Field not off the hook

It is pleasing to see that Labour is not being let off the hook over the Field inquiry. As one left commentator said – this is not about some tennis balls at school 20 years ago. This is about current actions as an MP. And the level of judgement shown was appalling.

The NZ Herald editorial on Thursday says Field is lucky to still be in Parliament, and talks openly about true corruption being so rare we “suppose the office holder careless, naive, unwise or uninformed, never simply venal”.

The Dom Post picks up on one of the many angles from the report (At last count I am over 20 instances of improper behaviour) – that Field had his ministerial staff arranging flights for his unpaid labourers.

The Press hits the nail saying:

The Labour caucus showed by their less than enthusiastic backing of Field in the House on Tuesday that they at least have the grace to be shamefaced about what they are trying to pull off. But the chances are that, as has happened before when a minister has behaved badly, they will succeed. Labour will squirm its way through the episode and survive, but the cost will be high. Yet another little piece will have been chipped out of the integrity of the system. For a Prime Minister and a Government who arrived in power full of self-righteous posturing about their ethical standards it is a decidedly grubby performance.

We also have a Dom Post editorial which says any claims by Field he has been vindicated are wrong.

And in today’s Herald, top lawyers shoot down the claim by the PM that Ingram could have asked for more powers. They point out that without changing his inquiry into a statutory commission or a royal commission of inquiry, he could not get more powers. Clark chose a form of inquiry that had no powers.

The Police Prostitute

To some degree, it makes a lot of sense for a police woman to moonlight as a prostitute. I mean she already has the handcuffs 🙂

More seriously, I do have to agree that it is an unacceptable secondary occupation for a police officer. There is a difference between legal and acceptable. I was a strong supporter of prostitution law reform, but that doesn’t mean I want careers counsellors advocating it as a profession in schools etc.

A couple of my friends used to be prostitutes (one male, one female) and from stories they have told, it’s not a lifestyle you recommend. It’s the massive earning power which makes it hard to resist. But they do pay a price.

Desperation

It’s amusing to see Clark try to talk up Winston’s US visit as a success.

As I said, the key thing was to make a good impression for future meetings. And after the McCain meeting, the State Department would have quickly done a briefing note for Condi along the lines of:

“Volatile and unstable. Do not agree to a joint press conference with him, as he may cut you off. Also do not mention the media at all to him. Also please remember that you can’t discuss trade or defence issues with him”

Server Change

On top of upgrading the software earlier this week, the blog is also shifting to a new server and host. It is hoped this will mitigate many of the performance issues of recent months.

During the change, the blog may be unavailable for periods of time. It is hoped to have the transfer completed today, but note that the DNS changes may take a couple of days to propogate.

“Cool” National presentation

Scoop kindly has put up a copy of the “Cool National” presentation that was delivered to Regional Conferences.

It’s status has of course been elevated to a formal marketing plan, when I think it was more a thought provoking powerpoint.

Beneath the hilarity of the choice of bands etc, there is a serious message that National does need to appeal to younger voters. It’s not so much being cool, but being seen as “acceptable”. The challenge of appealing to both urban liberals and provincial conservatives.

The Dom Post also has a story on the presentation.

Helen – he’s your problem

Helen has to do her job and talk to WInston about the level of behaviour needed to remain Foreign Minister. She made him Foreign Minister when she didn’t have to, so it is her problem. NZ First was willing to just do a confidence and supply agreement without any Ministerial jobs, but she decided to go for more.

She is so embarrassed by Peters, she avoided the media herself yesterday. Not good enough.

Last night TVNZ reported not only his antics during the McCain meeting, and his cancelling the press conference afterwards, but also that he had even refused to detail his itenerary, so the media had to jump into taxis and follow his car like some third rate spy novel.

Let’s be very clear. We the taxpayer are funding Winston’s travel as Foreign Minister. His travel is public, not private. The only way we can judge how well he is doing hos job is by there being media coverage – seeing we can’t all fly over to DC ourselves. His attempts to avoid media scrutiny of his job is offensive and undemocratic. It is the antics of a bully boy who purports to be above scrutiny.

Lots of coverage (domestically and internationally) today. The NZ Herald have a story and audio link.

The Dom Post covers the Rice meeting (halved in time from 60 to 30 minutes) and how the McCain meeting the meeting is now being labelled a diplomatic disaster.

One should also read the Press story that shows Peters blatantly lied to cover up. Peters claimed:

The only low-point of the meeting was the intrusion by New Zealand media. They arrived late but were admitted by Senator McCain’s secretary part-way through the meeting to take some photos.

And Tracy Watkins in The Press:

They had in fact arrived 20 minutes before Peters, and he had to walk past them on his way into McCain’s office.

I know who I believe. Helen – it’s time to neuter the poodle, or alternatively have him put down.

Heated Interview

A spokeswoman for the vile church/family which protests outside military funerals (because God killed the solider, as the military allows gays now) is interviewd on Fox News.

Watch the interview, with the anchor telling the woman she should burn in hell herself, and should leave the country.

Upgraded

A huge thanks to Gordon K who has spent most of the day upgrading the blog to the latest version of Movable Type. This won’t solve all the problems with freezes as that will continue until we get a more grunty server (should happen within a fortnight). A lot of the problems have been trackback spam.

The blog design has defaulted to the standard. Some of the extra sidebar features I will add back on manually. But this is an opportunity to tinker with the design so give me feedback as to anything you liked from the old site, and anything you want different on this site.

The Clown Fucks Up

Good God – so much for giving him a chance. I really tried. I blogged on Tuesday a very fair article saying one shouldn’t judge Peters harshly if he doesn’t pull off a “win” with Condi. I even pointed out the McCain meeting was as important, and that Peters has the advantage of having already met him, so could do well there.

But what does the stupid little clown do. He acts like a five year old in front of the big boys, and interrupts John McCain, while McCain was talking up a US-NZ Free Trade Agreement. Why? To play media manager and punish the media or something.

Good God, you’re meant to be the Foreign Minister of New Zealand, and you let your feud with the media over-ride any common sense. The future President of the United States is praising NZ, and you cut him off just to punish the media. Plus you have been playing hide and seek all day with One News and other media. God, just grow up.

It’s already been picked up by The Australian.

UPDATE: The Press Editorial this morning is well titled: Walking the poodle

Also NewstalkZB are already reporting it may have damaged relations, and that Peters is making it worse by sulking further and cancelling the post meeting press conference.

Covering the Ingram Report

The Herald coverage is generally quite good, except they need to shoot the sub-editor who came up with “Field exonerated“.

They correctly report that:

Dr Ingram also raised concerns about some of Mr Field’s versions of events and memory lapses, and suggested some of the evidence of other witnesses was “rehearsed”. He made it clear his inquiry was hampered by his inability to require people to give evidence. A significant number of witnesses refused to be interviewed.

Dr Ingram was unable to resolve several key questions and said if they were to be resolved, it “would be necessary for an authority with appropriate powers of investigation to inquire further”.

John Armstrong in his column is scathing:

Reading the damning report of Noel Ingram, QC, into the dealings of Taito Phillip Field, MP, it is hard to judge which is worse: the MP’s dubious behaviour or Labour’s shabby attempts to whitewash it.

Yesterday was a distinct low point for Labour in terms of putting power ahead of principle. And the party knows it.

Armstrong also paints the way to what Labour should do:

Labour should be instituting a full judicial inquiry with powers of subpoena to get the answers Mr Ingram could not because of his restricted terms of reference.

Labour should be looking at instigating expulsion proceedings against the Mangere MP rather than meekly applauding him.

Labour is harbouring someone who, by any reading of the Ingram report, has misused his position as an MP and used would-be migrants as cheap labour for personal benefit.

The Dominion Post also covers nicely the lack of co-operation by witnesses, and the call for a full inquiry.

Miss Universe 2006

The Power Line blog is most well known for its role in exposing the fakes used in the CBS story on Bush’s military service – they effectively forced Dan Rather off the screens.

But this week they return to their far more important duty – providing a short-list of those who may win the Miss Universe pageant.

My favourite to date is Miss Iceland:

IS29-thumb.jpg

The Ingram Report

Having now read the 160 pages of the Ingram Report, which cost almost $500,000, my conclusions are as follows:

– Mr Noel Ingram QC has done a fine job in chronicling the doings of Taito Field

– The multiple instances of appalling judgment, or worse, by Taito Field, should get have him denounced by his party leadership

Tim Selwyn jailed

It was with sadness I saw the story e-mailed to me this afternoon that Tim Selwyn got sentenced to jail for two months for his sedition conviction. That is a very heavy price to pay for a “press release”.

He also has been sentenced to a further 15 months in prison in relation to a ten year old fraud. I’m slightly puzzled by that, with some details provided by Bomber Bradbury on Tim’s blog.

It is weird and sad to think of Tim spending seventeen months in jail. Not that I have ever met Tim, but as a blogger he has generally been a polite and sensible adviocate for his views. I hope he is eligible for home detention as I certainly don’t see society being at any risk unless he is behind bars every night.

Having said that, Tim has done some pretty stupid things over the years, and may this mark the end of that chapter in his life.

Auckland Rates

The NZ Herald in today’s editorial absolutely lashes Mayors Hubbard, Curtis and Wood for their posturing over rate rises.

Key extracts:

– That the article continues in this silly vein … tells us more than they intend about the calibre of our civic leaders.

– If this is so, the weakness of Auckland’s local government leadership is worse than we feared.

– If rate increases are needed to maintain ordinary council operations, our elected representatives are letting us down

– Political representation is the only means we have of putting local bodies under the sort of financial discipline that competition exerts on private firms

The Herald gets it dead right with their summary:

There is no excuse for any organisation to need revenue increases of 8 to 10 per cent a year, every year. Many an operation in the private sector manages to increase the volume and quality of its output by using its existing resources more efficiently. Councils never seem to produce productivity improvements because they are under no apparent pressure to do so.

Winston and Condi

I suspect commentators are going to simplify the upcoming meeting between Winston and Condi, so that hey can declare it either a failure or a triumph, when in fact it will be neither – however it will still potentially be important.

An initial meeting between two Foreign Ministers will be strongly choreographed in advance. Diplomats will have worked to ensure that there are no surprises. Condi will know exactly what NZ wants her to say, and NZ will know exactly what Condi will say. So any words that come out of it, will have nothing to do with the actual Foreign Ministers, but the skill of their staff in negotiating a win-win.

Now if it is all down to the staff, why even have foreign ministers and such meetings? Well it is because personal relationships can move mountains in this area. The aim of an initial meeting is to establish a good personal relationship with your counterpart so that you can work outside the square with them in future.

A good foreign (and trade) minister develops contacts, and once they have done so, they actually start adding value to international meetings. There is no magic formula to this – just time, intelligence and effort and the right personality.

So when the meeting occurs on Thursday, ignore simplistic analysis which says it was a failure because we are still banned from defence exercises or a success because we were upgraded from “very very very good friend” to “an excellent friend” or similiar superficialities.

The reality is no-one will know for months or years how sucessful it was. Once there is a second or third meeting. Once our Foreign Minister can ring the US Secretary of State directly, you know that all the work is paying off.

The other advice I have for pundits is to place more emphasis on the John McCain meeting. You see Peters has already meet McCain, and so at this second meeting will be able to start to forge a good personal relationship. And this could be incredibly beneficial in future to NZ, as every poll in the US shows that if John McCain is the Republican nominee for President, he would take almost every state.

de Menezes shooting

I am bemused that no police officers are being charged with the shooting of Jean Charles de Menezes at a tube station, yet the Police will be charged with breaking health and safety laws!!

Considering they shot de Menezes seven times in the head, I’m not sure how that qualifies as merely unsafe! Think if OSH were around at the time of WWII – the Nazis would be facing chargs of failure to provide a safe genocide!!

Internet Police

The Police are setting up pro-active Internet patrols!

As easy as it is to crack jokes about it, it’s actually a good thing that the funding for the e-crime unit is expanding. I know from first hand experience that they have been so over-worked that complaints haven’t been able to be given the necessary priority.

Predictable

Meet the Friends

Friday Night was Meet the Parents, so Saturday was the more critical Meet the Friends. One can survive not having parental approval, but not having the okay from the friends can be lethal.

So I’m told to turn up to a house in Island Bay mid afternoon. Now most people will not know where Tiber Street is, but it is just one block away from my childhood home and the house in question I actually used to deliver newspapers to, so I had no problems finding it.

All up, there are 14 of us – eight girls, six guys. Initial game is a music quiz game called Buzz (Play Station 2 game), which thanks to my civil union with Andy, we actually won. Those who know my musical skills will correctly conclude that the division of labour was that Andy tells me which button to push and I pushed it!

Then we played the famous Hat Game. Yes it is really called the Hat Game. It’s a bit like Game of Two Halves but about celebrities.

Each person writes the names of six celebrities down, and puts them in a hat. So we have a total of 84 celebrities. Then you split randomly into two or in this case three teams. After this, starts Round One where a team has 60 seconds to guess as many names as possible. One team member pulls out a name, and describes the celebrity so that his or her team mates can guess who it is. At the end of 60 seconds, the hat goes to the next team, and it keeps rotating until all 84 names are correctly guessed.

Now it can get quite hilarious when someone doesn’t really know the celebrity and has to describe them, as they do it quite badly. Our team had Serah give us a clue of “A woman, slightly handicapped”. We used up our entire 60 seconds trying to guess who this was. In desperation I named my “companion” which went down well with everyone else playing, but less so with her. Finally we found out the name was Helen Keller!! I snarkily suggested that a woman who is blind, deaf and almost mute could be better described than “slightly handicapped”!

The most hilarious incident though wasn’t from that night, but from a few years ago, as I was told the tale of how the companion was having to do the descriptions for her team, and she was telling them that this person was a character in Lord of the Rings. They went through all the well-known characters but none of them guessed correctly – probably because Ghandi wasn’t actually in Lord of the Rings 🙂

Round Two has all the names put back in the hat and is identical to Round One except the person reading the name can only use one word to give you a clue. Hence you need to have remembered all the answers from the previous round.

Finally in Round Three it is Charades, where the name reader can’t speak at all. Gets very amusing as Britney Spears is shown as a woman dropping her baby. I won’t describe how Jenna Jameson and Devine Brown were portrayed!

We then headed out to dinner at Hede on Cuba Street. It’s a great place – good food, good atmosphere. After the meal, the boys insisted we do shots at the bar to celebrate my birthday. The fact that it wasn’t actually my birthday was dismissed as a triviality, and we proceeded to sample the bar wares. They even let me behind the bar at one stage to find any further liqueurs we hadn’t sampled. Thank God they had no Chartreuse!

After many rounds, we finally called it a night. Somewhat amused that the food came to only 15% of my total bill! Despite my clear desire to return home at this stage, I was further dragged down town and we ended up in that Karaoke bar in the Oaks Complex. To my great amusement I ran into my gym trainer there who is terrified I will tell everyone at her work she does karaoke 🙂

Finally got to head home, I think some stage after midnight. The friends tolerated my company very well, and everyone had a great night. And best of all didn’t even have a hangover on Sunday.

Obesity Taxes

Once again a group of do-gooders (in this case the CDHB) think tax is the solution to everything, and have called for GST on fruit and vegetables to be scrapped plus a fat tax on junk food.

Do these people ever go to a supermarket? Do they really think that if apples are $2.60 a kg instead of $2.95, suddenly hundreds of thousands of families will buy apples instead of coke?

The GST we have is regarded as one of the best in the world for compliace costs because of the limited exemptions. Australia has a nightmare situation with its exemptions as some sorts of breads have GST, while others do not etc.

And a “fat tax” will be just as much of a nightmare for retailers. Do you stick it on coke, but not diet coke? And dairy products such as cheese can have as much fat in them as “junk” food. In fact isn’t junk food just a label?

If kids are getting fatter, it is probably just as much to do with lack of exercise. Perhaps a tax in TV watching or video game playing would be more effective (yes I am kidding).

Judith Collins

I’ve always thought the worst thing that can happen to an MP is for the media to dub them a future leader. Up until the day you become leader (if you ever do) you are seen as never living up to the mantle. Plus of course all the unwelcome attention it draws etc.

So I’m not sure how welcome Deborah Coddington’s endorsement of Judith Collins will be, despite the fact it is a nice profile.

I also love in the story, the Margaret Thatcher quote:

Being powerful was like being a lady – if you have to tell people you are, you aren’t

More assessment problems

I’m somewhat staggered by the HoS report that for the last two years almost 30% of internally assessed school work has been found to be incorrect by external moderators.

I would expect you would always have 5% or so seen differently, but 30% incorrect just means that once more students, parents and employers can not rely on NCEA as a useful guide to learning and achievement. As an employer I doubt I could place any reliance on NCEA as a guide to job suitability.

A further HoS story reports:

– no school, or teacher, has ever been banned from marking because of the discrepancies.

– Principals say the marking farce has reached epidemic proportions and blame an “appalling” lack of internal assessment checks.

– Students can now go through their entire school career, and gain university entrance, without ever sitting an external exam.

The final word has to go Rory Barrett, head of maths at Macleans College.

“If I wanted to, I could get my cat through just about any internal unit standard,”

Meow!

A lovely day

Wellington is lovely today – not just warm but actually hot. A great day to be around Oriental Bay. Got up at 11 am, lunch with the parents, a visit to Oriental Bay, a bit of revenue generating activity this afternoon (while watching Hornblower on My Sky) and then DVDs this evening.

Competitive Board Game Playing

I enjoy a good board game as much as anyone, and not only play them with friends fairly regularly (Knights and Cities of Catan rocks!) but I have a wee bit of a reputation for being extremely competitive. This has rubbed off on some of the others so winning becomes extremely important to be able to call the others losers until the next game.

How-ever not even I get as competitive as this game of scrabble in Rotorua.

During the game Brendon Tahu was bashed 40 times with a silver aluminium baseball bat, and stabbed five times in the back.

Two of his fellow scrabble players are charged with his murder. Annoyingly though we don’t know who won the scrabble!

Princess Diana photo

The British newspapers have gone beserk (hypocritically so) at the Italian publication which has published a photo of the late Princess Diana after the accident which killed her.

Now the photo is below, and it isn’t a gruesome photo – in fact fairly unremarkable if one didn’t know the victim.

Having said that, the poor woman has been dead almost ten years, and her kids shouldn’t have to put up with all this crap all their lives. But the British newspapers are far worse offenders at not letting her rest in peace.

diana-chi.jpg

Hat Tip: Kieren McCarthy