Well done NZ Herald

It is good to see that investigative journalism is on the increase in NZ, after a few years with very little occuring amongst the major media.

Phil Kitchin, formerly of the Dominion and Dominion Post, and now with TVNZ, stands out with his Awatere-Huata and other stories.

The NZ Herald has done a good job on the Zaoui case by talking to numerous European intelligence sources and security experts.

Their conclusion is Zaoui did not personally blow up civilians himself, but that he probably was giving support to terrorists in the form of money or false documents. A bit like being in Sinn Fein, but not the actual IRA.

Combining that with the actual convictions, is more than enough reason to decline refugee status in my opinion.

For those interested in the Zaoui case, a previous post had 23 comments made to it debating the issue. The posters range from the Free Zaoui campaign to those who want all fundamentalist Muslism denied entry, so it is an interesting read.

Happy Easter

In the spirit of Easter I will only be posting nice, funny and thoughtful things for the next four days, so any roasting of stupid MPs will have to wait until next week.

I won’t even complain about the idiotic shop trading hours laws which means I can go to the movies today but not to the supermarket.

Very amusing yesterday was Green MP Sue Kedgley displaying a 1 kg Easter Egg in Parliament (I think she wants to ban them) and Finance Minister Michael Cullen seeking leave for the easter egg to be tabled to great hilarity.

Snow White and the seven dwarfs

I am not sure if it is MMP in process or a grotesque mating ritual, but the last minute negotations over the foreshore legislation have been either hilarious or tragic – I think both.

First we have United Future (Bashful) who have been the friendly Government lapdog. They vote for almost everything Labour asks them to, and in return get made to feel special by having lots of Ministers talk to them.

But after working with Labour for a year on the proposed legislation, they have been dumped for NZ First because NZ First has a couple more votes. So United Future have backed off just because two words were deleted.

Dunne has said the Government had to weigh up getting a deal with the wider context of its confidence and supply agreement with United Future. In other words he knows his party looks like absolute chumps who will be ditched by Labour the moment it is expedient to do so, so is not going to roll over so much now.

Then we have the Greens (Dopey) who got a phone call at 10.00 am (with a midday announcement planned) pleading with them to support the legislation or at least abstain on it. The Greens said to naff off.

And then you have NZ First (Grumpy). The Party that Helen swore she would never deal with, but in recent times has been flirting with her, as big bad Don is taking their votes. They have made United Future look impotent and got lots of publicity for nothing.

Snow White (Helen) must be really looking forward to dealing in future with either Winston who will negotiate through the media until you publicly back down, or United Future who knows they are just lobby fodder when useful and will be far less supportive in future.

New Blog

There is a new NZ blog – The Whig.

Unfortunately Blair needs to study electoral law a bit more. He assumes that if Labour lost two seats in by-elections they would get two more List MPs as top ups. It doesn’t work like that though. if you lose an MP at a by-election you don’t get an extra List MP and you can’t get overhang.

PNN has moved locations. Almost every day there is a new article highlighting how Hard News is twisting the facts to smear National at every turn.

Gay Nats

The NZPA reports that National has established a gay branch. This is well timed with the Civil Unions Bill due to be considered by Parliament soon.

Technically it is not a branch, but a policy advisory group which any group of members and supporters can apply to establish. Unlike Labour, this does not gain special representation rights – it is about participation and policy advocacy.

I just hope they can come up with a shorter name than the very PC equivalent in Labour which is something along the lines of gay, lesbian, bisexual, transgender etc etc etc.

Incidentially I am also trying to establish a policy advisory group, within National. A prize to the person who can guess what it is. Those who know the answer, can not compete. That means you Megan.

A sensible stance

Good to read that Tim Barnett is being sensible and backing the NZ Police being able to retain information on massage parlours.

It is wel known that the massage parlour industry has or had many criminal elements in it, and one doesn’t just throw away information which can help solve future crimes.

More false names

Okay, if I’m against Sunday News using false names for its journalists, should I also be against ACC staff using fake names for case managers?

Well I’m not. If I had to deal with someone who threatened parliamentary security with getting a shotgun, and had turned up at the private homes of senior ACC managers, then I would not be giving him my name so he can pay night-time visits to my family.

It wasn’t thet long ago that either an ACC or a WINZ case manager was murdered by a disgruntled “customer”.

While I have huge sympathy for Mr van der Elk, in having had grossly traumatic police experiences, I can only wonder how someone who is well enough to spend ten years writing hundreds of letters about ACC to the media and MPs, is not well enough to work?

What a surprise!

I was surprised to read in the SST that someone was claiming the Treaty settlement process is moving too fast.

It is in the interests of both claimants and the Crown to have settlements happer sooner rather than later (as long as full and final). So who could be advocating that they are moving too fast?

Oh, now it makes sense. He is a Treaty lawyer. His $107,000 legal aid for just one claim, is not benefiting him at all he claims.

He strangely says issues of murder and rape can take a long time in court normally as justification for a ten year delay, yet his litigation has been on fisheries settlements where the arguments are purely over the allocation model.

Driving with cellphones

The SST reports that the Government is going to ban the use of non hands-free cellphones in cars.

I accept that talking on a cellphone while talking, increases the risk of crashing. But so does talking to a passenger, tuning the radio or CD, eating, smoking, or having a drink from your water bottle.

It seems to me that cellphones are being targetted, merely because they are used a lot, not because as an activity they are more dangerous than any other potentially distracting activity. Evidence to the contrary is welcome.

From the research I have seen, there is little difference between using a hand held and a hands-free phone, in terms of distraction. It is the talking which distracts, not holding the phone. But because a total ban would be unpopular, a hand held ban is proposed.

Personally I prefer trusting people to judge the conditions. I find it useful to get calls on my cellphone when in my car. Sometimes I won’t answer the call at all, if I am on a tricky piece of road. Sometimes I’ll take the call, and sometimes I’ll take it and pull over if it is going to be an extended call. All depends on the road, the traffic and the weather.

Nick Smith’s status

It is very interesting that both the Registrar of the High Court, and two High Court Judges, have now all said that they are unsure whether the finding of contempt against Nick Smith is a crime or not (which if so would vacate his seat under the Electoral Act).

Most opinion appears to be that it probably is not, but not even High Court Judges want to say for sure. Of course the decision that matters is the one from the Speaker which is likely to be given at 2.00 pm on Tuesday, unless he refers it to the Privileges Committee as he did with Harry Duynhoven.

I was amused to note on Friday the large sign on a car driving through Wellington which proclaimed “Nick Smith for Principal Family Court Judge”. Now that would be interesting!

DPF

Things I learnt this week

1) The Speaker browses the Internet.

2) Standing Orders 396(b) and 397(k) are extremely interesting.

3) It is amazing how nervous you can get to reports your name, contempt of Parliament and Privileges Committee have all been mentioned in the same sentence.

4) I am grateful for Speakers’ Rulings 137-1, first made in 1879, and that the week is now past!

Fictitious News

Sunday News has admitted it has invented fictitious journalists and published stories from overseas newspapers as if they were original.

Well done to the NZ Herald and to Australian Media Watch for exposing this.

There is really no defending such behaviour, and one has to wonder if they invent journalists, what else do they invent?

Uninvited Party Guests

The Manawatu Evening Standard reports about how almost every student in Palmerston North has been text messaged an invite to an 18th birthday party, and Police are rightfully concerned about it getting out of control.

It does remind me of a great party I attended a while ago. The next day when someone who didn’t make it asked how many people turned up, the reply was “The Police estimate was 250 – 300”.

Heh!

My black sense of humour meant I did have to laugh when I read in the NZ Herald that Tama Iti had advertised Gerry Brownlee’s opening of his art expedition as “Meet the Prick”.

It’s a sign of Gerry’s good sense of humour that he is still going through with the opening.

The Zaoui case

As everyone knows the Inspector-General of Intelligence and Security resigned after the High Court ruled that Justice Greig should not participate further in the review of Ahmed Zaoui’s security risk certificate.

His comments to the Listener seemed potential grounds enough, but also the fact that he seemed to closely co-operate with the bodies he was reviewing rather than be semi-detached from them. I wonder whether the structure is the right one. An Inspector-General may feel that by not upholding an SIS decision he publicly undermines the SIS. Perhaps the IG should review decisions before they are public, rather than afterwards when he might be influenced to support them so we are not seen as weak on the war against terror.

I still believe on the evidence to date that Zaoui should be deported as he is a convicted terrorist in multiple countries. However it has taken far too long, and I have some sympathy for the notion that no-one should be in jail this long, unless convicted. Balancing that though is the delays are caused by mainly Zaoui’s team, but he is allowed to explore every option. A law review after this case would be a good idea.

Money not always the answer

No Right Turn has commented on United Future’s plans to reform CYFS (which look not bad).

NRT goes on to say that you can not ignore that it also needs serious resourcing.

Of course he does not back this up. Just the usual knee jerk response on any issue – more money and higher taxes.

So I checked with the worthy folks at the Treasury. How much funding does CYFS get, and has it been cut, stayed the same, or increased?

Well in 2003/2004 it is budgeted (taking into account DEFU update) to spend $364 million. An additional $92 million is also spent through non govermental agencies.

And how much funding did CYFS get say four years ago? Well again some quick fact checking and it was $249 million. Amd Mr Excel tells me that is a huge 46% funding increase in just four years.

So we have all these problems despite increasing funding by 46%! Time for some accountability.

Exit Interview Questionnaire

Length of Service: 7 years, 9 months:

What attracted you to work at Parliament? I got asked to help out for a few months in 1996

Have you ever lodged an ACC work related claim while employed here? No

Are you currently suffering pain and discomfort? Yes

If yes, what is the nature and cause of this discomfort? Farewell Drinks

What did you find to be the most enjoyable and positive aspects of your job? Winning elections

What did you find to be the least satisfactory and frustrating aspects of your job? Losing elections

Have you any suggestions on how to improve the Service as a place to work? Merge all five Parliamentary agencies together into one dedicated agency.

My final day!

Wow, after eight years working at Parliament, today is my final day. I made the decision a few months ago to set up my own company and go self employed from 1 April, and that’s tomorrow!

The farewell drinks are tonight, and lots of friends and colleagues, past and present, heading along on the basis of any excuse for a drink. With the House in urgency, the bar remains open until 1.00 am which is a happy coincidence (thanks to Dr Cullen!).

Yesterday had the slighly more formal Afternoon Tea. A couple of embarrassing stories as are usual for the occassions, including one I really had forgotten about, and really would have rather not emerged. Alcohol has a lot to answer for.

By coincidence Jenny Shipley, Bill English and Don Brash all there for parts of it. Just needed Mr Bolger for the full set, but he was no doubt busy banking somewhere. In my eight years I’ve managed to survive working for four Leaders, six Deputy Leaders and seven Chiefs of Staff.

Winston Peters once commented to me that he didn’t know how I managed to always stay on with all four Leaders and that it wouldn’t have happened if he had become Leader. I’m not sure whether he was implying that if he had become Leader, there wouldn’t have been four Leaders in total, or that he would not have kept me on. I suspect a bit of both 🙂

No-one should expect any updates to my blog on Thursday morning, and even Thursday afternoon will be pretty unlikely I suspect, assuming tonight goes to plan which I think may finish up at the Green Parrot sometime early Thursday morning.

But in theory I will have more time for blogging from tomorrow onwards, plus I will be slightly less constrained in what I can say so onwards and outwards!

I don’t like it

The more I think about the proposal to allow the Government to confiscate passports from NZ citizens, the more I don’t like it.

I regard a passport as a fundamental right of any citizen, because it allows people to leave a country – also a fundamental right (if not charged with a crime).

If there are genuine security fears about a NZ citizen, then the SIS can share its concerns with overseas agencies, and individual countries can decide whether or not to allow that person to visit. But the notion of NZ citizens who have not been convicted of any crime losing their passports at the discretion of a Minister is dangerous. I would need a huge amount of convincing on why this should be supported, or is needed.

On the citizenship issues, I am somewhat favourable. I think there is some merit in not having NZ citizenship automatically given to children born here, if *neither* parent is a NZer. The status quo provides a huge incentive to people to become illegal overstayers and have kids in NZ, and this is being abused a lot. Also if two German tourists (for example) happen to have a baby while holidaying here, it is hard to see why their child is a NZer.

It is essential though that no child ever be born stateless, so NZ citizenship should only be with-held if one is 100% sure that the child will have citizenship in another country.

Maori Television

Been watching the new Maori Television channel on Sky 33 most of the day. Congratulations are due to those who have worked so hard to make it a reality. It was quite moving to see the passion of many of the staff, and the importance this can have to a lot of people.

So far it looks to be pretty well done. I am glad that it make use of English sub-titles and have some programmes in English, as it used to annoy me a lot that I could not understand Te Karere despite wanting to view it.

MTV has had a nightmare establishment phase with two years of delays, fraud, sexual harrassment, cost over-runs etc. Whether or not they survive will depend I suspect on whether they continue to produce a quality product, and avoid the extravagence of Aotearoa TV.

On a related note I am surprised that a TV channel whose purpose is promoting local culture would use maoritelevision.com as its domain name instead of say television.maori.nz or tv.maori.nz. Incidentially the website isn’t responding at the moment, but that may be a problem at my end.

OSH Madness

Now this is just barking mad. The SST reports that they are banning couches from the Basin Reserve due to OSH requirements.

Couches at the basin have been a great tradition, and to claim that suddenly they might hinder egress from the ground, or create a fire risk is politically correct madness. How the hell does a small couch on a very big bank block things anymore than all the chairs, and people there. And if couches are likely to self-combust let’s ban them form homes also.

Incidentially I’m pretty sure the Tui couch pictured is one I know well and have spent many a Friday night drinking on, in Molesworth Street.

In more OSH madness a kayak race has been hit with the ever growing OSH bureaucracy, as have school camps.

Not long ago I saw a family faced prosecution for not getting a building permit for a tree fort!! What is this country that spawned Edmund Hillary coming to.

Russell Brown on Nick and Katherine

Russell Brown has pointed out that in the family court case which sparked the Nick Smith contempt charge, one has not heard the cousin’s side of the story, and that family court has to often decide very hard cases.

I think Russell has missed a hugely significant point though, which makes this different to normal family court cases. Most cases are between the two parents of a child, and yes they are often very difficult and messy.

But this was between both parents on one side, and a cousin who was a temporary care-giver. Unless there is concern for the safety of the child (and there has never been any suggestion of this), then this should not even be a debatable issue. Surely, surely, the starting point for any decision is that a child should be with their parents, unless this would place them at risk. This is hardly controversial. If one takes the decision in this case to an extreme you could have nannies claim custody of kids they look after because they spend more time with the kids.

Russell also blogs later in the week that MP Katherine Rich should “get a life” for demanding that Ruth Dyson resign as a Minister over calling her an “irresponsible tart”.

The only problem is she did no such thing. She has only asked for a proper apology, which even Russell admits should have been given. The headline of the Press article linked to by Russell states “Katherine Rich has called on the Christchurch MP to relinquish her portfolio” but you will note there is no quote from Katherine stating this.

It should be noted that resigning from one portfolio is not at all the same as resigning as a Minister. But in this case even that wasn’t called for. A journalist asked Katherine if Dyson should resign as Women’s Affairs Minister and the response I understand was along the lines of how she would have to decide if her comments were compatible with keeping the portfolio.

So I’m still somewhat perplexed at how Russell criticises Katherine more than Dyson, despite Dyson being the one who called her an “irresponsible tart”. I can only imagine the fury and condemnation that would have happened if the situation was reversed. I mean for example Gerry Brownless responding to a taunt from John Tamihere was so bad it was making the country being “flushed down the toilet?“

Race based funding