I’ve embedded a survey below where you can rate the major media websites in NZ on whether or not you think they lean left or right, or are neutral.
There’s also a question on how your normally vote so we can breakdown the perceptions of each media outlet by how the respondents normally vote.
Results should be interesting, which I’ll blog here of course.
Create your own user feedback surveyStuff reports:
The Teaching Council is considering complaints made about an Auckland teacher who wore a “Make America Great Again” hat to Auckland’s Black Lives Matter march and posted a video on Facebook defending his actions.
The man, a teacher at Manukau Christian School, was one of thousands at the protest on Monday, which was organised in response to the death of George Floyd and in solidarity with a wave of protests across the US.
The Teaching Council should dismiss this complaint immediately.
Teachers are entitled to have a political opinion, including whether or not they like the President of the United States.
It is repugnant that people are trying to get a teacher disbarred, simply because they disagree with his choice of political apparel.
In case any uneducated snowflakes get offended by the headline, the quote in full is “All animals are equal, but some animals are more equal than others” from George Orwell’s Animal Farm and is a comment on the hypocrisy of governments.
The Herald reports:
The Police Minister says there’s “no place for racism in the New Zealand Police” and promises if instances are found, it will be weeded out.
Stuart Nash said he did not think there was systemic racism in the police.
He was asked today to explain the over-representation of Māori in police statistics and said “we are dealing with that at the moment”.
The over-representation is primarily because more crimes are committed. This is not the fault of Police.
Men are also massively over-represented in police statistics. This is not because the Police are sexist against men. It is because men commit more crimes.
There are legitimate issues around when Police use discretion, if they use diversion, what charges are laid. But any issues there make up only a small portion of the huge difference in offending rates.
Media who assume that the over-representation of a particular demographic in crime statistics must be the fault of the Police in some way, do the public a disservice.
Stuff reports:
Enforcing alert level 2 restrictions at the Black Lives Matter marches could have caused tension in an otherwise peaceful protest, says one of New Zealand’s top cops.
Oh my Goodness. If you enforce the law it might cause tension, so instead we let people break the law.
Schwalger said the police’s role is to ensure safety and uphold the law while recognising the lawful right to protest.
The trouble is it was an unlawful protest. Personally I think the protest should have been lawful, but the Government has kept us at Level 2, which meant the protest was unlawful.
Have just published the first of my monthly Patreon posts analysing how well positioned Governments are for re-election in Aus, Canada, NZ, UK and US.
The analysis takes a long time to compile – around six to seven hours as there are 30 different data sources. It’s a good example of the sort of stuff I ave been wanting to do more of.
The graphic above shows the summary, without the data and legend.
I’ll be doing a new post in the first week of every month.
Newshub reports:
The National Party has been leaked a recent Cabinet Committee paper that says New Zealand could be at alert level 1 already.
It outlines the criteria for a move saying we need to have eliminated chains of transmission and had no new cases of community transmission for 28 days, and if that’s been achieved there’s no need for restrictions.
“The permissive nature of the alert level 1 controls reflect it is predicated upon having eliminated chains of transmission and there have been no new cases from community transmission for at least 28 days,” it says.
“If that has been achieved, and we have confidence in our border controls, there is theoretically no need for restrictions on people’s movements, interactions or activities.”
It’s now been longer than 28 days – the last community transmission case was 33 days ago.
So Cabinet itself has been advised you can go to Level 1 after 28 days of no community transmission, yet they are keeping us at Level 2.
I have been sent a copy of a complaint to the Auditor-General about the Mayor of Hutt City. It raises very important issues around taking donations and conflicts of interest.
The Mayor is Campbell Barry. It relates both as a Councillor and Mayor. Mayor Barry stood on the Labour ticket.
My summary of the complaint is this:
It would seem to me to be a no brainer that if four days before a Council meeting, to vote on a controversial issue, you receive a large donation from the major advocate to vote yes on the issue, you must disclose it as a conflict of interest.
Could you imagine the outrage if say a business lobby group dedicated to stopping the living wage donated $5,000 to a Councillor four days before the same meeting, and that Councillor met with them privately, and then voted against the living wage with no disclosure of the donation. The media would report this as a major scandal.
I’m not suggesting that Barry should have been unable to vote because of the donation or that the donations influenced his views. Money tends to follow policy, rather than policy follows money (except for one political party in Government). But absolutely Mayor Barry should have disclosed the donation as a conflict of interest so his colleagues would be aware he had just received $5,000 from the union pushing the living wage policy.
I will report further on the complaint once the Auditor-General determines how they plan to proceed.
David Fisher reports:
Photographs have emerged of the Prime Minister and director general of health posed for pictures close to wellwishers, prompting accusations of hypocrisy from a National Party MP warned by police for doing the same.
It has led to an admission from the Prime Minister it was a struggle to maintain “appropriate distancing” with people approaching wanting “handshakes and hugs”.
Bloomfield has also coughed to being in a photograph with strangers but says it was only for a moment.
The rules are for us to follow, not them, it seems.
Stuff reports:
A former police investigator is among a number of high-profile New Zealanders encouraging the country to vote Yes in the upcoming cannabis referendum.
The New Zealand Drug Foundation’s “Our Own Terms” campaign features Tim McKinnel, an investigator who helped prove Teina Pora’s innocence, alongside former Prime Minister Helen Clark, psychiatrist Hinemoa Elder and educator Richie Hardcore, among others.
“The system as it is now is a free-for-all, it’s unregulated and uncontrolled and forces people to dip their toes into the black market,” said McKinnel, who spent several years on the police drug squad.
“Police spend a great deal of time and money fighting cannabis, with helicopter recovery operations, or with uncovering underground growing operations. It’s a drain not only on policy but on our courts and prisons.”
He is supporting the Yes campaign because it will allow for stricter regulations.
“The Bill we are voting on is the Cannabis Legalisation and Control Bill. People tend to forget about the control part.”
This is a key point that the proposed law does in fact impose significant controls on the sale of cannabis, all of which are lacking in the illegal black market.
Stuff reports:
Countdown staff will be given a stake in the company.
The supermarket chain has announced it is awarding A$750 (NZ$808) of Woolworths Group shares to 14,400 Kiwi employees across 183 stores and distribution centres.
Australian-based Woolworths Group owns Countdown in New Zealand.
Countdown managing director Natalie Davis said the shares recognised the role staff played to keep the stores open during the lockdown.
What a great idea. I’m a big fan of having staff as shareholders.
Will cost Countdown around $12 million which is significant.
One News reports:
While the Ministry of Health doesn’t release details of where people have checked in, due to privacy concerns, the sheer number of scans of QR codes is recorded, albeit anonymously.
Since the app’s launch, each registered user has checked in on average just over one time.
The latest available figures requested from the Ministry of Health show that as of May 29, nine days after the app’s formal launch, users had scanned official NZ Covid Tracer QR codes 480,000 times.
However, on that same date, there were 446,000 accounts formally registered with the app.
I’m not surprised. The app seems okay but so few places are using it. Almost every place I go to uses a different system for checking in. It is frustrating.
The best one I’ve seen is the one where you don’t even have to enter an app, but you just open your camera in front of the QR code and it takes you to a webpage for checkin.
Stuff reports:
President Donald Trump, declaring himself a “president of law and order” has threatened o deploy the military to cities where, he said, governors and local officials have “failed to take necessary action” to end civil unrest.
“These are not acts of peaceful protest,” Trump declared during a brief speech in the White House Rose Garden, referring to the demonstrations and sometimes violent acts that have broken out in dozens of major cities. “These are acts of domestic terror.”
Trump said he was dispatching “thousands and thousands of heavily armed soldiers, military personnel and law enforcement officers” to end civil unrest.
Even as he declared himself an ally of legitimate protestors, police fired tear gas into peaceful crowds near the White House and advanced on horseback. Reporters in the Rose Garden could hear booms in the background. …
n private, however, during a call with governors on Monday, the president, who tweeted Saturday that looting leads to “shooting,” pushed for a harsher crackdown.
“Most of you are weak,” Trump said, berating the governors and urging them to “dominate” the protesters, according to a person on the call. He urged state officials to track down lawbreakers and send them to prison for five to 10 years.
A second person with knowledge of the call described the president as “bellicose,” raising the possibility of military action and describing the situation as a war. The message was echoed by Defence Secretary Mark Esper, who described the need to “dominate the battlespace,” language normally used to describe far-flung conflict zones instead of American streets.
Time for a sequel to Wag The Dog it seems.
Meet Mr Maka. At 3.45 am he drive to the home of his victims in Mangere. He didn’t even know them but his mate did.
He:
Maka is 24 years old and has six children. He claims to be a patched member of Black Power. The Department of Corrections assesses him as being at a high risk of re-offending.
For killing someone, assaulting two others and pointing a firearm he got 44 months prison. He will be eligible for parole in 15 months.
I did a very quick search through the QB Honours List for what people got their honours for. I thought it was quite illuminating for the obvious priorities of the Government.
The activities honoured for were:
Quite amazing that only one out of 200 were honoured for services to business, when it is businesses that provide over two million jobs for New Zealanders.
A guest post by Owen Jennings:
Here is an interesting question for you. How much Methane is there in the atmosphere? Now, come on, be honest. Do you know? Are you prepared to even have a guess?
You see, I have been asking people – family, friends, anyone who will engage for a few moments. What percentage of the air around us is Methane? They don’t know. The answers are all over the place. One brave soul thought it may be 10%. That would be called an “outlier”. Some said “not much”. Most thought less than 1% but were not prepared to go any further.
Does it matter? “Who cares”, was one reaction. “CO2 is important but Methane isn’t so much”.
Methane levels should concern you. The Coalition government, driven by the Greens and supported by all parties to a large degree, are in the process of imposing severe penalties on all of us because they claim Methane levels are too high. Farming, the mainstay of the economy is going to be hit very badly by taxes and restrictions because it is claimed there is too much Methane swirling around us, apparently. Farmers could lose a significant part of their income, stock numbers are going to be decimated, land values gutted, exports will be heavily reduced because, theoretically, Methane is playing havoc in the atmosphere.
It is described as a “dangerous Greenhouse Gas”, hugely more damaging than CO2. There are models and formulas that experts use to equate Methane to CO2 in terms of warming potential. These experts tell us privately that the formulas heavily overstate the relative danger of Methane but publicly they all stick with the “party line” because you get severely bullied if you step out of line. You could lose your job or lose a chunk of the generous research money sloshing around climate change science.
Alright, let’s get to the point. How much Methane is up there?
You probably learnt at school that 98% of the air around us is Nitrogen and Oxygen. Another 1% is Hydrogen, Argon, Neon, and Helium leaving 1% for all the Greenhouses Gases (GHG’s). What the advocates of dangerous climate change like to overlook is that of the 1% of GHG’s, 95% is water vapour. The biggest and most influential Greenhouse Gas is harmless, essential H2O. It is water in its various forms – gas, liquid, solid that totally dominates the GHG scene. It is in the NMPKT – “Not Many People Know That” category.
“Hang on,” I hear you say, “what about CO2?” Ok, the answer is 4.15% of the 1%. That means 415 parts per million or sweet fanny, muck all. Doesn’t leave much room for Methane and the others. Nitrous oxide is 0.0029% and Ozone is 0.00038% which leaves just 0.019% of all the GHG’s as Methane.
There you have it. According to NASA and NIWA and all the other big wigs, Methane is 0.019% of 1%. So that works out at 0.00019% of the whole atmosphere. Really tiny. In fact, miniscule.
What does 0.00019% look like in practical terms? Do you have a standard bath at your place? Fill it right up to the brim and you most likely have 180 litres of water. If that 180 litres represented the atmosphere, Methane would be 1/15th of a teaspoon. You would barely be able to see it.
Put it another way. Wellington to Auckland is 642 kms. If you decided to walk the whole 642 kms and the journey represented the atmosphere, Methane would be the first step only. For every molecule of Methane up there in the atmosphere there are more than half a million other molecules.
One more way to describe Methane. Have you ever done that 12 hour flight from Auckland to Los Angeles? If the whole 10,500 kms represented the atmosphere Methane would get you half way along the runway in Auckland. Are you getting the message? Methane is smaller than “miniscule”. It is infinitesimal.
It is so infinitesimal it is irrelevant.
Yet we are in the process of taking a very large axe to our economy because some scientists say it’s way too much. What???
But, wait. There’s more. Most of that infinitesimal amount of Methane around us is natural. It comes from swamps, termites, landfills and some from rice paddies. New Zealand farmers’ cows are actually only responsible for around 15% of the infinitesimal amount of Methane. It is part of a natural cycle that has been in place since cows first walked. We have more than enough sequestering going on with our trees to take care of all our Methane plus all of our CO2 and we are even absorbing, God bless us, some for the rest of the world.
Farm produced Methane in the atmosphere is therefore so preposterously microscopic it is meaningless. It is 15% of 0.00019%. The only analogy of the three above that really helps is the long haul flight. Farming’s Methane doesn’t even complete the pushback from the air-bridge. On the walk to Auckland it is the distance between your outstretched finger and thumb.
Get the picture? You need a Peter Jackson sized imagination on steroids to think Methane at 0.0000285% of the atmosphere is doing serious damage.
Just in case you think that a colourless, odourless, harmless gas in such minute, microscopic quantities may just be pernicious enough to create warming dig around into the science. Read Professor William van Wijngaarden, Professor of Physics of York University in Canada, Dr Tom Sheahen, B.S. and Ph.D. degrees in physics from the Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Dr Will Happer, Ph.D in physics and our own Dr Jock Allison (among others) who have all published papers stating that the earth emits very little energy/heat in the energy band where Methane can absorb radiation and even in those narrow bands water vapour dominates to the extent that Methane simply cannot delay heat being lost and therefore contribute to warming. More on that in Part Two.
Right now the Climate Commission is beavering away to determine some final numbers for Methane in the New Zealand scene. Hey, guys, don’t bother. Find something useful to do. Hit “delete” where it says climate models because they are the only basis for the outrageous claims that Methane causes significant warming. Ask Ms Ardern about “models”. She used one to say 60,000 Kiwis would succumb to the virus. Climate and Covid19 models? More useless than a parasol in a Wellington gale.
Stuff reports:
Act Party leader David Seymour has called on the Government to move to alert level 1 immediately after the Black Lives Matter protests made “a mockery” of Covid-19 distancing restrictions.
On Monday, thousands of Kiwis around the country marched in solidarity with Black Lives Matter protesters in the United States. In one of the largest protests seen in central Auckland for several years, protestors overflowed from Aotea Square into Queen St.
“Scenes of thousands of protesters shoulder to shoulder makes a mockery of the Government’s Covid-19 restrictions and insults every New Zealander who’s followed them,” Seymour said.
Seymour is absolutely correct. If you can have 2,000 people squashed into Aotea Square, then why are we stopping more than 10- people attending a church service?
These are the law-abiding New Zealanders playing their part in the ‘team of five million’s’ effort to beat Covid-19, he said.
“Tonight they’ll see thousands of people shoulder-to-shoulder protesting something that happened 12,000 km away and, thankfully, has no parallel in New Zealand.”
And the Government did nothing to stop them. I don’t mean breaking it up (which would have been stupid) but remaining silent. Why did the PM not explicitly ask people not to join the protest? It must have been apparent large numbers were expected.
Deputy Prime Minister Winston Peters agreed with Seymour from his Facebook page: “If the authorities allow this to occur then we should be at level 1 tomorrow.”
What hypocrisy. He is the authorities. He is the Deputy Prime Minister. He could force Cabinet to move to Level 1 by saying he’ll support legislation in the House to move to it, if Cabinet doesn’t.
If the Government is serious about Level 2 applying to everyone, they DG of Health would order all those who attended the protests to self-isolate at home for the next two weeks.
The full list is here. The titular honours are:
DNZM
To be Dames Companion of the said Order:
Distinguished Professor Jane Elizabeth Harding, ONZM, of Auckland. For services to neonatology and perinatology.
Dr Karen Olive Poutasi, CNZM, of Paraparaumu. For services to education and the State.
Mrs Aroha Hohipera Reriti-Crofts, CBE, JP, of Christchurch. For services to Māori and the community.
KNZM
To be Knights Companion of the said Order:
Professor Robert Bartlett Elliott, CNZM, of Auckland. For services to medical research.
Professor Derek Arana Te Ahi Lardelli, ONZM, of Gisborne. For services to Māori art.
So three professors, a public servant and a community worker.
Pleased to see Taika Waititi get an honour but surprised it is only an ONZM. He is a national and global superstar. He might not want a titular honour but I thought he’d be CNZM at least.
Of interest is in the entire list of a couple of hundred there is only one citation for services to business.
One News reports:
First home buyers caught up in a repeatedly delayed development in Wellington say they wish they’d never even heard of KiwiBuild and the Government is advising them to try to get their money back from the developer.
The poor buyers were promised apartments by July 2020. Then told December 2020. Then October 2021 and now it is June 2022.
One KiwiBuild buyer, who wished to remain anonymous, told 1 NEWS he was delighted when he first won a ballot for a KiwiBuild home in the complex.
“I was thrilled to be honest, I had almost given up on the idea of owning my own home. This seemed like a really good way to get started, to get on the ladder.”
But the repeated delays have left him and his partner now paying rent for two more years in a poor quality rental property – despite having paid their deposit.
They’re now wishing they’d never heard of KiwiBuild.
“I would have to say my wife and I are quite gutted with the way things have gone.”
National’s housing spokesperson Nicola Willis says it’s totally unacceptable for people investing in a government housing programme to be treated this way.
“They put their faith in the KiwiBuild brand, they paid their money and now they’ve been left high and dry.”
Just another chapter in the fiasco that was Labour’s flagship policy.
Caixinglobal reports:
Premier Li Keqiang said Thursday that China is willing to consider joining the Asia-Pacific’s largest free-trade pact, the Comprehensive and Progressive Agreement for Trans-Pacific Partnership (CPTPP), as Beijing sets its priorities for trade talks this year to drive an economic recovery amid Covid-19 pandemic.
When asked about China’s plan to join the CPTPP, Li told reporters at a wide-ranging press conference on the final day of the national legislature’s annual meeting in Beijing that “China has a positive and open attitude toward joining the CPTPP.”
That would be an excellent outcome, if it happens. The irony is of course that TPP was backed by the US as a way to isolate China. Then US pulled out of it, leaving an opening for China.
China is far from a benevolent country but they are a major economic force and the fewer trade barriers we have with them, the better it is for us. The economic benefits to NZ from the China FTA were massive and China joining TPP would be good for our exporters.