Waitangi Day

Well how nice it was to have basically a peaceful and protest free Waitangi Day.

For pretty much all my lifetime we have been the only country whose national day is not one of celebration of all the great things about a country but focused on recriminations and the like.

For that reason in recent years I had favoured that we set up a seperate New Zealand Day (say on 7 September – Dominion Day) to serve as a truly national holiday and Waitangi Day would remain as a day focused on the Treaty, but not our national day.

However this year has given me hope that Waitangi Day can be more than just a day of protests and indeed serve as our national day.

Legal Fees

Rather amused that some lawyers are upset by a trans-tasman study showing that the number of hours some law firms require their lawyers to charge weekly leads to padding some work.

An annual target of 1590 chargeable hours is an average of more than seven hours a day based on 223 working days.

Somewhat reminds me of the old joke about the lawyer who arrives in heaven to get feted with a special welcome. He asks why and is told because he is the oldest ever arrival having reached 185 years of age. The lawyer looks confused and then exclaims “Oh no, I’m not 185 – you must have gone off my chargeable hours” 🙂

Oh dear oh dear oh dear

I have almost had to restrain my laughter as over the last few days I read of the complicated love/hate trianages/quadrangles of four bloggers.

Start here with this posting on the Whig.

Then read over at Kelly’s for more bad encounters.

Then head to Clint’s and read the comments there. Also make sure you have been reading the previous comments also.

Then finally go to Pink Panda who lays into Whiggie and Whiggie responds.

1st thought: Why does PP thinks that Whig scoring a woman in a wheelchair is somehow bad.

2nd thought: After reading all this, maybe Destiny were right after all 🙂

UPDATE: And now Annika posts a previously deleted comment. War on all fronts!

UPDATE2: And the Whig posts what is hopefully the final chapter in the saga.

Former MPs

Scoop has done a story on what all the MPs who were forcibly retired are doing now.

The summary is:

Matt Robson – helping Ahemd Zaoui
John Tamihere – Waipareira Trust utu
Lesley Soper – home renovations
Jim Peters – Northland Regional Councillor
Brent Catchpole – Consultant (generally this is code for unemployed amongst ex MPs)
Dail Jones – Kumeu Law Centre
Craig McNair – losing virginity
Bill Gudgeon – babysitting grandkids
Mike Ward – Arty stuff
Gerry Eckoff – farming
Muriel Newman – Book on welfare reform!
Ken Shirley – Golf and surfing (sensible man)
Stephen Franks – Lawyer
Marc Alexander – Vigilante Gang
Larry Baldock – protecting daughters and learning Maori
Dr Bernie Oglivy – PhD Study
Murray Smith – Lawyer

TV3 Poll

TV3 poll last night showed Labour with a comfortable lead of 6% over National.

I’m not surprised as the Government has been away from parliamentary scrutiny for six weeks, and all the leadership speculation for National *always* drives a party down in the polls.

Parliament resumes Tuesday week on the 14th. Will be interesting to see what the key themes are.

I didn’t see the full results but am told NZ First were below 5% and Greens at 7%.

The Sevens

Had a fun time at the Sevens. Caught up with several groups I knew before settling into my proper seat next to the Jamaican Netballers.

New Zealand had a great quarter-final victory but lost the semi-final to Fiji. They had a slow start with Fiji going two tries up but then played magnificently to take the lead. Then at the beginning of the second half the referee sent a NZ player off and the game was basically lost at that point. Losing a player is far harder to compensate for in Sevens than 15 a side.

Quite amusing that the crowd took the sending off quite personally and for the rest of the match the enemy wasn’t Fiji but the referee. I almost felt sorry for the ref having 35,000 people chant non-stop for six minutes “The referee is a wanker, the referee is a wanker” 🙂

Lots of great costumes around, with a few photos below. Heh highlight was having a stunning blond in a revealing leather police uniform ask if I minded if she sat on the seat next to me for a while. Yeah sure I was going to mind 🙂

sevens1.JPG

Very impressive work by the SWAT Team.

sevens2.JPG

Pump must have sold tens of thousands of bottles and also had a rugby ball throwing competition.

sevens3.JPG

Speaks for itself!

sevens4.JPG

Hopefully this photo doesn’t lead to any trade boycotts!

Electoral Bribery

A hui has heard a proposal to ban Maori not registered on the Maori electoral roll from accessing money from tribal lands and settlements.

This would be tribal bribery if it was implemented. Iwi members have a hereditary right to the proceeds of settlements and banning people who choose not to go on the Maori roll is just as undemocratic as banning people who don’t vote for a preferred party.

Bouquets and Brickbats

With the ongoing Muhammad Cartoons saga some further bouquets and brickbats.

The bouquet is to the organisers and participants in the 800 strong Queen Street protest, protesting over the publications. It was peaceful, non-threatening and targetted at the media who made the decision – not the country. If people are upset and offended by a cartoon they should let it be known that they are offended. The issue overseas has been that the entire country of Denmark has been held to ransom, which changed the debate from a debate about a series of cartoons to one of media freedoms.

This is beyond the grasp of our Prime Minister who gets a brickbat for saying the publication is not a matter concerning liberty. Well if this is not a matter concerning press freedom and liberty I can’t think of any issue in the last 40 years which has been.

A brickbat to our Foreign Minister, Rt Hon Winston Peters, for saying the Dom Post has insulted the entire Arab world. Can someone at MFAT tell him the difference between Arabs and Muslims and point out there are Christian Arabs etc.

Back to bouquets a big one to the Pakistan Association general secretary Impaz Khan who is writing to 52 Muslim countries urging them not to boycott NZ products.

Thanks to Mr Khan and others I’m dropping my plans to publish a new cartoon every-time an Embassy is burnt down out of respect for the Muslim community in New Zealand who have put up with enough crap due to overseas extremists.

UPDATE: The Press has an excellent editorial on the issue.

Dancing Rodney

Now this would be great fun – Rodney Hide on Dancing with the Stars.

As much as I’d personally like to see Rodney show off his dancing skills, I would remind him of what happened to the last MP who took part in a reality TV show – George Galloway!

A SST editorial I agree with

Maori Party

Matt McCarten writes on how the Maori Party may hold the balance of power after the next election, predicting they will win all seven Maori seats.

It is highly likely there will be more than seven Maori seats next election. It could be ten or greater depending on how many Maori swap to the Maori roll.

And the overhang gerrymander gives a great incentive to go onto the Maori roll. The Maori Party could well end up with winning seats on the basis of half as many party votes as other parties need. Proportionality will be broken and there could well be moves made to change the law, but time will tell.

Treaty Claims Deadline

National has indicated it will change its policy of requiring all treaty claims to be settled by 2010. Party this is inevitable – you are not in Government so there is no way you can keep that as a policy when you might not be in Government until 2009.

But the original deadline was too tough anyway in my opinion. I don’t think all claims could have been settled in five years even with the greater level of resources that National wanted to give to negotiators and the Waitangi Tribunal.

Part of the battle has been won. Labour has said all claims must be lodged by 2008. 25 years since historical claims could be lodged this is definitely long enough.

If all claims must be in by 2008, when could we expect to see them settled by? If a Government gave priority and resources I think around 2014 is possible.

It will be interesting to see how much progress Labour makes over the next three years.

The Day the Music Died

Friday was the 47ths anniversary of The Day the Music Died.

American Pie is one of my all-time favourite songs (yes only the Dom McLean version not the awful Madonna version) and it used to play almost non-stop on the Otago University Union jukebox.

I never actually knew what the song referred to until a law firm a few years ago took a group of us to the stage production of the Buddy Holly story. Was a great production and has made the sing that much more meaningful.

It is also a very long song. Just over eight minutes long, so a good Karaoke number!

More on Muhammad Cartoons

I had a record number of visits on Friday, which is unusual as normally the slowest weekday for me. Looking at search terms though I noticed a lot were coming through on “Muhammad Cartoons” and checked on Google and I am the seventh highest site listed on that term. Explains a lot.

I note our beloved Government has stood up for freedom of the press. Ha if only. Nope Chris Carter has said the Dominion Post’s decision undermines New Zealand’s reputation as a tolerant country. Sorry Chris but the publications shows we are tolerant. Just as having C4 show the Southpark Bloody Mary episode will show we are tolerant. I am waiting to hear you demand that is not shown.

Some Muslims in the UK has called for a repeat of the 7/7 bombings in response to the cartoons. Hell considering how inoffensive the cartoons are, think if something really insulting had been published – they’d be calling for Iran to nuke the entire country or something.

Picture6_0.jpg

Also to highlight the hypocrisy involved in many of these protests, some of the cartoons published in Muslim countries have been collated at Whale Oil. The one above is pretty offensive (especially to Holocaust survivors) but they get published every day without any fuss.

Also useful to note in terms of hypocrisy is this story about a Turkish film which shows:

They kill dozens of innocent people with random machine gun fire, shoot the groom in the head, and drag those left alive to Abu Ghraib prison where a Jewish doctor cuts out their organs, which he sells to rich people in New York, London and Tel Aviv.

Yes a Jewish doctor cuts out the organs to make money selling to evil rich Jews around the world. How’s that for stereotypes. And yes Hollywood actors are playing leading roles!

In Syria the Danish and Norwegian embassies were set on fire. This is why it is crucial that every western country publishes the cartoons. One can’t let the bully boy tactics succeed by letting them focus on one target. Once every western country has published then trying to enforce trade bans will hurt them more than the countries involved.

Back home Tom Scott states the obvious saying “the Islamic community needed to get a sense of humour”. Scott talks of how in 1969 he was prosecuted for blasphemy and he planned to call God as a defence witness 🙂

In the same story the Federation of Islamic Associations of New Zealand president (and I must say again the generally the Islamic leadership in NZ is moderate, not extreme) that “Freedom of expression does not mean ‘absolute’ freedom, going as far as mocking other religions and their beliefs. Certainly, it would not mean to inflict emotional pain to anyone.”

Actually that is entirely what it means. No freedom of speech is not absolute but it certainly allows mocking religions and beliefs. I mean I don’t want to live in a country where I can’t mock the Church of Scientology no matter how much emotional pain it inflicts in Tom Cruise.

Oh and some good news to end this post on. C4 have confirmed they will show the Bloody Mary episode of Southpark. And Maria von Trapp shows the right attitude to them. She is a Christian and can’t wait to see them.

Dom Post on Min Wage

Friday’s editorial of the Dom Post endorsed calls for a $12 minimum wage. Their thinking and rationale is very sloppy.

They first claim that raising the minimum wage will somehow be a miracle cure to being a low wage low productivity country. Bzzt wrong. Increasing wages without any increase in output lowers productivity.

In a fit of economic illiteracy they compare the weekly minimum wage of $380 a week with the average household spend of $888 a week. This is like comparing apples and well not even organges but sausages. The average household has multiple children and multiple sources of income.

Saying “The CTU says that leaves a one-income minimum wage household $508 a week less than the average household to survive on.” is totally misleading and a nonsensical comparison.

The Dominion Post also ignores that very few workers stay on the minimum wage for long. They tend to be for “entry level” jobs. As people gain experience they get better jobs that pay more.

At a time when the economy is faltering and employers are laying staff off, well I can’t think of a worst time to raise the minimum wage.

Auckland Blogger BBQ

Well done Dom Post

The Dominion Post has published the infamous Danish cartoons. In explaining why they have done so, they cite both press freedom, and letting readers (well those not on the Internet) see what they are about.

The Dom Post notes that “In its pure form Islam is a religion based on peace and tolerance. This is a test of that tolerance.”

My hope for this is that the more radical elements of Islam will realise the counter-productive nature of their threats. If they had acted like any other religion and confined their protests to strong worded letters to the editor, then almost no-one would have seen the cartoons. By trying to threaten and intimidate the inoffensive Danes they have caused the cartoons to be seen by tens of millions of people. And every extra newspaper which publishes them, helps send that message and also helps protect just one country or newspaper from being targeted.

The NZ Herald has decided not to publish the cartoons, and that is of course their right.

Personally I find their reasoning to be illogical. They say it is fine to publish cartoons of Islam in the name of satire, but not to publish them just to prove you can. This misses the point that with no other religion do you have to worry about consequences of satirising them. Hell I even paused for a day before I decided to publish, having to weigh up the possible consequences of publishing them on my blog. In the end the fact that the NZ Muslim community is thankfully almost totally free of extreme elements is what convinced me to go ahead. Those in Australia and Europe are not so lucky.

Press freedom will have its victory when an editor doesn’t even have to pause and consider whether the threats are worth it. Press freedom will happen when an editor spends just as long deciding whether to publish a photo of “The Virgin in the Condom” as they do of these cartoons.

UPDATE: The editorial is also a must read. It deals with so much of the hypocrisy around this issue.

Ngapuhi wants money and the bag

Ngapuhi is refuse to settle its (legitimate) Treaty grievance for anything less than the full return of all lands, even those now privately owned.

That is their right of course but it means they’ll never get a settlement – they’ll just stay in permament grievance mode.

Sucessive governments have made it very clear that they will not confiscate privately owned land to settle Treaty claims, as this will merely replace one grievance with another.

The other issue is that no settlement will or can ever be for the full amount of land once owned. To ignore the huge increases in land value due to 150+ years of modern industry is also not justifiable.

I suspect Ngapuhi are simply saying “we want it all back” as a negotiating tactic to push the Crown into a more generous offer. However the Crown has to keep mind of relatitivies with other settlements so it is constrained also.

Yay going to Sevens

Excellent I have just acquired a ticket to the Sevens for today. Will be heading there this afternoon. Due to late acquisition I am not with a group, so if anyone I know is going to be there let me know approximately where you are and I’ll come visiting!

Fran gets it wrong

Fran O’Sullivan writes on how Don Brash needs strong women at his side.

However she weakens her own case by getting a key fact wrong. O’Sullivan says:

Of the 12 women in National’s caucus, only the feisty Judith Collins – resplendent in her yellow jacket – is on the front bench.

Rich still languishes one row back, ranked well behind male politicians who have yet to demonstrate her level of effectiveness.

However as this seating plan of the House shows, Katherine Rich is not only on the front bench but indeed seated next to Judith Collins.

What do NBR and the Greens agree on?

If one had to list all the issues that National Business Review and the Green Party agrees on, it would be a pretty short list. One item on it though would be the need for change in our telecommunications environment.

For those who don’t get the NBR print edition, they published a series of articles over five pages dealing with the “Telecom handbrake” on New Zealand. In what was effectively a front page editorial they called on the Government to take action. Less surprisingly the Greens have endorsed the call for action.

My economic and political views are pretty well known and I am not usually at all a fan of government intervention. I love leaving it to the market. But when there is an effective monopoly that is a different situation and I support local loop unbundling (as every other OECD country except Mexico does). In fact not local loop unbundling will be enough to get a level playing field and the vertical integration of Telecom also has to be looked at.

Now I have sometimes wondered whether it is just me being “soft” in this area because I am so involved with Internet issues. Well having seen both Gareth Morgan and Fran O’Sullivan in the last few weeks call for Government action on Telecom, I am reassured that I am at least in good company!

Also yesterday one had senior executives from Microsoft, Intel, Symantec and IBM all decry the broadband update in NZ and also call for Government action.

This adds up to what InternetNZ has called a cross-community chorus for change. The ball is firmly with the Government and Parliament.

Sevens Photos

Lee Tamahori arrested

Okay this is going to hit the news big time.

New Zealand filmmaker Lee Tamahori has been arrested when he sought sex with an undercover policeman, while clad in women’s clothes!

Our own Hugh Grant!

Reading other stories on this, it seems that Tamahori was the one offering to perform the sex act for money so he was not the potential client but moonlights as a prostitute.

Green figures

The Greens have asked for 50% of the Wellington transport funding for the northern access to go on a better train service.

They claim this will lead to 4,000 less cars a day on the road.

I’d love to see how they calculated that number (I suspect rolled a dice) as the local transport officials have predicted such a train upgrade will only lead to 100 less cars a day.

Oh wait I think I have worked it out. In a fit of intellectual firepower they have assumed that every single train would be full up, that these 4,000 motorists would just start using the trains if they were more frequent. Yeah Right

The reasons the Greens are wrong on almost every issue known to mankind is that they do not understand people and incentives. They fail to comprehend there are many reasons people want to have a car other than to get from work to home.

Cellphones on planes