Holiday continued

Yesterday went into Port Douglas township for the famous Sunday markets. Made a couple of purchases and then had lunch in town. The cafe had “pipis” on spaghetti which I couldn’t resist as I have fond childhood memories of catching pipis at Waikanae beach and then cooking them on a bbq at our farmlet at Reikorangi. I hadn’t had then since I was a kid.

In the afternoon just mucked about in the hotel swimming pool, and dined inhouse. One can see in the photo below what the hotel environs are like with native trees everywhere.

0100_0384.JPG

A fairly non typical holiday for me. Of my six books with me, I have not even got 10% through a single book. Likewise haven’t even switched the TV on yet – despite all those news bulletins! Just so many more relaxing things to do and see.

Media coverage of lawsuit

PC comments on the near total lack of media coverage of the lawsuit against Helen Clark. I have to say I have been amazed also that from what I can see the only mention in the print media has been a short NZPA story.

Perhaps there will be questions at post Cabinet today. No doubt Clark will dismiss it on the basis of who is bringing it, rather than a serious discussion of the merits.

National Board elections

The Herald has a story on the contest for National’s board. There are four going for three spots.

They are certainly correct that Judy Kirk will be re-elected to the board and re-elected President by the board. People in National generally seem very happy with the organisation.

Liz Dengate-Thrush

Ex-Leaders

The Weekend Press had an article on how Bill English has “stopped sulking” to play a lead role in National again. While it is correct that Bill is very much part of the shared senior management of the caucus, he never sulked for two years. In fact he has set a standard for ex-leaders which is hard to beat – turning his energy into his shadow portfolio and proving one of the best opposition operators.

This got me thinking about all the ex-leaders of both National, and Labour and how well one would score them for their post-leader roles. Here’s my marks:

Bill English – 9/10 – accepted loss, has been totally loyal to new leader and rather than fade away has a new lease on life as an aggressive opposition front bencher.

Jenny Shipley – 8.5/10 – also very gracious and loyal. Despite losing leadership remained part of the team until 2002 election. Also played a very significant role in helping the party fund-raise for her successor.

Jim Bolger – 5.5/10 – started well with going to the US to be out of the way, but many in National will never ever forgive him for his taking the chairmanship of Kiwibank. Still not over being rolled, a decade later.

Jim McLay – 8/10 – fought to stay on, but accepted the loss and went gracefully at the next election. Has remained a low key supporter since.

Sir Robert Muldoon – 2/10 – undermined his successor at every opportunity until he was rolled. Continued to undermine the party for years until he retired from Parliament.

Jack Marshall – 8/10 – gentleman Jack to the last.

Keith Holyoake 7.5/10 – was not happy at being pushed to retire early but never rocked things too much.

And for Labour:

Mike Moore – 1.5/10 – went even more ballistic than Muldoon in undermining his party and caucus. Get some credit for a makeup in 1996, but continued to harbour grudge beyond his retirement from Parliament.

Geoffrey Palmer – 9/10 – seemed almost relieved when Clark and Moore toppled him. Gracious exit from Parliament soon after.

David Lange – 6/10 – at first very supportive to Palmer but under Moore and to a degree Clark was a loose cannon and a liability. Should have retired in 1990 when he was great.

Bill Rowling – 7.5/10 – never made a fuss, but never particularly helpful to Lange.

Normal Kirk – 10/10 – many say a dead ex-leader is the best sort 🙂

Alister Taylor exposed

June 2005 NZ Blog Stats

Okay, it’s the usual story. Post as a comment below your blog name, the number of posts and if applicable the number of comments you got in June 2006, and I’ll update the main body with the details.

David Farrar 186, 4224
Sir Humphrey’s 180, 1990
Not PC 124, 221
New Zeal 61, 342
Spare Room 50, 124
Clouds of Heaven, 39, 13
Morph Blog 37, 12
backin15.blogspot.com 34, 67
The Red Letter 33, 50
Big News 30, 45
TUMEKE! 29, 131
Andrew Falloon 27, 168
Auckland At Large 26, 39
Just Left 23, 389
Hitting Metal With A Hammer 22, 186
urbancast 16, 2
On The Right 15, 95
peopleschoice.org.nz 15
Hitchens Watch 13, 560
IIQ illusions and allusions 11, 18
Spanblather 10, 45
Anarchia 9, 39
Laws Watch 7, 215

Gay Adoption

I do hope Metiria Turei’s bill to allow gay adoption passes first reading because it will be great to have a select committee consider the issue and allow submissions on it. The HOS has an article on it.

Opposition to gay adoption, tends to take one of two forms. The first is from those who think most gay men are pedophiles and they want to adopt so they can molest their own children, and bring them up gay. Not too many out there like this, but there are a few.

The second is from those who think that the best likely outcome for a child is being brought up by a man and a woman married or at least in a permanent relationship with each other. And I actually fall into the camp of believing that – how-ever I don’t support gay adoption being banned either.

First of all one should acknowledge there are already many gay parents out there, and many kids who are already brought up by gay couples after relationships have split up or more recently through IVF, or donors etc. And I’m not aware of any research that have shown gay parents to be any less loving than normal parents. So regardless of the fate of the adoption bill, there are and will continue to be many gay parents.

How-ever I do instinctively believe that, putting aside for now all other factors, that a child is best to have a male and female parent, and that having the parents married, or civilly united, living together is ideal.

So why do I still support gay adoption? Because the above is only one factor of a good environment to raise children. I’d take a non-alcoholic gay couple as parents over a straight alcoholic couple any day.

I presume that when couples are considered for adopting, there is a “points” system of some sort like immigration where various criteria are judged – length of relationship, sufficient income, commitment to education, lack of criminal record etc etc. So I would have couples of opposite gender scoring somewhat more highly than the same gender (because I do think male and female role models and parents are important and do fulfil different needs) but this would be only one factor, and would more affect your place in the queue, than your overall eligibility.

This debate might also be more theoretical than practical also. I think the number of babies made available for adoption is now very very low. At some stage I’ll research this in more detail.

The truth about ticket quotas revealed

There has long been suspicion that in recent years the issuing of tickets is more about quotas and revenue than the very important task of road safety. Speed cameras have gone from targeting the top 15% of speedsters to all over the tolerance limit etc.

Today the Herald on Sunday has blown a hole through the Police’s insistence that there are no quotas. Read this extract:

A June 21 job sheet for police officers in the Central North Island area tells officers to set up road blocks so they can target high volumes of traffic to finish “top group” in their district before the end of the financial year.

So police officers are told to ticket as many motorists as possible so that they can be rewarded for being “top group”.

It has been sad to watch the reputation of the Police get lower and lower every year. They used to be one of the great institutions of state that all could rely on.

Daintree

0100_0354.JPG

Well thanks to the early start, we made Cape Tribulation and found a lovely picnic area by Myall Beach. Was delightfully tranquil as we had a picnic lunch in the shade with the rain forest as a wonderful backdrop.

0100_0360.JPG

Then a short walk onto the beach

0100_0359.JPG

followed by the Dubuji boardwalk.

0100_0374.JPG

Then went as far north as one can go without a 4WD and went up to the Kulki lookout whch gave an elevated view.

0100_0375.JPG

Then time to head back down south, stopping at the Mardja Boardwalk and going through some nice mangrove swamp. Unlike the previous boardwalk, we wisely decided not to leave the trail on this one.

0100_0380.JPG

A quick stop at the Waluwurriga Alexandra Range Lookout.

a100_0383.JPG

At the Daintree Village came across this. It looks like a camel seduced a cow a few years back, but does anyone know what it is?

And then got back home around 5 pm – 13 hours after I got up! Now enjoying the free wireless they have in the hotel bar. Definitely starting to think a week isn’t long enough here!

National and Greens in a tree, k i s s i n g

Heh not quite, that old ditty just came to mind.

John Armstrong has an excellent analysis of the National-Greens relationship.

At first he covers National and Green MPs attending each other’s parties. Now this is in fact not a big thing. I can recall Green MPs attending a previous National party, and I even have been invited to a Green party in the past (sadly seem to be off current invite list – hint hint!).

Armstrong covers that people may read some significance into the party attending, on top of the dog micro-chipping vote. But he correctly states that at the end of the day the Greens and National disagree on 90% of policies and a post-election deal is never going to be a flyer.

But there is room for some co-operation in the House, such as gifting surplus question spots to the Greens when they are running a good attack line on the Govt. Sounds pretty sensible. Temporary alliances are at the heart of good warfare 🙂

Control of Benefits

The National Maori Urban Authority. has called for welfare benefits to be paid to Maori social service agencies which would control how beneficiaries spend the money.

It is impractical to do compulsorily (and would be wrong to apply just to Maori), but that shouldn’t change the fact there are a number of welfare dependent families who can not cope (as we have tragically seen) and make very very poor decisions on expenditure with taxpayer money not going towards food, health and education for the kids, but alcohol etc for adults.

No easy answers for how you overcome the problems in those families except try and identity assistance as soon as possible. Even schemes such as food and clothing vouchers do not work well (from what I have seen) as a black market gets set up trading in them for cash.

Responsibility a foreign word to Labour

One of the press gallery wrote a couple of weeks back about how Labour seem pathologically incapable of accepting responsibility for anything – despite seven years in office.

Mike Heine has compiled these extracts from just two days of questions in the House. Go read them – no matter what the topic or the issue, Labour balmes it on the 1990s despite having been in power for a long seven years. God they’d blame Governor Grey if they could.

In just two days, they blamed National for:

– Rates Increases
– Transpower
– Education Quality
– Lack of long term care assistance for spouses
– Disparity in tertiary salaries
– West Coast conservation strategy
– Access to Courts
– Skills Shortages

It would be hilarious if it wasn’t so sad.

Grrrr

Because a rental car is being picked up at 8 am (for driving through the Daintree and up to Cape Tribulation), I worked out getting up at 6 am would be necessary so one could pack for a day trip, shower, have brekkie etc.

Rather than order a wakeup call, companion insisted to rely on her cellphone alarm. And it went off at 6 am, and by 7 am we were all packed and ready to head out to breakfast.

I decided to turn on my laptop to check the news, and strangely the laptop was also showing it to be 7 am. Now my laptop always stays on NZST/NZDT so it should have been showing 9 am.

A look at the room clock shows it is 5 am!! Idiot had not changed her cellphone to local time, and hence we got up at 4 bloody am!!

Only redeeming aspect is it did end up giving me some time to blog!

Air NZ Premier Business Class

Ok well I just experienced the new “Premier Business” class on an Air NZ 747 and I have to say I am definitely impressed.

The TV screens are massive compared to most airlines. Really good for movies. And now they finally have a fully interactive entertainment system (Singapore Air has had one for years) you can pause movies for meals etc.

The privacy screens really do make it much nicer, and the fold-out to a bed works very easily.

The only small problem was hard to see out a window without turning the head around. But if you are lying down you get an excellent view.

I’d rank Air NZ cattle class 2/10, the old business class 6/10, the old first class 7/10 and this new premium business probably a 9/10. I haven’t tried the new premium economy class but it looks to be 5/10 – close to the old business class.

Am at the resort hotel and it is superb. All the rooms and paths are in native trees, next to the beach and a huge swimming pool with an adjourning bar. Mike M picked me up from Cairns and we had a great drive over Captain Cook Highway in his jeep.

Catching up with Stats Girl tonight, and tomorrow heading into the Daintree and up to Point Tribulation. All good. Hence very little blogging except maybe very early or late in the day.

Darnton vs Clark

A lawsuit has been filed today against Helen Clark and the other 48 Labour MPs (as at August 2005) in relations to their use of taxpayer funding for their 2005 election pledge cards.

The lawsuit claims the expenditure on the production and distribution of the pledge card and related brochure was a breach of Article 4 of the Bill of Rights 1688, section 22(c) of the Constitution Act 1986 s.22(c) and multiple sections of the Public Finance Act 1989.

A high court lawsuit is not a cheap affair, and the lawyers and parties involved would not be undertaking this without a very reasonable belief they can succeed. It will be a fascinating legal battle, somewhat reminiscent of Fitzgerald vs Muldoon 1976 (which Muldoon lost).

Telco Bill passes 1st reading 117-2

The Government’s Telecommunications Amendment Act has just passed its first reading by 117-2. Good.

Cunliffe’s speech is here. Also PR from InternetNZ.

It has been referred to the Finance and Expenditure Select Committee, not the Commerce Committee as I expected. Commerce has only three parties on it while FE has six or seven parties so will be an interesting committee process.

Southpark complaints rejected

Yay. Just read (not online yet) that the BSA has rejected all the complaints against the “Bloody Mary” episode of Southpark.

“The BSA acknowledged the degree of offence taken from this episode, noting that the broadcaster later undertook not to screen the episode again. But the Authority held that the broadcast of the overtly satirical programme, while clearly distasteful to the complainants, was protected by the Bill Of Rights Act 1990.”

They get it exactly right when they say:

Were the Authority to uphold the complaint, this would amount to a statement that broadcasters who offer satire, humour and drama _ may not offend against the religious convictions of others_That, in the view of the Authority, would be an unreasonable limitation of a broadcaster’s right to free speech, which includes the right to satirise religious issues.

It would have been an awful precedent if they had upheld the complaints. I’m very pleased with the BSA for this.

Auckland Evenings

On Tuesday evening I caught up with Brian , an old Usenet friend, and Peter Cresswell, and a couple of other Libz. Hadn’t met Peter before so was good to finally meet.

Wednesday saw me drinking cocktails with a gaggle of barristers. It started off as a celebratory cocktail with Jordan and InternetNZ’s barrister to celebrate the Telecom separation announcement, and then we met some other barristers and suddenly many cocktails later it was 930 pm and hadn’t had dinner. Finally had chicken soup in my hotel room, but it was too late to prevent a small hangover.

Have to get up at 3.30 am tomorrow to make 630 am flight to Cairns, so an early night tonight.

Long Term Fiscal Forecast for NZ

Treasury has done a 40 year out fiscal forecast, and not surprisingly it finds that the ageing population will lead to health and superannuation costs exceeding our projected income.

Some on the left are saying this is why we should not have tax cuts today, because in 25 years one may have to start increasing taxes. I personally reject a strategy based on constantly increasing tax rates as our population gets older.

On the income side, even a 0.5% annual increase in average GDP growth will make a big difference to future surpluses. A focus on lifting economic performance is vital.

For superannuation, I have no doubt the the superannuation eligibility age will over time increase from 65, and this will reduce costs. Even Dr Cullen has hinted that this is a legitimate future option.

Personally I would also means test superannuation as it is ridiculous to pay a pension to multi-millionaires. But there is no chance politically of this happening.

Health costs are more difficult. For 15 years all Governments have shied away from defining what health services will be publicly funded and what won’t be. No-one wants people dying early because they can’t afford an operation, but can we afford as a society to say fund liver transplants for 109 year olds so they make 111?

Progressive Staffing

A posting by Lindsay Mitchell about how Matt Robson has predicted both the date and result of the next election reminded me of a most curious entry in the NZ Government Directory published after the last election.

They list key staff in Minister’s offices, and Jim Anderton had a staffer whose job was listed as Caucus Secretary.

This is remarkable for a party of one. Does he just sit in a room and take notes of Jim speaking to himself?

Sharples praised

Babies in Jail

Interesting to note that every party in Parliament voted for Sue Bradford’s bill allowing mothers in prison to keep their babies with them until they turn two.

Possibly this is because, like me, they have no idea what is the correct age.

I have no idea whether seperation at birth, at six months or two years is better. This is one issue where I’d be guided by some good research.

13 years is not enough

13 years is not enough for Jarred Hutchison who was found guilty of 51 charges of sexual violation, 24 charges of rape and 16 charges of making objectionable material.

With parole he could be out in nine years.

I know sentencing is not cumulative but still for 91 serious offences, he should serve longer than two months per rape or violation. Over six years he not only raped a little girl, but he filmed himself doing it.

This is a classic contender for preventative detention where the burden will be on Hutchison to prove he is safe before he is released.

Views galore on Kahui deaths

It is natural when faced with not only the tragic killing of infant twins, but also a family who seemed to have adopted a mafia type vow of silence not to let any one be held accountable, that people ask how does this happen, that a family gets like this?

New blogger Patrick Dunford looks at the much lower rate of Pacific Island child abuse, and wonders if their religious faith and family based social structures explain part of that.

No Right Turn makes the unpopular but correct observation that the Kahui family are not legally obliged to co-operate with the Police. However actions have consequences and if they choose to take a mafia type vow of silence to protect the family, they will face public odium and pressure for that choice.

Parekura Horomia, Pita Sharples and Ron Mark have all called for the Police to “take” family members in for questioning and/or obstruction of justice. The family incidentally need to be careful about the difference between refusing to say anything (which they can do) and all agreeing to a line of they don’t know who did it (which would probably qualify as conspiracy to commit perjury or something).

The Counties Manukau’s police commander has stated there is an element of hypocrisy to Maori and Pacific Island cultures that promote aroha (love) and whanau (family).

Alan Duff refers to the once were warriors culture in the Kahui family which saw an adult passed out from alcohol at seven pm, when Pita Sharples called, and says the answer is “We’ve got to instil values.”

John Minto says “society is to blame” for the death of the twins. He claims Maori in our low income communities have seen their standard of living plummet in two decades, and this is to blame. The interesting thing is that while I don’t have figures right back to 1986 on hand, I have sourced some data for more recent years. A Treasury papers says from 1991 to 1996 Maori incomes increased. The Stats NZ income data shows average income for Maori increased 24% from June 2001 to June 2005 (identical to NZ increase of 25%).

And finally a Labour Department study of the years 1997 to 2003 found that the 22% increase in Maori income was higher than that of any other ethnic group (including European). I wonder with the Mintos of the world if there is anything at all they don’t blame on society?

Bruce Logan says family values help prevent abuse, lamenting that “Sex and marriage used to be about the birth and nurturing of children and social order. Now sex is about the acceptance of behaviour which is of no concern to anyone other than the consenting adults involved.” I agree with Logan that family values are crucial, but I don’t see that has much to do with consensual pre-marital sex. Family values are about having a work ethic in a family, valuing education, being prepared to put you child’s needs over your own etc etc.

Children’s Commissioner Cindy Kiro says the repeal if Section 59 is “a fundamental and necessary step to ensure that children in New Zealand grow up in safe and secure environments.” I will blog later on about the stupidity of the Section 59 repeal advocates in trying to link child murders to Section 59 in this way.

Dover Samuels has said “Some Maori leaders are covering up child abuse under the pretence that the violence is part of their culture”

As for my personal view, well the thing that struck me is how 11 out of 12 adults in that family are on benefits. With the lowest unemployment in the world there is just no legitimate excuse for that, and such a culture of non work would be an awful environment for bringing up a family.

This isn’t an argument against welfare per se. Far from it. I have friends who are solo mums or on the invalids benefit who are or will be great parents and they are using the welfare system in the way it is designed. But it was never designed to have 11 able bodied adults to be able to spend most of their day sitting at home getting pissed by 7 pm, while no one notices the kids being killed.

Perhaps CYPFS should not just be reactive to complaints, but be funded so it can be pro-active to identify at risk families such as this one, and intervene before it it too late? Maybe one needs agencies to share data to identify “profiles” such as over-crowded homes or more than x number of people on a benefit. People don’t like profiling, but waiting for the children to turn up dead isn’t a great alternative.

Sadly at the end of the day while there are many factors such as culture, poverty, family values, education etc there are no easy fixes. And regardless of all of the above, we should never let “factors” divert us from the fact that anyone who kills a child like this is quite amoral or evil, and those who cover it up are also evil. All (well bar sociopaths or severely retarded) human beings have the ability to know right from wrong when it is as basic as this.

UPDATE: Jordan has taken offence (well as much offence as you can when he is sitting next to me) at my last few paras. But he is reading things into what I said. I was very careful not to say benefits kill kids. In fact I specifically went out of my way to talk about my positive experiences with benefits helping people. What I was saying is that 11/12 adults on a benefit is an unhealthy environment.

I did not say the solution is to cut off their benefits. I raised it in the context of whether extremely high levels of benefit dependency may be an indicator of concern for child welfare. It’s one of the problems the left often has – that they feel any discussion of benefit dependency is an attack on the entire welfare system. And it needn’t be.