McCarten on Little

Matt McCarten examines the challenges for Andrew Little managing two roles:

But it seems a bit churlish for the party to not give Williams the deference he deserves and wait until the party’s conference until they replaced him. Just because Clark and her deputy, Michael Cullen, resigned their leadership positions it shouldn’t necessarily follow that the party president should have to fall on his sword immediately.

After all, Clark and Cullen are still collecting their parliamentary salaries until some better job comes up, while Williams is out of paid work.

If I’m not mistaken, Mike Williams did not get paid one cent by Labour Party members for his rull-time job as Party President.Instead he was appointed to six different Government Boards, which resulted in fees of close to $200,000.

Labour was in power then so there were certain advantages for his union, such as having access to Cabinet ministers. But it’s hard to see what the benefit is to the EPMU members when their leader takes up the presidency of the Labour Party when it’s the National Party that is running the country.

Imagine Little trekking up to the Beehive to lobby government ministers on behalf of his union members and expecting a sympathetic hearing. These National Party politicians know his other job is to kill them at the next general election. But it’s even stranger than that.

Little also says he will run for Parliament at the next election. Does Little or his union think his political opponents in the Government will give him anything that helps him?

What McCarten overlooks, is how much influence the EPMU will have when Andrew is the Leader of the Labour Party – or at a minimum, a very senior front bencher.

Trade unions face a hell of job over the next few years, given the global economy. It’s an even bigger challenge for the EPMU, given its central role in the export and manufacturing industries. I find it hard to believe that Little can do both his union job and the Labour Party role well. Either job is enormous on its own.

Little will obviously have a succession plan and delegate the day-to-day management of major challenges to others.

But anyone who has worked for a senior boss who has announced that they will leave soon, yet stays in their role while working part-time in a new job as part of a transition process, knows it doesn’t work. Frankly it’s bizarre.

What I will find interesting, is the fund-raising role of the presidency. Mike Williams met several business CEOs and owners a week, soliciting donations (as does National’s President). Will Andrew be meeting CEOs wearing one hat asking for donations, and maybe the next day meeting them with another hat, negotiating wage increases for staff employed by that business?

The potential for a clash of interests, seems large. I am sure Andrew will do what he can to minimise such clashes, but it will be a challenge.  Maybe one solution is that Andrew doesn’t do the corporate fundraising from businesses that have EPMU members?

Ralston on Labour

Today’s Ralston:

Not that Labour’s counterattacks have been particularly effective. It seems to have reverted to the same prophet of doom approach it adopted before the last election. “The End is Nigh!” Everything National says or does Labour hysterically portrays as part of a vast right wing conspiracy to destroy the fabric of our society.

If you listen to the opposition there is nothing wrong with ACC and the Tories are simply out to sell it to evil foreign financiers. McCully is callously ignoring the starving huddled masses that depend on our kind charity. Coleman is just politically grandstanding and there was nothing wrong with the Pacific Division’s handling of immigration issues, despite those police investigations.

Labour’s tactic seems to be to say, “see, we told you so!” Sadly, voters don’t like being told they got it wrong.

Ralston points out there is no nasty rght wing conspiracy agenda:

The truth is this Government does not have some huge hidden right wing agenda. In fact it doesn’t seem to have any sort of agenda. It is really a sheep in wolf’s clothing.

So far the Government has been a triumph of style over substance. National seems to think it can remain in power simply by being better managers and trimming a few costs here and there. Now the first 100 Days programme has passed, it might be nice to see a plan for the next 1000 days.

A fair point. The budget is much anticipated.

Obama’s troubles

Barack Obama has more troubles.

First of all three more nominees withdrew on a single day. He now has the most shambolic appointments record of any President.

The problem is so bad, that the Treasury Secretary doesn’t have any of his 17 Deputy Secretaries confirmed.

That has led to the AP story:

For five weeks, Treasury Secretary Timothy Geithner has battled the worst economic crisis in generations with no key deputies in place. That’s made for a rocky debut for the man President Barack Obama put in charge of addressing the financial crisis.

With an awkward first television appearance, a bank rescue plan that lacked promised specifics and two restructured bailouts that raised taxpayer risk, Geithner has failed to calm financial markets desperate for answers.

Critics say part of the problem is that Geithner is flying solo: Not one of his top 17 deputies has been named, let alone confirmed. And without senior leadership, lower-level Treasury employees can’t make decisions or represent the government in crucial conversations with banks and others.

There is growing criticism that Obama’s massive budget (did you know Obama will borrow more money as President than the other 43 US Presidents combined!) was all about spending wishlists, but little on fixing the banking industry crisis, which is causing all the othe rproblems.

And people are also noticing that Obama is unable to give a speech without a teleprompter. Now I don’t mean major set piece speeches, where of course you use a teleprompter. But he is using it for everything – five minute speeches announcing an appointment, and a short tribute to Abraham Lincoln speech.

Now to be fair to Obama, the financial crisis would test any President. Bush did not inspire confidence, and while McCain would have been a good President in other areas – I doubt he would be doing much better with this crisis.

The one who might be handling the job the best is the Secretary of State Hillary Clinton. I always had far more confidence in her abilities than Obama’s.

Kids!

Just heard this wonderful story from a friend of mine, who is dating a guy who has a ten year old son.

She was going out for her normal jog, and Master Ten asked if he could come along with her. She told us how she was puzzled by this as he had never asked before to do this. She wondered if he wanted to talk about something.

Well yes he did.

After a few minutes, he asked if he could ask her a question, and she said of course he could.

He then said he had a question about “big” people, indicating with his hands and arms, he meant large or fat people. She wanted for the question and it was:

Whenever I see a big person, my thing stands up. Why is that?

You can just imagine the effort required to keep a straight face, and/or not crack a joke that he has been watching too much of Rosie O’Donnell on The View.

So she did what a good politician should do, and answered the question with a question.

Ummm, that is interesting. What happens when you see a tall skinny person.

And another can’t make it up answer:

It makes me need to go to the toilet and have a wee.

Oh dear. He is going to have a rough few years!

In between uncontrollable laughter, as she told me this, my only advice was to remember the story so you could tell it at his 21st in 11 years time!

So much for power sharing

Zimbabwe gets worse:

ZIMBABWE’S Prime Minister Morgan Tsvangirai was injured and his wife Susan was killed in a car crash overnight, party officials confirmed, adding that suspicious circumstances could indicate foul play.

I think we can guess who.

President Robert Mugabe’s former regime had a long history of assassination plots, mass murder and torture of its opponents since it came to power in 1980.

However, within an hour of Mr Tsvangirai being brought to the private Avenues Clinic, Mr Mugabe and his wife, Grace, arrived to express their condolences, followed by several other senior officials of Mr Mugabe’s ZANU(PF) party.

I’m surprised Mugabe didn’t turn up to the clinic an hour before the crash!

Big swing in Roy Morgan poll

roymorganfeb09

The latest Roy Morgan picks up a big dip for Labour in late February, and a corresponding rise for National.

I’m starting to worry I may lose money on the Goff stock – I’ve invested on the basis he will last until 2010, and will lose money if he goes earlier. On the plus side, there is no obvious successor.

I’ve updated curiablog with all the latest polls, and will soon start up again the sidebar graphic.

More appointments the Government could consider

Reflecting more on the Dom Post story that the Government is looking to appoint Dr Cullen to chair a major SOE, here are some other appointments they can consider:

  • Winston Peters to chair the Asia 2000 Foundation
  • Peter Brown to chair the Immigration Review Board
  • Clint Rickards as CEO of the Ministry of Women’s Affairs

Make your own suggestions below.

UPDATE: Many good suggestions so far. Some of my favourites:

  • David Benson-Pope as Children’s Commissioner
  • Ruth Dyson for ALAC
  • Brian Tamaki to the Aids Foundation
  • Keith Locke, trade commissioner to Israel
  • Philip Field as head of the Pacific Island Immigration division
  • Winston Peters, Chairman of the Electoral Commission
  • Kyle Chapman, Race Relations Commissioner

Cullen to chair an SOE?

The Dom Post reports:

Michael Cullen is being tipped for a six-figure salary as chairman of one of the country’s top state-owned enterprises.

Top of the likely list is power generator Mighty River Power, Government sources say.

I have real problems with this.

I do not think it is credible you can go directly from attacking the Government in Parliament to working for them, chairing a major SOE, with say only a day or two in between.

Yes Jim Bolger chaired SOEs under Labour – but he was appointed around four years after he left Parliament. That makes a huge difference.

Supporting Helen for the UN job is different also – that is an international role – not a role that is serving the NZ Govt and at the total discretion of Cabinet.

I am not arguing that Cullen is not talented, and at the appropriate point in time, would be a good appointee to certain boards. But he should be out of consideration until National’s second term (if there is one), or at least for a minimum of a year after he leaves Parliament.

How can the Government think it is serious when it complains abut breaches of the Public Finance Act, massive blowouts in the Crown Accounts, the disaster of a purchase that was KiwiRail, and then people read oh yeah we are looking to reward the guy who did all this – before he even has even resigned from Parliament?

Most people in National were very relaxed about supporting Clark for a UN post. They are very much the opposite when it comes to having Cullen chair a major SOE.  I’ve already had absolutely furious phone calls this morning from very senior and long standing party members. I think some members would resign if an appointment was made during 2009.

Carter complains schools spending too much helping special needs

Chris Carter has attacked, well basically every high school on the North Shore. He claims:

“To be quite honest that’s the problem with the North Shore high schools. They’d all employed extra staff based on their foreign fee-paying students giving them that extra revenue, because … it’s the biggest concentration of high-decile high schools in one area in the country and they’re essentially in competition with each other for students.

“So they’d overextended themselves, parental donations were sliding, international student fees were falling – so somebody had to be blamed for the schools employing fancy ballet teachers, fancy swimming teachers, extra PE teachers, extra support for special needs.

How dare those schools employ extra support for students with special needs. Labour condemns such things.

Just as it was a bad idea for National’s Allan Peachey to get in a shouting match with Selwyn College, I am not sure Labour will see it as a good thing to have their Education Spokeperson trying to pick fights with every high school on the North Shore. Not the way to build bridges in opposition.

Armstrong on ACC

John Armstrong writes:

Is there anything more stomach-churning for an Opposition politician than watching helplessly as the enemy demolishes the very things he or she painstakingly put in place while in Government?

Not much. I remember the awfulness when Labour removed choice from ACC and legislated to end the very successful private management of Auckland Remand Prison. It hurts.

National’s immediate priority is to turn what the party feels had become a de facto welfare agency under Labour back into an accident insurance vehicle.

The prevailing view in National is that even if it wanted to privatise elements of ACC beyond what the party has already said will be opened for competition, it is going to have to fix things first. That is going to take some time.

A long time I would say.

David Bain coverage

The Herald has excellent coverage of the Bain trial. They have updates here and a lead story here. They summarise the prosecution case:

  • Stephen Bain’s blood was found on David Bain’s clothing.
  • A lense from Bain’s glasses was found in Stephen’s room while the frames and another lense were found in Bain’s room.
  • The trigger lock and the key to the .22 calibre rifle were also found in David Bain’s room.
  • Bain had also tried to wash blood out of some of his clothing, including a green jersey, in the laundry.
  • “Woollen green fibres were taken from under Stephen’s finger nails which match the fibres from the green jersey,”
  • A partial palm print of David Bain was found on the washing machine.
  • Bain was also seen to have scratches on his chest above his nipples.
  • A policeman also noticed a bruise on Bain’s temple, about the size of a 50 cent piece.
  • No finger-prints belonging to Robin Bain were found on the .22 calibre rifle.
  • There was about 20 minutes of “lost time” between the time that the Crown believes he finished his paper round – 6.45am – and the 1,1,1 call made by Bain – 7.10am – from the family home.
  • Alleged Bain had also displayed some “unusual behavior” in the days leading up to the murders.
  • Alleged Bain told a friend that he had had a premonition and that he “sometimes knew what was going to happen”. He also “told her he had a feeling something horrible was going to happen”.

Now this is only the prosecution’s side.Still to hear from the defence.

I am sure almost everyone here has a view on this case, but it would be safer not to express a view as to guilt or innocence until the trial is over. Not that I think any jurors will be reading Kiwiblog to help them decide the verdict – but better safe than sorry. General discussion about the strength of the evidence is probably okay.

Crown Accounts

The monthly crown accounts are out. Not pretty, but could be worse:

  • OBEGAL (the important figure – the underlying surplus) is $600 million in the black
  • But OBEGAL is $850 million less than PREFU forecast which suggest OBEGAL for the full year will be close to a $1b deficit
  • Operating Deficit is $5.5b due to $6b of losses
  • Cash deficit is $5.7b, which is $1b higher than PREFU
  • Gross Debt is 25.3% of GDP alreadybut net debt is only 1.3% of GDP (excl NZSF assets)
  • Tax revenue $574m less than PREFU but much in line with DEFU

Why TVNZ should still pay a dividend

NZPA reports:

The Government’s decision to take a dividend from Television New Zealand (TVNZ) “needlessly risks the livelihoods” of the state broadcaster’s workers, unions say.

TVNZ yesterday said it would have a detailed proposal of how it would cut $25 million off its budget by mid-month having last month revealed advertising revenues were 10 percent below budget, which represented an annualised shortfall of income of $30 million.

Quite clearly it is the lack of revenue that is the driver of the job losses, not any dividends. But do they have a point – should the Government not take a dividend, to save jobs?

The answer is no. First of all TVNZ is in a competitive industry. If you remove the requirement to pay dividends, it allows TVNZ to (for example) undercut TV3 in tendering for programmes, and NZ on Air funding. So you may destory more jobs elsewhere if you start playing favourites with one company.

The other reason is the opportunity cost of capital. The unions make profit sound like a dirty word, but it is simply a return on capital. And if that return is not greater than what you can get sticking the money in the bank, then you are effectively losing money on that investment. TVNZ’s return on equity in 2008 was 8.3% which is hardly huge, and I suspect it will be much reduced this year.

1000 free hours for jobs

Hazel Phillips covers the neat initiative by DraftFCB:

DraftFCB is doing its bit for the recession by creating a concept called the 1000 Hours Fund – at an estimated cost of $200,000.

The agency ran a full-page ad in today’s New Zealand Herald to announce its offering.

The project came about after staff heard ideas generated at last week’s job summit, which prompted them into action. Notably, PM John Key’s exhortation that each of us can do something that could save someone’s job, create a new job or help someone else find a new job as soon as possible.

The 1000 Hours Fund is a pro bono project where the agency is promising to provide 1000 hours of its services gratis to companies that could – as a result – create more jobs for Kiwis. The idea is to free up budgets to be spent in areas other than creating a communications campaign.

What a great initiative. Like ASB Bank, it is a win-win. Good for DraftFCB’s brand, and good for companies that want to create jobs, and can use this offer.

This week’s NBR column

My column at NBR is now online.

I look at the $2.5 billion increase in ACC liabilities and $1.5 billion extra needed for Kiwirail. The ratings thsi week are:

  • Best Play: Maori Party A+ for Foreshore & Seabed repeal
  • Worst Play: Govt D- for bailing out Mascot Finance
  • Patsy of the Week: Goes to Chris Finlayson with a B+ for his question to Pita Sharples that allowed Sharples to have fun with Labour leadership speculation
  • EFA Breach of the Week: NZ First with an A- of course!
  • Blog Analysis of the Week goes to Rob Hosking with an A for his excelletn Q&A on ACC.

As usual, feedback and comments can be made at NBR.

2008 Party Spending

The Herald reports on the 2008 spending returns. I’ll come to that, but first an error they made:

No parties exceeded their caps, unlike 2005 when Labour got into trouble for its parliamentary-funded election year “pledge card” – a cost which was later deemed an illegal election expense and put it over its spending cap.

It was not “later” deemed an illegal election expense. The Chief Electoral Office warned Labour three times before the election that their pledge card was an election advertisement.

Anyway the 2008 returns are on the Elections website. Be warned some of them are huge as every ad has to be listed.

NZ First is listed as havign filed an incomplete return. What this probably means if there is no statutory declaration and/or an Auditor’s Certificate. In other words no-one will swear it is actually correct!

Considering their 2005, 2006 and 2007 returns were all found to be false, it might be no surprise they are finding it difficult to find someone to sign them off.

Another Labour legacy

Poor old Pete Hodgson doesn’t seem to have realised they lost the election, and is complaining that Jonathan Coleman is going to dismantle the Pacific division of the Immigration Service. The Herald reports:

Labour Immigration spokesman Pete Hodgson said Dr Coleman’s decision was short-sighted and based on political grounds because Labour had created the division.

So let us look at this wonderful legacy Labour left, according to an independent report:

  • the division had had no clear picture of its duties
  • lacked strong leadership
  • had become isolated from the rest of the Immigration Service
  • its leadership created an “us and them” approach
  • attitude prevailed among staff that its leadership was “untouchable”
  • staff were not properly trained or resourced
  • problems with inconsistent decision-making
  • difficult decisions were sometimes put in the “too hard basket”
  • staff morale problems included grievances over pay and conditions
  • poor internal relationships
  • concern regarding financial processes and compliance
  • huge backlogs of applications and issues regarding timeliness and quality

They should be proud.

Holmes returns to TVNZ

I heard around a fortnight ago that Paul Holmes would be the anchor for the new TVNZ weekend political show, that is meant to be the substitute for Agenda.

The Herald covers this today:

Veteran broadcaster Paul Holmes is to front the new version of the political current affairs show Agenda.

The weekend political show – wholly made with taxpayer funding – is back on air this month with the new name Q&A.

The former Newstalk ZB breakfast host has been hired for the main hosting role, but TVNZ political editor Guyon Espiner is expected to provide long-run interviews – as he did on the old Agenda.

I think it is sensible have the Political Editor doing the main interviews as he has more in depth knowledge of the issues.

It will be interesting to see how it compares to the old Agenda.

A useful press release

NZPA run a press release service called mediacom. Basically PR companies pay a fee and NZPA distribute their press release for them. This means you can pick them up if you receive an NZPA feed (they are in their own category so no one mistakes them for news).

They also distribute these releases to other news organisations, and some time ago added Kiwiblog onto the list. So every day I usually get half a dozen or so releases through NZPA’s Mediacom service.

Most of the time, it isn’t stuff I find particularly useful, but sometimes there is a press release worth waiting for, such as the one I got this afternnon announcing that members of the Blues Rugby Team, and their cheerleaders, were jumping off the Sky Tower. And they even provided a link to photos.

Photography by Frances Oliver.

So it allows me to republish the photo, for all the Blues supporters out there!

Trans-Tasman on Key

Trans-Tasman (an invaluable weekly newsletter) looks at the week for Key:

John Key had three striking successes in the past week. All three demonstrated his capacity to take hold of a germ of an idea, nurture it and turn a political profit on it. The Jobs Summit hammered home the theme saving jobs is a top priority of the Key Govt. But its important achievement was to get sectors previously in conflict to work together. The Govt is willing to take on more debt, the banks are willing to lend some more money, the unions are not calling for pay rises, and employers accepted plans to reduce hours rather than jobs. As union leader (and presumably politically opposed to Key) Laila Harre put it: “In term of my political experience this was the first time I have personally been engaged in a genuinely tripartite process at a NZ level. I’ve never seen anything like that in NZ.”

The other two sucesses are putting the travel to Australia as domestic passengers on the fast track, and the decision to launch a Korean FTA.

At some stage, Key will have a really bad week, and it will be interesting to see how he handles it. But he is displaying very good political instincts to date.

Espiner on Foreshore & Seabed

I’ll start with Colin’s conclusion:

Key might think that we’ve entered a new age of multiracial harmony, and I’d like to think so too. But I’ll say this: National underestimates the depth of public feeling about ownership of the foreshore and seabed at its peril. If Key thinks that the public will be placated simply by being guaranteed access – and no longer having the beaches in public ownership – then I think he is, for the first time in his premiership so far, completely and utterly wrong.

First of all there is a difference between beaches and the foreshore. The foreshore is that part between low and high tide. Beaches tend to be the stuff above high tide.

Colin agrees with me that the outcome doesn’t look hard to guess:

Let’s be clear: the review of the act announced today is a jack-up. It has only one possible conclusion – repeal the Act. Why do I say that? Well, the panellists on the review are all sympathetic, to say the least, to the Maori Party’s cause: Judge Eddie Durie, a former chairman of the Waitangi Tribunal, which has slated the Foreshore and Seabed Act; Richard Boast, an academic specialising in Maori land alienation; and Hana O’Regan, daughter of Tipene O’Regan, a Treaty lawyer.

I think jack up is a harsh word, but make no mistake this is a panel that would regard the current law as the least favoured options. They still have to do the hard work of devising a more acceptable option.

There are a number of options that I can think of, if the law is repealed. First of all, it is worth remembering that the Court of Appeal set a high threshold for any claim to title. Something along the lines of continous customary use.  But what are the options for a Government if title was granted:

  1. Do nothing – it is for an area that the public never use anyway
  2. Offer to buy the title
  3. Negotiate an access agreement
  4. Offer a deal – title is exchanged in return for say some Landcorp land.

Now there are pros and cons of all those, and it isn’t quite that simple. But the point is there are several options that can be explored in good faith.

I await the work of the panel with interest.

I am also fascinated by how Labour will handle this. If Goff campaigns against any repeal, then they may lose significant Maori support – and any hope of getting some seats back. But equally it is a nightmare if John Key and Pita Sharples pull off a deal that works – that would just make Labour look so bad for not even trying to reach a deal before kneejerk announcing they will legislate.

Tertiary Education Commission

Further restructuring at the TEC, is likely to reduce staff levels by 70.

While unfortunate for the individuals involved, it is a good thing overall.

Labour set up TEC. We used to survive fine without one. As I understand it, around 25 staff worked on tertiary issues at the Ministry of Education.

TEC skyrocketed to 450 staff. And frankly it was adding little value – huge scams took place which it did nothing about. Hundreds of millions of taxpayer dollars went on so called free educational courses that had next to no value.

This will reduce TEC to 292.5 jobs. That’s a start, but not a finish.