Putting figures to the story

A useful story in the Herald about a struggling family who are being helped by the charity Variety.

The story gives enough info that you can work out their full financial situation. It is:

  • Salary from teaching $43,420
  • Tax $6.620
  • Net salary $36,802
  • WFF $14,040
  • Accom $6,916
  • Net income $57,758

As the youngest child is four years old there is also eligibility for childcare subsidy of up to $200 a week.

Now raising two kids on $1,110 a week would be tight. But it is worth noting taxpayers are already helping out considerably boosting the net salary of $37,000 by a further $21,000.

Kirk on stealth in health

Stacey Kirk writes in Stuff:

This week, Stuff revealed the planned introduction of a very specific mental health programme was quietly canned earlier in the year. It would have seen a mental health worker attend all crisis calls along with police and ambulance staff. 

That decision comes hot on the heels of news Health Minister David Clark ordered National Health Targets to cease being publicly reported, and it was also recently revealed by Stuff the Government had dropped $6.5m in funding for cochlear implant surgeries. 

That is not to say any of these were bad decisions – each might have been completely warranted, but there’s currently no way to know. Not a press release or pro-active release of advice in relation to any of these decisions has been issued. Clark did incorrectly claim there was no money for the mental health project, pointed to a mostly debunked news story regarding health targets, and refused to comment on the cochlear implant funding. 

So Clark’s responses has been an incorrect claim, a reliance on a fake news story and a no comment. Fills you with confidence eh.

Israel Archaeological Dig #9

2018 Israel archaeological excavation at biblical Gath (home of Goliath)
by John Stringer, Tell es-Safi, west of Jerusalem.
Into a the East Bulk and a Stairway Revealed

In the previous post (#8) I discussed soil stratigraphy and how it helps us understand the architecture of a site and its possible usage.  This image above looking into 82D (where the rocks are) shows the bulk between us and 82C west and reveals this stratigraphy very clearly. You can see the quickly erected clay brick wall at far right, then a clear large hole of grey ‘fill’ matter of dumped rubbish in-between, and then more clay brick work on the left. Our finds are all coming out of this grey matter in-between, stretching from foreground bulk to background bulk.  The image shows the lowered wast side bulk, but before that, we are redirected to remove the bulk on the far side in the photo, between us and 82C east.

And so we set to this…

Photo (above) 82C East (left) and 82 D (right). Me at work with heavy pick. We have to ‘process’ all this soil by hand with trowel, brush and bucket and cart it away up hill.  Pic (below) Erika from 82C East and I processing the bulk material ’fill’ between our two squares which will merge as one.

Below: after several of us (John and I, Erika and Ahuva) have removed the East bulk, we discover this very important brown layer at the back, inside the bulk.  Dr Jeff takes particular interest and it has a special string set across its base.  It is carefully photographed.  This is the termination of one of those rapidly constructed clay brick walls.  It’s also clear it has no stone foundation.  During the process of removing the bulk, I uncovered the large rock at centre.  This matches the rock at far left, and we establish these as ‘sitting stones’ that mark each side of an ascending stairway uncovered in 82C by Ahuva and Erik’s careful excavation.

Below are some further photographs of the bulk and the clay wall, as 82C merges into 82D. We are speculating all the way with each find and what it potentially means in relation to everything else.  Constant theorising and testing hypotenuses with more careful digging and trowelling.  And moving so much soil we recover bucket-loads of finds, which excites the rest of the dig site above us. 82C east – 82 D is now one square, carefully cleaned for photographs and site tours.

The Finds in 82C-D Keep Coming.  

At bottom left (below) is a small flint knife of three we discover.  After 3500 years it is as sharp as any razor and will slice your skin open as easily as a paper-cut.

The photo bottom left below is an oil lamp fragment, still with burnt soot on its edge. We find two of these, perhaps part of the same piece. And bottom right below is the pierced pourer from a juglet of some description.

And this nice large rim and painted bichrome Philistine handle I uncovered (Iron Age 1). There is rich red paint under the rim not so clear in the photo.

Here is a selection of some of the finds excavated at Tell-es-Safi Gath.

Police lost the plot on this one

Stuff reports:

Cracking a cold one after a game of bowls may become a thing of the past if Wellington police have their way.

After decades without any alcohol-related incidents, several bowling clubs across the region have found themselves in a battle with police over the renewal of their liquor licences.

It’s about time the Police did something about those rampaging drunken 80 year olds terrorising locals with their sprees of violence and burglaries.

MPs from all sides are not impressed:

Hutt South MP Chris Bishop fielded several emails and social media messages over the weekend from those concerned about the future of the clubs and the police’s seemingly “heavy-handed” approach.

“It sounds like an overzealous interpretation of the [Sale and Supply of Alcohol] Act to me … they [police] are really reading the act in quite a technical way rather than using common sense,” he said. …

O’Connor, a former police officer and current MP for Ōhāriu, said he had spoken with the Wellington Police District Commander on behalf of the bowling clubs after being made aware of the situation on Friday night.

“To be fair to him, I think I brought some things to his attention that he wasn’t aware of,” O’Connor said.

“I’m always aware there are two sides to every story but I think the police side needs to reflect some reality … if there are clubs that are abusing their privileges, deal with them individually.”

This just shows that some elements within the Police have become zealots. Their opposition to licenses should be based on if a licensed premise has been following the law, and has any history of alcohol related problems. To object to the licence of every bowling club in Wellington is nuts, especially when they’ve gone decades without complaints.

Bishop had not ruled out drafting a members bill to address the current situation and said he would attend the Bowls Wellington AGM on July 30 where police planned to brief the region’s clubs all at once.

The legislative fix is very simple. You delete S103 of the Alcohol Supply and Sale Act. That section requires the Police and Medical Officer of Health to be notified of all applications and to inquire into each application.

Just delete this requirement.

If the Police or a Medical Officer of Health wishes to proactively submit on an application, they could still do so – as could any other member of the public.

But the Police and MOHs have become such zealots that they should forfeit their special legislative role.

Rotorua ratepayers were fleeced

Stuff reports:

One of the organisers of the controversial Mudtopia festival has admitted the company established to run the event is being closed – but he denies the move was aimed at pre-empting future legal action.

Scott Rice, who co-ran Event Engines with Simon Brady, confirmed the closure to Stuff in the wake of calls by two Rotorua councillors for an independent forensic audit into the failed event which cost $1,681,814 to stage and lost $600,238.

That around $25 per household in Rotorua.

An Official Information Request shed new light on the finances around the festival, revealing the directors were paid $397,996 to run the event.

They were paid $400,000 to run a mud festival!!

The figures also revealed $77,040 was spent on social media, $10,050 on public relations and $128,654 on advertising and marketing.

Almost $80,000 on social media is a huge amount. I’d love to see the return on spend – bet you it was minuscule.

Brown said 14,000 people attended the festival and that from a ‘festival experience view point’, “the event could be considered a success”.

Well it cost over $100 per attendee. But it’s worse than that,

But the festival only sold 1500 tickets, 12,000 tickets were given away to residents and 3000 to sponsors and suppliers.

So actually it cost over $1,000 per paid ticket!

Good capacity

Stuff reports:

The 15,000km cable has a current total capacity of 43 terabits, enough to transfer the contents of a 4Gb USB stick in less than a millisecond.

A more useful calculation is that if every person in NZ was using the cable at the same time, they’d still be able to download at 9.5 Mb/s.

The Paparoa Great Walk

A good article in Stuff on the work being done to create the Paparoa Great Walk on the West Coast.

I’ve done seven of the nine Great Walks and will be keen to do this one, once it opens in April.

Will be a nice tourism boost for the West Coast also.

Israel Archaeological Dig #8

2018 Israel archaeological excavation at biblical Gath (home of Goliath)
by John Stringer, Tell es-Safi, west of Jerusalem.
Digging thru 3500 years of History in 82D

In 82D John and I are not yet at parallel ground level with the stone ‘E’ construction immediately behind the photo, so we will be digging down to this level carefully, analysing what we find as we go – and we find LOTS!

After the left hand side (pic 2 top right above) is more closely examined by one of the senior archaeologists to understand if it is a compacted clay floor, it is decided to remove this as well and extract all artefacts (below). We use the pick and the tourea for this (pictured), and then process the loosened soil with hand trowel and bucket. As each phase is completed it receives its own bucket with two tags, which are confined to this layer only.  That is an important part of the documenting process.  We then square off the floor and level it with tour, trowel and brush.  New tagged buckets will then be allocated by Eitan before John2 digs down into a new 20 cm layer with the pick and start troweling afresh.

Stratigraphy and Layers

If you look closely at the back wall and left bulk (above), you’ll notice some of the soil is a browner stain. The grey material (like ash) is ‘fill.’ This indicates compacted brick walls have been built across this area, and this find becomes significant. After 3500 years we are even able to carefully extract intact clay bricks from their surrounds and photograph them.  They can just be made out in situ to a trained eye.  We find no artefacts inside compacted clay bricks (obviously) but there are lots inside the grey material. What this means to us, is the Philistines quickly erected clay brick walls across this area, but with no important stone foundations, and then filled the gaps in-between with rubbish and old tip fill.  We speculate this is to secure this vulnerable point in the wall from Hazael of Aram’s attack in 830 BC in which he circled the city with siege works. In other words, the Philistine s very quickly blocked off the ‘Nixon Watergate’ with rapid brick walls, and filled the gaps in-between with rubbish and soil.  It is why we find so many artefacts in 82D compared to other squares 9and my older Bronze-Age Canaanite juggled from pre-1200 BC, another pic below).

The images below with the ‘Bedouin’ shade cover removed for some drone video capture, clearly shows the brown brick wall structures and the grey ‘fill’ in-between, pointing across the area of the gate (bottom left).

Observing best practice, John and I take great pride in finishing each day’s dig with as clean a square as can be managed in the time before back down and departure for the kibbutz 7 min away by bus.  We leave at 1 pm and lunch is at 1:30 pm at the kibbutz. Just time for a really quick shower (often in our clothes) as an all in one ‘semi-laundry.’ We then lay our ashes clothes on the grass for drying ready for tomorrow.  After lunch it is pottery cleaning, ‘pottery reading,’ and lab work, followed by lectures, and dinner later in the evening, about 7 pm.

The Food

The kibbutz serves us kosher food, which means we cannot bring independent food from elsewhere into the food area.    t is very nutritious and is mainly clean fresh vegetables served in a variety of different ways (see below). There is also chicken, other meats, and fish. I find it energises me, and there is no flatulence (quite helpful in dorm conditions). I drink copious amounts of water yet only pee once a day (most of it expires via evaporation or dripping heavy sweat).  The kibbutz also serves a pomegranate fruit juice like insipid Methodist communion ‘wine.’  But I drink lots of it. Pomegranates are everywhere in Israel and there are bushes of them in the kibbutz school. The roast spuds are to die for.  None of the kibbutz staff speak English, so it’s just ‘point’ what you want at the servery.  They do all our dishes, which is awesome.

A great find in Israel is a 500 ml bottle Aloe bits in water.  I recommend this as my favourite fluid intake in Israel.

 

 

 

 

Well done NZ Police

The Herald reports:

Meanwhile, New Zealand Police said they would not charge for providing policing for public safety.

Southern has been hit with a $A68,000 ($NZ74,000) bill by Victorian police for protecting her Melbourne event tonight.

Yes the Victorian Police are charging the people they have to protect, rather than the protesters threatening then. It is a horrible decision that provides perverse incentives.

The more you threaten a speaker you don’t like, the more money it will cost them to speak.

So pleased to see the NZ Police stick to a principled approach.

Jacinda backs Helen despite 91% of Aucklanders wanting the concert

The Herald reports:

LifePod incubator inventor Sir Ray Avery says planning delays could scuttle his planned charity concert at Eden Park because he has been given a “drop-dead” August deadline to confirm the headline star.

He said the unnamed international star’s promoter needs to confirm the venue by the end of August, but the Environment Court is not expected to rule until October on objections to a resource consent to allow the night-time event at Eden Park on Waitangi Day next year.

National MP Paul Goldsmith has urged the Government to “knock some heads together” to avoid the need to go to the Environment Court.

But a spokeswoman for Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern suggested Avery should look at other possible venues.

Which is what Helen wants.

Avery said he was inspired by a UMR poll for the Eden Park Trust today which found that 91 per cent of Aucklanders support the event going ahead at Eden Park.

The poll also sampled 350 people who live near Eden Park. Within that group support for the concert is at a massive 87%.  So the vast vast majority of locals support the concert being at Eden Park.

And the locals don’t just support this concert. Many it seems would like to be able to attend concerts locally. Of nearby residents:

  • 75% support up to 15 concerts a year there
  • 87% support up to six concerts a year there

If I was a local Labour MP, I’d be backing the concert strongly – it is overwhelmingly popular with not just Aucklanders but those who live near Eden Park.

An argument against the VUW name change

Hugh Rennie QC has a lengthy well argued article against the proposed name change for VUW. Some key points he makes:

  • In my view the reasons proposed for it are banal and lack any credible reasons. The alleged commercial features for national and international recruitment count for nothing. Status comes from a university building up its reputation over decades and even centuries.
  • A geographic name is meaningless (leaving aside the number of towns of that name worldwide). One instantly thinks of Monash, Macquarie, Harvard, Stamford, Sorbonne and many others without even knowing which cities they are found in.
  • VUW has spent an unknown number of hundreds of thousands of dollars20 without establishing a credible case for change, and is now about to commit to spend hundreds of thousands of dollars more to implementing a break with its past as a risky and unnecessary experiment as to its international reputation which is unlikely to succeed and whose failure would cause serious damage to VUW.

Would be good to have more parking operators

Stuff reports:

Wilson Parking could be forced to give up a parking building in central Wellington, as it faces court action alleging it “substantially” lessened competition in the area.

The Commerce Commission said it had filed proceedings in the High Court at Wellington against Wilson Parking over its acquisition of a large multi-level car park at 50-60 Boulcott Street in 2016.

It is seeking both penalties and to force the company to lose the lease.

In a statement, the competition watchdog said that in 2015, Wilson Parking was granted clearance obtain the nearby Plimmer Towers carpark, pointing out at the time that the company would face “competitive constraint” because a rival operated the Capital carpark on Boulcott St. 

There seem to be just two parking companies in Wellington. That’s better than one, but competition is limited.

Would be great to have more companies out there but I imagine it is a hard market to enter as you need high capital and good locations.

 

What would have happened if she had done this at Mecca?

Newshub reports:

Belgian model Marisa Papen has faced a barrage of online abuse after she posed naked in front of Jerusalem’s most sacred sites.

Ms Papen posted the controversial image of herself lying naked overlooking the Western Wall in Jerusalem. 

In a blog post called ‘The Wall of Shame’, Ms Papen defended the series of photos which were taken on a three-day road trip through Israel, where she travelled from Tel Aviv to Jerusalem, The Telegraph reports.

“I know my mailbox is about to fill up with threats and angriness again – to all the people typing down their ferocity right now, save your energy. I don’t even open them,” the post reads.

The purpose of the photoshoot was too “push the boundaries of religion and politics even further”. 

How brave of her. I think she could continue doing so by not just doing such a photoshoot at the most scared site in Judaism, but also other most sacred sites.

I suggest next she goes to Mecca, and pushes the boundaries there with a naked photoshoot. Probably no need to book in any more after that.

Israel Archaeological Dig #7

2018 Israel archaeological excavation at biblical Gath (home of Goliath)
by John Stringer, Tell es-Safi, west of Jerusalem.
Week One, Days 2-5: The Tools of Our Trade.

The tools we use in archaeology are selective and important, determined after years of experience re practicality and versatility. As well as high-tech (GPS, electro magnetometery, drones) we use a variety of hand tools largely unchanged since archaeology started 250 years ago.

We use a heavy pick (foreground) at first to loosen the soil, which is then meticulously sorted with a small trowel into a black soil bucket (“processed”). We work from the back wall forward, at about 20cm lengths deep, in a line. The heavy pick has a secondary narrow chopping or scrapping blade, and we have what we call a tourea (sp?) pictured in the background, a square bladed pick used to chop square sidings or scrape a soil level towards you (good for floor work).

Note the two large bulks on either side (above).  These have steel stakes pounded in and the spike tops are sealed with coloured plastic balls and a string is run straight and true between, at surface level for the length of the site (uphill). This sets right angle squares and matches the reality with what is plotted on the blue field plan. The coloured balls prevent people tripping and pitching head first into a ten foot deep pit often with rocks set in the floor. You have to be careful as the bulks are often very narrow and the edges can collapse.  As we find things, the square supervisor can plot the finds on the chart and draw in artefacts in situ. That is valuable data.  Without it, artefacts discovered become worthless.

We also use a broom head as a hand held duster, dusting over fragile artefacts of interest and to ‘clean’ a leveled surface (vertical or horizontal). Other implements include: the universal Marshall hand-held trowel (which does much of the work), a water canteen, vital in Israel. I like the brand pictured (below) at it is light, carries a lot of water, and can be hung in a tree for ready access or hitched over your shoulder while carrying other items.

Everyone wears gloves. I wear quality yellow leather gloves so they don’t get lost onsite; and leather is soft yet hard wearing. We are all attired in recommended long sleeves and long trousers (to ward off the UV despite the shading cover; insect bites, and skin snags on the vicious thorn bushes). Over top my trousers I wear heavy-duty knee pads as you spend a lot of time on your knees ‘processing’ soil.  These are a God-send and I’m glad I have good quality pads (particularly as I’m due a knee op. a week after I return to NZ, so underneath I have a knee brace on as well). Working for hours on your knees and then getting up, is tough on the back and knees. I also carry a large Bear Grylls knife, very useful in the hard soil (but which causes me no end of trouble in Korea- later) and a small Swiss-army-style pocket knife. (I actually get to use the fold out ‘stone from your shoe’ thingy – first time ever! that no-one ever actually uses).  At first I wear sunglasses but dispense with these as they discolour the coloured buckets (and pottery ends up in bone buckets) and it’s harder to detect the subtle soil differentiation’s. An ‘Indianna Jones’ hat is a must. I wear a Scottish gamekeeper’s-style ghillie. This is best as it has a chin strap for wind, and is vented on top so your head can breathe. Without this you sweat and overheat and salts build up on your forehead. Cowboy hats are not as good. Ghillies also press flat for easy packing.

Once on site I note professor Aren wears a similar hat, so I’m glad for this choice. Note Lucy’s hat behind him (below). After a career in the field in Israel, it is worth noting what he wears. He dons a small backpack with that fluid tube, but I prefer the separate canteen in a tree, as it is impractical to excavate with backpack straps under my armpits (as chief archaeologist he has a different role and function. I’m a grunt).

Below: 1) Aren and his backpack, note Lucy’s hat; and 2) on the trail up to the top of the Tell on the Day 1 Tour of the site. You can see the stoney nature of the surface and the need for robust footwear.

Arriving in Israel I had heavy duty hiking shoes, but these cause me real hell in the heat and after two days I’m hobbling with really painful blisters and raw foot soles.  So on the first weekend break, I purchase a cheap set of heavy duty soled boots like Aren’s, with soft sides that breathe, from an Old City Nazareth market store (more later). They only cost me $30 NZ and are a HUGE benefit in Week 2 making the archaeology way less uncomfortable. Israel shekel is 2.5 to $1 Kiwi dollar.

Donkey Work: Achish’s Ass

 

The filled black buckets are lifted up onto the bulk and must then be carried up the hill via the narrow bulk (which has a string on it that must not be disturbed) to a wheelbarrow, which must then be wheeled up a further slope to the upper soil dump site. The barrows can cope with 4 soil buckets each.  Anymore, and most people cannot wheel them up the slope. This is strenuous work, and as we are working with Ahuva and Erika, two of our veteran senior women, who cannot lift the soil buckets, John and I do their soil extraction work in 82C as well. As we ‘process’ with glove, trowel and bucket, we place any pottery into a blue bucket, and bones into a purple bucket (each bucket has two tags, more of which later).  Special or unusual finds (such as shells or flint) are passed to our square supervisor Eitan Meer, an ex-Israeli soldier and classics scholar.

Below: The upper soil dump site begins, and grows, and grows. This area is unshaded, so it’s very hard work in the blazing sun. One of the hardest workers on site is Dr David Kotter (pictured with barrow), Professor of New Testament Studies and Dean of the School of Theology, Colorado Christian University. A true servant to all. David and his colleague Dr Seth lead a student crew from Colorado. What a great bunch of Philistine diggers (verb not noun).

Occasionally artefacts are missed while being ‘processed.’ Wheel-barrowers extract artefacts in the dump soil and return them to the square they were from (if known) so they can be documented through the process. Significant finds are sometimes extracted from the dump site. This is because when we are ‘processing’ items, they are always covered in clay or dust and we often cannot see anything of significance, such as paint, so have to learn to bucket-sort by sight and feel what an object might be. For this purpose I keep a bucket with 2 inches of water in it nearby, to give oddities a quick ‘wash swirl’ to help identify where an item should go: pottery bucket; bones bucket; or dump bucket.  Better safe than sorry.

This colourful bichrome Philistine pottery sherd above, for example, was excavated by John and I from 82D but we did not see any of the fab painted decoration on it until it was cleaned 24 hours. It could easily have been tossed but for us discerning it by shape and consistency in gloved hands.

This Philistine leopard/lion rhyton (aka ‘The Happy Hippo’) below, I think was recovered from a dump site. It is Tell es-Safi’s official logo. Next to it I’ve posted some my photos from Ertez Museum (Tel Aviv) of similar Philistine zoomorphic sculpture, for comparison. The Philistines were very quirky in their art and clearly loved fauna and flora themes. We find a significant example in Week 3.

 

 

Jacinda should appoint Helen Ambassador to the US

Helen Clark used to run New Zealand. She then went on to running the UN Development Program.

Now her main activity seems to be picking fights with Eden Park.

She’s obviously bored and needs a job.

To spare us the daily headlines about what Helen has tweeted on any issue, I propose Jacinda gives her a decent job to keep her busy.

Why not Ambassador to the US? They are huge on hierarchy so nothing works better than a former PM. She gets to be called Prime Minister Clark for her duration there.

She managed to work with John Howard really well, despite their political differences (something this Government seems incapable of doing) so am sure she could work with Donald Trump.

So someone should start a petition demanding Jacinda appoint Helen as our Ambassador to the US.

Another day, another broken promise

Newshub reports:

The Government has stalled on plans to double New Zealand’s refugee quota – and it’s because of the housing crisis.

Immigration Minister Iain Lees-Galloway says Aotearoa need to sort that before it thinks about welcoming more refugees.

So yet another broken promise.

Labour have been saying there is a housing crisis for the last six years. So they knew all about it when they made their promise to double the refugee quota.

Looks like a no deal Brexit?

The Guardian reports:

The EU gave the British negotiating team a torrid time at the first presentation of the UK’s white paper on the future relationship during this week’s talks, the Guardian has learned.

Led by Michel Barnier’s deputy, Sabine Weyand, the EU’s team of officials picked apart the most contentious parts of the paper as it was presented by Olly Robbins, Theresa May’s chief Brexit adviser, leading to increased concerns on both sides that a no-deal scenario is moving from possible to likely.

“The white paper is not going to form the basis of the negotiations,” one senior EU diplomat told the Guardian. British government sources, in the wake of the latest talks, admitted growing despair over what they regard as the intransigence of their EU counterparts.

No deal is better than a very bad deal.

Hypocrisy on the West Coast from Jones

NewstalkZB reports:

Regional economic development on the West Coast needs to include mining, according to Regional Economic Development Minister Shane Jones.

Jones talks the talk but doesn’t walk the walk. His party put in place a Government that is hostile to the extractive industries.

“The extractive sector will not be written out of any script of regional development that I or the party I belong to are a part of,” said Jones, a New Zealand First MP.

“Just as the oil and gas reforms in Taranaki left intact people’s existing use rights, I am imagining any future changes to the mineral regime will not have an adverse impact on people’s existing use rights.

This is bullshit. Firstly the oil and gas reforms did demolish existing use rights. That is because there are three sorts of permits you can hold. They are:

  1. Prospecting
  2. Exploring
  3. Mining

A prospecting permit is a non-exclusive permit to survey an area to try and locate areas which are most likely to have oil or gas. Companies with prospecting permits sell the info they obtain to companies who want to get an exploration permit.

The Government has ruled out any future exploration permits which means the prospecting permits are now useless. They have no customers to sell to. They invested millions in prospecting permits in good faith.

Jones said a balance needed to be struck between conservation and mining.

Jones voted for the Greens to be in Government, meaning a Green Party Minister now decides all applications for mining on conservation lands. There will be no balance.

“Stewardship land has been lying around since Rogernomics times and any changes to stewardship land will be a change of policy agreed to by the entire Government.”

The PM has already said that no mining will be allowed on any conservation land. This is a major policy shift but it has already occurred and Jones did nothing to stop it.

NZ upsets Aussie again

News.com.au reports:

New Zealand Justice Minister Andrew Little claims that Australia is breaching human rights with its hard-line deportation policy. But Mr Hawke dubbed this “irresponsible”.

He took to Twitter during the night of the program to express his disappointment in Mr Little:

“Disappointing to see the NZ Justice Minister fail to use his TV appearance to remind people who are NZ citizens here to obey the laws of Australia. Obeying the law and not committing serious offences is the best way to not be deported.

Almost all the criminal deportations in the assault & domestic violence cohorts are shocking violent crimes. Many have multiple convictions & offences. Many had multiple ‘warnings’ about future deportation. Our Gov makes no apology for deporting serious & violent criminals.”

Don’t bash people in Australia and you won’t get deported. Pretty simple really.

During his Sky News interview Mr Hawke had a direct message for Aussies living across the Ditch.

“We would as the Australian Government say to citizens in New Zealand, ‘Well you must obey the law, and if you don’t obey the law you may be deported back to Australia.’

“We’d like to hear the same message from the New Zealand Government.”

No chance it seems. Those being deported are the victims of the nasty Australian Government, according to our Government.

Hehir on free speech

Liam Hehir writes:

Not long ago, an activist telephoned me about a column I had written poking fun at the Government for relying on so many “working groups”. It started with a demand to know why I had been allowed to publish it. The shrieking quickly progressed to obscenity and then to talk of unmentionable, violent things happening to myself and my wife. When I hung up, the activist continued trying to contacting me to resume the tirade.

I told the police about it. After a while, they sent me a letter saying they were on it. I’ve not heard anything since. As far as I know, nothing much has happened or will happen.

The growing intolerance to speech people disagree with.

Think about the phrase “fake news”. Today, you are most likely to hear it being used by United States President Donald Trump and his supporters to delegitimise opposition media. They have taken the concept, twisted it and made it their own.

Right now, the US government does not have the power to prohibit hate speech. But imagine if it did. How long do you think it would be before somebody like Trump started to apply the reasoning to his domestic opponents?

Those who want laws against so called hate speech will get a nasty surprise when those laws end up being used against them.

Those in favour of proscribing repellent views often fall back on the cliche that free speech laws do not protect “falsely shouting ‘fire’ in a crowded theatre”. In other words, some speech creates dangers to society. Accordingly, the state has a right, and indeed a duty, to protect its citizens from such speech.

Some people who use this metaphor know it originated with former US Supreme Court Justice Oliver Wendell Holmes. In my experience, however, very few of them are aware of the particular case that occasioned his analogy. They are usually surprised to learn it was made in the context of a judgment upholding the imprisonment of socialist activists who had distributed a pamphlet criticising conscription during World War I.

I did not know that. A good lesson from history.

In later years, that decision was largely overturned. In the intervening years, the US developed a more robust respect for the freedom of speech. New Zealand has developed a similar free-speech culture.

And the value of that culture isn’t that it protects racists and crackpots. It’s that it protects the humane and decent, who will not always hold the reins of power. The re-emergence of authoritarianism in continental Europe, where free-speech rights are less embedded, may well provide a warning here.

So should we accord liberal free speech rights to those with deplorable views? Yes. But it’s not to protect them from us. It’s to protect us from them.

Well said.

Read the statement of claim

The Herald has the statement of claim filed by the Free Speech Coalition. Here’s some interesting aspects that show you how badly Auckland Council has acted.

  • The decision to cancel was made before a health and safety plan was due to be submitted, showing that health and safety concerns must be phony
  • One of the plaintiffs had already booked airfares from Dunedin to attend, so Goff’s actions have caused people to be out of pocket
  • The organisers did not expect the venue to provide security. They are very experienced in providing security for events including several larger events in Australia
  • RFA refused to engage with the organisers about their alleged security concerns
  • Goff said on Radio NZ that it was his decision to cancel the licence but now claims it was made independently
  • The organisers were unable to get a private venue at ASB Showgrounds as Goff is a vice patron of them

Cabinet went against their own Minister on prisons

David Bennett released:

Corrections Minister Kelvin Davis advised Cabinet to adopt the previous Government’s plan to build 1500 beds at Waikeria Prison because it was ‘the only sensible plan’, but his colleagues ignored his advice, National’s Corrections spokesperson David Bennett says. …

“In a December 2017 paper also released yesterday, Mr Davis advised Cabinet that in recognition of the forecast shortfall, maintaining National’s plan was the ‘only sensible plan of action’ and recommended the Government implement the plan we had in place.

“But his colleagues ignored him and just six months later the Government recklessly went ahead with its dangerous plan to downsize the Waikeria Prison build by 1000 beds.

Incredible. They are deliberately building too few beds in prisons, so that they have to let dangerous prisoners out early on the grounds they prisons are overcrowded!

Also Stuff reports:

Double bunking in cells could increase the risk of prisoner-on-prisoner assaults and reduce rehabilitation opportunities at Waikeria Prison, a cabinet paper says.

Room sharing badly impacts inmates’ health, reduces rehabilitation opportunities, moves prisoners away from normalisation and can mean upping staff ratios, according to a paper Corrections Minister Kelvin Davis presented to cabinet before the Waikeria Prison plan was signed off. 

So they went for the option that increases assaults and reduces rehabilitation opportunities.

The guidelines for the minimum size of a two-person cell is 10sqm of living space, plus sanitary annex. The new cells, however, will be 9sqm. 

And they are going under the minimum recommended size.