Wellington Central

After around a decade of holding senior office within National, I have enjoyed semi-retirement since I retired as Lower North Island Deputy Regional Chair around 18 months ago. It has been nice to just help out here and there organsing the odd quiz night etc, attending conferences etc.

However all good things must come to an end, and I have accepted the offer to be Mark Blumsky’s Campaign Chair and Manager for the Wellington Central seat. My spare time has just disappeared.

Mark is a great guy, and an ideal candidate with endless energy, ideas and positivity for Wellington. I know I am going to enjoy the campaign, and already have been staggered at the amount of support there is for Mark. In fact co-ordinating all the offers of help is probably my largest task. Those who have been involved in campaigns before know how vital a large volunteer base is.

Bring on the election šŸ™‚

Best PMs

It says something about the prejudices of many political scientists when asked to rate PMs of the last 100 years, there is only one National PM in the top seven.

Holyoake won four elections in a row, and is only ranked 5th. Every single Labour PM who lasted more than a year in office is listed though.

The inclusion of Kirk who lost two elections and spent barely two years as PM is silly. He spent most of his time plotting against his colleagues, achieved little except sending a frigate somewhere, and makes the list while Holland is absent.

Likewise while I personally like David Lange’s charisma and wit, I could not rank him as a sucessful PM. He had almost no control over his own Government’s policy, alienated his own support base within the Government, and resigned leaving behind a shambles which led to their worst defeat.

And the most glaring absence is Muldoon. Now I think as Minister of Finance, he was very bad, but as Prime Minister he was beyond any doubt in the top ten for the century. In fact his force of personality was almost unique.

If I had to rate the top five, I would pick:

1 Seddon
2 Holyoake
3 Fraser
4 Muldoon
5 Savage

Without arrogance, I probably know more than most about the 40 or so people who have served as Prime Minister, as one of my more fun jobs in the PM’s Office was to write most of their biographies for the PM’s website. I still have a credit on there!

Kiwibank

An obscene photo

Saying what you think

It is a nice feature of blogging that people can let loose and say what they really think, regardless of whether a newspaper editor or talkback host would approve of it.

And fellow bloggers have certainly been doing that. Firstly we have Nigel Kearney who shows his displeasure at ACT MPs who voted against the CUB by exclaiming “Unfortunately, five ACT members disgraced themselves by voting against. So a big fuck you very much to Stephen Franks, Muriel Newman, Gerry Eckhoff, Deborah Coddington and Kenneth Wang.”

Jordan Carter is no more impressed with the five Labour MPs who did the same, stating: “As for the Labour MPs who voted against – John Tamihere, Ross Robertson, Harry Duynhoven, Clayton Cosgrove, Taito Phillip Field and Damien O’Connor – all I will say is they are very lucky they don’t depend on the Labour Party list for their election. I am ashamed that they have “Labour” attached to their names. To vote against this legislation indicates their values base is not Labour’s”.

And finally we have Blair Mulholland saying what he really thinks of some of the leading lights in ACT.

“ACT is run by people who have in the past been a complete disgrace to those on the freedom side of the spectrum. They often seems like a pack of boy racers trying to overcompensate for their penis envy, aided and abetted by a former leader who either deliberately or incompetently (still can’t decide which) encouraged and extended this “divide and rule” regime to the parliamentary party and its staff. Add to this a founder who set up the party structure so that ordinary members are completely at the whim of a politburo and you have a party that has remained afloat only through the twin graces of National’s unpopularity and a big wad of cash every three years.”

Wow tell us what you really think Blair šŸ™‚

ICANN coming to NZ

One of the things I have been involved with at InternetNZ, is being on a small working group which earlier this year bid to host the March 2006 ICANN meeting in Wellington, New Zealand.

We just found out today, that we have been successful. This will be a major challenge over the next 15 months, but hey the busier you are, the more efficient you get!

We have also bid to hold the Feb 2007 APRICOT meeting in Auckland. I am starting to get terrified that we may be sucessful with that one also šŸ™‚

ICANN tends to be a mainly policy focused meeting, while APRICOT is much more technically focused.

The press release just put out by InternetNZ is below.
Continue reading »

A nice summer day

Once again a stunning summer’s day in Wellington. Long may summer last.

10.30 am Brunch at Masi – eggs benedict and cappuccino.

11.00 am Read Dominion Post and its article on blogging. Greatly relieved to find that “more than useful” journalist Maggie Tait has not used any of my more stupid quotes and in fact the whole article is very good. My only objection is gratuitous mention of my age šŸ™‚
Continue reading »

The serial stalker

The NZ Herald reports on Glen Goldberg, who is obviously quite bonkers and a serious threat to women.

The Herald also has a much longer article detailing his background.

It is good the Judge has sent him away for a relatively long time – six years, but I still wonder if it is enough. He now has 191 convictions, and beyond any doubt will reoffend within days of being released.

I don’t advocate the US style three strikes and you are out policy, but would say 100 strikes and you’re out be unreasonable?

Hamilton night life

Ha – Tourism Waikato is spending $40,000 on advertising in Auckland that 18 to 25 year olds should come down to Hamilton for a drink as they are more likely to score, sorry I mean pick someone up.

Its a novel approach for tourism – suggesting that the local girls and boys are more likely to be slappers, and hence easy to pick up.

So what have people found – are Hamiltonians or Aucklanders easy to pick up when drunk? For safety’s sake I won’t share my observations!

Non intimate unions

Richard Worth has proposed changing the definition of civil unions to include non-intimate relationships, to distance them from marriage. This is quite an interesting tactical move.

I wonder whether intimacy is legally required for civil unions or indeed marriage? In fact I’d suggest after a few years many marriages are very non-intimate (well with each other anyway).

What I find very amusing is that I have often hassled a friend of mine, whose place I often visit, that once civil unions are passed I can claim half his wine and dvd collection as a de facto civil union partner, based on the amount of time I spend visiting.

Of course neither of us are gay which would make my claim difficult to win, but if Richard Worth’s amendment does get passed, it may actually help me win the precious wine cellar.

Founding Rats Jump Ship

ACT’s two founders, Sir Roger Douglas and Derek Quigley, have announced they have resigned as ACT’s patrons.

In one sense this may not be a bad thing for ACT as Sir Roger only made news when he was criticising ACT, and this makes it less news worthy. However I suspect some of the members will not be happy.

Sir Roger repeats his usual complaint about more focus on policies and less on scandals. And he is of course right to a degree. But what I think he misses is that the media give far more attention to scandals that serious policy alternatives.

If one looks at PRs from ACT, and Rodney’s blog, there is a lot of focus on policies, but they never get much media attention.

The price of wrongful conviction

An interesting NZPA article on compensation for three teenage girls jailed for a crime they did not commit.

They have been offered about $160,000 each, but their lawyer thinks it should be $1 million as Arthur Allan Thomas got. I note he did spent ten years in jail not seven months.

To be jailed as a teenager for seven months for a crime one is innocent of is an awful thing. I am not sure how one even puts a value on what compensation should apply as at that stage they wre not even earning money.

To my thinking it should be enough money to give a significant boost to quality of life, so as to make a difference. $160,000 would give around $10,000 a year extra income which is useful but not a huge amount.

If it was me, I would want more.

Susan Wood keeps her job

TVNZ have announced that Susan Wood will stay on as the permament host of Close Up At 7. Political Editor Mark Sainsbury will be the backup host.

I actually think it is a pity TVNZ did not take a risk and move Paul Henry from Breakfast TV to the 7 pm slot. I think Henry does a good job at Breakfast TV with Alison Mau, and like Holmes he has the capacity to stir things up a bit. Listening to him and Alison discussing whether it is okay to take photos of topless sunbathers in public places was quite classic.

Voting Details for Civil Unions Bill

The NZ Herald has kindly provided a list of how MPs voted on the second reading.

The summary by party is not given. For those interested it is:

ACT 4 – 5
Green 9 – 0
Labour 45 – 6
Maori 0 – 1
National 3 – 24
NZ First 2 – 11
Progressive 2 – 0
United Future 0 – 8

Total 65 – 55

On top of the 56 votes from MPs from centre left parties, I congratulate the nine other MPs who voted for the second reading. Well done ACT’s Rodney, Heather, Ken and Richard, NZ First’s Ron and Brian and of course Katherine, Pansy and Clem from National.

Civil Unions Bill second reading debate

1st speaker was David Benson-Pope (L). Nice move to quote George W Bush as having supported same sex civil unions in the US.

2nd speaker is Don Brash (N). Complaining about being pushed though in haste, not having companion bill to vote on also, and believes all adult NZers should decide issue on a referendum, which he would vote for. Does not believe homsexuality is a sin, but a predisposition people are born with. Notes Jesus Christ never condemned it.

3rd is Lianne Dalziel (L). A very passionate speech, attacks Maxim, use of children to campaign against.

4th is Moana Mackey (L) – she is great. Did a search of Maxim, Destiny, United Future websites to see how many complained about strangers marrying each other in a radio competition. None. Complained about Scott Watson marrying? None. They only complain when gay couples want to commit to each other. Is using lots of stats to refute myths.

5th is Dail Jones (NZF). Has same views on homosexuality as he did in maiden speech in 1975 (and it shows). Marriage is only for men and women. Then says his views should not bind NZ, as Tim Barnett’s views should not. Attacks United Future for supporting Labour, and not getting agreement to stop CUB being introduced. Says should not be passed as we celebrate the birthday of Joseph’s and Mary’s son Jesus (I thought God had a hang in that).

6th is Stephen Franks (ACT). Now voting against. Says the CUB is a blank cheque bill, as key details will be in the companion bill.

7th has Nandor Tancoz (G). Debate not about shacking up, but about human rights and what sort of society we are. Does not devalue marriage by allowing people to pledge their commitment to each other. Not sure why oppressing other people is seen as a Christian value. Says bible warns against usary (lending for interest) as much as it does against homosexuality.

8th is Murray Smith (U). He has just said he agrees that the decision on the CUB is more important to NZ than the decision to go to war against Hitler. (If he really believes that, the man is mad). Says CUs will be near identical to marriages.

9th is Georgina Beyer (L). Just wants equality under the law to enhance people’s lives. Celebrate diversity. Urges parties to listen to their youth wings and support the CUB.

10th is Nick Smith (N). Against as it undermines families. Part of radical social engineering by Labour. Is a gay marriage bill based on the looks like a duck test. Children do best when raised by a Mum or Dad committed to each other.

11th is Brian Connell (N). Says this is about homosexual marriage and backers are dishonest by not admitting this. Homosexual relationships are notoriously volatile (hmmn I’ve known a few females who could be described as notoriously volatile when they dated me). This is a recruitment drive for homosexuals. No mandate to pass this law.

12th Dave Heroera (L). Supports the bill, is not gay marriage. Lets those who will not or can not marry, register as a civil union.

13th George Hawkins (L). Missed what he said as had a phone call from Mark Blumsky – I’ll survive having missed George’s contribution šŸ™‚

14th Wayne Mapp (N) 56% of his electorate against civil unions. Wants a referendum.

15th Edwin Perry (NZF). Displays humour claiming to be youth wing of NZ First. Says it undermines marriage and should be a referendum. Attacks United Future for not stopping the CUB like they did with cannabis.

16th Tim Barnett (L). Says his opponents still call him a practising homosexual, despite 30 years of practice. Talking mainly about select committee process which he chaired. Their role was to seperate emotion from fact. Said many submitters said they were also against homosexual law reform in 1986. None could give examples of how that law reform had personally affected them. Quotes from a submission against from a 12 year old saying homosexuals are worthy of death. Wants passage as blow against prejudice.

1st vote is on accepting amendments from the select committee. This will be a personal vote and take a few minutes.

The vote is 66 in favour, 54 against.

The second vote is the actual formal passage through the second reading. It should be the same as the previous division but can not be sure. This one will be quicker as bells ring for only one minute not seven.

And the vote on the second reading is 65 in favour, 55 against. Yay!!

It will take a while to get a breakdown of who voted what way, but it looks quite good for next week, even if the two NZ First MPs in favour swap sides because of no referendum.

You are the weakest link – good bye

Letting Senee Niusila off once was compassionate. Letting him off a second time was a borderline call. Letting him off a third time is just plain wrong.

Here is Judge Farrar alternative sentencing:

“Mr Niusula.you are an overstayer in New Zealand who has no legal right to be here. However as a compasionate society we have allowed you to stay, so you recieve dialysis treatment to keep you alive. We are not obliged to do this anymore than we are obliged to keep alive the thousands who die every day around the world who are not legal residents of NZ.

Having been allowed to stay, you have an obligation to obey the laws of the land. You know that any criminal offending will mean automatic deportation and death. Despite this you beat up your wife in August 2003. One of my colleagues was compassionate and discharged you without conviction.

A year later you were still beating your wife up. Apart from the fact this is wrong, repugnant and criminal, it was the stupidest thing you could do, as it should have resulted in your conviction and deportation. But God must have been on your side and decided to influence my learned colleague to give you another chance.

Now you are up before me and have pled guilty to not just assaulting your wife again but now threatening to kill her. There are no words left to describe the level of stupidity this entails. You are obviously totally incapable of controlling your violence, as you have the fatal incentive to be the most peaceful man in New Zealand.

I have concluded you are too stupid to save. You are the weakest link. You are found guilty. Good Bye.”

Compare the arguments

The NZ Herald has an editorial in favour of the Civil Unions Bill and an opinion piece from Garth George against it.

The Editoral is a well reasoned opinion which points out some flaws in arguments on both sides, before concluding “It will be a landmark for human rights and its time has arrived. ”

Those who are voting against might want to look at the company they are keeping. Garth George writes about homosexuals as anti-semiitics writes about Jews: “They are in positions of influence in all the mainline churches, all the professions, in the media, the justice system and law enforcement, healthcare, education, Government agencies (human rights, censorship, Aids), and state bureaucracies in general.”

How dare those homosexuals actually hold jobs and be out of the closet?

Garth finally places himself in the role of Jesus Christ, saying of those who dare disagree with him ” “Father forgive them for they know not what they do.”

A well reasoned argument in favour and a gay hating rant against. Makes it an easy call I would say.

Good one Kenneth

CUB 2nd reading

This should happen from 3 pm to 4 pm today. My pick is 64 in favour, 55 against and one absence. The third reading next week may vary further depending on committee stage changes.

I see the Catholic Church is urging all Catholics to vote against MPs who vote for the Civil Unions Bill.

I am confident that most Catholics will take as much notice of this, as they do of the Catholic prohibition on contraception, sex before marriage and any other number of things. Which is not much at all.,

I really liked the joint press conference with members of Young Nationals, Young Labour, ACT on Campus, Young Progressives and Young Greens all in favour of the Civil Unions Bill. Not often you see the youth wings of 85% of Parliament united on an issue. This reinforces what the public polls have said – that those under 40 are massively in favour and just don’t see what the fuss is about.

I’ll post results of the vote as it happens.

UPDATE: Nice photo of the youth reps in the Dom Post. I know Emily Hayes and Michael Collins well (good one guys), and ironically also was talking to Iona Pannett last week on another issue. Yet to meet Michael Wood but he must be a good guy to cope with Spanner šŸ™‚

November 2004 NZ Blog Statistics

Once again by popular request we have the monthly summary of NZ political blogs. Thanks to Gary at I Hate Socialism, Phil Sage and Murray at Silent Running who counted their posts and comments up for me.

Anyway here are the statistics for NZ political bloggers for November 2004.

Lite Bloggers

Bloggreen Aotearoa – 5 posts and 2 comments (but had blog deleted so was more)
In for a penny – 6 posts and 16 comments
Grey Shade – 7 posts and 22 comments
Left and Lefter – 8 posts and 24 comments
Observationz – 9 posts and 2 comments

Medium Bloggers

Gareth Robinson – 11 posts and 0 comments
Dog Biting Men – 13 posts
Kiwi Jew Pundit – 15 posts and 24 comments
Peter Metcalfe – 16 posts and 6 comments
VUWA President – 16 posts and 37 comments
My Right – 18 posts and 28 comments
Fighting Talk – 18 posts
Generation Y Not – 19 posts and 41 comments
Hard News – 19 posts
Kiwi Pete – 20 posts and 5 comments
PNN – 20 posts and 12 comments
Darkness Network – 22 posts and 26 comments
Aaron Bhatnagar – 23 posts
Constar – 23 posts and 46 comments
Capital Pundit – 25 posts and 1 comment
Big News – 28 posts and 91 comments

Heavy Bloggers (more than daily)

Philosphy et cetera – 33 posts and 162 comments
Philosphically Made – 34 posts and 94 comments
The Whig – 38 posts and 38 comments
Span – 44 posts and 118 comments
Prime Minister – 55 posts and 65 comments
Just Left – 55 posts and 485 comments
About Town – 62 posts and 107 comments
Kiwi Pundit – 66 posts and 42 comments (welcome back)
Holden Republic – 71 posts and 39 comments
NZ Pundit – 80 posts and 325 comments
NZ Political Comments – 85 posts and 50 comments
Rodney Hide – 85 posts and 985 comments
I Hate Socialism – 87 posts and 213 comments
Sagenz – 93 posts and 99 comments

Need a life Bloggers

Sock Thief – 109 posts and 41 comments
Genius NZ – 115 posts and 105 comments
David Farrar – 122 posts and 1364 comments
No Right Turn – 142 posts
Silent Running – 149 posts and 1405 comments

On average I am getting 11 comments per posting. It will noyl get worse next year with the election šŸ™‚

Gambling Laws

I am not a fan of all these stupid gambling laws. Prohibiting 98% of NZers from betting on something because 2% may have a problem is bad public policy.

It is just silly one has a state monopoly on betting with the TAB. It is silly one can bet on the UK and US elections but not on our own, for example.

The latest law changes are going to cut the amount of funding for sports, arts and charity by $28 million to $48 million.

In my view the only role of the state should be to set policies around disclosure and fairness, and then let people spend their money as they want to.

Germany gets Czech territory

Practising what you preach – not

Oskar Alley (back at the Dominion Post) has a story which illustrates how Governments are so good at telling people what to do, but not doing it themselves.

He reports that staff at the government department responsible for promoting happy workplaces are among the unhappiest in the public service, with only 39 per cent of Labour Department staff giving their workplace a positive overall rating.

I suppose being experts in what makes an unhappy workplace, means they can tell the rest of us what not to do šŸ™‚

Oh dear

After movies I popped into the Backbencher to have a drink with Mr Carver and Miss Ten. Soon thereafter Rodney Hide turns up with some companions.

Rodney invites us to join him, recognising Miss Ten from my blog photos (heh heh), and pretty soon starts stirring by asking me how happy I am about National now backing the Cullen Fund etc. Also insists I tell stories of biggest stuffups in politics I have been involved in (I have many to choose from!). As I am just having a quiet drink amongst friends, I oblige.

Around halfway through I note that Rodney’s companions are filming us on handheld cameras. They explain they are doing a documentary on a day in the life of an MP. Oh dear. Oh shit.

I quickly explain that hey even Sir Keith Holoyoake was on record as saying he only agreed with 80% of what his party did, and he was Prime Minister for 12 years. Have a sinking feeling that this is not the footage they may use.

So in advance I wish to state for the record, that if I should appear on television at any stage, saying anything at all, that:

a) It is quoted out of context
b) I may have been drunk
c) You can’t prove it was not a body double
d) It was a plot of Rodney’s to lead me over to the dark side
e) I was joking
f) I normally lead a life of blameless excellence
g) All of the above

$300 movie outing

Hmmn, went to the movies last night and came back $300 poorer. My X chromosomes got the better of me when I got to Courtney Central and saw a temporary shop with a liquidation shoe sale. The prices were just too good, so bang $250 disappears for three pairs of shoes.

Then stats girl and I head to Masala for a quick dinner. This is one of the better Indian restaurants, just around the corner on Allen Street. Their prawn masala was excellent.

Back to Reading for Bridget Jones 2 which really was hilarious. Zellwegger’s facial expressions as she stuffs up are reason enough to see it.