MFAT accountability to Parliament

What does it mean when Murray McCully and liberal blogger No Right Turn agree on an issue?

Either:

“Today’s temperature in Hell is a a brisk -5 degrees”

Or someone has done something so wrong that everyone can see it.

The culprit in this case is MFAT who don’t seem to understand that their accountability to Parliament is not under the Official Information Act, and this required the Foreign Affairs and Defence Select Committee to reprimand them by noting:

We are concerned that such a substantial and senior agency of state such as the Ministry of Foreign Affairs and Trade does not understand its obligations to Parliament.

Now remind me again who the Minister of Foreign Affairs is?

Broadcasting Parliament

The Dominion Post slams Parliament’s plan to broadcast itself, but I couldn’t disagree with them more.

In a typical “old media” mindset they say that and their colleagues cover Parliament entirely adequately, and that anyone wanting more than that can use Hansard or turn up in person.

Well I don’t want the Dominion Post choosing for me what parts of Parliament I can view. I believe that Parliament is best held accountable by improving remote access to its functioning.

So I don’t just want the House broadcast whenever it is sitting, let alone the current question time only. Ideally I want every select committee to be broadcast or at least webcast. I want to be able to witness remotely submissions to select committees etc.

Finally I note that the Dom Post editorial refers to how James King, deaf and 16 months old, had to wait for a needed operation, and they suggest that the Govt should be spending money on such operations instead of broadcasting Parliament.

I have an alternate solution to help fund such operations. It could start charging rent on the press gallery offices, and use that rent to fund more operations. After all why should multinational companies worth billions of dollars get free accommodation from the taxpayer?

Dinner with Parents

Heh this has been very amusing. Last night I had dinner with my current “companion” and her parents. The restaurant was out of town for me, so I was greatly amused to be told by said companion that I can “stay the night” afterwards if I want to, but it will be in the spare room. Brings back memories of of being a teenager!

Even more amusing was to later learn the mother doesn’t mind if I don’t stay in the spare room all night!!!

Foreign Aid

Bob Geldof has labelled the level of official foreign aid as “shameful” and “pathetic”.

It’s true it is almost the lowest in the world at 0.27% against a target of 0.70% and the OECD average of 0.42%.

However I’ve always regarded private donations as the best way to assist. Personally I would rather be able to donate $500 to say the Red Cross whom I have faith in delivering, than having the Government hand over money to other Governments which then embezzle much of the aid.

National Leadership

Fran O’Sullivan talks about National leadership, in the backdrop of the Australian Liberal Party leadership issue.

I think Fran is a bit tough on Don over the TV3 Poll handling. She says he should have refused to discuss his leadership at all, and just pointed people to the Roy Morgan poll which showed National 8% ahead.

Taking these in reverse order, I understand that National drew attention to the Morgan poll at every opportunity. The fact the media only regard as news worthy the polls which put National behind, is not Don’s fault. To be fair some media did mention the Morgan poll in reporting the TV3 poll.

As for whether Don should be more “gifted in the dark arts of politics” and brush off any talk of leadership – I’m not sure I agree. Certainly that would be my advice for other MPs, but a large factor in Don’s appeal is that he isn’t a typical politician – he does answer the question, he does acknowledge when he stuffs up etc etc.

However John Armstrong also agrees with Fran, so perhaps it could have been handled better.

Waste Watch

National has launched a waste watch site, which one can access through the banner link below.

masthead.jpg

My favourite is the phone help scheme which with 12 staff at a time staffing it, means they have to cope with three calls a day each – for the cheap price of $1.02 million.

June 2006 Polling Newsletter

Curia’s June 2006 polling newsletter will be e-mailed out this afternoon. You can subscribe to it here.

The newsletter also covers early July including the latest polls in the UK and Australia as PMs Howard and Blair both face leadership rumblings.

Below is an extract of one graph showing the current positions of the parties in NZ, based on the weighted average of all public polls.

june06polls.JPG

Police Recruitment

The Labour/NZ First pledge to increase police numbers by 1,000 is looking increasingly shaky, and as Simon Power points out they are already on Plan B after just 13 days. Actually one can argue they are on Plan C.

Plan A – recruit 1,000 extra police on top of replacing retiring extra Police.

Plan B – lower fitness standards

Plan C – target teenage school-leavers

So what will be Plans D onwards? Maybe:

Plan D – reduce minimum height restriction to 4’6″

Plan E – allow police to charge protection money to supplement earnings

Plan F – designate all parking wardens as police officers

Plan G – strike profit-sharing deal with Mongrel Mob, in exchange for Mob acting as recruitment arm

IUSY

It seems like half of the NZ left blogs are heading overseas to theInternational Union of Socialist Youth Festival in Austria.

You have to love any organisation which still has a body called a “Presidium” – it sounds so Soviet 🙂

To be fair I’ve actually served on a UN Working Group with the former head of the IUSY and he was a great guy – got on very well. In fact the three political reps (the socialists, liberals and conservatives) often get on well as they all have an interest in politics, and hence more in common than reps from the non political groups.

Psychotherapists on S59

Ha – this NZPA report on the Psychotherapists submission on S59 is amusing.

First of all they try to argue that the biblical proverb “spare the rod and spoil the child” doesn’t refer to hitting people with a rod, as in biblical times the rod was used to guide and point people in the right direction, not “thrash” them.

I must have missed the point at which the Society of Psychotherapists became biblical and theological experts. Perhaps they have repressed memories from a prior life living with Moses.

Incidentially the better argument against the biblical proverb isn’t to try and argue it means something it clearly doesn’t, but to point out the bible also called for killing people who work on the sabbath, and times change.

But the other gem from the Psychotherapists was linking French football captain Zinedine Zidane’s head butting of an Italian player who was taunting him, with smacking of children. Yes, seriously – they did!

Craters of Moon

Law Society has it right

The Law Society has called for Section 59 to be amended, not repealed. A good common sense position.

They made the very useful point that:

… simply repealing the section without any kind of replacement would create a legal vacuum.

and also that

Failing to replace the section also gave parents little guidance on what was acceptable.

The Law Society has proposed a definition of reasonable force that specifically banned any discipline that caused “bodily harm” and striking of any kind above the shoulder, and that crrective action would also have to be the “sole” cause for the discipline with any other factors found to be involved negating the defence.

I hope their submission forms the basis fo a compromise that the sensible MPs can agree on. I am sure there are at least a dozen Labour MPs who don’t want to criminalise parental smacking.

Zidane should try cricket

Zinedine Zidane has said he attacked defender Marco Materazzi during the World Cup soccer final to defend the honour of his mother and sister.

Boy if he can’t handle that sort of sledging he should try playing cricket, where it gets really rough. Wikipedia has the goodies including my favourites:

Australian Merv Hughes to Englishman Robin Smith: “Does your husband play cricket as well?”

Merv Hughes & Viv Richards. During a test match in the West Indies, Hughes didn’t say a word to Viv, but continued to stare at him after deliveries. Viv said “This is my island, my culture. Don’t you be staring at me. In my culture we just bowl.” Merv bowled him out soon after and replied “In my culture we just say fuck off.”

Glenn McGrath to Zimbabwean Eddo Brandes after Brandes had played and missed at a McGrath delivery: “Oi, Brandes, why are you so fucking fat?” to which Brandes replied: “Cos every time I fuck your wife she gives me a biscuit!” Apparently even the Australian slips were in hysterics.

Mark Waugh standing at second slip, the new player Adam Parore comes to the crease playing and missing the first ball. Mark –

IP nails it

It is not often I come across a blog post which so stuns me, I don’t know how to even start to have a sensible discussion of it. How-ever Insolent Prick reminds me that parody is the best way to cope, so I repeat below his parody, and you can see via his site what he is parodying.

My friend just bought a puppy. Ever since I heard that he bought that dog, I

Drunk Girls

Drunk Girls can be very amusing sometimes. Last night as I am watching DVDs with friends I get not one but around 12 phone calls from Drunk Girl 1. Eventually I agree after DVDs to pick up DG1 from the pub and drop her home.

On the way to picking up, get further phone call asking if I can drop her friends off also. I agree and then find out later that this means I am doing drop offs from Miramar to Whitby!!

Then in car we have Drunk Girl 2 on back seat. She is fascinated by the large box I have on it and decides it must be presents for her. Despite my insistence that the box contains nothing intersting she insists it must.

So for several minutes DG2 rips it open, removes all the packing, and finally gets to the contents. She then loudly complains that the presents are just some supermarket survey forms!! I am berated for my boring presents.

Finally get home close to midnight and with a back seat full of survey forms and packing paper!

US Visit for BFM

The Herald reports on the planned US visit for our Beloved Foreign Minister. Winston, not Phil, that is.

I am bemused by the suggestion that having him meet the US Secretary of State would be a coup. It is absolutely normal and expected for one Foreign Minister to meet another. Meeting the President or the VP would be a coup.

It does remind me of when Phil Goff came back from a US visit and claimed to have met the US National Security Council. He got taunted about this for ages because in fact he just met some NSC staffers. If he had met the actual NSC that would be the President, VP, Sec State, Sec Defence, NSA, JSC Chair, CIA Director etc.

The Onion Strikes Again

Oh this is funny. Most netizens know about The Onion – the leading US satire site.

Well a blogger came across an old archived article from 1999 where a Miss Caroline Weber talks about how she is thrilled and looking forward to finally having an abortion. Typical Onion satire.

Anyway the March Together For Life blogger attacks Miss Weber for her article. He has 750 comments pointing out that the article is not real and The Onion is a satirical site.

He then responds a few days later, saying well the article may be satricial but he knows women like her who do enjoy abortions etc. He now has 602 comments on that post pointing out that there is no Miss Weber – everything about the article is satirical.

My God there are some very stupid people out there.

Hat Tip: Maia

Way Cool!

I’ve had a Blackberry 8700 for a couple of weeks and it is already surgically attached to me. It is great to be able to leave my laptop at home yet still keep up with e-mail and appts during the day. Oh yeah plus make calls on it.

Anyway just discovered a very cool feature. I had an e-mail from a journalist asking me to call. Now I was just about to try and memorise the phone number, click out of the e-mail, into the phone dialog and then dial off memory.

But I noticed a broken underline of the phone number in his e-mail. Curious I clicked on it and sure enough it automatically dialled the number. Now that is bloody useful. Even better it converts all numbers into the standard + 64 xxxxxxxx format regardless of whether it is down as (09) or 09 or 00 64 9 etc. That is seriously useful.

NZ Living Standards

It is worth reading the Overview of NZ Living Standards just published by MSD. Some fasiniating data.

I despite the traditional poverty definitions before they have nothing to do with poverty and are just about how much income distrubution you have. The poverty industry defines poverty so that a communist economy would have no poverty ever. In NZ if you cut 25% off the incomes of all those earning over $40,000, then you would officially have less poverty.

The NZLS uses a Economic Living Standard Index which while not perfect is a world acclaimed good research tool. For example in 2004 they found:

– 76% have a living standard of at least “fairly comfortable” to “very good”
– 96% have warm bedding
– 97% have a washing machine

Also have vs want:

– 79% of those wanting Internet access have it
– 64% of those wanting pay TV have it

At the bottom end, the survey found 8% of NZers live in “severe hardship”. Now living standards are not just about income. They found:

Low income people whose incomes are principally from income-tested benefits have generally low living standards, with more than a quarter in

NZUSA changes name

Homosexual Law Reform 20 years on

It seems incredible that it was only 20 years ago that homosexual acts (and effectively homosexuality) was illegal in NZ. The law change was hugely polarising and dominated the news for months on end. Today I doubt one could find even 5% of the population who seriously think that there should be a law which dictates what sort of sex two consenting adults can have in the privacy of their own bedroom.

I often find it hard to comprehend how only 100 years ago women were not regarded as “able” to vote and how the US remained basically segregated by race until less than 40 years ago. Having seen NZ society change so quickly, it is a good reminder not to be so judgemental of past eras. I am sure today’s 20 year olds can understand how those aged 40+ lived in a time when private sexual acts were illegal, and effectively homosexuality was underground.

The “wrongness” of the pre 1986 law can be seen in how gays and lesbians were portrayed and seen. Up until law reform gay sex was often associated with public toilets and this contributed to it being seen as “perverted”. Today that phenomenon seemed to have almost died out because “queers” looking for partners or sex can go to nightclubs, use the Internet, advertise publicly etc. It was society’s forcing of homosexuality underground that led to much of that behaviour, which led to a vicious cycle where forcing it underground made it easier to maintain support for its illegality.

Incidentally I recall gay friends saying that public toilet sex wasn’t something to do with being gay as much as male, and they suggested that if there was a known public toilet where hetero guys could go and be guaranteed to find a woman to screw, that there would be queues around the block!!

The other thing which strikes me looking back is how stereotypes of gays over-shadowed the reality. I recall at school anyone a bit effeminate was taunted as gay. Shameful in hindsight. But so few people had gay friends or colleagues back then.

Since the law reform, which led to so many people being able to come out and be known as gay with it being no big thing the dynamic has shifted so much for the better. At every job I have held in the last 15 years some of my colleagues have been gay and you know when their partner who attends the xmas party turns out to be the same sex, it is just not even significant.

I think I have mentioned before that I initially opposed the law change. It was no surprise really having been to a single sex boys school where no-one was “out” and the stereotype was these randy sex mad gays would pounce on you in the toilet. University was incredibly liberating for me as after a few months there my world-view changed 100%. I even ended up in the mid 90s being the Honorary Returning Officer for the Gay Assn of Professionals for a couple of years as a friend of mine helped set it up. Was amusing to be the only straight person out of 50 – 100 at the meetings 🙂

I suspect the US with its race problems has been similar. Now that “blacks” such as Colin Powell and Condi Rice has served with distinction at the highest levels, it is a lot harder for bigotry to survive and people to really think that your colour somehow limits your ability.

No Right Turn has a good series of links to articles about how much things have changed in 20 years. I certainly agree that the NZ of today is a far better place to live in than what Idiot/Savant calls “an alien past”. But at the time it was not alien, it was just the way it was.

UK Leaked E-mails

Don’s not the only Opposition Leader with a leaked e-mail problem. UK Tory Leader David Cameron has had e-mails sent to him from his parliamentary aide (an MP) leaked.

Extracts include:

– Francis Maude, the party chairman, described as “not yet trusted by the parliamentary party”

– Theresa May, the shadow Commons leader, said to be “neither liked nor trusted across the party”.

– a senior backbencher, was described as “Mr Angry”

– a loyal group of followers called the Industry and Parliament Trust was maligned as “a bunch of boring colleagues with nothing better to do”.

– William Hague, the shadow foreign secretary, was accused of briefing the media against the party line and of “wobbling” on the issue.

These make the ones to Brash look positively boring and rountine in comparison.

62 question meme

Labour’s 90th

All things considered, you’d have to be pretty happy to be a Labour Party activist at the time of their 90th birthday.

A few years ago it was very different. From 1949 to 1999 Labour were in power for only 12 out of 50 years. They had two one term Governments and one two term Government which most of them are now ashamed of. National was regarded as one of the most successful democratic parties in the world in terms of election wins.

Today Labour are in their third term of Government – for the first time since WWII. They have a reasonable, say 40% to 45% chance of winning a fourth term and if they do might get to claim that precious label as the natural party of Government.

Factionalism seems largely dead in their party, or at least until Clark steps down as Leader. Most activists wants the Government to be more leftish, but accept the pragmatic decisions of Clark, even though they don’t always like them.

So yes all in all a pretty good place to be for their 90th.

Tony Milne has a copy of his speech to Canterbury Labour for the 90th celebration. I like the speech as it comes from a background of personal conviction. One interesting thing though is as Tony recounts great Labour moments of the past he can’t really point to any of this Government except being in power and not sending troops to Iraq (overlooking she did send some actually). And this is not Tony’s fault – Clark will leave behind a legacy of capable control of power, but no vision, no major achievements. Cullen if anyone can claim major achievements such as the Superannuation Fund.

Spot the mistakes