Social Reporting

The concept of an annual social report for New Zealand is not a bad one. But what it measures is all important.

If as suggested it will measure family incomes against the median family income, then it will just be a useless politically motivated report advocating socialism, not a useful measure of low incomes or poverty.

I absolutely reject that if the low income families have a 20% increase in their real income, that this should be seen as making them “poorer” because other families had a 25% increase. This is all families getting richer which we should celebrate, not mourn.

The world is ending

The world is ending, the world is ending, and in only ten years.

Yep without a single opposing view, Chicken Little, sorry the NZ Herald, reports that in ten years time the world will be doomed having passed the point of no return with global warming.

There’s none of this only one or two metre increases in sea levels. This report says sea levels could rise by over ten metres. Shit all that sand for Oriental Bay no longer seems such a good idea. Anyway I’m on the 5th floor, so I’ll be okay!

How tiresome

I see that just like last year, Labour Ministers such as Steve Maharey are labelling Don Brash racist and an “educated idiot”. So much for debating the issues. of course that would have to wait until he delivers his speech tonight, but why let facts get in the way of name calling.

Full Disclosure

There has been quite a bit of focus in the US, including an article in the Wall Street Journal, on the fact two prominent bloggers were paid to be consultants for the Howard Dean Presidential Campaign, and that their disclosures were not as thorough as some deemed desirable.

Since I started blogging in July 2003 I have assumed that almost everyone knows my background and affiliations, but as the audience gets bigger this may not be as true as it once was. Therefore in the interest of full disclosure, I will link this statement from my front page as a permanent link.

Political Views

I self identify as a classical liberal, which the Institute for Liberal Values of New Zealand succinctly summarises as a belief in individual rights, limited government, private property, free markets, tolerance, and reason.

On the political compass test I score +10 (right) on economic issues and -6.15 (libertarian) on authoritarian/libertarian issues. One can seee NZ blogosphere charted here and NZ politicians here.

Political Affiliations

Since I joined Young Nationals in 1986, I have been affiliated to, and a member of, the National Party. I do not regard National as always right, but it is the party which I believe gives me the greatest opportunity to achieve the New Zealand I want.

As a volunteer, I established National’s initial Internet presence in 1996.

Employment

I worked in Parliament for eight years from July 1996 to March 2004. I initially worked as a media advisor to Ministerial Services when Jim Bolger was Prime Minister. I then had the rare privilege of working in the Prime Minister

Memberships

I am a member of the Internet Society of New Zealand, the Centre for Independent Studies, and the World Wildlife Fund.

Anniversary Weekend

A fairly quiet but nice three day weekend. No big events but a number of small things, plus quite a bit of work on campaign issues.

Saturday had a pleasant few hours at the Malt House with ginger boy and Miss Ten, discussing work and other issues over some beers in the sun. Sadly my lack of folical covering meant had to move inside. Malt House is one of my favourite drinking places in Wellington – very handy and good clientele.

Sunday had lunch with law girl, where we discussed everything from magna carta to whether a government could rule by order in council alone.

Sunday evening had a lovely bbq next to the botanical gardens in Kelburnat the flat of OIA girl and TC girl. Huge amount of food, a nice Te Kairanga wine and after dinner port was the backdrop to animated discussions including me previewing potential extracts from my book. General consensus that the book is likely to face a number of legal problems.

Monday had coffee with Miss Ten as we attempted to do a budget for her, as her bank was keen on the concept of her living on her money, not theirs. Discovered that a second year student allegedly needs over $31,000 a year in living expenses which unfortunately gave a five figure gap over her income. Her future husbands (a category which I am thankfully ineligible for, on basis of height) should take note.

After much negotiating we managed to reduce expenditure by $8,000 or so. My major sucesses were reducing coffee budget from $2,600 to $1,900, alcohol from $2,600 to $1,000 and hair from $1,000 to $500. I totally failed in reducing clothes budget of $1,200.

Over all the revised budget should mean that all money from the student loans scheme (which as it is interest free, you are stupid if you do not max it out) can go into sharemarket investments, allowing a nice return on capital when loan is repaid at end of degree.

We had dinner at Cuba Street Little India to celebrate. Most amusing moment is when passing youth decides to show his appreciation of Miss Ten by pressing his face up to the restaurant window and kissing and licking it. This was not a pleasant sight. I suppose he thought this would so impress that she would run outside and do him there and then. He must have been visiting from the Hutt.

ACT Polling

Richard Prebble in his first newsletter of the year did a bit of research and has listed ACT’s poll rating with Colma Brunton nine months before each election. The data (I have not checked but assume is right) is:

1996 1.6%
1999 3.9%
2002 2.7%
2005 2.8%

It will be very interesting to see what happens as we get close to September.

Good Disclaimer

Like most, I get sick of all those lawyer written disclaimers you get in e-mail – blah blah must return e-mail if received by mistake blah blah.

I much prefer the disclaimer I got in an e-mail today:

Notice: Unless you have exactly seven (7) letters in your middle name, you may read only the words in the above message that start with a vowel and/or contain the letter z. Failure to adhere to this notice will result in Microsoft Explorer 2.0 being installed on your system as your default browser and a fee of one dollar ($1) per word that you have read that is in violation of the above mentioned statement.

Brash’s Ratana Speech

Despite the fact that it is about as sceptical audience as one could find, Don Brash doesn’t resile from his views at Ratana. Good. And he will front at Waitangi also, unlike Clark.

I do doubt though that as Ratana debate whether to stay with their endorsement of Labour, or endorse the Maori Party, or neither, that they will take up his optimistic suggestion that they consider National 🙂

As it is a Wellington holiday, Don’s epeech isn’t online anywhere else yet, so I’ve included it below.
Continue reading »

26 bodyguards

Domain Name Disputes

2008 Republican Presidential Nominee

Right Wing News did a survey of right bloggers to see who their top five and bottom five picks were for the Republican nomination in 2008.

The top 5 were:

5) Newt Gingrich (19.0)
4) Bill Frist (20.0)
3) Jeb Bush (31.0)
2) Rudy Giuliani (39.0)
1) Condoleeza Rice (61.5)

and bottom five:

5) Dick Cheney (21.5)
4) Chuck Hagel (29.0)
3) George Pataki (29.5)
1) Newt Gingrich (39.5)
1) John McCain (39.5)

Now personally I doubt Condi would run. She has never sought elective office before. Rudy will probably run, but he will be bitterly oppossed by the religious right. Jeb Bush has ruled out 2008 so Bill Frist is a real possibility.

Student Loans

The SST also has an article on student loans.

It quotes a medical student with a $75,000 loan (which is four times the average – one never sees interviews with people with average balances) saying the student loan calculator has said she will take 50 years to pay off her loan, and there will be $300,000 interest.

This seemed high to me. So I went to the calculator and stuck in figures that 1st year income will be $50K and in 5 years would be $100K. This may be too much but as a starting point it said (assuming one was born in 1980) that the loan will be paid off in 15 years and interest will be $42,000.

An extra $20/week repayment, over the minimum would see the loan paid off in 12 years and interest shrink to $32,000.

I wondered how low the salary would have to be to get this 50 year repayment. A start salary of $40K and $80K in 5 years has 20 years repayment and $54,000 interest.

A start of $30K and $60K in 5 years has a 29 year repayment with $70,000 interest.

If one assumes a junior doctor earns $25,000 and in five years will only be on $50,000 (last DHB survey had average medical officer who is not a specialist on $100,000) then one gets a 36 year repayment and $80,000.

I can’t see how one gets a 40 year repayment with $300,000 interest as asserted in the SST.

Also the article repeats the assertion that one has to pay off the debt before one can have children. If you drop out of the workforce for a few years (for any reason) then your loan balance doesn’t increase one cent in real terms. It only rises in line with inflation, thus staying the same in real terms.

Personally I have sympathy for medical students who like Charlotte Oyston do have $75,000 loans. The costs of doing medicine do not align with their future income very well. If I was to change tertiary funding, medicine is one of the areas I would target. However the situation is not as grim as the article makes out, by a long long way.

Tertiary Education Costs

Amie Richardson in the SST reports that Kiwi students pay some of the highest university fees in the world with research from Buffalo University ranking New Zealand fourth in the world for fees at public tertiary institutions.

Rather annoyingly the article does not quote a particular publication or reference, so one can easily check the source data. Google News doesn’t show any other media reporting a study from Buffalo. Finally much searching finds a footnote in a UK AUT journal which has me discover the International Comparative Higher Education Finance and Accessibility Project.

As the SST article notes the figures are from 2001, and have presumably been public information for some years, so I am not sure how it qualifies as news.

The project does show US$2,500 for B.Ed, $2,400 for LLB and $2,100 for B.Com in NZ in 2001. It calculates direct study costs as being $3,200 for humanities, $3,800 for sciences.

Looking at the database I find Chile is much higher, Canada higher for moderate and high public unis, US higher for moderate and high, Hong Kong higher, Australia is higher, Japan is higher, Singapore has some higher.

Now this is not proof that the SST article is wrong, because I don’t know the basis for their assertion and they have not given any data to back their assertions. How much was our average fee, how much were those higher? Did they take the lowest fee for each country or the average?

The bottom line is that with no actual references cited, only unnamed research, and no figures provided, the assertion is hard to justify. It may be correct but how do we know this? And with the spy scandal lately, a policy of “trust me” isn’t enough.

One specific assertion was that the average costs are higher than those at similar institutions in Australia. Well the database shows Australian instruction costs range from $3,155 to $$5,380 at public unis. This is generally more expensive than NZ (all figures are adjusted into US$).

Again the SST may be absolutely correct. I may even be looking at the wrong data. But I would like to see some facts to back up assertions, so we can decide for ourselves.

11 quakes now

Blogger Drinks Wed 26

Jordan proposed a few days ago to have some drinks in Wellington for bloggers and blog readers who are keen to catch up. There was quite a good reaction so the drinks are confirmed for 7.00 pm onwards at the Backbencher.

As we are not Aucklanders (well Jordan used to be but he is recovering) we will not be having anyone getting up to wax about why they blog and what it means to them. The intent is just to be social, no doubt have some good debates, and have fun.

I will have my digital camera with me, and plan to take a few photos. But if you prefer not to be living your life in public, like me (I can not believe NBR published one of my New Year’s resolutions!) then just let me know and I will make sure I avoid photos of you, or at least identifying you in them.

The drinks are not just for political bloggers, but anyone who has a blog, or comments or reads blogs. Basically any excuse for a drink 🙂

We’ll book a few tables, so it would be useful if those planning to come along let Jordan or I know.

Speeding Tickets Treble

Anna Claridge in The Press reports that the number of speeding tickets issued has trebled since 1999.

The Police hierarchy have said the massive jump in tickets is the result of targeted road safety campaigns, but the problem is they are not targeted at all. Targeting is not issuing tickets to every single motorist who drives past, over the limit and tolerance.

The police in Hawke’s Bay were so busy with their speed traps, that they took hours to come out to an unexplained death at the beach. The poor person who had to wait with the body commented “It would seem that, increasingly, the only way to access any service from the police is to drive at 111kmh on the open road.”

Even worse that the local police commander claimed the officer spotted on speed camera duty was dealing with a car crash, yet the Fire Service says it did not attend any crash on the street in question that afternoon. Was he just covering up?

The Police Associaition itself agrees the police image was being tarnished by the policies where police no longer have any discretion to give a warning instead of a fine.

Auckland Harbour Bridge Use

Readers will know I am absolutely no fan of Destiny Church, However if the Foreshore Hikoi are given permission by the Police to march across the bridge, why not Destiny Church?

Personally I do not favour it being closed to traffic for any political march, but if the Police have set a precedent by allowing some marches, then they should allow all. I don’t want the Police deciding which marches are or are not allowed.

Overseas Students Working

Education New Zealand has proposed that foreign students be allowed to work for 20 hours a week, while studying.

I think this is a reasonable thing to do. Overseas students bring in $1.7 billion a year to New Zealand, and allowing them to do part-time work will help attract students. I understand this is common in many other countries.

Good vs bad headline

The NZ Herald sub-editor who picked “Brash to focus on welfare reform” gets a gold star for a neutral correct headline.

Contrast the Dominion Post sub-editor who wtached two many WWII movies and penned “Brash to launch assault on welfare”.

Note that the journalists in each case are not the ones who write the headlines. The stories themselves are both quite fair.

Candidates can make a difference

It is great that ACC have backed down on their daft plan to scrap the rescue helicopter service based in Palmerston North.

Nathan Guy, National’s Otaki candidate, has led the charge on this issue. For months he has been organsing petitions, getting media coverage, arranging local MPs to raise the issue etc and all that hard work has paid off. The petition got more than 10,000 signatures in Horowhenua.

It’s a prime example of the difference a good hard working candidate can make.

A sack of mail

I hadn’t cleared the PO Box for a few days so wet down today and had quite a few yellow cards in there saying there were items that could not fit into the PO Box so I went to the counter.

I was staggered when they went out the back and came back with what was literally a sack full of mail for me.

I’d forgotten that when I visited the Cato Institute late last year in Washington DC, I said that I’m always keen to receive literature and that I’m interested in all policy areas.

The sack was full of books, newsletters, DVDs, CDs etc from Cato. Very very cool. I’m just about to start reading Meltdown by Patrick Michaels. Michaels is a past president of the American Association of State Climatologists and writes about the predictable distortion of global warming by scientists, politicians, and the media. Michaels beleives that the earth is warming because of greenhouse gases, but he says that the warming will probably be modest and that nature and humanity will easily adjust to it.

Something to do for the weekend now!

Lower Hutt City Council

The Mayor of Lower Hutt, David Ogden, has proposed (the story is not online – Pg A8, DP 19 Jan) changing the city’s name to Kupe City and setting up a Maori only electoral ward.

I have no problems with the name change. Hell if I lived in Lower Hutt I’d support any name change. I have been a long standing fan of the proposal to rename Porirua City to Mana City.

But having electoral wards based on race is quite simply wrong and very bad for New Zealand. It is divisive nonsense.

Women & Science

The President of Harvard University has apologised after suggesting women do not have the same natural ability in math and sciences as men.

I wonder, to use a phrase to annoy Jordan, this is politcal correctness gone mad again?

First let me say I believe one can have group traits, but I never ever think you should judge individuals solely on the basis of a group affiliation. Thus on an individual level I have absolutely no doubt that women scientists can be and are every bit as brilliant and talented as male scientists.

But the Harvard President was talking about why women as a group do not succeed as much as mens in math and science careers, and he said that innate differences between the sexes may help explain it.

Based on my recollections of brain studies, there are differences between men and women. Where men do tend to be better at certain brain functions and women better at others. Again not to say that an individual woman can not be the best maths scholar in the world, but as a typical group attribute.

Men and women are different, and not just with reproductive functions. Is it wrong to acknowledge this, as a factor in why fewer women than men succeed in science? Not the only factor, but one factor.

Australian Young Labor – teaching hate!

ABC has a transcript of an interview with Rodney Cavalier, a former NSW education minister, and Labor Party historian and commentator.

He laments the factions in Labor, and also the fact that almost all new Labor MPs come from Young Labor or are employed be an MP.

The key quote is “Young Labor does one function

Inauguration Speech