Photos from Great Barrier Island

img00085

On the Saturday it rained all day, and this leads to flooding towards the North of the Island. We were lucky that by pure chance the rental car was a four wheel drive as the road just ahead of here was under a good two feet of water. I’ve not driven a four wheel drive before so was a bit nervous going through the water as it was crashing over the bonnet and if we did get stuck, there was no cellphone coverage. The flooding lasted for 100 metres or so. Managed to get through to Motairehe which I had not seen before. Next time I want to see Kawa where there are graves for the SS Wairarapa.

img00090

This is down at Tryphena. Sunday was a warm sunny day. But the nice thing about the island is that even when pouring, it is a great place to be. At home in Wellington having the rain pour down is depressing. But over there, you could happily just spend a day watching the rain come down, as the views are so great.

img00092

This is the view from the South-East of GBI, on Cape Barrier Road, It is 4WD access only so had not been there before. Just magnificent views.

img00095

Part of Cape Barrier Road before it become 4WD only. Most of the roads are unsealed.

I’ve yet to go there in summer. I want to avoid peak time when lots are there, but would be nice to go when the climate is at its best. Will probably organise a group to go.

National buys a web hosting company

The National Government has just purchased a web hosting company. Yes us lucky taxpayers now have own own state owned web hosting company.

To be fair to the Gvoernment, they did not buy it directly. They own Kordia and Kordia owns Orcon and Orcon purchased iServe.

But the end result is the same – iserve goes from beign in the private sector to the state sector. It has been nationalised.

I have huge problems with Government owned companies acquiring other companies that operate in a competitive. It sees an expansion of the state in the economy. It also can get an unfair advantage to state owned companies with an implicit Government guarantee and access to capital.

Advice for Chris

Chris, Chris, Chris, Chris

Did you notice everyone laughing at you today in the House?

That is because you referred to people as political hacks, when you yourself were a political hack for three Ministers. It’s like Paris Hilton calling someone a slut.

Even worse, you chose as your targets a former Deputy State Services Commissioner and two former Treasury Secretaries. So we had someone ehose entire life has been a student politician and a partisan Ministerial staffer, calling political hacks three of the most senior state sevants we have had who have 100 years experience between them.

Do you now understand why everyone was laughing? Not only is it like Paris Hilton calling someone a slut. It is like Paris Hilton calling Mother Theresa a slut.

Harden up

Both Tane and Irish Bill at The Standard are aghast that Russel Norman has criticised the Labour candidate for Mt Albert as not progressive enough.

I’ve got just four words for them – Harden the fuck up.

Oh my God – how dare the Greens criticise Labour’s candidate. This can not be allowed.

Try being a National supporter. ACT has sniped at National and National candidates for years. Hell Rodney called John Key as more left wing than John Key Helen Clark on some issues. ACT have called National Labour-lite for months on end. They said vote National and you get Labour’s policies.

Do we cry like little pussies because our coalition partner has a swipe at us, and tries to establish their own brand. No we don’t. We understand smaller parties need to do these things.

ACT tried to win Jim Bolger’s seat off National in 1998. Did we sob how unfair it was? No we just got on with the job. ACT came bloody close also.

Russel Norman is going to try and win Mt Albert. No -he is not going to try and just build profile – he is going to try and win it. The Greens rationale is they need the seat more than Labour does.  So get used to it.

Labour’s reshuffle

Phil Goff has announced some changes to Caucus following the departures of Clark and Cullen:

  • Chris Carter takes Foreign Affairs off Clark
  • Mallard takes Education off Carter and moves to front bench, plus gets Rugby World Cup and America’s Cup
  • Shane Jones picks up Economic Development off Mallard and Environment off Mahuta
  • Nanaia Mahuta is demoted off the front bench and takes up Maori social development
  • Maryan Street picks up Treaty Negotiations off Cullen
  • Darren Hughes picks up Shadow Leader of the House off Cullen
  • David Parker picks up Conversation off Chadwick
  • Charles Chauvel picks up Associate Justice
  • Winnie Laban gets Interfaith Dialogue
  • Steve Chadwick gets Arts Culture and Heritage off Clark
  • George Hawkins gets Local Government off Jones
  • Damien O’Connor gets Rural Affairs off Mackey, Biosecurity off Davis and Associate Agriculture
  • Ashraf Choudary gets Associate Research, Science and Development
  • Kelvin Davis gets Tourism off Mahuta and Associate Maori Affairs
  • Chris Hipkins gets Sport & Recreation off Mallard
  • Mackey picks op Housing off Hawkins

The big winner is Trevor Mallard who moves to the front bench and also Shane Jones who gets more substance. No one big loser but Mahuta is demoted, Carter moves to a role where he will see little action and Grant Robertson misses out on getting any of the two portfolios he was understudy to Clark for.

I must say though it is a bit weird to do it during the by-election. If Shearer wins, then they will need another reshuffle.

The other strange thing is how many changes were made just six months after the initial allocation. This is actually a fairly major reshuffle, which suggests the initial allocations had proved unsatisfactory.

Kiva

I’ve just made my first micro-finance loan through Kiva. You can find out more about them at Wikipedia.

Basically you loan money to entrepeneurs in developing countries, through Kiva. It is called micro-financing as they are all for small amounts, and the typical lender contributes $25 – so 40 people lending $25 allows $1,000 to be made available.

The default rate is only 2.5%. This means if you lend $1,000 through it, you’ll on average get back $975. But instead of just donating $25 to  a charity, you are helping fund $1,000 of business development.

I’ve just lent US$25 to a 24 year old in Nicaragua who is expanding her parents painting business. She is after US$1,000 and has previously paid back two prior loans.

I really encourage people to sign up, and loan money if they are able to do so. It’s a great innovation.

The numbers in Mt Albert

First some stats:

  • National’s party vote in Mt Albert was only 35.7% – 4.4% lower than any seat National did win.
  • Clark’s majority of 10,351 is the third largest of seats not held by National – only Epsom and Manukau East are higher
  • The combined party vote for the left (L/G/P) was 54.3%, for the centre (NZF/M/U) 4.1% and for the right (N/A) was 39.2%
  • The combined party vote for the right is the 9th lowest out of 63 general seats. For the left their party vote is the 9th highest out of 63 general seats.
  • Seats with a smaller gap between right and left are Mana, Wigram, Hutt South and New Lynn

Mt Albert is fundamentally a leftwing seat. This does not mean it is impossible for National to win it, but the focus purely on National vs Labour party vote is misleading.

Also at the end of the day, while the party vote is the best primary indicator of support, this is a winner take all electorate vote contest and we will see tactical voting on the right and left. So how might we calculate how thinsg look. Let us start with 2008 party vote:

  1. Labour 14,894 or 42.6%
  2. National 12,468 or 35.7%
  3. Green 3,846 or 11.0%
  4. ACT 1,227 or 3.5%

Now let us adjust these for movement since the election, taking the Curia public poll average:

  1. Labour has gone from 34.0% to 30.8% – a relative decrease of 9.4%
  2. National has gone from 44.9% to 53.1% – increase 18.2%
  3. Green has gone from 6.7% to 7.5% – increase of 11.6%
  4. ACT has gone from 3.6% to 2.5% – decrease of 31.4%

So applying this to the party vote, we get

  1. Labour 13,497
  2. National 14,735
  3. Green 4,291
  4. ACT 841

So does this mean National is in the lead? Well hold off. Because this is an FPP electorate contest and minor party voters vote tactically. How did votes split their votes in 2008? We can’t use Mt Albert as an example, as that was influenced by the Clark factor. So let us use the overall vote splitting for general seats. This tells us:

  1. Green party voters voted 33.9% Green candidate and 47.9% Labour candidate and 10.9% National candidate
  2. ACT party voters voted 16.4% ACT candidate, 4.8% Labour candidate and 73.1% National.

What does this then give us:

  1. Labour 15,593
  2. National 15,818

So on these calculations, it is within 250 votes. But then you look at more qualative factors:

  1. Shearer is the only non List MP who can say I will not be in Parliament if you do not vote for me. I think this is easily worth 2,000 votes.
  2. Despite high honeymoon polls, there is little reason for people to give the Government an additional seat – no Government has won a by-election for at least 70 years. It is hard to excite pro-Govt supporters to get out and vote as they no this won’t change anything – worth around 1,000 votes
  3. Greens and ACT will be mounting vigorous campaigns. As the Greens have more voters to appeal to, I would say this could knock 1,000 votes off Labour and 500 votes off National, so a net loss to Labour of 500
  4. Labour’s on the ground organisation in Mt Albert should be worth at least 500 votes
  5. Shearer will appeal to some centre-right voters with his backgroudn and views – again maybe 500 votes.

So add all these factors up and I’d say they give Labour an extra 3,500 votes or so, which if nothing else happens would have them win the seat by around 3,250 votes.

Now it is never this simple. Events will occur that change this. But at this stage what I think it shows is that yes it is possible National could win the seat with a very narrow 250 vote majority, but more likely Labour holds on with 3,000 or so votes.

What will be the events that can change this? Well polls and tactical voting. If a poll shows National and Labour neck and neck, and Greens well back, then the Green vote may collapse to Shearer. But likewise if a poll shows the Greens at over 15%, maybe even 20% – then they could make a strong play for Labour voters to vote Greens to give Labour a guaranteed future coalition partner (Labour can probably never govern again without the Greens).

Let the campaigns begin!

Super City bills

The Government has given details of three bills that will be considered by Parliament to establish the Super City. I like how they have split the bills up, so only the bare minimum is done under urgency, and the rest goes out to select committee. They are:

  1. Transition Bill – will establish the Council as a legal entity, establish the Auckland Governance Transition Agency (AGTA) and constrain decision-making powers of existing Auckland councils. This will not go to select committee and presumably be passed in May
  2. Composition Bill – will set the number of Councillors, the split between wards and at large, the establishment of local boards and high level functions for those boards. This will go to select committee and is to be reported back by September. Also deals with the water infrastructure
  3. Details Bill – will provide full legislative framework, functions, roles and powers of Councils and Boards. This would be introduced later this year and go to select committee, reporting back around April 2010

In an ideal world, even the first bill would go to select committee. But there is no way it could all be completed by October 2010, if a transition authority can;t start work now – and the longer the transition, the harder it is for current staff. Also what the Government has done is only include in the first bill the very high level decisions recommended by the Royal Commission – which were consulted on for around 18 months. It does not include any changes made by the Government – those changes will all go to select committee.

I remain supportive of the overall direction, but think eight is too many at large seats – in fact would prefer none at all. And I think the Government needs to make sure the local boards are meaningful enough that they will attract good candidates. The ability to propose a targeted rate for their area, to fund additional facilities and services is actually quite powerful as I can’t see why the Auckland Council would turn down such a recommendation – so long as the local Board has adequately consulted local residents.

TVNZ upholds moustache complaints against Henry

The Herald reports:

TVNZ has upheld viewer complaints against Breakfast host Paul Henry after he commented that a female guest had a moustache.

I’d take that more seriously if it wasn’t the same TVNZ whose staff very quickly got the comments out on You Tube, so 100,000 extra people could see them.

Henry had been spoken to and told on-air editorial decisions were not his to make and that he must adhere to the executive producer’s decisions.

That must be the “I’ve got a voice in my ear telling me not to read them out”!

Oh dear – as I type this he may have just done it again – but accidentially. They had a reporter in a lawyer’s office – in the photocopier room and they were talking about if any items of clothing had even been found in there. Henry then said he is sure all sorts of shenigans happen in there and that if you lift up the photocopier lid, there is probably a crack on the glass.

It took only a second for the possible second meaning of this to strike Henry, but his reaction was nothing compared to Ali Mau who absolutely lost it on screen.

Lee selected for National

National’s selection panel of 60 members has selected Melissa Lee for the by-election. Congrats to Melissa.

The result is not a big surprise considering Melissa was ranked a very high 37 on the 2008 list, and Ravi was ranked No 65.

Tomorrow I’ll take a look at how the numbers for Mt Albert stack up.

UPDATE: For those who are stupid enough to believe the media story that a National Party conference had already listed Melissa as the candidate, Homepaddock has the actual facts:

But it’s the paper that’s got it wrong. I’ve got a copy of the official programme and it says:

Address by Mt Albert’s List MP Melissa Lee.

There is a big difference between being a candidate for an electorate and a List MP for an area.

Powershop Winners

Scoop has details of the two Powershop Pioneers who have each won $1,000 of free electricity. They are Brenda Leeuwenberg and Steve Withers.

By coincidence, I know both of them. Brenda and I were at the same university hostel, and were both at Foo Camp this year. Steve and I used to debate MMP and many other things on Usenet in the 1990s, when he was Secretary of the Electoral Reform Coalition.

There is a third power giveaway at the end of May, for people who sign up as Powershop Pioneers – details at Scoop.

Big Brother is watching!

While clearing through my inbox this morning, I found this e-mail:

Hi, David Farrar (dpfdpf).

Karl Rove (KarlRove) is now following your updates on Twitter.

And yes it is that Karl Rove. Incidentally I will over in DC in June. Can’t wait.

P J O’Rourke

There were so many highlights from P J O’Rourke’s speech, it is hard to know where to start. I guess I’ll start with the one that resonated most with me:

The 1 trillion, 487 billion dollars that America is spending on the financial bail-out plus the economic stimulus package is equal to more than a year’s worth of U.S individual and corporate income tax payments put together. Which raises the question: Instead of a bail-out and a stimulus, why not no taxes for a year? Zero. Zip. None. Stop taxing us!

Would this be an economic stimulus? Uh, yeah.

Just imagine that – a tax free year. Think what they would do to prosperity, economic confidence and growth.

Economic freedom is the freedom we exercise most often and to the greatest extent.

Freedom of speech is important – if you’ve got anything to say. I’ve checked on the internet. Nobody does.

Freedom of Belief is important – if you believe in anything. I’ve watched cable TV. I can’t believe it.

Freedom of assembly is important – if you have an assembly to go to, the way we do.

But most people to go to the mall. And, at the mall, they exercise economic freedom.

I’ve often said I value my freedom of speech more than my freedom to vote – because I exercise it every day – not just once every three years. But O’Rourke usefully reminds us that economic freedom is the one we use the most. This is partly why things were so ghastly in the old Soviet bloc.

The worst thing in politics is “bipartisan consensus.” Bipartisan consensus – that’s like when my doctor and my lawyer agree with my wife that I need help.

He had dozens of good lines like this. Most have been used in his books, but not the same as hearing them in person.

The Free Market was killed by the Bolshevik revolution, by fascist central planning, by Keynesianism, the Great Depression, World War II economic controls, the British Labor Party victory of 1945, Keynesianism again, the Arab oil embargo, Tony Blair’s and Bill Clinton’s “Third Way” economic policies, and by the current financial crisis.

That’s ten times the Free Market as has died in the past 100 years. And every time the Free Market dies, everybody wants to know, “What would Adam Smith say?”

It’s a “Hi, God. How’s my atheism going?” moment.

A useful knocking back of those who claim this is the end of capitalism.

So how would Adam Smith fix our financial crisis?

Sorry, but it’s fixed already. The answer to a decline in the value of speculative assets is to pay less for them. Job done!

O’Rouke argued strongly against bailing out banks that made bad investment decisions.

So far, the best Barack Obama has been able to do by way of an Iraq policy is to make what I think of as the “high school sex promise:” I’ll pull out in time, honest, Honey.

Heh.

Best investment I’ve made lately? I left a $20 bill in the jacket pocket of this suit last month. And I just found it this morning. (Which puts me way ahead of my mutual fund.)

Double Heh.

Not that we’d want to live in a country ruled only by the best and brightest. That would be too much like being married to Cherie Blair.

A very backhanded compliment.

Obama’s got a great economic plan. If it’s working, tax it. If it isn’t working, bail it out. If it’s just scraping by, drop the Federal Reserve Bank on it ‘till it screams for help.

The Libertarianz liked that line. They had two tables there. Was very funny when they announced that they had 20 people at the dinner, as someone yelled out “So your whole party is here, is it” 🙂

Politics is going to take over the car industry. I can predict the result – a light-weight, compact vehicle with a small carbon footprint using sustainable alternative energy. When I was a kid we called it a bike.

He also railed against bailouts of US car manufacturers.

What we get is a choice between left-wingers who can’t learn from the past and right-wingers who can’t stop living in it. Between left-wingers who want to tax us to death and right-wingers who would prefer that we get shot with an assault rifle by a lunatic in the work place.

Targets on all sides.

And I don’t just hate bad politics. I hate all politics. I even hate democracy.

Imagine if our clothes were selected by the majority of shoppers, which would be teenage girls. I’d be standing here with my midriff exposed.

Amongst the humour is a powerful reminder that the state should not decide all things for us. That we should get to decide what light bulbs to use, what shower pressure to have etc.

Last year the U.S. Congress passed “The Farm, Nutrition and Bio-Energy Act of 2008.” This was $285 billion dollars worth of agricultural subsidies and price supports. $285 billion dollars is five times the pre-war gross national product of Iraq. For what the “Farm, Nutrition and Bio-Energy Act of 2008” is costing American tax payers, we could have avoided the war with Saddam Hussein and just bought his god damned country. (And I bet we could have sold it to China for a profit. The Chinese want oil. Hand’em the deed to Baghdad and let ‘em go get it. Give the Communist Chinese a little taste of Falluja and they’d be wishing for monk riots in Tibet.)

A great solution to Iraq and China!

So, while I’m holding the cow’s head and my friend is holding the cow’s middle, Pete takes this freezing cold syringe thing and inserts it into a very personal and private place of the cow’s. Then what Pete does, is he stick his arm into an even more personal and private place of the cow’s – all the way up to the elbow.

Now, Pete does this not to get on the internet with a pornographic website, but so that he can feel the tip of the inseminator tube through the cow’s intestine wall and guide that tip into the cow’s uterus.

It was a pretty gruesome thing to watch and, I’m glad to say, since I was up at the cow’s other end, I didn’t watch it. But I’ll tell you one thing – I will never forget the look on that cow’s face.

It was the same look that I got on my face – for the same reason – when I read the “Farm, Nutrition and Bio-Energy Act of 2008.”

This probably got the most laughs of the night – again it was superb humour but with a serious message underneath.

Once more, huge kudos to the CIS for bringing P J to NZ. A great night.

20 years of NZ Internet

I was on Media 7 last week with Russell Brown, Nat Torkington and Colin Jackson discussing 20 years of the Internet in NZ. It was a fun discussion and reminded me of how much we take for granted today, and how different the world was before the Internet.

The new blogmobile

I announced last week the blogmobile is back. Well it is bigger and better, as you can see below.

vnc-motorhome

Yes we now have dual donors – Barrons and VnC Cocktails. And even better VnC are suppling copious amounts of product – so there will be Blogmobile party nights!

Hat Tip: Whale Oil

Labour breached EFA – again

Just saw a story on NewstalkZB about Labour breaching the EFA with undisclosed donations:

Mike Smith, Labour’s party secretary, admits failing to disclose $25,000 from Meatworkers Union; says omission was an oversight Labour acknowledges it made a mistake in the filing of its donations ahead of last year’s elections.

Labour’s Secretary Mike Smith says he is personally responsible for failing to disclose donations totaling $25,500 from three branches of the New Zealand Meatworkers Union. He says the omission was an oversight and is in breach of the Electoral Act which requires that donations from the same donor of more than $20,000 be declared. The donations should have been declared last year.

The incident follows other instances of Labour being found to have breached the laws under the now-scrapped Electoral Finance Act.

The parties that have breached the law the most often are Labour, Progressives, Greens and NZ First – the very ones that voted for it.

National’s Mt Albert selection tonight

National selects its candidate for the Mt Albert by-election tonight. On Friday the Herald had a useful article on it.

The National Party is embroiled in a backroom power struggle over its Mt Albert candidate, with the hierarchy’s favourite, Melissa Lee, trying to tip out grassroots toiler Ravi Musuku.

Ms Lee is a list MP and one of National’s new stars. Mr Musuku stood unsuccessfully against Helen Clark in the last two elections.

It’s a contested selection – not really a power struggle.

The hierarchy/grassroots divide is deepened by the selection process, with the 60-strong panel of party delegates made up of appointments from both sides. The panel will vote on Monday night.

A number of new local members have been ruled ineligible after they were signed up in a recent “recruitment drive”.

This is a deliberate feature of the rules, to stop selections being stacked. To vote at a selection meeting you have to have been a member for at least six months (off memory). So it is for those who have demonstrated some long-term commitment to the party.

The local electorate organisation’s proportion of the panel is based on the number of party members it has. National Party northern region chairman Alastair Bell decides the rest.

Also a design feature. If an electorate has 900 members (as many do) they select all 60 delegates at a ratio of 1 for 15 members. If they have less than that, then the Regional Chair (elected annually at the local regional conference) tops them up to 60. It is designed to stop very weak electorates being taken over by an individual and encourages electorates to increase membership.

Mr Bell would say only that he would be appointing a “fair number” of delegates to the panel. He had used his discretion to appoint some from outside Mt Albert, but most would be from within the electorate.

I understand over 80% are from within the electorate. It is common to have a few experienced members from neighbouring electorates get appointed. I’ve been a top up for various Wellington electorates from time to time.

I would be amazed if Melissa does not win. Her maiden speech to Parliament was superb, and she is a star for the future.

Cullen’s speech in full

Big donations in 2008

The Electoral Commission has published the list of “big” donations each party received in 2008, big being over $10,000 in value. So which parties got the most big money?

  1. Labour got $431,917 in big donations. Their biggest individual donor was the Vela Family who gave them $100k. The unions gave $117,500 and individuals (mainly from arts/culture sector) gave $134,830. Also a total of $60,000 from corporates and lobby groups, $10,587 from Helen Clark and $9,000 anonymously through the Electoral Commission.
  2. ACT got $315,906 in big donations. John Boscawen gave $101,000, Alan Gibbs $200,000 and $14,906 from Virtual Bucket Ltd!
  3. National got less than half as much as Labour in big donations. They got $207,001. John Key put in $30,000, some other individuals $30,001, $70,000 from corporates and a lobby group, and $77,000 anonymously through the Electoral Commission.
  4. Greens were 4th largest for total big donations on $184,693. These were all individual donations with MPs putting in 70,725 and others $114,238.
  5. NZ First got (assuming this return is accurate – the last three years were not) $111,999. The Velas gave $100,000 to their favourite boy and Sir Patrick Hogan also gave his thanks with $11,999.
  6. The Family Party had $88,044. Destiny Church handed over $10,926, Paul Adams $41,037 and an Elias Kanaris $36,081

National’s level of “big” donations is very small. Part of that will be that some gave in 2007 (2011 will be interesting) but part is that the vast majority of National’s revenue comes from smaller donations. The members alone contribute between $1.5 and $2.0 million a year in small donations I would estimate.

Also somewhat amusingly, NZ First broke the law – again! They received a $2,190 donation from a foreigner on 22 October 2008. As it exceeds $1,000 it has to be paid to the Electoral Commission within 20 working days. They only paid it over on 12 December 2008.

Labour also received an overseas donations in excess of $1,000. They got $10,000 which they had to give up.

Q&A on Key

John Key was not on Q&A, but Air NZ CEO Rob Fyfe was, and had some interesting observations:

PAUL John Key, when he was in China recently, he said, he made it clear he wants to use the power of Prime Minister to forge linkages to form relationships between New Zealand and Chinese businesses, do you welcome that?

ROB I welcome it enormously, relationships are key in China but you’ve still gotta do a good deal I mean but the relationship gets you in the door and I think New Zealand is really well regarded, I think Helen Clark built a really good platform there and I think John Key’s built on that.

PAUL Yes, they’re different people though aren’t they?

ROB Very very different.

PAUL You’ve seen them both operate in China haven’t you?

ROB I’ve got huge respect for Helen Clark as a global statesman as a political manager. John’s a very different style, he’s more intuitive, he tends to be very responsive very interactive, his interpersonal style is more relaxed, I think a change of style is good, you open new opportunities, you identify new sources of creativity and I think we’re seeing that with the Prime Minister and I think that’s very healthy actually.

PAUL What did this achieve for us up there, I know that Mr Key was able to get Henry van der Hayden to the top table so that he sat with Premier Win and John Key and so a hand was shaken, so that was symbolic wasn’t it, but you did well as well I understand in getting a new time slot for take offs from Beijing.

ROB Yeah getting the right time slots is very valuable to us, people don’t want to arrive at the airport at early hours in the morning or late in the evening they want to go when they want to go, so it’s good. What happens in China, whenever you get a visit of a statesperson the Chinese are very keen, they’re very gift oriented, and they like to be able to give you things and so they gave us better slots, and it became a catalyst for moving the Fonterra relationship forward. That’s the nature of that relationship dynamic in China and I thought John positioned that very well as Prime Minister on that trip.

PAUL Is what you’re saying about him, he’s more naturally business?

ROB I think he understands the opportunities.

PAUL He’s a capitalist, he’s one of them.

ROB He does deals, he actually knows how to take advantage of situations and he puts himself out there, he’s a marketer. I saw him talking to a bunch of truism travel agents, we had a luncheon that he spoke at, and selling and marketing New Zealand I mean they all walked out of there buzzing I know, he created more tourists at that lunch than probably any single interaction we’ve had in our time in China, it was great.

The PM will be pleased with his Minister of Tourism!

National-lite!

Heh after a year or two of National being called Labour-lite, the Greens are calling David Shearer National-lite.

Dr Norman played up the link, saying it meant he himself was the only “progressive” candidate on offer.

“The right of the party – the Goff faction – have got their man. Labour have chosen the grey machine man. I’m sure he’s a very nice guy, but it means we’ve got National versus National-lite versus the Greens.”

Actually in terms of privatisation, he could be called ACT-lite or even Libertarianz-lite 🙂

Shearer wins Labour’s nomination

Congratulations to David Shearer who won Labour’s nomination, and commiserations to those who missed out. So who are the winners and losers:

Winners

  1. David Shearer – likely MP for Mt Albert
  2. Phil Goff – he got his hand picked candidate through, despite local resistance
  3. Russel Norman – Shearer’s selection allows him to campaign more aggressively for left wing votes
  4. John Key – having Shearer in the Labour Caucus will reduce the impact of any cries of privatisation from Labour – not a get out of jail card, but will be useful.

Losers

  1. The National candidate – Shearer will be tougher to beat than some of the other candidates Labour could have gone with. His overseas work is appealing
  2. Helen Clark – I doubt someone who advocates replacing UN peacekeepers with mercenary armies would have been her first choice of candidate
  3. Phil Twyford – won’t find a seat as good as Mt Albert
  4. The other candidates for Labour – the flying in of Shearer was a signal that the hierarchy was concerned none of them would win

Now of course six weeks is a long time in politics, and by-elections are fickle creatures. I know at least two media organisations are planning to poll the seat, so it will be interesting to see how it looks in a fortnight.

McCarten on Mt Albert

Matt McCarten looks at Mt Albert again:

Goff’s photo opportunity last Sunday with the accepted nominees was to showcase their line-up. Goff obviously wanted to be seen as stamping his leadership on the party when he announced he had interviewed all the nominees. But selections are for the party organisation, not the caucus.

I know of no previous example in which the parliamentary leader gets this involved. It’s the party president’s job to manage selections. So it speaks volumes that the Labour Party president, Andrew Little, wasn’t even in the picture.

I’ve never heard of the party leader interviewing candidates. Poor Mt Albert electorate seem to be getting little say – which makes the slogan of “Put Mt Albert first” rather ironic.

Even Goff’s rather public recruitment of getting an outside high-profile candidate seems to be backfiring. The extraordinary opinion of Goff’s favourite, David Shearer, that we should use mercenaries in international hotspots is a real clanger.

The Labour Party is opposed to the privatisation of prisons, but I’m not sure how Goff spins his way out of his candidate supporting the privatisation of war.

Labour should be very grateful that McCarten is not going to be involved in the Mt Albert campaign. Why? Well on Thursday night a high profile left winger told me that if Shearer is the candidate, someone should arrange a dozen teenagers dressed as mercenaries to follow him about everywhere he goes – not saying anything or doing anything – just silently standing there as guards.

I thought this was a brillant idea for a party of the left to do (Nats can’t do it as they agree with Shearer on privatisation). The Greens get sniffy about such stunts. But, think of the fun if McCarten was involved. I still remember his chicken suit from the 1998 TKC by-election – it probably cost National 2,000 votes. McCarten would probably not just have a dozen mercenaries on the campaign trail, but have them wheeling a coffin about too.

With Shearer now causing serious concerns among the locals there is a real potential that any successful nominee will have minority support in the electorate and that Labour’s head office will effectively make the decision for them.

The Greens will be silently praying that Labour picks Shearer.

The Greens have always resented the way that Labour has taken them for granted and constantly sniggered about their MPs behind their backs. The Green candidate and party co-leader, Russel Norman, knows he has a golden opportunity to brand his party’s message and differentiation from Labour.

Byelections are unpredictable. At present, no one would pick Norman to win. But as someone who has managed a few close-call byelections, I know that a third party candidate can pull it off, given the right circumstances.

I agree. And they can have a powerful message about tactical voting to get a Green electorate MP to help Labour have a guaranteed coalition partner in future.

If the polls during the campaign start to show a trend toward the Greens, then anything is possible.

A lot will come down to Labour’s selection today.