John Key’s Ministry

John Key has announced his Ministry. There are 28 Ministers:

  1. Hon John Key, PM, Tourism
  2. Hon Bill English, Deputy PM, Finance, Infrastructure
  3. Hon Gerry Brownlee, Leader of the House, Economic Development, Energy & Resources,
  4. Hon Simon Power, Justice, SOEs, Commerce, Law Commission, Associate Finance, Deputy Leader of the House
  5. Hon Tony Ryall, Health, State Services
  6. Hon Dr Nick Smith, Environment, Climate Change, ACC
  7. Hon Judith Collins, Police, Corrections, Veterans’ Affairs
  8. Hon Anne Tolley, Education, Tertiary Education, ERO
  9. Hon Christopher Finlayson, Attorney-General, Treaty Negotiations, Arts & Culture
  10. Hon David Carter, Agriculture, Biosecurity, Forestry
  11. Hon Murray McCully, Foreign Affairs, Sport & Rec, Rugby World Cup
  12. Hon Tim Groser, Trade Negotiations, Conservation, Associate Foreign, Associate Climate Change
  13. Hon Dr Wayne Mapp, Defence, Research, Science & Tech, Associate Econ Dev, Associate Tertiary Ed
  14. Hon Steven Joyce, Transport, Comms/IT, Associate Finance, Associate Infrastructure
  15. Hon Georgina te Heuheu, Courts, Pacific Island Affairs, Disarmament & Arms Control, Associate Maori
  16. Hon Paula Bennett, Social Development & Employment, Disability Issues, Youth Affairs
  17. Hon Phil Heatley, Fisheries, Housing
  18. Hon Pansy Wong, Ethnic Affairs, Women’s Affairs, Associate ACC, Associate Energy
  19. Hon Dr Jonathan Coleman, Immigration, Broadcasting, Associate Tourism, Associate Health
  20. Hon Kate Wilkinson, Labour, Food Safety, Associate Immigration
  21. Hon Maurice Williamson, Building & Construction, Customs, Statistics, Small Business
  22. Hon Dr Richard Worth, Internal Affairs, Land Information, Archives NZ, National Library, Associate Justice
  23. Hon John Carter, Civil Defence, Senior Citizens, Racing, Associate Local Government
  24. Hon Rodney Hide, Local Government, Regulatory Reform, Associate Commerce
  25. Hon Heather Roy, Consumer Affairs, Associate Defence, Associate Educations
  26. Hon Dr Pita Sharples, Maori Affairs, Associate Education, Associate Correction
  27. Hon Tariana Turia, Community and Voluntary Sector, Associate Health, Associate Social Development and Employment
  28. Hon Peter Dunne, Revenue, Associate Health

I’ll comment on the choices in another post. Key has also confirmed that Lockwood Smith will be nominated as Speaker.

For those into demographics, they are:

  • Eight female Ministers
  • Four Maori Ministers
  • One Asian Minister

Trotter’s curse on the Maori Party

I was overseas, but a reader has sent me Chris Trotter’s column yesterday on the Maori Party. The poor chap seems rather upset, calling them all sorts of names:

KUPAPA – that was the name they gave to the Maori who cooperated with the British colonists. The colonial authorities’ terminology was somewhat kinder. They dubbed these collaborators the Queen’s ‘‘Loyal Maoris’’ and erected statues in their honour (one still stands on Auckland’s Symonds St).

How ironic, then, that a political party whose very name pronounces its ambition to speak for and on behalf of all Maori should end up throwing its support behind the direct political descendants of the colonial authorities who enlisted the kupapa.

Will John Key erect a statue in your honour, Tariana Turia? He should, because you, and the once-proud party you are dragging behind you, have just voted to become his ‘‘Loyal Maoris’’.

Oh, and in case you’re wondering, Tariana, this column is not patronising you – it’s attacking you.

As a Pakeha, I am not constrained by traditional Maori decorum, nor am I silenced by a people’s shame.

The anger that is stirred in me by this latest political betrayal of your people is the same anger that rises every time I read about the way the Scottish lairds of the 19th century abandoned their people for English gold. Or, the way the South African chiefs abandoned their people in the 1970s and 80s for the Afrikaners’ krugerrands.

They, too, professed the purest – the most high-minded – motives for throwing in their lot with the men of power. They, too, were seeking a ‘‘voice in government’’ and equally determined to get the ‘‘best possible deal for their people’’ under the circumstances.

But the reality was always the same. They got the equivalent of the ministerial houses, and the people remained the playthings of their leaders’ new playmates.

And please, Tariana, don’t insult the intelligence of Maori and Pakeha by pretending there is anything even remotely democratic about your party’s decision.

We have seen your much vaunted ‘‘consultation hui’’ – or, perhaps I should say, we have seen as much of them as you have allowed us to see.

The news media has been prevented from recording the real debates, and so the people who must live with the consequences of your decisions have not been able to hear your justifications for making them.

And what happened to your party’s generous invitation to all those on the Maori roll to participate in these hui? At whose insistence was that rescinded, Tariana? John Key’s – or your own?

Did the prospect of those Maori who gave their electorate vote to the Maori Party and their party vote to Labour turning up in their tens of thousands to have their say frighten your new friends? Is that why participation was suddenly restricted to Maori Party members only?

If only 40 people could make it to the hui held in Pita Sharples’ South Auckland headquarters, I can imagine how risible the turnout was elsewhere. We saw the one-time radical, Hone Harawira, chatting away with about a dozen party faithful somewhere up north. I’m guessing that was about par for this farcical course.

I know whakapapa is everything to you Tariana, so I invite you to consider the whakapapa of Labour’s relationship with Maori.

I ask you to recall the alliance forged between the prophet Ratana and Michael Joseph Savage.

I ask you to recall who it was who gave Maori full citizenship – and equal access to the benefits of citizenship.
I ask you to recall who established the Waitangi Tribunal.
I ask you to recall who extended its remit back to 1840.

Your people move forward on the road they laid with Labour, Tariana, not with National.

And, you do not recite National’s whakapapa correctly. How do you dare cite te kohanga reo, one of the most outstanding and independent cultural initiatives of modern Maoridom, as a National Party achievement?

Your people will not easily forgive this turning away, Tariana. When unemployment and homelessness and poverty bite. When the prisons are full of your rangatahi. When National’s true whakapapa stands revealed.

They will curse your name.

Kupapa!

I don’t normally quote in full, but how could I cut any of it out? It reminds me of when John Hart Minto lectured Nelson Mandela on not having done enough for blacks in South Africa as he didn’t overthrow capitalism.

The Intel Core i7 processor

Tomorrow sees the worldwide release of the new series of Intel Core i7 processors. I was lucky enough to get a first hand briefing from Intel staff on the processor, and even better try out some great games, on PCs with the new chip.

This will be Intel’s flagship brand going forward, but they will continue to support their other products, which is sensible. The i7s are aimed at the higher end of the market – those who use their PCs to produce content, and/or serious gamers.

The presentation by the Intel product manager said that on average there is a 40% boost in power. The processors can run up to eight application threads simultaneously, but also has a turbo boost option where it can close down cores not used, and speed up or overclock those cores in use. So you get the best of both worlds.

The top chip is the Intel® Core™ i7‐965 Extreme Edition with a 3.20 GHz clock speed. I can recall clock speeds of under 100 MHz 🙂

Most people don’t worry too much about the type of processor they have in their PC. If you just use it to do e-mail and world and excel, you don’t need to.

But if you are a power user of Adobe products, like editing videos, or love games that chew up capacity, then you probably do care about your processor, and I suspect will like the i7.

The briefing on the i7 was in Melbourne on Friday, as part of the Melbourne e-gaming convention. In recent years my laptops have been small, to allow for easy travel, so I have not done much gaming. In fact I only have one small game on my laptop. Also I have been somewhat busy of late, so it has been ages since I spent hours playing a decent computer game – and God was it good.

On Sunday I spent four hours playing the latest James Bond Casino Royale game. The video and graphics are superb, and it doesn’t even pause for a split second as you have huge battles with a dozen opponents. As you hit them, they fall off balconies, slump down dead etc in impressive fashion. And the laser sights on your weapons are truly impressive.

If it weren’t for the fact I know I would spend too much time with them, I’m bloody tempted to go out and buy a desktop PC just for gaming. But alas I need to earn a living, so will resist – for now anyway.

Disclosure: Intel paid for my travel and accomodation to Melbourne for the briefing on the i7, and associated e-gaming convention.

Special Vote Count

Unlike previous years, the Chief Electoral Officer will not be releasing the final count (including specials) progressively as each electorate is finalised. They will all be released this Saturday.

However some electorates will have observers there for the count of the specials. This may give some indication as to the overall trend. Therefore, if anyone out there gets any info on how the specials have gone locally, could you e-mail them to me. If I get half a dozen or so, then I should be able to make some predictions on how many list seats, if any, will change hands due to the specials.

The Maori Seats

Labour won the party vote easily in all seven Maori seats. Their party vote ranged from 45% to 57%, and the Maori Party ranged from 21% to 34%. Waiariki was closest with an 11% gap and Ikaroa-Rawhiti had a 31% gap.

In 2005 Labour ranged from 49% to 58% and Maori Party from 18% to 31% so not much change on the party vote.

National in 2005 got from 2.7% to 7.4% in the Maori seats. In 2008 it was from 5.5% to 10.9% so a very small improvement there.

The electorate votes we start from Te Taik Tokerau in the North. Hone Harawira won it by 3,600 in 2005 over Dover Samuels. This time he has a 5,500 majority.

Pita Sharples evicted John Tamihere from Tamaki Makaurau by 2,100 in 2005 and holds it over Louisa Wall by a massve 6,300.

In Waiariki, Te Ururoa Flavell won by 2,900 in 2005. In 2008 he doubles that to 6,000.

Nanaia Mahuta held onto Tainui by 1,860. The boundary changes to Hauraki-Waikato did not favour her, so she did well to hold on by 1,046.

In Te Tai Hauauru, Tariana Turia won by 5,000 in 2005 and this time he rmajority is almost 7,000.

The big battle was in Ikaroa-Rawhiti. Parekura held off Atareta Poananga by 1,932 in 2005, and Poananga’s former partner, Derek Fox, challenged in 2008. But Fox fell short by 1,609.

Finally in the South, Te Tai Tonga was held by Mahara Okeroa in 2005 by 2,500. New Maori Party candidate Rahui Katene beat him by 684 votes in 2008.

Herald on the new Government

The Herald Editorial:

And on the eighth day, he created history. John Key’s confirmation yesterday of his Government with partner parties may not be of biblical dimensions but it is telling in its achievement.

First, New Zealand has been spared the interminable post-election horse-trading that has done more to damage MMP than anything else. Second, Maori have been embraced into a centre-right Government in a spirit and in detail that gives far broader hope for our society’s development than the mere completion of a political support document. Third, two parties, the Maori Party and Act, that have not been in government before now have an opportunity to introduce their philosophies directly into the sharp end of our politics.

That is an aspect I had not considered before – that neither ACT nor Maori Party had even been in Government – unlike Alliance, Progressive, United and NZ First before them.

In the short-term National could have bypassed the Maori Party and relied on Act and United Future to give it 65 votes in the 122-member House. But Mr Key is not thinking short-term. By committing his Government to some of the Maori Party’s goals he is hoping to transform politics and society beyond 2011.

By choosing – and not being forced – to work with the party, he sends powerful signals of where this co-operation might lead.

An agreement forged in possibilities has more chance of thriving than the lowest common denominator of painful concessions. It should have been no real disappointment for anyone that National will not, as it claimed, seek to eliminate the Maori electorates. Its “review” of the Foreshore and Seabed Act is vague but has the chance of finding a solution rather than cementing a problem.

I think there is a real possibility of an agreed solution to the Foreshore & Seabed issue.

In the meantime, there is no gainsaying the achievements of his first eight days. The economic crisis meant we needed a Government as fast as one could be formed. What we have been offered is something much more than the sum of its parts.

That is the hope – having the additional parties such as the Maori Party may allow the Government to make progress in areas such as welfare, that would be difficult without.

A speedy deal

As the Herald shows, John didn’t get Sunday off. And later today the full Ministry will be unveiled.

I am disappointed to read that we will be keeping the Ministry at 28 Ministers. That is far too much. I guess I should be grateful that it isn’t increasing from the record high Helen took it to.

In my ideal Government you would have around 12 Ministers in Cabinet and 10 – 12 outside Cabinet. The Ministers in Cabinet would each look after a cluster (such as Law & Order or Education) and Ministers outside would look after specific portfolios delegated to them.

Anyway that is 23 Ministers from National. Who will they be? I may be wrong, but I would say there are 17 definites or near definites.

  1. John Key
  2. Bill English
  3. Gerry Brownlee
  4. Simon Power
  5. Nick Smith
  6. Tony Ryall
  7. Judith Collins
  8. David Carter
  9. Anne Tolley
  10. Murray McCully
  11. Maurice Williamso
  12. Wayne Mapp
  13. Chris Finlayson
  14. Tim Groser
  15. Pansy Wong
  16. Steven Joyce
  17. Georgina te Heuheu

That leaves another six places for the 2005 intake and others to fight over.

There will also be three National MPs in Speakerships, two Whips and half a dozen Select Committee Chairs so all up 35 or so baubles to allocate 🙂

Could specials change any electorates?

I’ve previously blogged on whether specials may change any allocation of List MPs. The other question is whether any seats held by narrow majorities could change due to specials. The answer is yes, but unlikely.

The most marginal seat is New Plymouth – Jonathan Young got 48.6% of the vote to 47.6% for Harry Duynhoven. There were 32,029 valid votes. There are 2,351 known specials for the seat and we estimate 1/70th of the 32,000 overseas specials, so the numebr of specials is predicted to be 2,808.

The specials would have to be 6.1% better for Labour and worse for National for Harry to win. Or in other words they would need to go Harry’s way 53.7% to 42.5%.

In Auckland Central Nikki Kaye beat Judith Tizard by 1,181 votes. However there are a large 6,420 specials plus overseas votes. Niiki beat Judith 43.0% to 38.8%. Judith would need to win the specials 49.5% to 32.3% to close the gap.

In Christchurch Central, Nicky Wagner would need specials to go her way 53.3% to 32.2% – 12.1% better than on the day.

New Plymouth looks to be the only seat which could seriously change, and even that isn’t very likely.

National – Maori Party Agreement

Well John Key did it, he has 70 votes to 52 in Parliament, and has forged an agreement with the Maori Party that makes Labour’s chance of winning in 2011 a lot harder.

The agreement is here.

  • Establish a group by 2010 to review constitutional issues, including Maori seats

Oh this will be fun. I love constitutional issues. There are so many – the Crown, the Treaty, the Bill of Rights, a written constitution, the Electoral Act etc etc.

  • National not to remove the Maori seats without the consent of Maori, and the Maori Party not to seek to entrench them in the current term.

Absolutely predictable.

  • Review the Foreshore & Seabed Act by end of 2009. If there is a repeal, All NZers will be guaranteed access to foreshore and seabed.

Labour’s legislation was wrong. I will not be surprised if the eventual agreement is to scrap it, but to legislate for access rights for all NZers.

  • Pita Sharples to be Minister of Maori Affairs, and Associate Education and Corrections
  • Tariana Turia to be Minister for the Community and Voluntary Sector, Associate Health, and Associate Social Development and Employment

I think Sharples will be a very good Maori Affairs Minister. There is some potential for conflict in Corrections between what National/ACT want to do, and what his instincts might say. But also areas of commonality such as the privately managed prison that had rave reviews from local Iwi.

  • Maori Party to agree on Chairperson of Maori Affairs Select Committee, who will be a National MP.

If Georgina and Tau both make Cabinet, then I would guess this could be Hekia. But if one of the two existing Maori MPs misses out, then that one.

Incidentially there may be five Maori Ministers – Georgina, Tau, Paula, Pita and Tariana.

  • All Maori MPs and MPs with an electorate larger than 20,000 sq kms to get a third Out of Parliament staff member

I would rather decisions like this are made through the Parliamentary Service Commission. But this was recommended by the Goulter review, and two offices are not enough for some of those large electorates.

Quote of the day goes to Hone Harawria:

“In three days, National offered us more than Labour did in three years,” said one of its MPs, Hone Harawira.

If Labour had gone with the Greens and the Maori Party in 2005, they wouldn’t have had to put up with effectively condoning Winston’s antics.

National – United Future Agreement

The National – United Future agreement is online here.

  • Peter Dunne to be Minister of Revenue and Associate Health

Good. He can keep pushing for flatter taxes from there.

  • Maintain Families Commission

I just knew that would be there!

  • Reduce elective surgery waiting lists by greater utilisation of private hospital capacity, in a planned way where this cannot be met by the public hospital system

Excellent – no arguments at all.

  • Progressing the long-term medicines strategy for quality use of pharmaceuticals in the health sector
  • Support Public Private Partnerships for major roading infrastructure developments such as the Transmission Gully highway

I’ll celebrate the day the first car drives along it, but not before!

  • The government notes that United Future has been committed to income splitting as a key part of their tax policy and agrees to support appropriate legislation to First Reading in Parliament.

Where parties can’t agree on something, an agreement to support to select committee is quite sensible, as it allows the public and other parties to consider their positions and submit on it.

  • Establish a Big Game Hunting Council as part of a national wild game management strategy

I guess that came from the Oudoor Recreation Party they gobbled up a few years ago.

I did note one section in the agreement:

Cabinet Manual

The Leader of United Future agrees to be bound by the Cabinet Manual in the exercise of his Ministerial responsibilities, and in particular agrees to be bound by the provisions in the Cabinet Manual on the conduct, public duty, and personal interests of Ministers.

This is what you would call the Winston clause. Helen allowed Winston to trample all over the Cabinet Manual – he didn’t get permission for travel, he ddn’t declare gifts, he didn’t get the PM’s permission to keep gifts etc. John Key is signalling he will expect a higher standard of integrity from his Ministers than Helen Clark did.

The National-ACT Agreement

National has put the coalition confidence and supply agreement online (staff are working long hours!).

  • goal of closing the income gap with Australia by 2025
  • require a sustained lift in New Zealand’s productivity growth rate to 3% a year or more
  • agreed on the establishment of a high quality advisory group to investigate the reasons for the recent decline in New Zealand’s productivity performance
  • Rodney to be Minister of Local Government, Minister for Regulatory Reform and Associate Minister of Commerce and a member of the Cabinet Expenditure Control Committee

Very pleased to see Rodney get Local Government – he will be a champion for ratepayers.

  • Heather to be Minister of Consumer Affairs, Associate Minister of Defence and Associate Minister of Education

Also good to see Heather get more than Consumer Affairs. I hope she can keep her role in Territorials despite being Associate Minister – the Forces will appreciate a Minister who is one of them! Education will also be a key area for change, if we are to close the gap with Australia.

  • National agrees to introduce the ACT Three Strikes Bill
  • National agrees to a review by a special select committee of Parliament of the current Emissions Trading Scheme legislation and any amendments or alternatives to it, including carbon taxes, in the light of current economic circumstances and steps now being undertaken by similar nations

Having it reviewed by select committee is sensible as that gives a voice to all parties. And the ETS legislation was so complex it needed another look by select committee anyway.

  • National further agrees to pass forthwith an amendment to the ETS legislation delaying its implementation, repealing the thermal generation ban and making any other necessary interim adjustments until the select committee review is completed
  • Establishing a series of Task Forces that include private sector representatives and private sector chairs to undertake fundamental reviews of all base government spending in identified sectors, and to report findings progressively to the cabinet control expenditure committee and relevant ministers.

This should have been happening for the last nine years. The status quo is not an adequate reason to keep funding something. Public funds should be spent on areas where they actually achieve good outcomes.

  • Support, within six months, the referral of ACT’s Taxpayer Rights Bill to the Finance and Expenditure Committee of Parliament as a government measure with the aim of passing into law a cap on the growth of core Crown expenses.
  • National and ACT note that United Future favours reducing and aligning personal, trust and company taxes at a maximum rate of 30%. They agree that such a tax structure is a desirable medium-term goal.

Who would have thought – United Future gets to se the tax policy for the nation 🙂

  • National and ACT agree that the government will establish a task force to carry forward work on the Regulatory Responsibility Bill considered by the Commerce Committee of Parliament in 2008.
  • National and ACT agree that the National-led government will explore the concept of a New Zealand Productivity Commission associated with the Productivity Commission in Australia in order to support the goals of higher productivity growth and improvements in the quality of regulation.

I can’t stress how important this might be. However to be truly successful, it would need bipartisan support. It is in all of our interest to improve productivity – even if not always popular with every lobby group. National should try and work with Goff and King to get their support for such a Commission.

  • The National-led government will establish a high quality advisory group to recommend short-term amendments to the RMA, including but not confined to those which National has put forward, as a basis for select committee consideration early in 2009.
  • National and ACT have agree to set up an inter-party working group, which shall be resourced as necessary to consider and report on policy options relating to the funding and regulation of schools that will increase parental choice and school autonomy.
  • National has identified the initiatives on National’s “My key commitments to you” and “National’s Post-Election Action Plan” publications as priorities for them. ACT agrees to support the legislation required to give effect to these policies. These publications are attached as Appendix 2.

This means National can implement its key manifesto items.

  • ACT agrees that it will support the government on procedural motions in the House and in select committees unless ACT has previously advised that such support is not forthcoming. National agrees that it will operate a no surprises policy with ACT on procedural motions it intends to put before the House or a select committee. If National fails to give ACT 48-hours notice of intended procedural motions, ACT shall not be bound by its obligations under this heading.

And means ACT will generally support National on procedural motions, so long as they are given enough notice to decide. There will inevitably be urgency to deal with the 2008 legislation that has an election mandate. I do hope in future urgency is not used too often – or if it is, only to increase sitting hours, but not to rush laws through more than one stage.

Rodney has delivered a good agreement for his supporters, and he also did well in taking ACT from two MPs in 2005 to five MPs in 2008. That gave him the increased clout he needs.

Key has also done well. He has secured support for National’s key manifesto items, and many of his own supporters will welcome the concessions to ACT. Yet nothing there to really scare away the centrist voters – at this stage – that will depend on how certain items are implemented. Issues around the ETS should not be allowed to drift for too long.

Rodney on the coalition agreement

Not online, but a PR from Rodney on the coalition confidence and supply agreement with National:

I see National and ACT’s Confidence and Supply Agreement as a victory for democracy.
A week ago New Zealand voted for a Centre-Right government and today, with this historic agreement, we have one.

Yep 64/122 seats.

Agreement was achieved at an unbelievably quick pace. Tremendous ground was covered as a result – and only because – of the tremendous spirit of good faith and trust built up between my self and John Key during his time as Leader of the Opposition, and throughout the past week when he gained enormous respect from me with his openness and willingness to see the other’s point of view.

All our discussions this week indicate we have the basis for a long-lasting and fruitful relationship based on that mutual respect.

Sounds good.

John Key and I have set the big goal of New Zealand closing the income gap with Australia by 2025. We aim to catch and match Australia. That’s a stretch. It’s what we need to do to bring our kids home.

Heh, always set a goal that you can’t fail at while still in office 🙂

That’s a wee bit cynical. People won’t expect much progress in the first term as we recover from the inherited recession, but will expect progress in subsequent terms.

We share the view of the need to make New Zealand safer. That’s why ACT’s ‘Three strikes and You’re Out’ Law & Order policy for violent offenders will have National’s support to a Select Committee. We look forward to New Zealanders getting behind this measure that will save lives.

A sensible compromise is having it go to select committee.

On Climate Change we will review New Zealand’s response with agreed draft terms of reference. The implementation of the Emissions Trading Scheme will be delayed until the review is completed, and the thermal generation ban will be repealed.

ACT did not get the ETS scrapped, just reviewed which was going to happen anyway. And the thermal generation ban was loopy.

On spending, we will establish a series of task forces to undertake a fundamental review of base government spending in identified sectors. Capping core government spending will receive Select Committee consideration.

Yes and yes. Both good.

We have set a medium-term goal of setting the top rate of tax at 30 percent. In doing so, we have made the clear statement that New Zealand now has a government that will reward and celebrate success – not punish it.

United Future also supports a 30% top tax rate. It won’t happen in the next three years but is a good goal to aim for.

National and ACT are committed to combating the red tape that’s tying New Zealanders in knots, with John Key appointing me Minister of Regulatory Reform. We will establish a task force to carry forward work on the Regulatory Responsibility Bill, and we will explore the concept of a New Zealand Productivity Commission.

The NZ Productivity Commission is a very worthwhile concept. The Australian equivalent has been very successful in attracting bipartisan support for its ideas. Phil Goff could be smart here and support this.

Rodney as Minister in charge of reducing regulations also a win-win.

I’ve yet to see the full agreement, but what Rodney has mentioned sounds very good – some real wins for ACT supporters but nothing that National would be uncomfortable with. The biggest risk area is around delaying the ETS too much – it would just give ammo to Labour/Greens – but if the outcome is a better designed ETS, then that is good.

Problems for Rodney

Rodney may have his hands full with David Garrett. At Backbenches last Wednesday he surprised a few by advocating a Sheriff Joe type prison of war camp at Waiorou for hardened criminals, with food to cost only 75c a day instead of the current $5.

And the HoS reports he caused waves at Eye to Eye, and was allegedly drunk. However (and you have to look hard to find this, the show was recorded in June before he was an ACT candidate):

During the show, Garrett, speaking slowly and occasionally slurring, made rambling comments which were rubbished by the other panellists, particularly former Act MP Deborah Coddington.

My motto is to drink after the TV show, not before! Mind you on election night it was a mxiture of both!

Coddington said she was shocked by Garrett’s attitude: “He was really rude to me. He walked up and said `Deborah Coddington, my brother hates you’.”

She said recording was stopped several times because of Garrett’s behaviour but didn’t think any more about the incident until Act announced Garrett as a list candidate.

Which was some months ago.

Garrett confirmed he made the comment to Coddington.

“That was a stupid thing to say. But I might have said it stone cold sober.”

He denied he was homophobic and said the other panellists had not listened to his arguments.

“What I said was, paedophilia is a sexual orientation just like homosexuality or heterosexuality. Deborah Coddington just didn’t get it.

“I am not saying gays are the same as paedophiles. One of my closest friends is flagrantly gay. He was the MC at my wedding.”

Garrett said he “certainly regrets” his long lunch and had rung Hauiti to apologise. “It’s certainly not appropriate behaviour for an MP.”

Not a helpful story, but when I first read it, I thought this had just happened this weekend. It is somewhat of a different story that it was before he was even a candidate.

Oh and for the record homosexuality is a sexual orientation. Paedophilia is a psychological disorder.

Gore does not forgive

US shows being shown earlier here

The HoS reports:

An explosion in online piracy has forced New Zealand’s free-to-air TV networks to fast-track the screening of top international shows.

Superhero drama Heroes and British car series Top Gear topped the list of the most illegally downloaded TV shows in New Zealand last year, with millions of copies hitting cyberspace as soon as they were made available overseas.

As a result, those shows and others including House, Private Practice and Survivor are aired within days of their international release.

And that is the logical response. We live in a borderless world and if people can read online the latest Heroes episode is out, they want to see it now – now in six months. If NZ is only a few days behind few will pirate it, but if it is a choice of waiting for months or downloading a copy of something that will be free to air  anyway, people download.

As a matter of principle I will not download movies, as they are distributed in NZ within days of overseas release, and you have to pay to see them.

I have occassionally downloaded a TV show if it either does not show in NZ at all, or the wait to see it will be too long. I always watch it again on the TV once they do show here also. At present I haven’t downloaded a TV show for months – partly too busy, but partly because TV networks here are screening them faster.

Tony Eaton, the executive director of the Federation Against Copyright Theft, says that the authorities in New Zealand had yet to conduct extensive research into illegal downloads.

“Our primary focus has been the film industry but in saying that we have turned our attention to television more,” he said.

“It makes sense for networks to make shows available as soon as possible on television here.”

Good to see FACT agreeing.

The trend may explain why the big two free-to-air networks offer legal downloads of top shows for a limited period after they screen on TV.

“It may be that online availability of programming is actually having the effect of boosting television viewing – that is certainly the case with `catch up’ television,” said Richards.

I have no doubt this is the case.

HoS on Goff

Some interesting and amusing aspects in their Goff profile:

“I don’t regard myself as being arrogant,” he says. “I’ve never regarded myself as being nakedly ambitious. I’ve actually set out, rather, to do the jobs that have been given to me as well as I could.”

Did he manage to say that with a straight face?

There are numerous superficial similarities with Helen Clark: both became involved in Labour when they were young; both were pointy-headed young political scientists at the University of Auckland; both were elected to Parliament straight from university; they ended up in adjacent Auckland electorates.

But Goff is anxious to highlight the differences: she was a farm girl, his dad was traditional Labour blue-collar, a fitter and turner with the railways. His grandmother, widowed in 1934, lost her house in the Depression. She thought that Michael Joseph Savage, the first Labour Prime Minister, walked on water.

Goff worked in the freezing works in his school and university holidays, with men who had been there since the 1940s. “I learned a lot at university, but I also a learned a hell of a lot working on the factory floor.”

And Goff is much much more centrist than Clark. If he gets Labour to drop their almost unique ban on asset sales (which would outflank National) I would almost vote for him.

Poor Don McGlashan

The HoS reports:

Anchor Me, by McGlashan’s former group, The Mutton Birds, was used during a post-election wrap on TV One last Sunday.

In an angry letter to the network, McGlashan said he had never voted National and “would rather have sex with a very ugly crayfish than let them use my music”.

I like the fact the crayfish had to be very ugly 🙂

McGlashan said he had plenty of suggestions if TVNZ wanted other songs for broadcasts involving the National Party or Act.

They included Take the Money and Run by the Steve Miller Band, Gold Digger by Kanye West and Out of Ideas by A.C.T.

Heh.

Great way to unwind

The early afternoon Friday saw me covering the unofficial launch of the new i7 Intel chip. I’m going to post on that more on Monday, and chatted to the Intel Product Manager about it.  Gamers and content producers are going to love it.

The launch was at the Melbourne e-gaming convention, and I found one very good shoot me up detective game – great graphics, and an awesome choice of weapons. I got so engrossed in the game, I spent five hours on it!! It has been literally years since I spent that long on a computer game.

I am returning today to try and find my saved game and coninue!

Roughan gets it

John Roughan in the Herald:

A week ago, when the votes were in and National didn’t need the Maori Party, a deal didn’t seem to me to be worth doing. How wrong I was.

If this deal can be done it will be the better because neither side needs to do it.

Exactly. It is more durable and genuine when it is unforced.

The Maori’s choice this week was National or nothing, which are both serious options. If National is offering next to nothing Maori might do better to wait. What’s another three years after 168? I bet that was said at all the hui held these past few days.

And I’ll bet something else: if National’s offer is accepted , the reasons that persuaded the hui will have little to do with the positions and portfolios agreed with John Key. The decisive reason will be the Maori leaders’ reading of National’s new attitude.

And more specifically John Key’s attitude. He has spent a long time building up a constructive relationship with the Maori Party, supported by his MPs.

It will have to be a radically new attitude for the National Party.

Roughan may be surprised by how keen rank and file activists are for a deal also.

My guess is they will have made it very clear they are not content with a relationship in which they are given a couple of self-contained responsibilities in Maori Affairs and Social Welfare and left alone with them.

They are more likely to want an assurance of being treated as an equal partner in all major decisions the Government will make.

That does not mean a right of veto but it does mean they are brought into the discussion, their viewpoints are taken seriously, disagreements respected, and each side makes genuine and strenuous efforts to reach decisions that satisfy both.

I guess the combined Maori Caucus of 11 MPs could play a role also.

No agreed formula of words is sufficient to make that sort of arrangement secure. Its success will depend completely on the heart of the more powerful partner. Key and his Cabinet will have to genuinely want this partnership and even be excited by it.

They should be excited. They have on their table a historical opportunity such as no incoming government has been given. They could be the authors of a constitutional precedent that will do more for the social wellbeing and national identity of New Zealand than they can yet imagine.

Okay, now John’s getting a bit too excited. 🙂

But indeed it is a future with some promise.

Who will be Speaker?

The Herald reports four contenders for Speaker. They are:

  1. Lockwood Smith
  2. John Carter
  3. Eric Roy
  4. Richard Worth

They each have their own claims for the job. Lockwood is National’s longest serving MP. John Carter has been a Whip for many years, knowing Standing Orders well. Eric Roy was a very popular Assistant Speaker and Richard Worth would being a first class legal talent to the role.

This may dismay some, but I think Michael Cullen would also be a damn good Speaker. But I think his latest game playing over Treasury accounts has killed off any chance that he could be seen to make the transition from partisan player to referee.

As for the four candidates, it will presumably go to a National Caucus decision and then the preferred candidate checked with coalition partners.

But wouldn’t it be nice if it was left to the House as a whole to decide? If all parties would agree not to apply the whip and allow a free vote, then they could have a preferential ballot as allowed for in Standing Order 19. It would be fascinating to see all MPs vote from their seats.

I presume two of the unsucessful candidates will probably become Assistant Speakers and that Labour’s Ross Robertson will be Deputy Speaker.

UPDATE: Mallard is against Lockwood being Speaker. That probably helps Lockwood immensely.

Nice headlines

From the NZ Herald:

Prime Minister-elect John Key has promised iwi a working relationship which they have welcomed as a new era for Maori-Crown relations.

It’s amazing how much one can achieve when you don’t call them haters and wreckers.

The Lower South Island Seats

Dunedin remains happily red. Labour beats National in the party vote by 16% in Dunedin North and 12% in Dunedin South. This is a lot better than 2005 though when the margins were 29% and 28% respectively.

Pete Hodgson had his 7,900 majority drop to 6,700, which won’t lose him sleep. David Benson-Pope had a 10,100 majority and new gal Clare Curran traded that for a still healthy 6,000.

In Clutha-Southland National gets 60% party vote to 30% for Labour. Bill English trades up his 11,500 majority for a 14,300 one.

Finally in Invercargill, National wins the party vote by 10%, after losing it by 1% in 2005. And Eric Roy’s 4,000 majority is turbo charged into a 6,100 one.

That’s the end of the series. All graphics taken from the NZ Herald. When final results come in, I’ll provide a lot more data.

Investing on Specials

I am doing well to date on iPredict. Of 11 stocks, I have made money on 10 on them, totalling a net gain of just over $1,000. I lost money on Benson.Pope contesting the election, but have made money on:

  1. Goff to be Leader
  2. Cunliffe not to be Leader
  3. Maori Party to have an agreement with National (not yet closed)
  4. Peters not to be an MP
  5. Bridges to win Tauranga
  6. John Key to be PM
  7. Peters not to resign or be sacked
  8. Obama to be President
  9. Short selling President not to be Obama or McCain
  10. The third quarter inflation rate

Yesterday I blogged the Specials:

For Labour to gain a seat off National

If National gets 0.16% less on the specials and Labour 0.16% more on the specials, then Labour get the 120th seat. So if National gets 45.29% on the specials instead of 45.45% and Labour gets 33.93% instead of 33.77%, Labour gain a seat off National.

For Greens to gain a seat off National

If National gets 1.62% less on specials, and Greens 1.62% more, then Greens would get the 120th seat off National. Another scenario is Greens get 1.55% more and National and Labour lose 0.78% each.

For both Labour and Greens to gain a seat, and National lose two seats

If Labour does 2.51% better on specials and Greens 2.10% better, than they will take spots 119 and 120 and knock two seats off National. This would mean National gets only 40.8% of specials, Labour gets 36.3% and Greens get 8.5% for this to happen.

Ipredict has the following stock prices:

  • National to lose no seats – $0.77c
  • National to lose one seat – $0.24c
  • National to lose two seats – 0.02c

I have just purcahsed some National to lose one seat stock at a bit over 20c. It is by no means certain National will lose a seat, but with Labour needing to lift its vote for specials by just 0.16%, then I’d put the probability at well above 20c.

Google Rome

NBR reports:

Users of the search giant’s Google Earth can now add a new layer that lets them wander a 3D version of ancient Rome (or at least they will be shortly. Google has just issued a service advisory, titled “Rome wasn’t built in a day”, announcing a delay of 24 hours or so before the new service goes live).

The latest addition in Google’s product release frenzy graphically recreates Rome as it looked 1688 years ago under Emperor Constantine. Users can take a virtual stroll around 6700 buildings, crafted in 3D in cooperation with the Rome Reborn project – a virtual reality project that saw UCLA, the University of Virginia, the Politecnico di Milano and others create a 3D model of the city in 320AD.

I am a huge Romophile so am downloading that for sure.