Becoming a farce

Sigh the Field inquiry is becoming more of a farce every day. A nine day inquiry is into month nine. But even worse the draft report has been out for weeks, yet no final report. Now I can guarantee you the PM (in her role as party leader!) will know exactly what is in that draft report. In fact probably most of the Labour Caucus probably know.

They are busy working on a political solution to the report, while Field tries to delay it further. And then we are all earnt to act surprised when Clark gets a final report and declares no further action is necessary.

With reports of this natuyre, the period between draft and final report is days not weeks. You give affected parties a few days to comment on adverse findings, you consider their submissions, and then you hand in your final report.

When the report finally is published, Dr Ingram better be very explicit about how on earth the report has taken so long, and also why there has been such a delay between draft and final report.

We now have Field getting up in Parliament, having seen the draft report, claiming the only thing he is guilty of is to go the extra mile to help people. You have Helen Clark (who will have been told what the draft report says) agreeing he is only guilty of trying to help someone.

Yet the media and the rest of the country can not judge it, as the report is not out. This looks like a script for Yes Minister.

Anyway let’s not overlook one hilarious exchange. After Lockwood asked whether the Asian Crime Unit had been investigating Field’s activities, Winston responded saying Dr Smith could not make such a serious allegation without “some proof or documentary evidence”.

Oh that is hilarious. We are all awaiting the documentary evidence for the fleet of WINZ limos, the Iraqi in Saddam’s Republican Guard, the bribe from Selwyn Cushing etc etc etc.

Intriguing headline

David Slack has a headline of “4 Votes for Krystal, 28 for Farrar“. This got my hopes up, until I realised he only put it there so I would link to him.

I have a brief few seconds imagining what the contest could be in which I scored seven times as many votes as Krystal. Rodney’s next dancing partner? Lawyer for Telecom? Blind Date contestant?

Then I thought perhaps it was something where I would get to meet Krystal. Perhaps I could get her to pat me on my head also, like Rodney has managed.

But alas Mr Slack just wants nominations for the “person who has had the most influence on our little country in the past twelve months”. So follow the link and nominate away.

And remember, like Time Magazine, it is the most infleunce for better or worse. So Ministers of the Crown are eligible 🙂

A milestone

As of midnight this blog has had 2,995,461 visits. Therefore at some stage probably around lunchtime, it will have visit number 3,000,000. Yay!

During the close to three years of operation there have been almost three quarters of a terabyte of data downloaded. And this morning by coincidence I made my 5,000th post (a few have been deleted so the public counter shows a bit less).

Not too bad for a hobby 🙂

Easter Trading Bill

Change comes slowly sometimes. Earlier this year Parliament voted 73-41 to send a bill to select committee which will allow Tauranga and Wanak to open on Good Friday and Easter Sunday.

Today MPs vote on another bill which would allow any city or district council to decide if local shops could open on Easter Sunday.

Both are steps in the right direction, but this is what the law should be:

SHOP TRADING HOURS ACT 2006

1. Short Ttile

The Act shall be known as the Shop Trading Hours Act

2. Shop Trading Hours

There shall be no restriction on any shop, anywhere in the country, from opening on any day, for any hours it so wishes.

So long as elsewhere you have a provision that employees in non essential industries can not be forced to work on public holidays, then that is all that is needed. The state has absolutely no role in preventing customers, employees and employers from earning and spending money on certain days, if they wish to.

Tuhoe custom?

Tame Iti claims he was allowed to fire a gun without a permit, as doing so was in accordance with Tuhoe custom.

I could have sworn that there were no guns in NZ, until Pakeha brought them in. So stuff introduced in the 1800s now counts as customary usage???

How long until the Internet is claimed as a taonga!

Telecom to split voluntarily?

Good to see Telecom is talking to British Telecom and taking the idea of a voluntary wholesale/retail split seriously. That would be a good outcome – for Telecom as much as the country.

One of the benefits of a split, is that much of the regulation would then be unnecessary as the wholesaler would be treating all retailers equally. Vertically integrated monopolies are inevitably regulated. Without the vertical integration then the only regulatory role you should need is a very light handed eye on pricing.

A question?

Having abolished an air force strike wing, what would be the reaction of the Government if it learnt a plane had taken off from Wellington and in 60 to 90 minutes was going to hit the Sky Tower?

(a) Ask everyone in the CBD to move away from the Sky Tower
(b) Ask Bush to test out the US Star Wars defence system by taking out the plane
(c) Hope Johnnie Howard can get a plane over here in time
(d) Send the Minister for Auckland Issues into the Sky Tower and declare her a cultural icon, so that the pilot will change his mind.

I mean who needs a combat wing for an air force, because our PM has declared we live in a benign strategic environment. A benign strategic environment ignores:

(a) terrorist plot uncovered in Australia
(b) flatmate of terrorist pilot found doing pilot training in NZ
(c) Riots in Solomons
(d) Civil War in East Timor
(e) threatened coup (again) in Fiji

In fact I wonder if anything could convince the Prime Minister to say that we no longer live in a benign strategic environment?

Govt defeat now likely on micro-chipping

Thanks to some clever procedural manouevres, it looks like micro-chipping of all dogs will not pass.

The only two parties in favour of micro-chipping all dogs are Labour and their poodles in NZ First. 57 votes. And presumably Anderton makes 58 votes (if Anderton voted against his stocks as Agriculture Minister would rise).

National, ACT and the Maori Party are against micro-chipping and will vote against any micro-chipping, or vote for some micro-chipping so long as rural dogs are exempt.

The problem had been Greens and United Future. Greens would only vote against all micro-chipping, while United said it would not vote for an amendment to remove all micro-chipping and would only vote for an exemption for farm dogs.

Hence it looked like Labour may win, despite minority support only.

But on the Local Government Committee, a majority voted for an amendment to change the bill so only dogs deemed dangerous need to be micro-chipped. The Committee has four National MPs, four Labour MPs and one Green MPs so it would have been a 5-4 vote.

Now the House, during committee of the whole stage, can try and reverse the amendments but the way the House procedures work, has meant United Future will probably not vote to over-turn the select committee changes.

You see the House does not get to vote on the changes made by the select committee one by one. If they did then they might get United Future to vote against the change. But the changes made by select committee become part of the bill automatically and the Government will need to move an amendment at committee of the whole stage.

And this is the problem for United Future. It is one thing to vote against an amendment (on the grounds the amendment is not exactly what you want), but quite another to vote in favour of an amendment to increase the scope of the law from dangerous dogs to all dogs, because their policy is not to include all dogs.

The Government now has a decision to make. Eiether leave the bill unchanged so it applies to dangerous or meancing dogs only, or to agree to exempt “working dogs” so United Future will vote for such changes at the committee of the House stage. Either option is loss for Labour.

I’m confused

Is this a bauble?

Does getting to attend the Asia Pacific Women MPs Conference count as a bauble?

In his speech Winston decries that “women remain severely under-represented in parliaments and decision-making bodies across the Pacific region”.

So how do NZ parties line up as % female? The NZ Parliament as a whole is 32% female or 39/121.

Green 67%
ACT 50%
Labour 38%
United 33%
National 25%
Maori 25%
NZ First 14%
Progressive 0%

I knew they couldn’t keep Keith quiet for-ever

As reliable as ever, the only thing surprising about Keith Locke’s statement on the deported Yemeni, is that it took him two days to escape from his minders.

Keith has said (and to be fair, this is very restrained for him):

“I’d be a bit annoyed if just based on circumstantial evidence he was kicked out.

Everyone deserves that their case be considered on the facts, not on an unhappy meeting of coincidences or circumstances.”

For one to accept Ali is just a victim of coincidence, you have to accept:

1) It was a coincidence he flatted with the terrorist who flew a plane into the Pentagon.

2) Despite living together, he had no idea at all, of what his flatmate was planning.

3) That while he was known for giving extremists statements at his old mosque, he didn’t really mean it.

4) That his change of behaviour from extremist Muslim to not even attending a local Mosque was a genuine change of heart, and not just a ploy which just happened to match the Al Qaeda training manual.

5) That his decision to want to be a commercial pilot, is genuine, despite the fact that with his background he would be unemployable in most countries.

Ali is not a New Zealander, he is not a refugee or asylum seeker. We owe no duty to him, and I 100% back David Cunliffe’s decision to deport him without appeal. This is not a case of proof to put someone in jail, this is a case of the circumstances are too suspicious to risk keeping him here.

Now some people may say, but what if really does want to be a pilot, and what if he really was just an innocent flatmate of the guy who flew into the Pentagon?

My response is, well life is tough sometimes. The reality is that from the moment his flatmate flew into the Pentagon, being a pilot was no longer a career choice for him. Let me give an analogy.

Say you flat with that nice psychiatrist Dr Hannibel Lecter. You get on well, enjoy many a meal together. You have no idea he was a psychopathic cannibal and the dinner parties you both held, included human body parts.

Now after Dr Lecter gets arrested, then your plans of becoming a restaurant chef are no longer viable. It’s tough because you had no idea what your flatmate was doing, but no-one will want to eat in a restaurant where Dr Lecter’s flatmate is the cook, just as no-one would want to be on a plane where the pilot used to live with someone who flew a 747 into the Pentagon.

Rugby Bikini on Trade Me

Dancing Over

Well Rodney made the final four, but dropped out just in time for the House resuming this week. He has blogged on how much he enjoyed doing the show.

It’s obvious how well Krystal and Rodney got on. He was so obviously devastated when he dropped her last night, and she was all sort of mothering him and saying not to worry.

I think the Judges decided to make sure Rodney went this week, giving out several 10s to others, and all 1s for his second dance. But I think that was just as well, as if Rodney had stayed in he may have got a backlash for knocking out one of the three other couples.

This has convinced me of one thing – never to enter a reality TV show like Dancing with the Stars. I would not be able to do it with so many people watching.

I could handle a Big Brother type show, because you just get to be yourself and have lots of fun. Survivor would be far too much of a starvation regime. The show which really would be cool though is The Amazing Race. That would be so cool travelling from country to country solving the clues. I would be very good at that.

Spoof of Speights Ad

$18 an hour?

The NZ Herald’s frontpage (story not online) declares junior doctors are getting $18 an hour for a 65-hour week.

Now I can’t see how this adds up. The junior doctor quoted an annual salary of $105,000 a year. At $18 an hour this would equate to 5,833 hours which is 112 hours a week. Not 65. Now sure you can work a 112 hour week (I have) but not over a whole year.

Specific examples are given of working a 65 hour week and a 175 hour fortnight. A 65 hour week is a pay rate of $30.98 an hour and a 175 hour fortnight is $21.37 an hour.

So I can’t see how they get their headline of “$18 an hour for 65-hour week”. That would be a salary of $61,007 not $105,000.

I should note that I actually support the young doctors in their cause. No-one should be working 175 hour fortnights in a hospital, and even a pay rate of $31 an hour is pretty lame for their training.

But if you are going to assert a calculation in a headline, it should be real.

Citizenship

I am delighted to see the DIA suggest it is timely to promote the uptake of citizenship by migrants, and develop awareness of citizenship in the community.

I believe citizenship is important, and that having the right incentives for migrants to become citizens can contribute greatly to more harmonious society – especially if as part of becoming a citizen, the core values of New Zealand can be communicated. And yes I do mean especially the separation of state and religion, commitment to free speech etc.

Australia does this very well, and you see TV ads encouraging residents who are not citizens to “become an Australian today”. Now I don’t quite go that far but we should be doing something.

But one at the end of the day needs incentives also, and NZ is one of the few countries where there is almost no difference in law between a permanent resident and a citizen. You need to be a citizen to be an MP, but not to vote.

Over time (ie grandfather in existing permanent residents) I would like to see voting restricted to citizens. Not as a punishment for residents, but as an incentive to become a citizen, become a New Zealander and make a commitment to NZ.

Feedback is welcome on this issue. Do people think we should promote citizenship more? What time limit should there be before someone can become a citizen? What rights should citizens have, beyond other residents? Should residents wanting to become citizens undergo some sort of test or course about New Zealand?

Whangamata marina

The e-mails from former Labour Party President Bob Harvey show beyond any doubt that Chris Carter had made up his mind at an early stage to deny the application, and then sought supporters to justify it.

This creates two problems for the Minister. The first is that there must be a very real risk of the High Court ruling he did not follow correct process in declining the marina proposal.

The other is that he may have lied to the House, and is now the subject of a complaint to the Privileges Committee.

Now this is an unacceptable outcome to Labour, so Bob Harvey will know he has to take the fall for the Minister, and claims his own e-mail was false. Now how do you do that?

I predict Harvey will use the following claims:

1) The Minister never told me what he would do, I just gained an impression that he might go against

2) I in fact made the offer to the Minister to get people to come out opposing it, and it was a hypothetical “Would it be useful to have more voices in the debate”

3) I am passionate about this issue and in my passion I attributed desires to the Minister which were in fact my own.

Crown Law (representing the Minister) have insisted on Harvey doing an affidavit explaining the context of the e-mails. I will be most surprised if it is not similar to the above, because if he came out and said “Yes that is right the Minister told me his decision, asked me to line up supporters for my declining the application” then there would be a new Minister of Conservation and maybe even a new MP for Te Atatu.

Auckland Power Cut

I generally don’t have a problem with power cuts in Auckland. The last big one lasted two months and did wonders for Wellington as a place to live 🙂

However this morning I am not happy. My ISP Ihug is not recognising my broadband connection, presumably because of the problem. And then when I called them the lines were engaged (and it seems no-one can take the calls anyway as power cut has hit the call centre).

So I then tried my old 56K dialup with Ihug. It allowed me in, allowed me to clear my mail, and check out the Ihug MOTD. However I can’t access any website beyond the Ihug network!

So finally I succumbed and am now using my backup Xtra dialup account – which is working very nicely.

But as recently I have been e-mailing around 100 MBs a day of files (and yes all wok related) I really hope I can be back on broadband before long as 100 MB on 56Kb would take over four hours to send!!

Monday is normally the day I do my grocery shopping. Looking at weather outside I think I might survive off tinned food for another day, rather than go outside.

Final words of al-Zarqawi

Scott Adams has a hilarious thread speculating on what the final words of al-Zarqawi may have been. Included are:

Remember to watch my new reality show, “Jihad with the Stars!”

Two 500 pounders – is that all you got?

And to think: My dad wanted me to be an accountant!

“I dont have health insurance.”

D’oh

“wow, that’s strange…who would have thought there’d be so many flames and people with pitchforks in Heaven?”

I want a lawyer.

Just don’t let Tom Cruise play my character when they make the movie… Desert Storm II – The Revenge.”

The new National Front

I’ve always regarded the National Front as a not very funny joke, than a serious problem.

However reading about the former NF leader setting up a “secret survivalist militia” does make me wonder if they could become more than a nuisance one day.

The Police seemed very disinterested in them, yet on the face of it the group’s policy manual would provide a far better case for a sedition prosecution than a press release from Tim Selwyn. After all they call for:

* making change any way we can… If that includes militant action, then we will do what we have to do

* urges members to provide supplies, such as weapons and ammunition

* have lies prepared if caught in possession of firearms, and never disclose information on fellow members.

* Even if you do go to jail it would not be for too long.

* an urban survival plan recommending shelters are secured with snipers

Now don’t get me wrong – I’m not saying the Police should do anything because 90% likely they are just a bunch of very stupid racist idiots who couldn’t organise a piss-up in a brewery and writing survival manuals acts as a substitute for having sex.

But they are worth keeping an eye on.

PTEs

As I blogged last week, the Government has made a change to student loan eligibility which will destory many private training establishments.

Deborah Coddington in the HOS details the stupidity of this policy change. Basically it is a kneejerk response to the interest free student loans bribe.

This policy change is going to remove choice from many students. Coddington sums it up with:

The Government, it seems, is more intent on obliterating the private sector and protecting incompetent polytechnics from competition. In less than a decade taxpayers have bailed out various polytechnics to the tune of $120m. If they were privately owned, they’d be floating around like deceased goldfish.

Gnome Homes

Citizen Journalism

This is an old article, but recently noticed by the online editor for the NZ Herald.

One idea put into place by the Washington Post is to place Technorati links to blogs on its articles. This is a great idea – you can read the article, and then see any discussion or coverage on blogs of it. The Herald article yesterday on the deportation has been linked to by blogs around the world, and would be nice to be able to follow that directly.

Another option is to allow comments directly on the newspaper website, as some uK papers now do.

Merge and Purge

The Dom Post yesterday called for a “merge and purge” of local body councillors.

The Wellington Region includes nine local authorities – four citiy councils, four district councils and a regional council. This gives us over 100 local body politicians for a population of 300,000.

I would have just four Councils. A Regional Council, a Wellington Council which includes the Hutt and Porirua, a combined Wairarapa district council and the Kapiti Council.

Advice for the Greens