NZ on Screen

I’ve spent hours this week looking at some classic NZ television at NZ on Screen. NZ on Screen is funded by NZ on Air to allow access to historical NZ television and film etc. I think digitising the archives is a wonderful thing to do.

Highlights are the Simon Walker interview with Rob Muldoon. I’d forgotten how young Walker was then.

Also Brian Edwards negotiating an end to a Post Office strike on screen.

They’ve got 434 titles on there so far, and have them sorted by genre which makes it easy to find your favourite classic. They have an episode of It’s In the Bag, some Billy T, McPhail and Gadsby, a 1953 short film on Hillary returning to NZ. and the first ever episode of Gloss!

Lots of goodies to enjoy.

Vodafone and Telecom settle

Very pleased to see an agreement between the teclos. Vodafone says:

Vodafone and Telecom NZ have worked together over the last 48 hours to reach a solution to resolve the issues between them, which have been identified by both parties.

This agreement has been reached by both parties, to achieve the best outcome for their customers, the telecommunications industry and all New Zealanders.

Telecom has agreed to extend its network filter installation programme, in order to help resolve the interference issues identified as impacting Vodafone mobile customers.

Vodafone has agreed to discontinue its injunction proceedings. Telecom’s new XT mobile network will go live for New Zealanders by the end of May 2009.

I have not followed the court case, but the fact Vodafone has withdrew suggests they were unlikely to win.

UPDATE: A spokesperson for Vodafone tells me that they withdrew the court proceedings because Telecom agreed to everything they asked for.

Bay of Plenty ratepayers the losers

I could not believe what I read on Stuff:

Bay of Plenty ratepayers face “very extensive costs” with Whakatane District Council continuing legal action to prevent the regional council relocating headquarters to Tauranga, Environment Bay of Plenty chairman John Cronin says.

The Whakatane council has said it would appeal last month’s High Court judicial review finding that Environment Bay of Plenty followed correct procedure in deciding to shift from Whakatane to Tauranga.

This is insane. You have Whakatane ratepayers funding court action agaunst the Regional Council, funded by all BOP ratepayers.

The Regional Council is going to have its HQ where it sees fit. Even if the process had been wrong (and the court said it wasn’t), they will eventually be able to move. The only winner will be the lawyers.

Rodney Hide should tell the Whakatane District Council to drop its lawsuit, or face replacing with a Commissioner. The purpose of TLAs is not to sue employers who decide to move to other towns.

Unemployment hits 5.0%

Could be worse, but I think the worst is yet to come. The March 2009 HLFS reveals:

  • Employment drops by 24,000 jobs
  • Unemployment increases by 7.000 – or from 4.7% to 5.0%
  • Total Labour force drops 17,000

The revised figures for 2008 have unemployment increasing from 3.5% to 4.7% in that calendar year.

20 – 24 year olds especially hard hit with their unemployment rate going from 7.3% to 12.0% – some of that may be seasonal though. 25 – 29 year old unemployment only went from 4.6% to 4.8%.

Employment changes by sector is interesting:

  • Ag/Forest/Fish up 800
  • Manufacturing down 6,700
  • Construction up 2,700
  • Wholesale/Retail down 31,400
  • Health/Comm up 8,200

One bright spot is number of hours worked did not fall – rose from 73,261 to 73,424. This may be reflected by the fact only 11,000 FT jobs were lost while 16,000 PT jobs went.

Another rare bright spot is our OECD ranking moves from 10= to 9. We are now better off (less worse really) than Australia and Luxembourg. It is worth reflecting that 5.0% is a lot better than OECD average of 7.3% or the US at 8.5%.

Front bench blog poll

In the sidebar are blog polls on how well the Cabinet front bench Ministers are doing. This is our second blog poll on the Ministers, so it will be interesting to see how perceptions have changed from two months ago. They are of course unscientific, but can still show interesting trends.

Voting closes arund midday Wednesday next week.

Three Police shot, one dead

Oh God. NZPA reports:

Up to three police officers have been shot at in Napier this morning.

One officer was dead, NewstalkZB reported.

The shooting took place in Chaucer Rd, in Ahuriri north of the central city.

Police confirmed to NZPA there had been a firearms incident but would not say whether police had been shot.

My thoughts go out to all to all the Police, and especially the families of those shot. Hopefully the other two Officers will survive.

UPDATE: Latest reports are slightly better – one dead, one injured. The shooting took place in Chaucer Rd, on Napier Hill – near a gang headquarters. The AOS have flown in by helicopter.

UPDATE2: A woman has been arrested – believed to be the girlfriend of the alleged killer.

UPDATE3: Latest report is back to original story of two officers wounded and one dead. Also it was meant to be a drugs bust.  The offender is still holed up in the house it seems, so hpefully only a matter of time until he is arrested or dead.

UPDATE4: It seems a forth person in in hospital with injuries – presumably shot – they are a civilian. One officer is is a serious condition, while the other officer and civilian are stable. Also the location of the house is confirmed not to be the gang HQ which is some way away.

VUWSA and flag burning

Having failed to burn a flag on ANZAC Day, certain idiots instead burnt it at an SRC discussing ANZAC Day. To e fair to VUWSA it was former executive members rather than current ones. NZPA reports:

The New Zealand flag was set on fire today at a meeting called to resolve whether Victoria University students should lay a wreath on Anzac Day.

Joel Cosgrove, a former Victoria University of Wellington Students’ Association (VUWSA) president, burnt the flag after making a speech against New Zealand imperialism.

He and fellow Workers’ Party members Marika Pratley, a former VUWSA executive member, and Alastair Reith doused a New Zealand flag with an accelerant and lit it, student magazine Salient said.

Staff from the student bar swiftly put the fire out, and ejected Mr Cosgrove, who later said he had been served with a trespass order banning him from the Student Union building.

Interesting is this statement:

The Workers’ Party action was nothing to do with VUWSA, president Jasmine Freemantle said.

Yet Freemantle is a member of said party I understand – is she saying she knew nothing about it? UPDATE: I am told Freemantle resigned some time ago from the party.

The original Salient story is here.

Dom Post on Mt Albert

Today’s Dom Post editorial:

For once Labour has got its selection right. By standing a candidate who is not a list MP it has averted the nightmare scenario of perennial time-server Judith Tizard returning for another 2 1/2 years on the public teat as a list MP. And, if he is successful, David Shearer a highly regarded international aid specialist who resigned as United Nations deputy chief of mission in Iraq to contest the by-election will add greatly to Labour’s talent pool. In fact, he would be part of that pool already were it not for the determination of the union movement to use its muscle to turn the Labour side of Parliament into a rest home for tired union officials.

Ouch.

In 2002, Mr Shearer was edged out of what was then the safe Labour seat of Waitakere by Engineers Union organiser Lynne Pillay and bumped out of a winnable position on the party list by another Engineers Union organiser, Dave Hereora. Neither Ms Pillay, who remains in Parliament, nor Mr Hereora, who was ousted last year, have ever done anything that suggests they are an answer to any of Labour’s problems.

No wonder Phil Goff intervened in the selection, rather than leave it to Andrew Little.

Abortion scans

The Herald reports:

Women should be offered the opportunity to view the ultrasound scan of their baby before they decide to abort it, the Health and Disability Commissioner says.

Anti-abortion group Right to Life complained to the commissioner after finding four district health boards Auckland, Waikato, Wairarapa and Canterbury did not offer women the chance to view the scan before going ahead with an abortion. Waikato DHB said it was an “infringement of the patient’s rights” to offer it.

Commissioner Ron Paterson said any pregnant woman should be told of their right to view an ultrasound, and it was up to them whether they did or not.

I am pro-choice but agree with the Commissioner that the woman should always be given the opportunity. The attitude by Waikato DHB is ridicolous and paternalistic.

It is a debate that is raging in the United States, where a number of states are considering passing laws that would force women to view an ultrasound before obtaining an abortion. Some want them to listen to a fetal heartbeat as well. Critics have labelled the proposals “emotional blackmail”.

And that would be as wrong as Waikato DHB’s practice. Both deny the woman a choice.

A NZ First voter

I read this exchange in the Herald:

White-haired Mt Albert pharmacist David Baird met his first living, breathing politician yesterday – and gave her an earful.

“Hi, I’m Melissa Lee, National candidate for Mt Albert,” said the politician.

“Well you won’t be getting my vote because I don’t think we need any Asians in Parliament,” the pharmacist shot back tartly.

Or Jews. We don’t need any Jews either.

Korean-born Ms Lee, a former journalist who has been in New Zealand for 21 years, asked brightly, “Why not?”

Mr Baird said he had his reasons. “They are very difficult people to deal with. They don’t spend any money. I don’t see that they bring any money into the country. Another problem is their English is very bad.

Good on Melissa for not taking offence. Not sure I would have been as reasonable.

As I read this, I thought to myself that this guy sounds like a NZ First voter. And later on we read:

Mr Baird voted NZ First last year and has not decided whom to support in the June 13 byelection, caused by Helen Clark’s departure to the United Nations.

Will NZ First stand a candidate? If so, who will they take votes off?

And a Pakeha mother who declined to be named turned out to be as “red” as Mr Baird’s wife. Her simple verdict: “I’m going to vote for him – he’s the right colour.”

So is she voting Shearer because Labour is “red” or is she voting Shearer because he is white?

Crown accounts to 31 March 2009

Treasury released yesterday the crown accounts for the first nine months of this financial year. Here’s the differences between what Labour projected in the PREFU and the reality six months later:

  • Tax revenue down $1.9 billion
  • OBEGAL down $2.1 billion from $1.9 surplus to $0.2 deficit
  • Investment losses total $5.7 billion
  • Acturial losses of $3.6 billion
  • $0.7 billion gain on Kyoto
  • Overall deficit is $7.7 billion – a blow out of $11.1 billion from the projected $3.4 billion surplus in PREFU
  • Gross debt now $45 billion or 25.1% of GDP (do you recall Labour saying 22% would be a disaster?)
  • Net debt (which I find more useful) is $5.1b or 2.9% of GDP – against forecast of 3.0%

The one off investment and acturial losses are not that major a concern for me, but the $2.1 billion change downwards in OBEGAL is a huge issue.

Wanganui gang patch law passes

The law passed last night by 62 votes to 59. If Helen Clark was still an MP it would have been 62 – 60. ACT had three MPs (Hide, Boscawen and Garrett) vte in favour and two (Roy and Douglas) vote against.

I’m not convinced the new law will be effective, and I also think criminalising people for what they wear, rather than what they do, is the start of a potentially slippery slope.

However this has been a law strongly sought by the Wanganui District Council, and most of the people who live there. Parliament has a tradition of agreeing to most local bills.

It will be interesting to see how the law works in practice.

The Credit Contracts and Consumer Finance (Break Fee Disclosure) Amendment Bill

National List MP Aaron Gilmore has put together a useful private member’s bill. It will:

require banks and other credit providers to include the dollar amount of any break fee payable in the credit contract, as well as a plain English description of the calculation.

Transparency is a good thing. This is the first private members bill by a National MP since the election, so hopefully it will get picked from the ballot.

The full bill is after the break:

Continue reading »

Boris on Maggie

Sunday was the 30th anniversary of Margaret Thatcher’s election as Prime Minister of the United Kingdom of Great Britain and Northern Ireland.

London Mayor Boris Johnson pays tribute:

But, even as an apathetic and cynical teenager, I could see that she was doing some tough things, and the moment I came down most vehemently on her side was the Falklands conflict of 1982. So many people I knew seemed to think she was wrong, and bellicose. I remember my grandfather frequently saying that he was going to shoot her. You will still meet left-wing bores who say that she deliberately ignored the “Peruvian Peace Plan”. And yet what she did was so clear and so right.

I was 14 at the time, and remember all the predictions of disaster.

The Argentinian junta had taken by violence a British protectorate, in clear contravention both of international law and the wishes of the islanders. It took fantastic balls to send the antiquated British Navy half-way round the world, and risk disaster on those desolate beaches and moors. It took nerves of steel to sink the Belgrano, and, frankly, I don’t think there were any other Tory politicians who would have done it.

Sadly Boris is probably right.

By the end of the Eighties, she had cut taxes and the economy was roaring away; and it wasn’t just that the country as a whole seemed to have recovered some of its confidence and standing in the world. Individuals were able to take control of their destiny in a new way. They were no longer completely beholden to local authorities for their housing: they could buy their own homes, and to this day, as any Tory canvasser will tell you, there are people across Britain who will always vote Tory in thanks for that freedom alone.

Her vision was a property owning democracy.

She gave people the confidence to buy shares, to start their own businesses, to move on and up in society – and there was more social mobility under Margaret Thatcher than there has been since. She was a liberator, and she gave the Labour party such an intellectual thrashing that they ended up changing their name. In some ways, the most significant political legacy of Margaret Thatcher is New Labour (now being abolished by Gordon Brown).

Blair in many ways carried on her legacy. Brown, indeed, is not.

But she believed she had to shatter the post-war consensus that the solution to every problem was always an expansion of the state. Indeed, she did not think much of the word consensus itself, since it was not only too Latinate for her taste but also because it probably masked a conspiracy by cowardly politicians to dodge the hard questions, and, if you look at the consensus that now exists around, say, academic selection, you can see that she is right.

A consensus can be wrong, and in fact often is.

Margaret Thatcher will always divide the British people, not least since we are ourselves divided. There is a part of us that will always dislike the acquisitive, appetitive instincts she seemed to espouse, and yet we also recognise that they are essential for economic success. More than any leader since Churchill, she said thought-provoking things about the relationship between the state and the individual. Some of them were unpalatable, some of them were exaggerated. But much of what she said was necessary, and it took a woman to say it.

The simple truth is she changed Britain, and the world, for the better.

More on purchase advisors

I’ve been reflecting more on the Ministerial purchase advisors, and while Labour have largely stuffed up this issue, there are a couple of aspects where the Government can be legitimately criticised.

First of all, I have to say that Labour are seriously misjudging NZ outside the beltway, if they think they are going to get any resonance by complaining about how Ministers have used some experienced experts to help cut costs in their Departments. Only the PSA think this is a bad thing. In provincal NZ, and Auckland, you could put on a parade and have these advisors celebrated for their service to NZ. It would get more people along than the Santa parade.

Simon Upton writes in the Dom Post about his experience with purchase advisors:

The country learned last week that government ministers have been employing “purchase advisers”. The scoop was portrayed in sinister tones. The advisers were “secret”, “handpicked” and had been “unmasked”. Their employment amounted to an “unusual arrangement”.

Shocked to the core, I sought clarification and was disappointed to learn that the conspiracy only ran to seven such operatives. I rather hoped there would have been more because it is an eminently sensible use of public money.

So sensible in fact (and so “unusual”) that I took the trouble to extol the virtues of this approach to Trevor Mallard back in 1999 when he succeeded me as state services minister. I strongly commended the continued use of purchase advisers, a role I – and some of my colleagues – used extensively during our decade in office.

Upton continues:

Mr Mallard didn’t apparently take much notice of my advice.

Purchase agreements, I understand, became optional and in recent times ministers have contented themselves with negotiating “statements of intent”. A decade of billowing surpluses meant that no- one had to worry too much about priorities. Ministers could afford to indulge themselves with words rather than don overalls and climb down into the engine room of the numbers.

There are those who regard the idea of ministers “purchasing” outputs as an ideological tool to undermine public service and the Public Service. For me it was completely the opposite.

Without transparently negotiated prices there was no way of resisting the call for across-the- board spending cuts. Nothing is more injurious to the professionalism of the Public Service. It is a lazy way in which ministers can make demands of their officials without taking responsibility for the consequences.

Now there is an issue about whose budget do they get paid out of? Should it be Ministerial Services or the Department whose purchase agreement they are advising on? I would have thought it would be easier to have them contracted and paid through Ministerial Services – as does Andrew Geddis. The Government says it has advice that it was proper for Departments to pick up the cost. I presume the rationale is that as the savings they identify will come out of the Departmental budgets, the costs of the purchase advisors should also be reflected there.

Also in the commercial world, when two parties are negotiating a contract, it is not unheard of for the contract to include that one party will pay for an independent advisor for the other party.

I’ve yet to see the advice the Government has as to whether or not they should be funded out of Ministerial Services or each Department. I think it was tabled in the House yesterday so would be great if someone can publicise it.

So what is my criticism of the Government on this issue? That they allowed Labour to portray this as some sort of secret, to be ashamed of. The Government should be proud they have got former state servants of such high calibre to help negotiate purchase agreements that will result in a more efficient public sector. They should have been boasting of the names and front footing what they were doing.

When in doubt, publicise it. It always looks better being released proactively by the Government rather than weeks later under the OIA.

Bulldozers and the by-election

The NZ Herald’ Rudman Column is titled:

Brian Rudman: Bulldoze and Nats blow byelection

This may be true but I would much rather the Government doesn’t pick up a seat off Labour (that it doesn’t need anyway) than spend $3 billion on a tunnel.

I also think the Government will pick up support nationally for not caving into pork barrel politics for the by-election and putting the national interest ahead of buying local votes.

Size of Fiscal Stimulus

Maori Party and Fiji

Audrey Young blogs on Fiji, and you have to agree with her it has not been handled well by the Government. Discussions have been occuring through the media, not directly to each other.

It looks like the Maori Party will still send a delegation – probably led by Hone Harawira. That is their right of course.

I’m a bit puzzled by the Maori Party stance on Fiji. The original Fiji coups were about preventing the majority Indians from forming a Government. It was about protecting what they saw as the right of indigenous Fijians, and that stance had the support of some Maori activists in NZ.

But the Commodore’s coup is (officially anyway) about the opposite. He is saying he wants to remove any special rights from indigenous Fijians, and replace the constitution which has race based seats.

Somewhat strange bedfellows for the Maori Party I would have said whose entire party is about how there should be special rights for indigenous people.

Top 10 complained ads

The ODT has the top ten complained about ads:

The 10 most complained about ads of 2008

1. Tui Beer, billboard. “Let’s take a moment this Christmas to think about Christ…Yeah Right — Tui”. (86 complaints). Settled, when withdrawn by advertiser.

2. Brandex Adventure Sports Ltd, television. Skins sportswear, touting the physicality of African-American athletes, saying they have a “warrior” mentality and “killer instinct”. (73). Upheld, racial stereotyping.

3. Alcohol Advisory Council of New Zealand, television. A drinking “Uncle Mark” grabs a young boy, swinging him into furniture on an “aeroplane ride”. (68). Settled, when advertiser and broadcasters resolved to show it only after 8.30pm.

4. New Zealand First, direct mail advertisement. A NZ First flyer said an anti-John Key site had been set up in the name of the ad’s recipient. (43). Not upheld.

5. Advanced Medical Institute, billboard. “Want long-lasting Sex?”, ad for nasal medication to battle premature ejaculation. (38). Upheld, did not meet due sense of social responsibility.

6. Sky Television, billboard. An ad for a Sky television programme stated, “all business considered, even from Jews”. (27). Settled, advertisement removed and an apology published.

7. Beds R Us, television. A couple searching for the perfect bed are shown kissing passionately, then the female, clad in underwear, straddles the male. (23). Settled, ad replaced after complaints that sex was being used to sell.

8. Fonterra, television. In an Anchor trim milk ad, a child tells his mother “you’re fat”, then adds, “yeah mum, you’re not fat. Nana’s fat”. (18). Not upheld, light-hearted and unlikely to cause offence.

9. Tui Beer, billboard. “Sure, I’ve got ten minutes to talk about Jehovah”. (16). No grounds to proceed, did not meet the threshold to cause serious offence.

10. Hell Pizza, direct mail. `$25 Hot as Hell” ad showed a photo of a Thai woman in high heels and a bikini, promising a Thai massage, if the offer was redeemed in Thailand on the day of purchase. (15). No grounds to proceed, as it did not meet the threshold to breach the Advertising Codes.

I wonder how many of them are on You Tube?

Wolfram Alpha

This sounds great – from the Herald:

The biggest internet revolution for a generation will be unveiled this month with the launch of software that will understand questions and give specific, tailored answers in a way that the web has never managed before.

The new system, Wolfram Alpha, showcased at Harvard University in the US last week, takes the first step towards what many consider to be the internet’s Holy Grail – a global store of information that understands and responds to ordinary language in the same way a person does. …

Sounds good.

Wolfram Alpha will not only give a straight answer to questions such as “how high is Mount Everest?”, but it will also produce a neat page of related information – all properly sourced – such as geographical location and nearby towns, and other mountains, complete with graphs and charts.

The real innovation, however, is in its ability to work things out “on the fly”, according to its British inventor, Dr Stephen Wolfram. If you ask it to compare the height of Mount Everest to the length of the Golden Gate Bridge, it will tell you. Or ask what the weather was like in London on the day John F Kennedy was assassinated, it will cross-check and provide the answer. Ask it about D sharp major, it will play the scale. Type in “10 flips for four heads” and it will guess that you need to know the probability of coin-tossing. If you want to know when the next solar eclipse over Chicago is, or the exact current location of the International Space Station, it can work it out.

Sounds even better. Can’t wait.

Goff shifts to the right

A future Goff Labour Government’s economic policy is looking to be far more centrist and understanding of business, than the Clark’/Cullen Government was.

The three key economic Ministers are PM, Finance and Economic Development. You can arguably add Commerce onto that also.

Cunliffe is no academic socialist. He has worked in business and has a Harvard MBA. His work with Boston Consulting Group would place him as a high achiever, who understands business. This does not mean business will like everything Cunliffe would do, but I doubt you will find an ideological opposition to tax cuts here.

Jones is also no socialist. Quite the contrary. He has spoken to many business audiences, and generally leaves them impressed with his ideas and analysis. He also has a successful business background.

Goff is harder to pin down. He started off as a staunch socialist and then became a disciple of SIr Roger in the 1980s. He towed the line under Clark. His picks of Cunliffe and Jones for senior economic roles suggests he does deliberately want to move the party more to the centre, with a more balanced economic policy.

Dalziel continues on with Commerce. Despite her background as a union lawyer, she actually picked up a reasonable amount of praise for her work as Commerce Minister and I doubt she would fight a more moderate economic policy.

So it will be very interesting to see what alternative budgets and economic policies Labour comes up with in the next two and a half years.

You heard it here first!

NZPA reports:

Wellington, May 6 NZPA – New Zealand Post chief executive John Allen will be the next head of the Department of Foreign Affairs and Trade, NZPA understands.

I like this new order of reporting senior appointments:

  1. Tipped on Kiwiblog
  2. Predicted on Transtasman
  3. Reported on NZPA
  4. Announced by the SSC

🙂


April 2009 Public Polls

april2009polls

The gap between National and Labour is a healthy 21% but this is down from 26% in March. This suggests the honeymoon is ending with National back down to the level it enjoyed in early 2008.

Further graphs and tables are in Curia’s monthly e-mail newsletter which you can subscribe to here.