The talent-free zone

Chris Trotter brutally assesses the new Labour MPs as a talent-free zone.

He says that since the early 1990s, only a handful of new MPs have shown promise, and most of them ended up blotting their copy book.

Trotter says that the Labour selection system is set up to favour those who win patronage from one of the three powerful sector groups – the affiliated trade unions, the Women’s Council, and the Rainbow Council.

Now it is interesting to look at the top ranked new candidates on Labour’s 2005 list. After Shane Jones at 27 we have the next six new candidates:

STREET, Maryan – female, gay
MORONEY, Suzanne Mary – female, unionist
FENTON, Darien Elizabeth – female, unionist
CHAUVEL, Charles Pierre – gay, lawyer for unions
SOPER, Lesley Frances – female, unionist
WALL, Louisa Hareruia – female, gay

Now this is not to say on an individual level, any of the above won’t be good MPs – Maryan Street for example is already regarded as doing well. But it does reinforce Trotter’s point that the way to get elected from Labour is to have backing or be a member of one of those three groups.

Another tertiary scam

At the same time as Labour is trying to destroy most private education providers (which I will detail separately), it is still allowing publicly owned polytechnics to rort the system.

The Nelson Marlborough Institute of Technology has had $5 million of funding for what appears to be a Cool IT type scam. The course has

* no tuition
* no assessment
* no qualification

This is just incompetence of the highest level that years after these scams were exposed, Labour is allowing them to continue. The issue isn’t whether they are approved by the Tertiary Education Commission. The issue is that the policies as set by the Minister allow this to happen.

As I have said many times one could halt all these scams within days by merely requiring a minimal fee to be charged for courses. That is why the market is not working – because students can sign up for free, so they don’t evaluate the merits of the course.

Bill English points out that the Polytechnic doesn’t even have half as many computers as it would need to run the course if everyone they got funding for turned up.

Whenever Labour goes on about how there is no money for tax cuts, remember the hundreds and hundreds of millions they have wasted on some of these scams. Now it’s no disgrace to find that people are starting to rort a system and you need to change the system. But it is an absolute disgrace that years and years later they are still doing it!

Reminiscent of the dying years of Sir Robert Muldoon’s reign

“It’s all horribly reminiscent of the dying years of Sir Robert Muldoon’s reign” is how Fran O’Sullivan describes Helen Clark’s “tired tactics of demonising her opponents as ‘unpatriotic’ when they tell the truth about New Zealand’s declining international competitiveness.”

O’Sullivan points out that Muldoon’s classis trick was to “resort to personal attacks rather than debating the substance of critical issues”.

The whole article should be read, especially this part:

If Clark allows Field to play hardball she will have crossed an ethical line from where there should be no real recovery.

The debate should not be about whether Field should force a byelection, but whether the Government is so bankrupt in purpose that a full-scale general election should be held.

t’s barely more than six months since the September election where Labour took power after clearly breaching electoral spending limits.

National Front Adverts

A community newspaper has had dozens of complaints after accepting an advertisement from the National Front (they were politically unaware of the group) calling for equal rights for Kiwi Whites.

The NF are now complaining the newspaper won’t accept any more advertisements.

I believe a newspaper owner has the right to accept or reject any advertising at their discretion. It is their newspaper.

Having said that, personally I don’t think banning their ads is an effective strategy. What I would do is make sure I place a big article on recent arrests of National Front members next to their advert. That way you take their money, and diminish the effectiveness of their ad.

Tana’s Handbag at

Ending the ban on support for National

Nandor Tanczos wants the Greens to drop their ban on propping up National-led governments.

Now this would be an incredibly smart thing for them to do, and I don’t mean that from a National viewpoint. The reality is that the chances of National and Greens ever being able to agree on policies is exceedingly remote.

The reason the Greens need to do this though, is because it is the only way Labour will stop crapping on them from a huge height. Helen Clark shafted the Greens after the election, and she did it because she could do it with inpunity. The moment the Greens said that under no conditions would they support a National-led Government, it mean they lost all leverage with Labour.

If the Greens hold out a possibility in future of supporting (or more likely even abstaining on supply and confidence) for a National-led Government, then Labour would have to actually make them a better offer than watching Winston become Foreign Minister.

Revenge is sweet

Oh dear. A 19 year old sold a laptop on Ebay and he lied about the amount of RAM and more importantly over the fact it did not work. And he ignored requests for a refund.

But the silly wee boy had not securely deleted his hard drive. And on there were photos of him, dozens of photos of women’s feet suggestign a fetish, his scanned passport, some exagerrated CVs (different grades in each) etc etc.

So you guessed it, the disgruntled buyer has put all this on a blog. A blog now viewed by 2.8 million people!

And in the best Internet tradition, there’s now another blog where you can comment on the dishonest seller, and post photoshopped images of him.

I suspect he is now regretting not giving a refund!

Political Dating Guide

Are blogs the new Iowa Caucus?

An interesting article in the Chronicle of Higher Education, suggesting blogs have become the new Iowa Caucus in US Politics.

The Iowa Caucus is the traditionally primary that annoints a front-runner. However just one blog, Daily Kos, has more monthly readers than there are residents in Iowa and New Hampshire.

The article tries to define what blogs are for campaigns, asking:

* Are blogs the new Iowa caucus?

* Are blogs fund-raising machines?

* Are blog posts campaign literature?

* Are blogs “meet the candidate” get-togethers?

* Are bloggers political operatives?

* Are blogs campaign rallies?

* Are blogs television ads?

* Are blogs talk radio?

And it just keeps getting bigger

No wonder Dr Cullen was unhappy people keep linking surpluses with room for tax cuts – it just keeps getting bigger.

Treasury has released the Crown accounts for the 10 months to 30 April 2006.

The operating balance or surplus is $9.4b over just ten months. OBERAC is at $7.4b. But none of it is available to greedy journalists – okay!!

Oh yeah and net debt (excluding super fund) is almost non existant at $7.9b.

Crown revenue is $4.5b higher than a year ago.

Under 1% of kids receiving working for families subsidy

The NZ Herald reveals that less than 1% of children eligible for a childcare subsidy through Working for Families are getting it.

Now bear in mind the Government spent $15 million on WFF advertising, so what can we conclude about this advertising?

I conclude that the advertising was totally misdirected. They spent $15 million or so on flashy TV ads whose main purpose was to make people vote Labour, rather than actual helpful targeted advertising to make families aware of relevant parts of the package.

I would say $2 million spent just on direct mail, and a two-way call centre would have been far more effective.

Tana’s handbag on Trade Me

Will Taito Phillip Field jump?

Labour woes may be set to multiply, with rumours all week that Taito Phillip Field is set to leave Labour. Not for good reasons, but as a threat to Helen Clark, whom he wants to reappoint him as a Minister. As the Executive is already at a record 29, I can’t see him being reappointed.

The Labour-Progressive-NZ First-United Future Government has 61/121 votes. If Field leaves Labour, then they lose their majority. They will still have confidence (as the Greens abstain) but it will mean they will have a much harder task to pass legislation.

So what are the options here:

1) Clark succumbs to blackmail and reappoints Field as a Minister (unlikely, but not impossible if she is desperate enough)

2) Field is not reappointed, listens to reason, and remains a Labour backbencher, maybe with a promise of promotion after the next election if they win.

3) Field resigns from Parliament. Until a new MP is elected, the Government has only 60/120 votes so will have to delay some legislation. It is likely Labour will win the by-election, but you could see a split vote between Labour, Field and the Maori Party.

4) Field defects to United Future (Field is very conservative on moral issues). This would keep the Government as a majority one, but would humiliate Labour. This will not happen though as Peter Dunne is not a stupid man, and he will know allowing Field to defect would be electorally fatal.

5) Field becomes an Independent MP. The Government loses its majority and has a much harder time passing legislation. Labour may then try and get the Electoral Integrity Act passed back into law more quickly so it can expel Field under its provisions.

There are other options such as Field defecting to the Maori Party, but no suggestion to date this has been canvassed.

Field is deeply unpopular within Labour. I would go so far as to say he is detested by the socially liberal wing. He was also widely seen, even putting to one side the conflict of interest allegations, as a pretty dismal Minister who was made a Minister just because he is Polynesian. Now Labour have replaced him in the Ministry with Winnie Laban (who unlike Field is regarded as actually doing a pretty good job as a Minister) so if Clark makes him a Minister again, she will alienate many within her own party, and make Field an easy target for the Opposition.

In the best interest of open Government expect to see Clark make an announcement at 4.30 pm on a Friday 🙂

Dr Cullen shoots some more messengers

I couldn’t blog this last night due to blog problems, but for those who have not seen it, you should click on this link to TVNZ and then click on the “Cullen attacks press over tax cuts (2:22)” related video.

Cullen loses it talking to TVNZ’s Guyon Espiner, accusing the media and press gallery of biased reporting because they personally want tax cuts for themselves.

You hear an incredulous Espiner ask him if he really truly believes that all these reporters are reporting negatively on the budget just because it is a “personal” issue for them.

Probably still unable to believe what he is hearing, Guyon names four senior members of the gallery – himself, Colin (Espiner, Vernon (Small) and Tracy Watkins and specifically asks Cullen (or Dr Sullen as he currently is) if he really thinks those four are reporting on tax cuts, because they personally want one, and not because it is a matter of public interest and Cullen says “absolutely”.

The hilarious thing about this exchange is that Guyon hasn’t just named any four journos, but four people who, well let me just say would not qualify for membership of the Vast Rightwing Conspiracy. For the record I’m not casting any aspersions on their work (overall I think our gallery journalists are pretty good), just saying that if I had to rank the leanings of the press gallery, they wouldn’t be too close to me (which many may say is a good thing :-). So this is what makes the exchange so delicious – Cullen is attacking the very journalists who are least open to criticism on this score.

What this shows is a very pressured and angry Minister of Finance, and also Prime Minister. Earlier in the week you have the PM do a disgraceful attack on Colmar Brunton because she didn’t like a poll result showing 63% think tax cuts are affordable, and now Cullen claims the press gallery is full of greedy journalists who just want some extra cash themselves and have invented this issue.

I think it shows how out of touch the Government is getting. Another highlight was as Dr Cullen almost shouts at Guyon about the Dom Post headline of a $8.5 billion surplus and still no tax cuts, demanding to know what the connection between the two is. Well hello, trying to argue the level of surplus has no relationship to the affordability of tax cuts is almost comical.

What a pity the House is in recess. WIth Dr Cullen’s current mood, I suspect John Key would be able to get a Cullen eruption in the House, which always provides such good future quotes asuch as “We won, you lost, eat that”.

May 2006 NZ Blog Stats

Okay another month gone, another set of blog stats. As usual post your blogname, no of posts and if applicable number of comments as a comment on this post and I’ll update the main post.

UPDATE: Several new blogs this month. Good to see.

David Farrar 226 posts, 4,710 comments
Spitting Llama 153, 70
Lindsay Mitchell 140, 252
No Right Turn 133, 575
Red Letter 122, 32
Iworldpeople 119, 21
Silent Running 106, 754
New Zeal 61, 325
Clouds of Heaven 52, 12
Andrew Falloon 49, 306
House of Honcho 37, 24
Big News 34
IIQ illusions and allusions 33, 60
Michael Ellis 30, 37
Brain Stab 22, 37
Urbancast 22, 0
Tumeke! 19, 70
Backin15 19, 7
Laws Watch 17, 510
Celebrating Mediocrity 17, 64
Random Contributionz 16, 13
Daniel’s View 14, 3
Latitude 45 South 13,0
Mike Heine 12, 51
ACT on Campus 11, 111
Auckland at Large 8, 23
Steve Martin 7, 1
Anarchia 6, 83
Fighting Talk 2

Today is Tax Freedom Day

Today, June 1st, is Tax Freedom Day for New Zealand. Yes it is not until the sixthj month of the year do you stop paying for the Government and start saving money to pay for your own expenses. This is six days later than last year.

Australia had their tax freedom day three weeks ago on the 10th of May. Graphs below show how we compare internationally, and how much later tax freedom day has come in the last few years.

days to pay nations tax bill.jpg

international comparison.jpg

international annual comparison.jpg

Local MPs working together

It’s good to see MPs from different parties working together, for their local areas. You had Sue Kedgley, Mark Blumsky and Marian Hobbs combining to lobby for retaining the Wellington trolley buses.

Now, and more unusually, both Marian and Mark have criticised a Government decision as “crazy” and “shafting” Wellington.

It all relates to a grant for building a visitor and education centre at the Karori Wildlife Sanctuary. You see the Government in June launched a “Significant Community Based Projects Fund”. And it launched it at, of all places, the Karori Wildlife Sanctuary with the PM specifically saying it was the sort of project the $32 million fund aimed to help.

So it is little surprise the local MPs feel “embarrassed and hurt”, as having the PM launch the fund at your project and hold your project up as what the fund was designed for, yet then not be successful with your application.

Bill Hastings

I found it amusing yesterday to listen on the radio to the SPCS explaining why they thought Bill Hastings should stand down as Chief Censor after ten years in the job. They sounded like they were just concerned for his welfare – how horrible it must be for him etc to have spent ten years having to look at such awful stuff, and how you would get desensitised.

Now I think you can have a legitimate debate about whether censors become desensisited, but this is a red herring. The SPCS have campaigned against Bill Hastings for years, mainly it seems because he is gay.

The silly thing with all of this, is that Hastings is not the final authority. His decisions can and do get appealed to the Film and Literature Board of Review.. And off memory they have actually been more permissive than Hastings, so it is perverse that he is the one who gets targetted so much.

A Government booze-free day

Jim Anderton has proposed an annual booze-free day. He obviously has too much time on his hands.

How about something more useful like a tax-free day? One day a year the Government says you can keep everything you earn that day.

I wonder how long it will take for the Government to move from smoke-free days, and booze-free days to bring back car-free days and then no doubt sex-free days. I mean hey they now want to decide what sort of soft drinks kids can buy.

Fire Service Restructuring

I am nervous about what may be the outcome of the fire service restructuring. The professional firefighters (arguably the most militant and feather bedded union in NZ) have longed aspired to reduce or wipe out the volunteer brigades.

As the NZ Herald notes, something of the nation’s life would be lost with the volunteer brigades.

It will be interesting to see what is proposed.

Rakon shares

Now this I find amusing. The Weekend Herald did a big expose on Rakon, and how some of their products are being used in smart bombs, as part of their GPS systems.

I think it was designed to damage Rakon, but as Fran O’Sullivan notes their share price has risen. Up a whole 20c since the weekend, which shows investors are a canny bunch.

Personally I don’t see the objections to what Rakon does. If one is going to have wars, then you are going to have bombs. And if you have to have bombs it is far better than you have smart bombs which hit their intended target than the bombs of old where you just flatten entire cities etc.

Dr Cullen’s surplus projections

I’ve blogged in the past how the Treasury projections of future surpluses have consistently been much less than the actual surpluses – the actual surplus often being twice as large as the projected surplus.

Now it’s a bit unfair to call this a Treasury problem I’ve decided. Why? Because Dr Cullen in recent years has been sticking huge numbers in as “provisions for future initiatives” and by use of this provision you can make the projected surplus be anything at all you want. With a stroke of the pen a $6 billion projected surplus can be reduced to $4.5 billion by allowing just an extra $500 million a year “provision”.

Let me explain. You are projecting for the next three years after the current one. Now the provisions work like this:

Year 1 $500 million
Year 2 = $500 million from Year 1 + additional $500 million = $1billion
Year 3 = $1 billion from Year 2 + additional $500 million = $1.5 billion

So by adding in an extra $500 million a year provision, you knock $1.5 billion off the Year Three surplus.

Now since 1997 it has been common practice to have this provision. It recognises that every year you may have demands for increased expenditure such as wage increases, or some new initiatives. Known initiatives will generally be included in the vote for that portfolio.

In the late 1990s, the average provision was around $600 million. And Dr Cullen for the first couple of years had sensible provisions of $470 million, $480 million, $550 million and $315 million etc etc.

But then in 2004 the provisions started growing like topsy, just at the same time as the surpluses were growing to a degree people weer calling for tax cuts.

In 2004, the provisions for the next three years was $978m, $926m and $1463m.

In 2005 they were $1249m, $1757m and $1845m.

And finally in 2006 they were $1416m, $1868m, and $1913 million.

Now these are cumulative, so year by year the provision is:

07/08 $1,416m
08/09 $3,284m
09/10 $5,197m

So that is almost $10b of “provisions”. And that number is not worked out by Treasury scientifically. It is not based on known demand. It is a policy decision by the Minister of Finance. He gets to decide what number to put in, and by doing so he can move the projected surpluses up or down by billions of dollars.

So when Dr Cullen refers to future surpluses showing tax cuts are unaffordable, remember that he has almost $10b of unallocated provisions in there, with no rationale for them being at that level.

Death of Professor Lloyd

The death of Professor David Lloyd brings back memories of what was called the Poisoned Professor trial.

Personally I don’t think there is too much of a mystery behind his “mystety illness” despite the trial result. I recall quipping at the time that Vicki Calder may have got off, but I bet you she won’t be getting any dates for a while 🙂

Mike Moore on Globalisation

A good speech by former WTO Head Mike Moore to La Trobe University. Some key points:

* growth of freedom and information was also helping consumers demand more from their governments and businesses.

* there has never been a period in the history of our species where we’ve seen freedoms and living standards rise so consistently for most people

*China has undergone huge advances in freedoms of ordinary citizens

* opponents of free trade were effectively arguing to keep the poorest nations of the world in poverty

* the $12 billion the Un wants to fight AIDS, equates to just 12 days of subsidies paid by rich nations to their protected farmers

* open markets means that cosy, crony capitalists with businesses purchasing privileges from politicians against the interests of workers and consumers, doesn’t work

Port Douglas

I’m off to Port Douglas for a holiday at the end of June. Any suggestions for activities from people who have stayed there? I’ve been to Cairns before so have been to the rainforest (will probably visit it again) and some diving or snorkelling on the great barrier reef is mandatory of course.