Poor Allan Dean

The ODT reports that A UN Human Rights Committee has ruled that nasty old New Zealand has breached the rights of Allan Dean, by not giving Dean a parole hearing three years earlier than it did. New Zealand has been instructed to offer a remedy for this breach and report back to the UN within 180 days on what it has done – persumably how much money Dean has been given.

So the UN has agreed with Tony Ellis that Allan Dean’s rights have been infringed by giving him preventative detention with a ten year non parole period. So what is Allan Dean’s record:

  1. In 1959 indecently assaulted a youth in the dark
  2. In 1960 indecently assaulted a solider
  3. In 1964 indecently assaulted a 15 year old boy in a cinema
  4. In 1966 sentenced to jail and warned of preventative detention if he reoffended
  5. he then reoffended six months after being released
  6. In 1970 sentenced to eight year’s jail for three indecent assaults on boys aged under 16, and warned of preventative detention if he reoffended
  7. He then reoffended seven months after being released
  8. In 1993 sentenced to jail and warned of preventative detention if he reoffended.
  9. He reoffended three months later after being released
  10. In 1995 indecently assaulted a 13 year old boy in a cinema by fondling his crotch
  11. Admitted in 1995 that his offending was much more regular than his convictions indicated
  12. Finally given preventative detention in 1995

The ODT continues:

Mr Ellis said in a statement that the only effective remedy was compensation.

A spokesman for Justice Minister Simon Power said the committee’s report was being considered.

Yes let us give money to the paedophile, as the nice UN wants us to. And also let him out of jail to molest more children. I mean he only got three explicit warnings about preventative detention, before it was imposed. And hell the Courts rushed to judgement – they rushed to preventative detention after only 36 years of offending.

Crime not a big issue says Shearer

NZPA report:

Ms Lee said she was “feeling great” about the campaign, and had already started door knocking.

“We are in the rain and cold to meet the people in Mt Albert to see what they are concerned about,” she said.

Residents were concerned about the same things the rest of New Zealand was, she said.

She believed law and order was a big issue for people in the area.

“As a victim of a home invasion myself I understand exactly how they feel. I want to feel safe in my own home and on the street.”

Few would disagree, would they?

He said the big issues for the electorate were the Waterview Connection motorway, the “super-city”, which people didn’t understand, and the economy. Mr Shearer said he did not believe crime was such a big issue, but people did want “strong, safe communities.”

So crime not such a big issue. Putting aside the unfortunate timing in such a statement, I doubt few many Aucklanders would agree.

Dyslexics have a sense of humour

I am sure mosy dyslexics have a very good sense of humour, but you wouldn’t think so from the Dyslexic Foundation. NZPA reports:

Posters advertising the New Zealand Comedy Festival have been withdrawn after sponsor Cadbury received complaints that its dig at dyslexics wasn’t funny.

Posters for the festival in Wellington and Auckland reading: “10 out of 9 dyslexics prefer Crunchie” had drawn the ire of the Dyslexic Foundation, The Dominion Post reported.

“You certainly wouldn’t make comments like that about other groups who have a disability,” foundation spokesman Guy Pope-Mayell said.

The posters were insensitive to people living with dyslexia, and misrepresented the condition as not all dyslexics transposed numbers and letters.

Cadbury had immediately withdrawn the posters from Auckland buses and bus stops, and apologised for any offence, company spokesman Daniel Ellis said.

One day all humour will be exterminated.

MFAT

Two good articles on MFAT and NZ Aid. Fran O’Sullivan has a look at MFAT and what the (yet to be announced) appointment of John Allen means. Fran says:

The commission’s panel was encouraged to look at the top MFat job in an “expansive way” and select a new chief executive who could (and this is the most important point) provide leadership for New Zealand – not just the Foreign Affairs Ministry – to help propel a much more aggressive approach offshore.

Fran says it is about getting less silos and better co-operations from not just MFAT, but also NZT&E, Immigration Service, Education NZ, and Tourism NZ.

Meanwhile in the Dom Post, Nick Venter looks at NZ Aid:

He starts with why NZ Aid was made semi-autonomous:

Eight years ago an independent review of New Zealand’s  aid programme raised major  concerns about the way aid  money was distributed.

The reviewers reported that the Foreign Affairs and Trade Ministry, which administered the aid programme, regarded aid as “an instrument of foreign policy”, that almost a quarter of the total aid budget of $250 million was spent on tertiary education scholarships – despite poor completion rates and the failure of many students to return home.

The ministry had used $500,000 of aid money to relocate the Samoan Department of Lands, Surveys and Environment so a new New Zealand high commission could be built, that the ministry used its development agency as a “dumping ground for non-performers” and that there was no “formal documented system of analysis or defined criteria used for determining the annual allocation process”.

McCully says:

“You don’t make changes like this if you don’t have to,” he said. “But in terms of the audit reports that have been brought down and some of the examples that I have looked at, over months now, I made up my own mind that I wasn’t going to carry the can for those things.”

Mr McCully has publicly questioned NZAid’s priorities, the amount of money it puts into “unproductive” regional bureaucracies, the size of its staff (281) and the proportion of the aid budget spent on internal overheads (about 8 per cent), but concern about accountability persuaded him to put it back under the umbrella of the ministry.

He says the agency, headed throughout its existence by former diplomat Peter Adams, wrongly assumed that being a semi-autonomous body entitled it to operate outside the normal state sector controls. “NZAid looked at the word autonomous and ignored the word semi.”

One of the consequences was that NZAid did not tell the ministry things it needed to know, “sometimes involving large amounts of money or serious matters of national interest”.

McCully also seems to think overheads were too high:

Mr McCully said he had also been concerned by NZAid’s response to questioning of its overheads. “I was annoyed to find that we were running overheads that were about 8 per cent of the total budget and that NZAid regarded themselves as being immune from any sort of scrutiny in that respect.

At a time when I was putting MFAT through the wringer, I was being told that NZAid were not open to that degree of scrutiny because we just gave them a bulk number and they decided how much of it was going to be overheads . . . . When I said, ‘Okay, presumably that will go down quite a lot when the budget goes up to $600 million,’ I was told, ‘No, it will go up to 9 per cent.’ I said, ‘How is that?’ They said, ‘That is just what we have decided.’ “

The story also focuses on what the goal should be:

He is also sharply critical of Mr McCully’s decision to abandon the poverty alleviation focus favoured by other Western governments as well as the International Monetary Fund and the World Bank.

“Economic development is an important contributor to poverty alleviation, but it’s a means to an end, not an end itself.

“The key to poverty alleviation is benefiting those most in need. Traditionally the elites benefit when money is pumped in with an economic development focus. You achieve poverty alleviation through investment in education, health, literacy and governance.”

Mr McCully, who has described poverty alleviation as a “rather nebulous concept”, says the success of the new focus will be measurable in, among other things, improved trade statistics.

“It is unacceptable that we should be exporting a billion dollars worth of goods to the Pacific and having empty ships coming back here. It shows that we are spending too much of our money on stuff that might help alleviate poverty this year but it does not do anything about next year and the year after.”

One thing is for sure – all eyes will be focused on NZ Aid for the next few years.

Molenaar dead

It looks like the Napier siege is over, with Jan Molenaar presumed dead at his own hand, and Police seen in his house this morning, after some blasts during the night. Herald has updates.

Even better news is that Police have recovered the body of Len Snee, and Police Dog Fi recovered alive.

Also stories are confirming that the civilian shot, probably saved the life of two Police officers by intervening. Giove that man a medal.

An interesting tidbit, is that Police Minister Judith Collin’s husband used to be an undercover officer himself. So she will know well the worry you can have about whether they will return home unarmed.

UPDATE: He is confirmed dead. Found dead in a bedroom just after midday.

Grey Power on Ministers

Even I was laughing yesterday as Annette King was reading out some frank observations from Grey Power on initial Ministerial meetings, wth Bill English trying to sugarcoat them. Claire Trevett reports:

The post-mortem by president Les Howard on the March visit has handed King a wonderful arsenal.

She first reads out his rendition of bumping into ACC Minister Nick Smith, who had not responded to their requests to meet.

“His face reddened, and with his head down the moment the lift arrived at the ground floor he took to his heels and was last seen hurrying away in the distance.”

Heh, and even better:

King, obligingly, shares their verdict of that hard-won meeting as one that “left a sour taste in our mouths as we felt we had received the old-fashioned ‘brush-off’.”

It went on, saying Bennett needed to “shape up to her obligations”, before ending, “It appears she thinks a loud laugh will solve all questions put to her and this meeting was a complete waste of her time. Well, it certainly was a waste of ours.”

Ouch.

However Claire goes on to report on teh quotes that Annette did not read out:

Had English read the full report, he would have had a happier time. Grey Power described him as “very pleasant”, and Senior Citizens Minister John Carter as “one who can be trusted to get things done, rather than just talk about what needs to be done”.

Nice.

But the real killer English needed to take the wind out of King’s sails came in their verdict of the PM: “I found John Key much easier to talk to than the previous Prime Minister”.

Heh that would have been a wonderful rejoinder, if Bill had it at the time.

The Brash e-mails file

The Dom Post reports:

Police national headquarters confirmed this week that the file’s release was imminent, after fighting its disclosure for more than a year.

A Brash ally, government relations consultant Matthew Hooton, has been battling police for more than a year over their refusal to release the file. He took the case to the ombudsman.

Mr Hooton was yesterday cautious about the police about-turn. “We may be pleasantly surprised, but our understanding is that the file will be so heavily censored as to be meaningless and we expect the matter will return to the ombudsman or even end up in the courts.”

Dr Brash said police had told him they were about to release the file and had sent him a “heavily censored” version.

This is ridicolous. Why won’t they release the full version, rather than one with 90% redacted?

Hooton in NBR states:

The file will be so heavily censored it will largely be blank and will contain no new information.  This pseudo-release follows an Official Information Act (OIA) request my government relations firm lodged on May 27, 2007.  Under the law, PNHQ had 20 days to respond.  In fact, getting to this point, two years later, has required enormous effort by my staff and pro bono assistance from Kensington Swan.

Lest anyone think police files can’t be released, the “paintergate” press conference, at which PNHQ announced Ms Clark would not face forgery charges, suggests otherwise.  Then, PNHQ staff told journalists that if they scribbled down an OIA request, the file would be released, uncensored, the same day.

I think Mr Hooton and Kensington Swan need to press on – even if it means court action. Hell I can think of a lot of people who might donate to help cover the costs.

Let the truth come out.

The Selwyn Electoral Petition

Legal friends have forwarded to me the judgement of the Electoral Court – civ3089_08-payne-v-adams. To save people reading the full 42 pages (except Geddis and Knight), here are some key extracts:

payne1

This is the primary reason why National did not want a bar of Payne. Breaking a written undertaking is no small thing. In fact it normally leads to expulsion from the party, let alone precluding future candidacy.

payne2

Oh dear. Here the Justices fund Mr Payne misled the court.

payne3

No you did not misread this. Mr Payne has had 70 court hearings on other issues, and personally sued three Judges. I almost feel sorry for the three High Court Justices who made up the Electoral Court – he will probably now go after them.

payne4

The Court finds that Payne does not even have standing to bring an electoral petition. It is all over at this point, but for the sake of completeness the Justices helpfully make findings on several other issues.

payne5

This confirms that electoral petitions are about elections – not about internal party issues around candidate selections.

payne6

And here they concur with a previous court case that the National Party rules comply with the Electoral Act.

payne7

payne7

A private group such as the National Party is not required to have “natural justice”, as per public bodies. But here the Court rules that even if there was a natural justice test, the verto of Payne’s nomination did not breach the Act.

payne8

And here the Court finds that Payne lied on his nomination form, or as they put it “made untruthful and inaccurate statements”.

payne9

Usefully the Court also finds no evidence of wrongdoing by President Judy Kirk, Regional Chair Roger Bridge, and Electorate Chair John Skinner. The former two men especially have had their names dragged through the mud by Mr Payne.

payne10

And here we have the dismissal of the petition, the confirmation of Amy Adams as MP for Selwyn and a reservation over costs.

This has cost the National Party an immense amount of money – over an issue that was always doomed to failure. Sadly I suspect that no matter what damages the Court orders paid, the party will never actually see the money.

Arguably there was some minor good from the case – the rulings on electoral petitions and candidate selections under the Electoral Act are useful confirmations of the law.

Sir Keith Park campaign is sucessful

The campaign to have a statue of WWII hero (and Kiwi) SIr Keith Park in London has been sucessful. Thanks to all those who supported the campaign.

Stuff reports:

A statue of New Zealander Sir Keith Park will be erected in London’s Trafalgar Square, the Westminister City Council has just ruled.

Sir Keith led the Battle of Britain which saved the country from the Nazis.

The statue will be on the fourth plinth around Nelson’s Column for six months before being moved to a permanent position on Waterloo Place.

park1

Long may people view the statue of Sir Keith – who won the Battle of Britain!

Health Targets

The ODT reports that Tony Ryall has set just six targets for DHBs (I presume on top of don’t run out of money). They are:

  1. cut emergency department waiting times so 95% treated within six hours
  2. deliver faster treatment for cancer patients – all those needing radiation treatment to get it within six weeks by July 2010 and within four weeks by Dec 2010
  3. carry out more elective surgery – an extra 4,000 operations per year
  4. more immunisations – 85% immunised by July 2010, 90% July 2011 and 95% July 2012
  5. better help fro smokers to quit – 95% of smokers in hospital to be given advice and help to quit
  6. better diabetes services

What were the targets from the previous Government:

  1. 13 health priorities
  2. 61 objectives
  3. additional subset of 13 health objectives
  4. 10 health targets measured through 18 indicators
  5. 25 other indicators of DHB performance
  6. 4 hospital benchmark indicators assessed through 15 measures
  7. an outcomes framework with 9 outcomes, measured against 39 headline indicators

Sounds like doctors may have more time to see patients and be spending less time reporting on priorities, objectives, indicators and outcomes. Also sounds like we may have a few less administrators.

New iPredict stocks

Some fun new iPredict stocks:

  1. Who will win in Mt Albert – Labour is at 86c, National 13c, Greens 2c
  2. Will NZ get a credit downgrade by end of July – 17c
  3. Will swine flu become a pandemic – 42c

Investors seem very confident that Bill English will do enough to prevent a credit downgrade.

Julian Robertson

This Herald story from 2005 has Trevor Mallard accusing Julian Robertson of being a secret American bagman for National, despite the fact he had also donated to Dover Samuels.

Mike Williams called him a “very right-wing activist”.

This awful American bagman, and “very right-wing” activist has just donated $115 million of art to the Auckland Art Gallery.

Bravo Mr Robertson. The largest single gift in Australasia. The donated peices include two Picassos.

He said he and his wife had the idea for the gift after the gallery hosted an exhibition of 14 paintings from their New York collection in 2006.

The free show attracted 30,000 visitors in 30 days, and the positive public response via letters and comments, which the gallery sent to the Robertsons, profoundly moved them.

“They were most appreciative of seeing the pictures, more appreciative than anything else we have ever done,” said Mr Robertson.

“You fall in love with these pictures a little bit and you want to be sure they will be left with somebody who loves them and that [exhibition] made us realise that they would be loved … We are really very happy that those pictures are going to be in Auckland for the rest of their time on Earth.”

What a stunning gift, that will be with us for centuries.

Labour MPs blog

Excellent initiative by Labour – they have set up a Labour MPs blog.

National should look at a parliamentary blog – I would do it like the Greens. MPs posting under their own names, and staffers posting under a generic name (Frog for the Greens).

Fed Farmers on ETS

The Fed Farmers VP has an op ed in the Dom Post:

Today, we can ill afford to further weaken the economy unless we wish to replace recession with depression. Research by the New Zealand Institute of Economic Research shows that the ETS could lead to 22,000 job losses.

The Agriculture and Forestry Ministry says the ETS will progressively reduce farm profitability and viability by 61.6 per cent for the average dairy farm and 80.3 per cent for the average sheep and beef farm. That is an economic implosion.

All of this will be taken from a sector that has outperformed the rest of the economy for 25 of the past 27 years.

The ETS over-reaches itself by putting a price of carbon on all emissions, whereas Kyoto requires New Zealand to account only for emissions above 1990 levels. We don’t need an ETS to meet our Kyoto obligations.

For better or worse we are in Kyoto. But whether a carbon tax, an ETS or simply just paying our liability (if we even have one) is the best option is far from clear. And if we have an ETS, will we be the only country in the world to include agriculture?

Worse, the ETS takes us where no other country has gone and applies a price of carbon to emissions arising from food production. It also prevents productive land being used for farming if it has trees on it. Forests are best planted on marginal land unsuited to food production, so we need pragmatism not dogmatism.

Therefore, we must ask, where is the global upside if New Zealand artificially throttles back its agricultural production, allowing less efficient producers to fill the void?

And that is why any replacement to Kyoto, must include all emitting countries. Otherwise we will damage our economy and damage the environment more.

But before anyone accuses Federated Farmers of being reactionary, climate change is real. There is no doubt that 6.8 billion human beings affect the environment and humanity grows at the rate of 80 million new mouths each year.

So, if we abandon the ETS, what could be done to get New Zealand through to 2012 when the Kyoto protocol lapses?

Given carbon is cheap right now, the Government could purchase Kyoto emissions units to put in the bank, giving us the means to meet our liabilities through to 2012.

A low-level carbon charge could be introduced and set at a rate that recovers just enough revenue to account for any emissions deficit.

The Government could fund the planting of lots of trees to develop new forestry sinks and jobs. Instead of following the international pack, New Zealand could lead it by pushing for each country to allocate a percentage of GDP toward climate change initiatives.

It is interesting that even Australia has delayed its ETS by a year.

Denmark, one of Europe’s greenest countries, considered a tax on its farming sector in February but quickly realised what folly this was and excluded the primary production of food from its Kyoto response in March. Denmark correctly saw there was no point in sacrificing its farmers when less efficient countries would only produce more.

In Denmark, agriculture accounts for about 19 per cent of all exports; in New Zealand, it’s a jaw- dropping 64 per cent. So why should we care if New Zealand agricultural emissions actually increase? Our farmers generate enough food to feed at least 1 per cent of humanity but are continually chastised for the supposed 0.1 per cent of global emissions this generates.

He makes a strong case.

Napier stand off continues

The Herald has coverage of the ongoing seige.

I am surprised the Police have not gone in yet, but sounds like the House is booby trapped, so that is no doubt a factor.

I recall some dark humour the last time an officer was shot in the Hawke’s Bay – in the mid 90s. The killer escaped and there was a manhunt. He was eventually caught up with, refused to surrender and shot dead.

At Parliament the normal group met every morning to work out what questions to ask to Ministers. A mate of mine known for his sense of humour chipped in with “Will the Government provide counselling to those officers who did not get a shot away”. It took a few seconds for people to realise the subtle change from the normal “WIll the Government provide counselling to the Officers who did the killing”, recognising that when it comes to shooting a cop killer, Officers don’t normally feel as much moral anguish as shooting someone else.

The fact this killer won’t even let Police recover the body of their fallen comrade (and has prevented them from any chance of saving his life) will have them in a silent fury – still professionaly focused on the job, but very determined not to let him kill anyone else.

I do like the report that Whale has of the killing of a cop killer in Florida:

The cop killer was shot 68 times with Police, with 110 rounsd fired at him. The Polk County Sheriff when questioned on why he was shot at 110 times, replied:

Polk County Sheriff Grady Judd said he was not concerned by the number of shots fired.

“You have to understand, he had already shot and killed a deputy, he had already shot and killed a K-9 and he shot and injured another deputy,” Judd said by phone Saturday. “Quite frankly, we weren’t taking any chances.”

Ten SWAT officers surrounded Freeland on Friday as he hid beneath brush and a fallen tree in a rural area. Authorities say he raised the gun belonging to the deputy he had killed, prompting nine officers to fire.

“I suspect the only reason 110 rounds was all that was fired was that’s all the ammunition they had,”

Heh, and in NZ we debate whether cops should do a single or double tap!

Latest news from the Herald is here.

The Herald also has a profile of Len Snee. I’ve also had e-mails from people who know him, and he was hugely respected and liked. The Dom Post also profiles him, including comments from Pita Sharples who has known him for decades.

Labour’s lineup provides hope for the future

My weekly Dispatch from St Johnnysburg is up at NBR, and I look in more depth at Labour’s lineup in the economic portfolios. Some extracts:

Labour’s lineup with regard to economic policies is showing some promise. No they are not going to be reformers in the Douglas/Caygill mode (but neither is National), but Phil Goff is assembling a team that has business experience and may not treat reform as a dirty word.

Policy in the 5th Labour Government was driven by four university lecturers – Helen Clark, Michael Cullen, Heather Simpson and Steve Maharey. They had no serious agenda to increase productivity – their job was working out how to spend the money.

This is different to other Labour Governments around the world. In Australia Labor PM Kevin Rudd and Treasurer Wayne Swan have both attended the Consilium conference put on by the Centre for Independent Studies. In NZ, Michael Cullen would simply attack their report on the basis that one of their researchers once worked for Bill English.

Feedback and comments can be made at NBR.

Lockwood being tough

Lockwood was pretty tough on the Government today. Made Rodney Hide admit there was no cost estimate for the Auckland re-organisation, told Pansy Wong off for far too long answers and slapped down Jonathan Coleman for not answering a question and just attacking the Opposition spokesperson.

To which I say – keep it up Lockwood. Good job.

RIP Len Snee

Senior Constable Len Snee is the 29th police office to die in the line of duty. The Police are one of the very few jobs where you do have to regularly risk being assaulted, or more rarely killed, as part of the job.

Three officers have been killed in the last nine months. To put that into context, there were only three officers killed from 1991 to 2007.

Lies and Fearmongering

David Parker manages both with this press release.

The National Government has given its clearest signal yet that superannuation entitlements will be cut in the future, Labour Associate Finance spokesman David Parker says.

Fearmonger No 1

A reminder. John Key has said he will resign his seat in Parliament if he cuts superannuation entitlements. But not even that will stop Labour trying to prey on the insecurity of retired or near retired persons.

“The pensions of tomorrow need to be protected today. National said before and during the election they would continue with payments to the Super Fund, but have now resiled from this.”

And if Parker reads the announcement from Michael Cullen, when the Fund was established, he will see that Cullen explicitly said that contributions are funded out of surpluses and would be suspended temporarily when there is no surplus.

Not even Dr Cullen was foolish enough to advocate borrowing money to save money.

“Mr English argues that he’s not prepared to borrow to fund the investment in the Super Fund, but he’s already done that to pay for his tax cuts – an astounding third of which go to the top three per cent of income earners,” David Parker says.

Then we have the lie – the claimed borrowing for tax cuts. The extra tax cuts by National were fully paid for by reduced expeniture on KiwiSaver. This is a fact. Parker knows this. He just hopes if you repeat a lie enough times, people will believe it.

“Those tax cuts were not just unfair, but they are a substantial cause of the structural deficit New Zealand now faces and are behind the Government’s plan to now cut investment in the Super Fund.

And he lies again. National’s tax cuts are considerably less foregone revenue that the reduction in KiwSaver subsidisies. The structural deficit would be worse, not better, if National tax cuts and KiwiSaver changes had not been made. This is indisputable. The quantum of each is known and the foregone revenue from tax cuts is les than the reduction in KiwiSaver subsidies.

Everytime you hear Labour talk about borrowing for tax cuts – they are lying. They are desperate to have people beleive it, but it is not true, as National reduced expenditure by a greater amount than the tax cuts to pay for it.

If Labour were honest they would campaign on how National reduced KiwiSaver subsidies for tax cuts, and debate the merits of that. Of course they don’t want to, as anyone economically literate now concedes the KiwiSaver subsidies were far too generous.

Blog Bits

  1. Rob Hosking at NBR looks at Mt Albert. He also makes some astute observations that almost all of the issues Labour is pushing are beltway issues of concern to few people. He concludes the seat is Labour’s to lose.
  2. Gooner at no Minister is concerned for David Bain’s poor memory.
  3. Roarprawn approves of Murray MCcully giving $5.6 million to help treat blindness in the Pacific via the Fred Hollows Foundation.
  4. Whale Oil has a Twitter screen shot of Labour MP Clare Curran saying “rodney hide gives me the creeps”. Pretty pathethic.
  5. Editing the Herald reports on a nastygram from the Herald’s lawyers over their banner. While the Herald has every right to protect its trademarks, I must say a polite request to stop would go down far better than immediate threats to sue.
  6. Chris Keall at NBR looks at the Vodafone vs Telecom lawsuit

Exorcism

My first reaction upon reading The Dom Post report of the trial for exorcism manslaughter was that at least when the US water boards, they don’t actually kill the detainee.

A teenager has told how she was pinned down, and water poured in her eyes and mouth to free her of the demon insider her.

She remembered saying, “I’m gonna die,” before blanking out in a ceremony in which another person is alleged to have drowned.

And

The recording was played in the High Court at Wellington yesterday where nine people are charged with the manslaughter of mother-of-two Janet Moses, 22, who the Crown says drowned during the same water-based exorcism ritual.

I find it hard to believe that nine adults could actually think that possession by demons or curses was literal, and that exorcism was the preferred response. And these people get a vote!

Selwyn Electoral Petition outcome at 2 pm

I understand that the Speaker has been delivered the judgement in the Selwyn Electoral Petition by Roger Payne, and he will announce the outcome and table it at 2 pm.

It will be a relief to Amy Adams to have it all out of the way.

UPDATE: And the Speaker has announced that the determination of the High Court is that Amy Adams is confirmed as the MP for Selwyn. Goodbye and good riddance Mr Payne. What a waste of time and money.