Demotion by Promotion

Helen Clark has nominated Attorney-General Margaret Wilson to replace Jonathan Hunt as Speaker.

This is fairly clever politically as it gets rid of a highly unpopular Minister without actually sacking her. It is definitely a demotion from her current role as a highly ranked Minister with five full portfolios and two associates.

This has taken the media by surprise as all the attention was on Burton (probable) and King (possible).

Winston will spit tacks at having his nemesis as Speaker.

I have never regarded Wilson as particularly strong on standing orders or in the House generally. She may struggle in the role.

Incidentially this means that women will hold the top three spots in the order of precedence.

A brave Kiwi crushed

A brave Kiwi who works for an evil multinational corporation blew the whistle on how his employer sustained corruption, failed in its most basic purposes, was dysfunctional and even promoted known corrupt staff members.

The evil multinational corporation has struck back, and has laid him off despite promising not to take action against whistle blowers.

Oh and the name of this evil multinational coorporation. It is the United Nations.

The $800,000 women

Every man and their dog seems to have an opinion on whether Judy Bailey should be getting $800,000.

If TVNZ was a private company I would say it is totally up to them. They know how much money they would lose if they lost her, and presumably pay the amount they figure they need to, in order to maintain ratings and advertising revenue.

But given that St Helen has gone on the record condemning that Paul Holmes was paid around the same level, it is of course fair game to rub her face in this, and ask why after five years the “culture of extravagance” at TVNZ is still there.

In question time a few minutes ago in the house Deborah Coddington made the point that Labour Party President Mike Williams earns almost as much, being paid over $500,000 from having been appointed to eight different boards by the Government. Helen’s catty reply was “yes, but that isn’t for spending four minutes a day on TV”. How correct – it is for running the Labour Party.

Australian High Commission protest

As I live next door to the Australian High Commission I should link to this protest covered on Scoop. It was very amusing.

In fact most of the time there is someone protesting outside the poor Aussies. There has been one lone protester who has spent weeks at a time outside, protesting about something. I don’t think he has ever managed to get noticed.

Two new National Board members

National has announced that it has c-opted two new members to their ruling Board of Directors to replace Eric Roy and David Bennett who will next year be the MPs for Invercargill and Hamilton East respectively.

The first new board member is former Deputy Prime Minister Rt Hon Wyatt Creech. Wyatt is an excellent pick having served previously on the party’s former national executive and having considerable experience in governance and politics.

The other appointment is Peter Goodfellow from Auckland. Peter, like me, has been around for donkey years having joined as a Young National and forgotten to ever leave:-)

Peter has been involved with communications and campaigns for many elections and will also be a big asset to the board with their responsibility of overseeing the campaign.

So congratulations Wyatt and Peter. – remember we will blame you if National loses 🙂

Unis vs Government

Hubbard seeking attention

Dick Hubbard has said he is seeking legal advice over whether the distribution of the NBR story on him should have been included in John Banks’ election return.

He should save some money, as it is pretty clear cut. A copy of a newspaper article is not an election expense, even if a candidate paid for it to be copied and distributed.

Race based funding

National has calculated that more than $6 million of school funding would be reallocated if race based funding was removed from the decile system.

This is a simple issue – if one already is calculating funding needs based on socio-economic data such as income, there is no need to give a school more money because they have more Maori students. A poor pakeha student should attract just as much money as a poor Maori student.

There is also a wider debate to be held on whether the decile system is given too much weighting in funding. IIRC a decile 10 school gets around half the operational funding of a decile 1 school.

Conflicts of Interest

The Government has effectively said no (or at least not now, and probably no) to the plans to make Whenuapai Air Base a commercial airport.

The company involved has accused the Government of acting to support Air New Zealand due to their ownership of the airline..

Now I think the Government made the right call on this issue, but the proponents do have a point. There is a conflict of interest for the Government. This is of course a good reminder of why it is preferable for the Government to own as few competitive enterprises as possible (few=none).

Wellington V8 race

Great to see that a survey has shown heaps of support amongst Wellingtonians for holding the V8 Supercar street race here with 71% very positive, 18% slightly positive and only 5% negative.

It wasn’t a fully scientific random poll, being amongst rugby fans only, but still a great level of support.

Talking of motorsports I had to laugh reading yesetrday about how things are going with Michael Laws in Wanganui and specifically his axing extra funding for the local art gallery. All the locals interviewed agreed with him, with one young resident saying how he would never go to an art gallery but would love to have some money for some sort of demolition derby where he can watch cars smash into each other all day. Why not I say!

Whenuapai Airport

Cabinet is due to make a decision on whether to turn Whenuapai Air Base into a commercial airfield.

If, as reported in the NZ Herald, the Government is sceptical, that is a good thing.

I think it hasn’t got a chance in hell of being comercially viable. Auckland is a tiny city on the wolrd stage compared to those which have more than one airport.
.
Yes driving to Manukau Airport is a pain, but the answer is better motorways, not a second airport.

John Key is a very smart guy and if as the local MP, he is saying he doesn’t support it (a rare principled stand by a local MP not to support something stupid just because it is popular locally) then I really doubt the numbers add up

Tamihere Report

Purely in a professional sense, I have to admire the 9th floor spin machine. We now have newspapers running the headlines that John Tamihere will be cleared by the White Report.

One has to read furthe rin to see it is just referring to the liability over the tax on the $195,000. Well this part of the scandal has been known for some months anyway as the Trust have accepted responsibility. So the clearance relates to something already known.

In the NZ Herald we get some further details. There we find that if their source is correct John Tamihere is in fact criticised over a four-wheel-drive vehicle he received and tax liability for a 1998 bonus of $22,784.

So the tactic is to get the media to focus on the areas where he has been cleared, and not worry about the others.

Sharks

A bit of everything

Saturday was a busy fun day, with a bit of everything, ending with seeing Team America at the Reading Cine-lounge.

7.00 am Start blogging

9.00 am Brunch at Astoria. As usual, run into half a dozen people you know there (Wellington has only one degree of seperation)

11.30 am Xmas Shopping at North City Plaza, Porirua. Managed to get presents for niece, sister in law and stats girl.

2.30 p.m. Xmas Shopping on Lambton Quay. Get present for parents and for Ten while she isn’t looking. Only still got to get presents for brother, Estonian friend and German friend. Everytime I try to buy a nice painting for one of the overseas girls, I am told by Miss 92% in art history that it is awful and I have no taste. The sad thing is she is probably right.

4.00 p.m. Catchup with Blumsky. Head out for look around potential office sites, along with his little dog Winston. Winston normally very placid but goes quite off his head at the Cuba Mall fountains which he tries to attack despite seeing them every day. Very funny.

7.00 p.m. Team America. It wasn’t quite as side splitting funny as the Southpark movie (when you were laughing so much it hurt) but it was still very funny and well worth seeing. The puppet sex scene was hilarious, while the vomiting scene was painfully life like.

The theme song lyrics were of “America, fuck yeah!” were a wonderful pisstake, as was the ending when Gary explained how many americans are dicks, the film actors guild are pussies and the terrorist are arseholes and what happens with different combinations of them. I am already banned by Net Nanny so won’t give the full quote here, but if you are impatient it is the top quote at IMDB quotes for the film..

If you like Southpark you will probably like Team America. It takes the piss out of both conservatives and do gooding liberals, which makes it all the better. Oh and be prepared for certain film stars to die in extremely graphic fashion.

UPDATE: Kiwi Jew Pundit liked it also.

NBR Poll

The NBR Poll on Friday was interesting, showing only a 7% gap between Labour and National. Earlier polls by other compnies had all shown a gap twice as big or more.

The combination of the Zaoui case, civil unions and smoking ban may have combined to shift some voters away from Labour. This is of course why they wanted to get it all passed before 2005.

Of course the NBR poll (which had 11% gap the month before) may just be a one off. TV One should have their final poll of the year either tonight or next Sunday so we’ll see if the gap is under or over 10% for them.

Hubbard assistant quits

I don’t normally like to make predictions so far out from an election, but I do predict Dick Hubbard will not be Auckland Mayor after the next local body elections. In fact he may not even run again.

His personal assistant has now quit in protest at Hubbard’s total reversal on the civil union bill.

I wonder if we may see a Banks vs Hucker contest in 2007?

Christoper Harder

Just as Deborah Manning would be one of the first lawyers I would call if I was in trouble, I have to say Christoper Harder would probably be very bottom of the list.

As the SST reports, Harder has Harder has “travelled to Fiji, Peru and Waco, Texas, to negotiate peace and hostage releases”. What they don’t mention is that in every instance he was unsought and uninvited and half the time almost got arrested himself. To say he seems to have a messiah complex is probably unfair to Jesus.

Harder is complaining that being repeatedly brought before the tribunal has made him depressed. Well there is an easy solution – stop assaulting other lawyers etc.

I love how he says it wasn’t really his shouting at the Judge which intimidated her, but the fact he did it while opening and closing a five-inch blade which was a potential exhibit.

I’m sorry but is the man a moron?

Faux Pas Time

Well worth reading a very amusing thread of Tim Blair’s blog about bad faux pases. Over 100 listed so far.

Some of mine are not fit for this family blog, but I can relate one I have seen and one I did.

In my 5th form at Rongotai College, we turned up to school one morning to be told two fo our classmates had died with one of their mothers in a casr crash yesterday. We were all devasted and naturally sombre. A class mate turned up a bit later, and upon walking in the door to observe our normally vivacious class all quiet burst out with “Jesus what is wrong you you guys, you look like you are at a funeral”. He was horrified when told about Stephen and Paul.

One pretty bad one for me was at the Captain Cook tavern in Dunedin. We were watching NZ get dicked in a test match. The previous series was the one against the West Indies when a new Ken Rutherford scored an average of single figures and had been dropped. Observing how badly NZ was doing I commented to my group of friends, in my normal quiet voice, that we were doing so badly we should recall Ken Rutherford to see if he could increase his average from two runs per inning to three. The entire table went silent at this, and as I asked what was wrong, one of them pointed to the table next to me where of course Ken Rutherford was seated!

Media Competition

Great to see more competition in the media. Next year for current affairs at 7 pm we will have choice of:

TV1: Susan Wood/Mark Sainsbury
TV3: John Campbell/Carol Hirshcfield
Prime: Paul Homes/Alison Mau

Of course I’ll probably be watching Shortland Street to save me deciding. I suspect both TV3 and Prime will do well at expense of TV1.

On the radio side, RadioWorks will be offering “fresh and contemporary news and information”, in 21 centres from April.

And finally on the newspaper side, we now have the healthly competition on Sundays between Fairfax and APN. However I observed the political editor of the Sundary Star-Times (Helen Bain) having breakfast with the political editor of the Herald on Sunday (Jonathan Milne) at Astoria this morning. They are meant to be rivals and enemies, not swapping gossip. Someone should alert the Commerce Commission 🙂

Comments Galore

Tax Cuts

It is great to see Don Brash putting tax cuts back on the political agenda.

The surplus NZ currently has is not only the highest in our history but I suspect the highest in the developed world. The claims by Cullen and co that we can not afford tax cuts is ideology gone mad. Dr Cullen would always rather spend your money for you than give any of it back. This is why he won’t even commit to specifying a level at which he would agree to tax reduction.

Tax cuts are not some mad far right thing to do. If I recall correctly every OECD country in recent years has reduced taxes – we are the only one that does nothing but increase them. And many of these countries have centre left Governments.

Cullen insists a huge surplus is needed to keep gross debt from increasing. A 7th form accounting student should know better. The issue is simple. Increasing debt to fund an operating deficit is very very bad and unsustainable. Increasing debt to fund capital and infrastructure is not bad, and in fact is the sensible way to do it. The contributions to the superannuation fund are needed to be funded from the surplus, but National has said it will keep a surplus high enough to do that.

John Armstrong in the NZ Herald observes “voters [should ask] one crucial question: if tax cuts amount to loose fiscal policy, why doesn’t the same argument apply to Cullen’s spend-ups?”

There is also the start of a good debate about whether for example health insurance should be tax deductible. Most people with health insurance are paying three times over. As higher income tax payers they are paying taxes for their own public health care, which they rarely take up. They are also paying for all the public health care for all the NZers who are not net taxpayers (around half), plus they are paying for their own health insurance. Allowing them to at least get some tax relief for the fact that by having private insurance they reduce the cost of public health care works for me.

UN Scandals

It would come no doubt as a huge surprise to most NZers that the UN has been facing major scandals. There has been a few articles in the media here about it, but really just the odd one off article in the world news section, not the day on day front page coverage that some issues attract.

Max Boot in the LA Times sums it up perfectly by noting:

Imagine if U.S. troops were accused of sexually exploiting children in impoverished nations. Imagine if a U.S. Cabinet secretary were accused of groping a female subordinate, whose complaint was then swatted aside by the president. Imagine if the head of a U.S. government agency and the president’s own offspring stood accused of complicity in the biggest embezzlement racket in history.

He is of course right. If this was the US not the UN it would be the main news item for weeks on end.

Helping Mr Hubbard

Ahmed Zaoui humour

A reader poses two questions:

1) Given the Catholic Church’s recent record, would Ahmed Zaoui not possibly be safer back at Auckland remand prison?

2) How good will Deborah Manning, his lawyer, become when she is old enough to vote?

CUB Opposition

This story by Ruth Berry in the NZ Herald touches on a few issues, I mentioned yesterday.

It was hilarious when the CUB supporters played the song Chapel of Love.

” … we’re going to the chapel and we’re gonna get married … ”

The look on some faces – pricesless.

The Herald highlight how contradictory the opposition to CUB was. Half the MPs said the bill was gay marriage while half condemned because it was not. Even within the same party with Winston Peters saying it was not and Dail Jones saying it effectively was.

They have also confirmed the impression I gained on Wednesday night that the comments by some opponents were so horrifying other MPs, it came really really close to tipping a bunch of them into voting in favour.

Hopefully this may be a lesson to people the next time there is an issue like that. The tactics of extremism backfire and repulse. In fact many people at the CUB victory party thanked Brian Tamaki for doing so much to help get the bill passed – and they were serious.