Radical Youth

They have two students from Radical Youth on Breakfast TV. I wonder if Mr Joseph Minto might be related to Mr John Minto.

Having said that good to see students willing to beat apathy and stand up for something they believe in. Even if they’re wrong!

South Park vs Scientology

Tom Cruise has thrown a tantrum and got Viacom which owns Comedy Central to stop a repeat of the classic “Trapped in the Closet” episode which mocks both Cruise and Scientology.

I just love the response from Parker and Stone:

“So, Scientology, you may have won THIS battle, but the million-year war for earth has just begun! Temporarily anozinizing our episode will NOT stop us from keeping Thetans forever trapped in your pitiful man-bodies. Curses and drat! You have obstructed us for now, but your feeble bid to save humanity will fail! Hail Xenu!!!

– Trey Parker and Matt Stone, servants of the dark lord Xenu.”

Andrew Sullivan has details of how you can protest to Viacom for their actions

A question for the Police

The decision not to prosecute Labour for over-spending would have been made collectively by the Senior Managament of the Police – the Deputy and maybe Assistant Commissioners.

I wonder how many of those involved with making that decision are applicants for the vacant job of Police Commissioner?

And is it possible they realised that nothing would be more likely to kill their chances off than prosecuting the person who makes the decision on who gets the job? I mean that Helen doesn’t hold a grudge does she!

It will be extremely interesting to see who does get appointed Police Commissioner, and what role they had in the decision making on the over-spending.

The not needed Foreign Minister

Oh dear. The NZ Herald Editorial has said that Winston Peters has shown you don’t need a Foreign Minister as he is shut out of almost all major issues by the PM and the Trade Minister.

The Herald do suggest that Winston could be engaged as say parliamentary undersecretary for overseas aid. Heh.

Cyber Cops

The NZ Herald reports that ” Cyber police are among measures being considered by the Government in a new discussion paper aimed at improving security in information and communications technology.”

This is just one aspect of their report which is online here.

Personally I would find it useful to have more Police who can deal with Internet issues. The e-crime unit are pretty knowledgable but they are very few in number and vastly over worked. Having at least a couple of officers in each police region who are up with the play would be good.

There is also a suggestion NZ looks at setting up a CERT (Computer Emergency Response Team), as most other countries have. By coincidence an issue InternetNZ has been exploring for a while.

You can make submissions at the link provided until 13 April.

David Parker Investigated

Investigate Magazine has put details of their latest cover story on their blog.

Basically they allege (and have documents showing) that the Attorney-General has filed false statements with the Companies Office relating to a private company he is a director of.

Dispelling Student Loan Myths

The SST has a useful article dispelling seven “myths” about student loans. I comment on them below:

1. You have an obligation to pay your loan back.

The SST is right that some people will never have to pay their loan back but they contribute to another myth – that a “failure to pay means the outstanding balance swells like a tumour”. Absolute crap – the loan balance will never ever increase in real terms once you stop studying. It will only increase by the rate of inflation which is not swelling like a tumour. This is widely misunderstood about the current scheme.

2. Women find it particularly hard to repay student loans.

The SST point out that NZUSA’s claim about women taking longer to pay off is not bearing out. Didn’t know that and is useful to know.

3. Higher education is a path to riches.

The SST claim that this is not true as six years after leaving study 25% of former students are earning under $10,000. I disagree with their analysis. The census and QES income shows very clearly that NZers with a degree will earn around $500,000 more in their lifetime than those who do not.

The SST includes references to those who do not graduate and this is misleading. Of course if you fail you papers and do not finish study then you will not be magically more likely to earn money. The more intelligent comparison is between those who do complete a degree and those who do not and there is a significant income gap.

4. Students are slack about money.

Agree with SST. Some are but many are not.

5. The poor have the biggest loans.

Again didn’t know this was a myth. Useful research

6. It takes most people decades to pay their loans back.

Great to see this myth debunked. NZUSA scare mongered with 51 years for a woman and 28 years for a man to repay their loans. In fact looking to be under ten years.

7. The interest-free policy means students will blow their loans on overseas holidays.

The SST point out living costs are no longer lump sum so it’s not as simple as blowing a big cheque twice a year, but that students can still make a lot of money by borrowing unnecessarily and making interest off the money.

Would have also been useful to debunk the myth about the average loan size. I am sure most NZers think it is $50,000 and in fact just a bit over $10,000 if I recall correctly.

Penthouse Party

Oh God the karaeoke has started at the party at The Penthouse. This is a certain sign far too much alcogol has been consumed.

The Penthouse residents have even allowed me to do a guest blog on their site.

Very weird to be singing along to Uptown Girl while the projector is showing Nazi propoganda films! Very bad taste humour but hey if people call ACToids Nazis then might as well live up to the stereotype.

The apartment has a great view from Victoria Street of the inner city. Very nice. Well a lot nicer than the singing which makes up in volume what it lacks in quality.

I am currently on 50/50 mixes of Vodka and Apple Juice. Works quite well I have to say.

UPDATE: Hey some f**ker just took away 3 am and has made it 2 am. This is not acceptable. Oh yeah party still going. Well not really but hard core still drinking. This has been a fun night.

UPDATE2: For the benefit of the concerned citizens out there the film was actually a doco on the war not a propoganada film. One of them PH crew got it from the Imperial War Museum in London.

Rugby and The Treaty

Goodness no end of ways to extend the Treaty of Waitangi. Despite rugby not being introduced to New Zealand until 1870, somehow it is subject to the Treaty of Waitangi.

Bill Bush has called for The All Blacks to have a 50% Maori quota in line with the Treaty. Yeah I also missed seeing that clause.

UK Labour

If you think that NZ Labour is dodgy with its election funding, they are only learning from UK Labour.

As Radio NZ reports Labour has been forced to admit it was secretly loaned 14 million pounds for the last election. That is around NZ$40 million.

The reason Labour does this is to avoid disclosure as donations must be disclosed but loans do not have to be. The difference may be negligible as one can never ask for repayment and have it transferred to a donation upon your death.

Now it gets worse. Three of the loaners, who lent four out of the 14 million pounds have all been offered a Peerage.

Now it is not new that large donors tend to do well with honours, but in the past it has been transparent as one knows the identities of the donors and can judge politically how they feel about them receiving a peerage. But by doing it secretly by having donors do loans instead, one can only conclude the purpose was to hide the connection.

The future of TV

NBC is producing ten web only episodes of The Office to keep fans interested during the off-season.

Delivery over the Internet is the future of television in my opinion. In a decade or so people will not choose channels, they will choose shows on demand. This is one reason why our pitiful broadband with its speeds and data caps need a quantum improvement.

Uncyclopedia

Uncyclopedia is a parody of WIkipedia with grossly inaccurate (and highly offensive entries). As with Wikipedia anyone can edit these.

Entries on Winston Peters who is described being Jim Anderton’s partner (Winston tops and Jim bottoms). Don Brash gets off more lightly.

Also profiles on George Bush and Marcus Crassus.

Also worth reading is the entry on New Zealand.

Battlestar Galactica

Battlestar Galactica keeps attracting growing audiences and rave reviews in the US. They have done a brilliant job of taking the 70s show, and making the new series better than the original.

The Season Two finale screened a couple of days ago. Jacquline Passey has a thread dissecting it.

The series creator, Ron Moore, also has a blog himself in which he regularly discusses aspects of the show and answers questions.

And for those who want a full recap of an episode, the catty Television Without Pity has recaps and commentary.

The season finale has some big plot twists. Very big!

New teacher discipline methods

This Kentucky teacher obviosuly went to the training college which advocates sticking tennis balls in mouths to keep stiudents quiet.

But Caroline Kolb went one better. She bit her student on his upper left shoulder. She was dismissed after admitted to finding fabric in her mouth afterwards!

Why the Police are wrong

The Police decisions not to proceed with prosecutions are embarrassingly badly reasoned. It seems an obvious attempt at deciding not to prosecute and then looking for ways to justify it.

Firstly the Police have said there was sufficient evidence to establish a prima facie case in respect of an offence under s221 of the Electoral Act. Let’s look at the key paragraphs in 221(1).

It says that any advertisement which “encourages or persuades or appears to encourage or persuade voters to vote for a party registered under Part 4 of this Act” must be approved in writing by the Party Secretary and contain the name and address of the person approving the ad.

So this means that the Police did find that the pledge cards constitute an advertisement which “encourages or persuades or appears to encourage or persuade voters to vote for a party”

But then they say there was insufficient evidence ob the over-spending to indicate that an offence under s214b of the Electoral Act had been committed. Let’s look at what definition is used in 214B.

An election activity is defined in Section 214B(1) of the Electoral Act 1993, with the key line being in paragraph (c)(i):

“Which encourages or persuades or appears to encourage or persuade voters to vote for the party”

Okay take note. This is almost the exact same definition as for 221 in regard to needing authorisation. So the Police are saying the pledge cards were an election advertisement which needed authorisation, yet somehow they are not an election activity and expense which uses the same definition.

Now carrying on in 221B we have:

In the same section it goes on to define an election expense as “expenses that are incurred by or on behalf of the party in respect of any election activity” and specifically notes “includes the cost of any printing or postage in respect of any election activity, whether or not the expenses in respect of the printing or postage are incurred by or on behalf of the party”

In today’s Herald the Police try to justify this outrageous and inconsistent decision in relation to the over-spending saying there was insufficient evidence to prosecute overspending, because there was no evidence it had been intentional.

Now Section 214(3) defines the two offences related to over-spending:

Every person who directly or indirectly pays or knowingly aids or abets any person in paying for or on account of any election expenses any sum in excess of the maximum amount prescribed by this section is,

Maori TV ANZAC Day coverage

A wonderful idea by Maori TV to provide non stop coverage day of ANZAC Day – a day fast becoming our de facto national day.

I’m still not convinced that Maori TV is attracting enough viewers to be viable (their 400,000 a month may be only 1,000 people for any one programme) but they seem to be producing some good quality programmes and avoiding the excesses of their predecessors.

The face of abuse

Labour hit with a slightly damp very light very small bus ticket

I am disgusted. The Police have said they will issue a warning [oh how scary] to Labour if they infringe again, but despite *another* prima facie finding of the law being broken, there will be no prosecutions at all. Fucking Incredible.

I actually agreed with Police decisions not to prosecute for paintergate, for Hodgson’s technical assault and for Benson Pope’s assaults. While I was critical of the Ministers making excuses for what they did, I have said that the offending wasn’t so serious as to need prosecution. I have been relatively balanced on the Police using their discretion.

However this case is very different. The over-spending was massive and letting them off just makes a mockery of having spending limits. A $400,000 over-spend is huge.

The Police rationale is also bizarre. You see they have found a prima facie case in relation to the pledge card not being authorised but have said they do not have enough evidence on the charge of over-spending.

Now if you conclude that the pledge card needed to be authorised, then you have concluded it is an election activity because otherwise it would not need authorisation. And if you have done that then that must count towards their spending limit. I can’t see how it can be one but not the other.

I also believe for the record that National should have been charged over the GST mistake with the broadcasting allocation. National admits there was a mistake and too much broadcasting was booked, so the law was broken. I would have expected a Judge to be lenient based on a genuine mistake but believe charges being laid would have been appropriate.

My respect for the NZ Police have just shrunk to near zero. Both the Chief Electoral Officer and the Electoral Commission independently concluded that the pledge card was election spending and Labour over-spent. For the Police to conclude otherwise against the two specialist agencies is astonishing.

This is the Police Force which decides to prosecute an Opposition MP for driving a tractor up some steps, yet time and time again bends over backwards to never take action against infringements by members of the Government.

The fact that Crown Law were meant to consider this matter for another week and a decision has been rushed out today suggests to me they had overlooked the deadline and have rushed this decision through. I look forward to seeing OIAs on the reports and correspondence, though I suspect they will suppress some of it.

Well this has really fired me up and my motto is don’t get mad, get even. If one needed motivation for 2008 you now have it.

Around and about

Morph has four jokes which aren’t bad. I like No 4 the best.

Peter Metcalfe catches Judith Tizard out in a porkie. Of course as the porkie related to Judith claiming to be busy, I doubt anyone believed her in the first place! [Update: porkie accusation retracted – Judith’s office have confirmed she was subbing on a select cmte]

Mike Heine has taken a break from getting Marian Hobbs into trouble and has some nice transcripts from question time on Whangamata Marina.

Liberty Scott blogs on why local content quotas for radio are a nonsense.

No Right Turn keeps up his excellent efforts with details of which private members bills get drawn from the ballot and also descrptions of new bills submitted to the ballot. NRT gives far better coverage of private members bills than the media or even the main parliamentary website.

Clint Heine has details of a Dutch immigration film where they show potential migrants a topless woman emerging from the sea, and advises people that if they can’t bear to watch it, no need to apply. Heh I think I might pass!

Not a blog but in equally bad taste Mike M has pointed out to me the Schapelle Corby Tours website where you can arrange to visit her in prison and have a photo taken with her. I’m pretty sure it’s a joke!

Michael Ellis discovers that kangaroos are now on the loose in Austria as well as Australia. Truly.

Shopping for the Apocalypse

Keith Ng blogs on how his flatmates think he is nuts because he justifies every purchasing decision with “this will/will not be useful in the Apocalypse”.

Now some people may think Keith is exaggerating but as it happens I have been at Keith’s flat when he and flatties have returned from a shopping expedition, and this is literally true.

In the best student traditions they purchased everything in the largest size possible. First a 20 kg sack of rice emerges. I joke to Keith that he must be Asian!

Then they have around half a kilometre of gladwrap. You could have wrapped their flat in it. Also laying in the lounge is 72 rolls of toilet paper. Either someone has a medical condition or it should last for six months or so.

So people if the big one ever strikes Wellington head over to Keith’s. Their little bunker should be able to survive for a year or so.

Press Editorial on Clark

Our Prime Minister has been in the Phillipines where once again she sold out free speech. The Press Editorial says it all:

Rather than, for instance, deploring the extremist threats of death and destruction that followed the cartoons’ publication, and the attempt (largely successful) to intimidate the media into self-censorship, she chose again to emphasise the alleged poor judgment of the editors who used them.

The Prime Minister could have told her audience of multinational religious representatives, some of them from countries that have only the shakiest grip of the idea of freedom, that free speech is not just an optional extra for free and democratic government, but that such government depends upon it. She could have added that free speech consists not just of sober debate and argument, but includes all kinds of abuse, mockery, ridicule and other such verbal and pictorial mayhem, and that no religious or political or other opinion can legitimately impose itself on the others to protect itself from such stuff. She could have added much more besides in defence of this essential element of the western political tradition to which she is heir.

As a figure on the Left of politics, Clark has often claimed to speak up for the rights of others. It is deeply disappointing that in the face of an unacceptable challenge to a central right of our own she has settled for the kind of mealy-mouthed posturing that she engaged in this week in Manila.

The “Black Cocks”

Some good humour with the NZ Badminton team and supporters who have eighty t-shirts and caps promoting the unofficial team nickname.

The t-shirts say “Black Cocks: Expect Big Things”, the male caps are: “Not A Soft Option” and the female caps: “Nobody Likes To Come Second”. Heh.

I am sure some official somewhere is very upset.

Ironically the team plays Jamacia tomorrow!

Labour may escape prosecution

This will be an outrage if they get away with it, but Labour is claiming if they are not charged by the end of tomorrow (over their $400,000+ of over-spending) they are home free because a prosecution has to occur within six months of the offence and it has been six months since the election.

Lawyers, according to NZPA, say it is not clear when you count the six months from. There are three main possibilities:

1) From when the pledge cards were ordered (July)

2) From the date of the election (17 Sep)

3) From when election returns were submitted (January)

If the Police and Crown Law come out saying oh yes they broke the law in our opinion, but it is too late to prosecute – then heads should roll for their slowness.

Unless the Police are sure that time will not expire tomorrow, they should lay charges immediately to ensure a prosecution can go ahead.

Brokeback Mountain 2

Today in Parliament

Peter Brown on Ahmed Zaoui. Brown manages the near impossible – getting me more favourable to allowing Zaoui to remain!

Wait now Keith Locke is speaking which swings me back to the Deport Zaoui case. Locke compares sending Zaoui back to Algeria to sending a Jew back to Nazi Germany. Nice moral equivalence.

Peter Brown now complaing that Zaoui appeared in a music video. Good God.

How about we keep Zaoui and deport both Brown and Locke??? 🙂

UPDATE: Rick Barker on the marina issue has just said:

Just because somebody says something doesn’t mean it is true

General laughter especially as he is next to David Benson-Pope. So true. Anyway it means that the Government is saying Bob Harvey is lying about being told Chris Carter’s decision in advance.

Good God Clayton Cosgrove has less hair on top of his head than I do. Those shots from above are very cruel to male MPs!

Nice question from Tony Ryall on why 10 DHBs have sent up to five staff each to a recruitment expo in London. Insane they they have not pooled resources. Minister basically agrees it is bad.