Smoking Ban

The Maori Party is drafting legislation to ban smoking and make it illegal to produce or sell tobacco.

Now there are two main arguments against trying to ban smoking. The first is practical – it simply will not work as too many people are already addicted and a huge black market would merely be created.

The second is philosophical that people should be free to kill themselves if they choose to do so. Taking that stance to extremes you would also have to consider not criminalising ‘P’, heroin etc.

However it is worth considering the issue purely from the health and safety perspective. Let’s assume that somehow tobacco/cigarettes has not yet been invented and a company suddenly invents it. Now it would have to submit it to medical safety authorities in various countries such as the Food and Drug Administration (FDA) in the US. And could anyone imagine it would be approved? I mean it would be like asking for permission to sell flavoured arsenic in school cafeterias. “Hello FDA, we want to sell this product that will horribly kill over quarter of the people who use it, knock years or decades off their life and massively increase their costs of health-care.”

Now I am playing devil’s advocate here somewhat and not actually advocating that smoking should be banned. But that it is worth reflecting such a lethal product would probably fail to be accepted as a safe product for sale if it were not already in such widespread use.

Odds and Ends

Iain Dale blogs on the poll showing 40% of Muslims in the UK want sharia law there. I really can not work out why people move to secular countries and want to turn them into countries governed by religious law. Why not stay in one of the 50 countries that do have sharia law!

David (son of Milton) Friedman muses on whether one has rational bigotry.

Maia blogs her list of the ten worst New Zealanders. I thought of doing this myself but I don’t know enough ‘bad’ people from our past. Oh and goes without saying I disagree with almost all of Maia’s picks!

Down in hell Satan reports that they now have ice skating because Trevor Loudon has blogged he agrees with Keith Locke. And Keith is holding up an “Obey the UN” placard! 🙂

Rodney highlights how Winston has moved his electorate office to Auckland. Has he moved house also?

Frit also has a disturbing newspaper headline in the UK.

Bloody Mary to air 9 pm Wednesday

TV3 has very sensible decided to cut the controversy short and will now be showing the Bloody Mary episode of Southpark on C4 at 9 pm on Wednesday instead of in April.

Thanks to the protests it will of course have record viewers.

Incidentially I agree with Trevor Loudon that groups not wanting the episode on air have behaved entirely correctly and have every right to lobby on the issue. Just as I have every right to lobby TV3 the other way and say I’d never watch them again if they backed down.

It’s a pity that the punch line from the Pope is so well known now because it was very funny watching it when he first said it.

More PM spin

Internet Research by Jurors

I’m on National Radio’s Checkpoint just after 6 pm talking about the case of the Jury which conducted its own research on the Internet of what the legal defintions of burden of proof and beyond reasonable doubt are.

My main comments are that this is as much a case about stupidity as the Internet, but we will also chat about the implications of the Internet in other areas such as criminal backgrounds of defendents and supression orders.

Radio NZ has an audio file of the interview here. Was a fun discussion.

Why Global Warming is Good

David Irving

No Right Turn had a good post yesterday on David Irving which shows what a nasty man he is. His statements have not just been holocaust denial but “poisonous, anti-semitic lies”.

Today he has been sentenced to three years jail. And as much as I detest Irving I am uncomfortable with people going to jail simply for their views.

In principle I oppose laws criminalising holocaust denial. The way to beat them is toi expose and ridicule them. But to be fair to Austria I can understand why in that country especially, the birthplace of Hitler, they felt a need to have such laws. Sometimes it is a bit too easy to criticise from afar. NZ didn’t suffer in the way Austria did from the Nazis.

But even if such laws were justified in the immediate decades after Hitler, it is time to get rid of them. Jailing Irving for statements he made in 1989 just makes him a martyr.

Slippery Slope

I know the PM can’t resist having an opinion on everything but I think she will find she is on a slippery slope when she starts giving her views on individual programmes such as South Park. I mean does she really now want gallery journalists ringing her up every week after a new episode comes out asking if she finds this one offensive also?

“So Prime Minister did you find the episode where Cartman gets Scott Tenorman to accidentally eat his parents more acceptable than the Bloody Mary episode?”

The NZ Herald has also shown online a variety of letters on the episode. Some good quotes include:

“As an atheist, I am offended by television broadcasts that implore me to find religion and, in doing so, give up my own beliefs and 10 per cent of my gross income. But I don’t organise a boycott – I just change the channel. ”

“I respect the right of anyone to follow the religion of their choice, but they do not have the right to try to shape my life according to their religious beliefs. Their tactics are those of a bully. ”

“Let’s be blunt. We cannot be tolerant of intolerance. All intolerant irreligious and political beliefs should be lampooned into oblivion. Their advocates should also be left in no doubt that any resort to force will be met with uncompromising and overwhelming counter-force. “

And amongst the arguments in favour of censorship we have:

A civilised society is not one where one part of society broadcasts denigration of the core beliefs of another simply because it can or “is funny”.

Umm actually that is indeed the hallmark of a civilised tolerant society.

Freedom of speech is a duty and not a right. Race Relations Commissioner Joris de Bres and the Broadcasting Standards Authority should have the final say in this matter.

Oh yes I want Joris to decide what I am allowed to watch on TV. Not.

As a Catholic I am appalled that Canwest chief executive Rick Friesen plans to run this South Park episode which I understand portrays Mary, the Mother of Jesus Christ, menstruating.

Incorrect. It shows a statue of Mary menstruating. Important difference!

PM spins on refund

Almost amused that once again when questioned on the taxpayer funded pledge cards, Helen refers to the Exclusive Brethren pamphlets also being under investigation.

What she fails to mention is that the complaint about how they should be part of National’s return has already been considered and dismissed as having no merit.

There is still an outstanding matter relating to improper authorisation on one of the pamphlets but that is of course a matter purely for the Brethren and relatively minor compared to the $418,000 over-spend.

Bye bye to 5c

On 31 July the 50c, 20c and 10c coins all shrink to a smaller size and on 1 November the 5c coin disappears as legal tender.

When I was in North America I ended up accumulating a large number of 1c and 2c coins which are basically worthless so personally getting rid of smaller coin values works for me.

I feel a bit sorry for the companies which operate coin-operated machines as I imagine they will have to spend millions reconfiguring their machines.

DPF – Defender of Southpark

I’m on NewstalkZB some time between 6 am and 9 am tomorrow defending TV3 for going ahead with plans to show the Virgin Mary episode of Southpark on C4.

Not sure how much of the interview they will use (and I was highly amused to be interviewed in my capacity as a Southpark fan) but my major points were yes it is offensive to some, but so is every episode and people shouldn’t watch it if they don’t like it rather than try to stop people like me who do enjoy it from being able to watch it.

I also pointed out they have managed to ensure this will be the highest rating episode ever!

I was on more shaky ground as I had to give examples of equally offensive previous episodes. Some of them I just didn’t want to describe on air 🙂

The Importance of Disclosure

In today’s Dominion Post a column was published by Rob McLeod in his role as Chairman of the NZ Business Roundtable. It argued against any further regulation of Telecom. And I have no doubt this is the honest opinion of the Business Roundtable who show an admirable consistency on these issues.

How-ever it was a major error for there to have been no disclosure that Mr McLeod is also a Director of Telecom. This information is of vital importance as directors are legally obliged to act in the bests interests of companies they are directors of.

Now I am a huge fan of the contribution Rob McLeod makes to New Zealand. I am not suggesting he personally has acted improperly. He may not have realised the column would not mention his Telecom directorship (as it may have been submitted by staff) and likewise there is a responsibility on the Dominion Post itself to make sure full disclosure is supplied.

But there can be no doubt that the public have a right to know that an opinion piece arguing against further regulation of Telecom was written by a Director of Telecom. Public debate is not well served by such omissions, even when accidental as I am sure this one was.

Beheading Rewards get higher

An Iman has already offered $1 million for the murder of any of the Danish cartoonists. This has been beaten by an Indian state Minister who has offered a six million pound reward for anyone who beheads a cartoonist.

Now remind me again that this isn’t a debate about free speech.

I have to say for NZ$20 million I’d be half tempted to claim the reward if I met a cartoonist in a dark alley with no witnesses.

Another contender

Another contender has declared for the role of male co-leader of the Greens. According to Peter Metcalph it is Mike Ward.

This means the list of contenders to date is:

The Rasta (Nandor Tanczos)
The former commie (Russel Norman)
The defeated MP (Mike Ward)

Other possible contenders are Joel Cayford and Roland Sapsford.

Nominations will close on 28 April. Kiwiblog will continue to monitor this leadership battle.

Pay It Back Now

Old News

The latest stuff on David Benson-Pope is not new, despite being featured in Investigate Magazine. The accounts of him forcing kids to stand outside in the cold were all in the Police reports and I recall them getting some minor media coverage at the time of the reports release.

Normally I’d say time to leave the issue alone, but considering how appalling Benson-Pope has behaved in trying to smear the kids who complained, he isn’t exactly a poster boy for clemency.

But nevertheless I believe it is of marginal news value. I think enough material has been published for people to form their own views on his character, and this as I said was known last year.

UPDATE: More details at The Briefing Room. An interesting twist is that DBP is trying to stop his submissions to Police from being released under the OIA and that the grounds cited are because he is a Minister. That should be more reason to release them.

UPDATE2: Peter M compares making kids stand outside in the cold for an hour with almost no clothes on to a CIA interrogation method which has been condemned as too cruel to use against terrorists!

Jo Gaul – hero!

I have a new hero – Jo Gaul.

She got conned as part of a kitchenware scam where you pay more than $3000 for top German kitchenware and end up with cheap Chinese ones. Now of course the Police were too busy to like investigate fraud but that didn’t stop Jo.

She arranged to meet the con-man again and being a good horsewoman she made up some lassos. She then phoned back the Police to say she was going to catch the fraudsters and said

“I am going to try to get support from some Kiwi guys at the bar to cover the front and back door and if they make a run for it, we’ll tie them down”

The Police of course told her she is not allowed to do this. Now she was keen to go ahead saying “I would have used my handcuffs. I don’t find restraint intimidating. I’ve roped sheep and cattle before. They were characterless, sleazy men and that type are usually quite gutless.” but instead just took photos of the men and their car and handed the case over to the Police for prosecution.

What a great example of Kiwi can-do spirit and refusing to let either con-men or an apathetic police response stop her from getting her money back and bringing the crooks to justice.

Major security breach

The University of Canterbury appear to have had the mother of all security breaches with all students being able to access any other students details, and even edit them!

This is not a minor problem, but almost the worst case scenario. Having 10,000 people able to access every account. This is like a bank giving all customers access to every account held at the bank. More than an apology is needed here.

A couple of people have got excited over whether The Press reporter broke the law by checking for him or herself that you could access other student’s accounts. I don’t think they did anything wrong because they were using a legitimate username and password. Anyone who changed someone else’s details though could be facing some legal problems.

No no the visual images no no

Please please could the NZ Herald not start stories with statements like:

Helen Clark will get the chance to grill former United States President Bill Clinton in public this week

It gets worse as we read “Helen Clark was a great admirer of President Clinton”

Now this is what the Catholics should try to get banned not Southpark! 🙂

Support TV3

TV3 are showing wonderful common sense over the Southpark controversy saying:

“If Catholics feared they might be offended by the ‘Bloody Mary’ episode of the South Park show, they should switch it off.”

Hear hear. How dare they try to force their views on all the non Catholics who want to watch it. Mind you it was very amusing seeing Lyndsay Freer on behalf of the Church describing the episode on the TV News. She gave an excellent description which will help boost ratings massively.

Anyway not sure if the opposite of a boycott is a girlcott but to show my support for TV3 refusing to bow to censorship of its C4 channel I am going to watch TV3 News instead of TV One News for at least the next month. I urge others to also support TV3 for their stand.

I also bet you that probably a record number of Catholics will now watch the programme, intrigued by what the fuss is about. And many will laugh. It’s hard not to.

I’m also surprised they never objected to the episode that shows Jesus as a submachine toting fighter!

Dom Post has a story also.

An offensive judgement

Over the years a few Judges have come out with judgements which look they belong to the 18th century not the 19th or 20th. Normally they have been UK or Australian Judges.

But the Italian Supreme Court has joined their ranks.

I almost can’t believe this is a real story but they have ruled that the sentence for a man who forced his 14 year old step-daughter into oral sex should be reduced because the girl was not a virgin!!!!

I’m speechless.

Hat Tip: Captain Ed

Windows Vista

Listener takeover by NBR almost complete

I’ve always had a soft spot for both NBR and the Listener. Because both undoubtedly stood for values on the right and the left. I just look at the subject of any story in the Listener and know what tack it would take on the issue. Likewise for NBR.

I prefer media which are upfront about where they come from rather than the New York Times of the world which laughably claim to be neutral and impartial.

How-ever Scoop points out that step by step the Listener is being taken over by current or former NBR staff. Some former editos must be rolling in their graves.

Scoop notes that Gordon Campbell has been made redundant and current writers are:

Deborah Hill Cone on media
Nick Smith is a staff writer
David Young is the business columnist
Graeme Hunt is a regular contributor

At this rate I am going to have to subscribe again!

Political Novels

Iain Dale has blogged his top ten political novels. Being a Brit, they obviously have a UK bias but they have some of the best political fiction. I still regard First amongst Equals by Jeffery Archer as stunning.

I’ve read five out of the ten books listed.

House of Cards needs no explanation. The best of the trilogy. Mde immortal by the TV series.

Winston’s War by the same author. I now buy all of Dodds books he is so good and as previously blogged especially like historical fiction. Compulsory for Winstonphiles.

51st state is about the UK becoming of course the 51st state of the US. Not my favourite but okay.

Black Book is a hilarious take of the Chief Whip’s black book of all the MPs misdeeds.

And Edwina Currie writes what I took to be at the time an excellent story of a young female MP having an affair with a senior MP. It later emerged it was basically here and John Major!

False Allegations

Six men were arrested when a woman alleged they gang raped her. Now there was no dispute sex happened, and who would believe she had consented to sex with multiple partners she had not met before.

Luckily for the men though it was all captured on videotape, and it showed that not only was it consensual, but the woman was directing the action.

If the tape did not exist, I wonder if any jury would have refused to convict the six men.

Hat Tip: Dr Helen

Incidentially found in the comments is a post by Eugene Volokh on why false rape complaints can be a relatively large proportion of all complaints but that one still has a very very low (2%) percentage of women who would ever make a false allegation. Basically the maths is that very few women make false complaints but also relatively ‘few’ women get raped. Check out his maths.

UPDATE: Of course should also link to Dom Post story of the Kiwi serving 20 years in Cambodia on what now appears to be false allegations.