 year old girl will not be suspended as she was too good an actress.

I think it was a decent call, as using someone just three months under the age limit, is making it very very hard. I’ve noticed out clubbing that 14 year olds can pass for 25 when they want to. It would have been a better idea for the authorities to use someone who was say 15 or 16 and looked it.

In theory the guidelines are to ask for ID from anyone who looks under 25, and they still should have done it, but a suspension would be a bit too hefty so nice to see some common sense.

Pub Smoking Ban

I did have to laugh when viewing on the news last night one determined pub owner who not only said that he will not be enforcing the smoking ban, but that if any health inspector tries to enter his premises he will take out a tresspass order against them. I think he was from the west coast 🙂

The new law does take effect from midnight tonight. I have mixed feelings on it.

From a principled point of view I have sympathy for the impact it may have on bar owners, and there is a lot of logic to their call for the Government to set clear air standards, rather than a smoking ban. On the other hand I do like the quote that having a smoking area within a bar is like having a peeing area within a swimming pool 🙂

There is a very strong argument that if employees choose to work at a smoking bar, and customers choose to drink there, why should the state interfere? But I depart from the libertarians when I don’t think for example you would allow employees to work in a workplace with asbestos everywhere, and that there is a parallel to passive smoking.

At the end of the day, while I have mixed feelings, I personally can’t wait for the ban to apply, simply because I detest being in smoke filled bars, as it affects me quite badly.

Yes I know that I could choose never to go to a bar which allows smoking, or ask my friends not to smoke when we are out at a bar, but the reality is I would have few friends or social life if I did, and hence I put up with smoke filled bars.

So on the basis of purely what is good for me, I welcome the law, even though on an intellectual and political level I don’t really agree with it.

Hey I almost sound like a politician trying to be on both sides of an issue, like that!!

Free taxis unless you are white

Tukituki National candidate Craig Foss is doing a nice job highlighting the race based policies of this Government.

The local PHO is providing free taxi trips to the doctor for all Maori and PI patients. If you are not Maori or PI, then you only get access if you live in certain streets or hold an appropriate card.

So under this regime a Pakeha family in certain areas who say have a household income of $55,000 have to pay to travel to the doctor, while their Maori neighbour who may have a household income of $100,000 will get a free taxi.

As Craig says you should target on need, not race.

NZ Herald

I know some have not liked it, but I am finding the new NZ Herald website to be really good. They have categorised many stories so one can easily find all stories on a topic, or even all by a particular journalist.

John Armstrong has commented on Peter Brown’s stupidity yesterday, which is good. Hansard didn’t record the comments, and it would be a pity for it to escape recording.

Plaudits also to Sideswipe for crediting the Falwell/Matthews exchange to me and Wonkette. I’ve often seen stuff in newspapers which I suspect was blog originated and was all prepared to get indignant until I saw the credit at the bottom. To be fair Ana Samways is consistently good at souricng info she uses in Sideswipe.

Frequent Visitors

It is interesting to see the most frequent visitorsto this blog, by site, so far in December.

No 1 is Parliament
No 3 is APN (publishers of Herald)
No 7 is TVNZ
No 9 is AUSA

Not far off the top ten I also see the Labour Party Head Office, Airways Corp, IPENZ, and the Ministry of Education.

Certainly a diverse group!

Blackadder speaks out

The UK Government has a bill to ban hate speech, as some also push for in New Zealand.

The very talented Rowan Atkinson has launched a campaign against the bill, specifically the outlawing of inciting religious hatred.

Atkinson says “The freedom to criticise ideas, any ideas – even if they are sincerely held beliefs – is one of the fundamental freedoms of society. A law which attempts to say you can criticise and ridicule ideas as long as they are not religious ideas is a very peculiar law indeed.”

On this issue I agree with No Right Turn who has said the best defence to hate speech, is more speech, not less speech.

Expensive Photo Ops

Regional and Business Development is a bit like motherhood and apple pie – everyone is meant to support it, because I mean it sounds awful not wanting to help poor little businesses.

The problem is that the history of Government to pick winners is very patchy, and as the Auditor-General has pointed out this Government has been handing out money left and right, without clear objectives except to provide photo ops for Jim Anderton and Helen Clark.

Some of the findings include:
* missing paperwork
* no evidence of even basic credit checks
* clear breaches of Cabinet guidelines.
* controls on spending were so loose in some cases that it was not always possible to tell who had received the money or how much had been paid out.
* NZTE had difficulty producing reports of even basic information, including documents detailing the grant recipient, the amount allocated or the amount paid out to date.
* highly critical of the Visiting Investor Programme
* lack of transparency about how the money was spent.
* paperwork backing up expense claims remained of a poor standard.
* officials failed even to document meetings to show what had been achieved.

Jim Anderton thinks there is no problem, and that you don’t want the system to become bureaucratic. Hello Jim you are giving away tens of millions of dollars of my money, and you can’t even provide a report of whoim you have given it to. You should be ashamed.

Rodney has been a long-time critic of the schemes and worth a read on this.

Aaron reads between the lines

MP E-mail Wizard

I’ve avoided using or even looking at the e-mail wizard the Campaign for Civil Unions has been promoting, partly because I have been doubtful how much of a good idea it is to mass e-mail MPs.

I am actually the former staffer who managed to convince some very sceptical Ministers in 1997 to allow people to e-mail them and have a public e-mail address. So I feel guilty when an issue drives their inboxes to overflowing.

Having now looked at the wizard, I must say it is actually a very smart piece of work. Instead of just sending a form letter to every MP, it allows you to either choose an indiviudal MP, a group of MPs from a particular party who voted either yes or no, or all 120 MPs.

It also allows you to write your own e-mail, use some key lines from their campaign, or do a semi-form e-mail. They can tailor e-mails based on your religion, sexuality, race etc.

I am definitely impressed with the sophistication compared to merely having a form which bcc’s to 120 e-mail addresses.

Having said that I am still not a huge fan of mass e-mails to MPs. Basically it so swamps their inboxes that they don’t get to read any of it. I understand that if one side is e-mailing there is a need to balance things up, but it is a pity there is not a better way of doing it. However if one is to mass e-mail MPs, the CUB Campaign wizard is a pretty sophisticated way to do it.

Vote for Risawn!

Nice Maiden Speech

Kenneth Wang gave his maiden speech today. I thought it was a nice positive one.

A part which resonated to me was “As a small business owner I know how tough life can be for the small and medium-sized businesses, which make up 90 percent of all New Zealand’s businesses. For many years I often sacrificed my own wages to pay my staff”

I think a lot of people would be surprised by how common this can be. In one small business I worked for, the owners for many months were paying themselves less than the receptionist, to keep the business going.

Oh sending a letter will do it

The latest outrage in Zimbabwe is the sending of an Opposition MP to jail for a year’s hard labour for pushing a Minister during a debate.

It is tempting to suggest Winston should have got the same for allegedly doing the same to John Banks, but I’ll resist.

The Opposition MP’s family were also evicted from their land in April, and also many of his employees have been killed, raped or shot. Despite six court orders, the land had not been returned.

So what is our Government doing to protest? Oh sending a letter of complaint. Wow that will really have an effect and have Mugabe trembling.

Shouldn’t we be leading the charge for sanctions against Zimbabwe? Sporting, trade, cultural the whole lot. And expel them from the Commonwealth. And make them ineligible for the UN Security Council as Israel is. And halt all foreign aid and development.

Let’s face it the gentle persuasion approach is no more effective with Mugabe than it was with South Africa.

Censorship Policy

Okay a nice short censorship policy. There will also be a seperate posting policy for those who comment.

1. Do you ever edit comments made by other people?

Yes, but only with great reluctance. And I always make it clear that I have edited the comment by noting the changes I made, so it does not look like they wrote it.

2. How often have you had to edit a comment?

Only twice as of today. Once was in relation to comments made about a Mayor, which were highly defamatory, and the other time was in response to a request of behalf of someone who had been mentioned in a comment, and my high Google rating meant it was coming up as the top search for their name.

UPDATE: Actually it is three times. I forgot that last week I edited a comment speculating about someone in a nasty way.

3. Are you liable for comments other make on this blog?

The advice that I have had is that in some circumstances yes I can be. That is why I reserve the absolute right to delete or edit anything on this blog. The advice from a barrister who specialises in Internet law is that if I had knowledge of the comment, and did not delete it, then I could have liability. As all comments made get e-mailed to me, it would be hard for me to deny knowledge (even though some days there are so many I don’t see them all).

4. So if you sometimes delete comments, how often and why?

I delete thousands of commercial spam comments every month. Have I mentioned I detest spammers?

I have only once deleted a comment outright based on its content. That was in fact just in the last week, being an anonymous highly racist comment. I hope this will not be a habit.

I will also delete any comments made by someone I have banned from commenting on my blog. Only one person has been so banned in 18 months. How one gets banned will be dealt with in my Posting Policy.

5. Do you ever edit your own postings, after publication?

Generally only for typos that I have noticed or had pointed out. If new content is added on, this will generally be noted as an update.

I have also been known to occassionally succumb to pressure and blackmail, and delete a photo which the subject objects to as unflattering. There are some fights you just don’t want to endure!

Sage Advice

Mr Sage has summed the blog stats I did, by political alignment, concluding the right blogs are more productive, with more commentary.

Of course the answer might just be that I link to more right blogs than left blogs 🙂

Incidentially Aaron Bhatnagar’s site now allows comments again, so I think every right blog is a bastion of free speech!

While over at Sage, I did have a chuckle at some of his 30 commandments for men. Yes some are old, but I did laugh at the acceptable circumstances for men to cry rule.

Groan

Just now in the House, NZ First Deputy Leader Peter Brown was asked to adjust his microphone. His attempt at humour saw him reply along the lines of that he was nervous about bending over to do so, because of the MPs behind him.

The groans were audible, as were the looks of horror from his own colleagues. The Speaker looked mortified and said he gives up, no doubt thinking what the several visiting MPs from overseas must be thinking.

Choice or Nature

I see Paul Adams has said “The ‘homosexual lifestyle’ should not be portrayed as normal to children, he said. “It is not genetic, it is a choice. We were born male and female as far as I am concerned. We are one or the other.”

I’ve always wanted to ask someone saying that, well when did you decide to be heterosexual. Chris Matthews in the US has done just that, asking Jerry Falwell:

MATTHEWS: How old were you when you chose to be heterosexual?
FALWELL: Oh, I don’t remember that.
MATTHEWS: Well, you must, because you say it’s a big decision.
FALWELL: Well, I started dating when I was about 13.
MATTHEWS: And you had to decide between boys and girls. And you chose girls.
FALWELL: I never had to decide. I never thought about it.

Wonkette has more on it. Very very funny.