Why Republicans are better in bed

VUWSA General Meeting

VUWSA looks to have had an interesting general meeting with most of the resolutions but forward crashing to a massive defeat at today’s general meeting.

A trivial resolution on disclosure statements appearing in Salient was the only one carried – by 90 to 4.

A resolution to remove the two year term limit for VUWSA President went down 6 to 70.

One relating to how rep groups such as the Maori Students Assn was withdrawn.

A resolution to have the general executive roles split into individual jobs elected separately failed 10 to 53

And finally the 5th resolution failed to even gain a seconder. It sought several things including STV for elections.

All info stolen from Gareth Robinson who does a good job in keeping people informed.

Islam related issues

The Anglican Church has grovelled and recalled its Welash magazine which had a cartoon in it which depicted Muhammad sitting on a heavenly cloud with Buddha and Christian and Jewish deities. In an apparent reference to the cartoon controversy, he is told: “Don’t complain … we’ve all been caricatured here.”

The Swedish Foreign Minister has resigned after she lied about not knowing about the Government closing down a website which carried the infamous cartoons. It turns out the official who did it consulted with him.

Meanwhile in Iraq the nice “moderate” Grand Ayatollah Ali Al-Sistani has a website and it even has an FAQ. Now take in this one:

Q: What is the judgement on sodomy and lesbianism?

A: “Forbidden. Those involved in the act should be punished. In fact, sodomites should be killed in the worst manner possible.”

So the Anglican church is concerned that it may have offended by publishing a harmless cartoon, yet not an iota of criticism that one of the most senior figures of Islam calls for homosexuals to be “killed in the worst manner possible”.

Equality for Women

Where was the damage?

Peter Cresswell has asked “What David Parker is alleged to have done looks pretty bloody trivial, doesn’t it? Where was the damage, and to whom?”

This is a good question and one I shall answer. In fact this issue has been entirely missing in the media.

There are various sorts of companies. Some are sole owned. Some are family owned and some have multiple owners outside the family. One of the requirements of the Companies Act is for accounts to be audited unless *every* single shareholder agrees not to. Audits are a very important protection for minority shareholders to ensure their interests are looked after. The “harm” is the failure to have the accounts audited as required by law. This is not as minor an issue as some make out – this denied legal rights to minority shareholders and the rights of shareholders form the basis of company law.

If you are sole owner of a company, then I suspect indeed you don’t often sit down by yourself and formally convene a shareholder meeting to resolve not to have an auditor. This situation is what one would call a technical breach of the law.

If your company is solely family owned, then again it is likely that you may not have had the formal shareholder meeting required by law to resolve not to have an auditor and it may have been a conversation over dinner. However you better make sure that every member of the family listed as a shareholder does agree

Now in the third scenario you have a minority shareholder who not only is not a family member but in fact is very very aggrieved with you and you management of the company. What on earth are you thinking when you go ahead and claim he has consented to no auditing of the accounts? Hell if anything is certain, it is that this disgruntled shareholder wants the accounts audited. And by falsely claiming he has agreed you have undermined his rights as a shareholder.

So let us have an end to the writing off of what David Parker did as a purely technical error which harmed no-one. He broke the law by not having the accounts audited and he broke the law by claiming permission of a shareholder he did not have. And it is entirely possible he did it on purpose because common sense would tell you that he knew the aggrieved shareholder would not have agreed.

UPDATE: I should point out I am not accusing David Parker of having done a heinous crime. What I am trying to dispel is that he did nothing at all really wrong and he is some sort of hero for resigning. He did the correct thing in resigning but that doesn’t mean what he did wasn’t trivial. It wasn’t.

More caucus splits

Goodness a new story this morning from the NZ Herald. The Labour Caucus is starting to leak like a sieve with details two weeks running of unhappy MPs. Don’t just leak to the Herald – remember you can e-mail me also 🙂

The MPs are unhappy that Parker went and DBP did not. As I said this morning it is entirely because they kept defending the indefensible with DPB that they had to sack Parker. It is a stark lesson to Labour that if they had done the right thing and sacked DBP for lying to Parliament (which he did at least twice and maybe three times) then they might have been in a position to expend political capital on Parker.

This isn’t a comment on the merits of whether or not Parker should remain a Minister (I believe resigning was appropriate) but a comment on the political reality of how Labour had no choice but to have him resign due to the DPB saga.

Labour MPs not charged

There has been considerable comment about how Labour MPs on three occasion have been found by the Police to have prima facie broken the law but not charged. In fact there are four.

The three quoted are:

PM for Paintergate
DBP for assault
Labour for breach of electoral act

People overlook that Pete Hodgson was found to have assaulted a protester and was also not charged. So in fact that is four.

UPDATE: Fran O’Sullivan has an excellent column in the NZ Herald on the whole situation of charges not being laid. She also makes the point that Labour have reneged on Shane Jones stepping down as Chair of the Maori Fisheries Commission ($70K on top of being an MP) and he is going to retain the chairmanship for 18 months of his time as an MP. This is the sort of situation which can lead to MPs getting in trouble and if they don’t force Jones to step down earlier than to quote O’Sullivan “this Government’s growing reputation for political sleaze will worsen”.

Dover attacks Marina decision

The Independent has a story about Labour Minister Dover Samuels attacking in caucus the decision by Chris Carter to reject the Environment Court decision to allow the Whangamata marina.

It is not unusual for a Minister to be criticised in Caucus. However it is very unusual for the attack to be from a fellow Minister. And it is almost unheard of for that Minister to then talk to the media about what he said in Caucus (which is strictly confidential).

This story may just be starting.

UPDATE: In the House Dover is trying to claim he was speaking in his role as a district councillor, not as an MP. Yeah right.

Win a trip to Palmerston North

No this isn’t a joke. If you are able to write why you would like to visit Palmerston North in less than 20 words, then you may win a free trip to Palmerston North.

God if winning a weekend in Palmerston North is the first prize, then the second prize must be winning a week there and third prize winning a month! At that point I would suggest your friends apply for a write of habeas corpus to demand you be returned.

And oh look at this list of their top five things you can do as a tourist:

* Jetboating along the Manawatu River.
* Strolling through world-class rose gardens.
* Driving a circuit of the Manfeild racetrack.
* Listening to top academics at Massey University.
* Not yet decided

Oh my God. They can’t even come up with a No 5 and their No 4 is listening to an academic talk!!! Oh yes this will bring the masses in.

Nine months and no apology

The two Iraqi immigrants whom Winston Peters wrongly accussed of being senior members of Saddam’s former Baath Party, and also for one a former chief person in the Saddam police force, are still waiting for an apology from Peters after nine months.

I thought about compiling a list of all the false accusations Peters has made under parliamentary privilege. But I only have a 40GB hard drive so might not be able to complete the task.

David Parker round-up

As one would expect many stories today. The NZ Herald reports that the Companies Office inquiry could be over in a few days. There’s also a profile of him which reflects how he has been held in high regard and seen as competent. They also talk to his former business partner, Russell Hyslop, about why he went public.

In the Dom Post Tracy Watkins and Vernon Small write that Parker’s resignation came after being told the PM had lost confidence in him. The Dom Post editorial refers to the “shallow gene pool” of the Clark Ministry (a wonderful phrase) and notes “Unlike the teachers, university lecturers and one-time unionists who populate Cabinet, Mr Parker himself noted that he was ‘probably the only MP who has taken a company from start-up to the main board of the New Zealand Stock Exchange’.”

Finally back to the NZ Herald their editorial laments Parker’s departure and says that the Prime Minister made the wrong decisions in both the Benson-Pope and Parker decisions.

The two certainly are linked. A Government only has a limited amount of time and energy it can put into fighting off calls for a resignation. By expending so much energy on keeping Benson-Pope in place, it meant that any future Ministerial misbehaviour would and could not be allowed to stretch on. The sadness for David Parker is that the PM mistook one battle for the war. In hindsight it was a massive error to not have Benson-Pope resign for what was very serious deceiving of Parliament as it meant the next Minister in trouble would have to be chopped. I doubt a single member of the press gallery thinks Parker would be gone as a Minister of the Benson-Pope saga had never occurred.

So the irony is that the damaged discredited and unpopular Minister carries on in his job while the popular and competent Minister is gone.

UPDATE: John Armstrong has much the same conclusion.

Games Chair swipes at Clark

The chairman of the 2006 Melbourne Commonwealth Games has taken a swipe at Helen Clark for not making they very short journey to Melbourne to support some of the NZ athletes.

He has concluded she was “either too busy or doesn’t like sport or both of those things”. Well she does prefer reading a book to being forced to endure a rugby match so an easy call.

Australian Labor want to ban the Internet

Well not quite but their daft plan to force ISPs to block violent and pornographic material on the Internet is ludicrous and may impose huge costs on Internet Providers.

Their reasoning is “It was ‘too hard’ for many parents to install internet blockers on their computers”. What idiocy.

And Kim Beazley is totally getting it wrong when he says similar systems operated in Sweden and Britain. The systems he refers to are:

(a) voluntary
(b) only block illegal child pornography
(c) do not block perfectly legal R rated material
(d) despite best efforts only block a small amount of illegal material anyway

Thank God almost all parties in NZ have MPs who understand the Internet reasonably well and there is no likelihood of such a stupid policy here from a major party.

Is it any wonder John Howard is in his 10th year as PM if this is what his opposition come up with.

Yay Alan B’Stard is back

Now this is great news. The wonderful anti-hero conservative MP of the 80s is coming back, and this time he is a “New Labour” MP.

But it will not be on television but instead a stage play: The New Statesman – Episode 2006: The Blair B’Stard Project.

Definitely a must see for those who are in London, or an excuse to go visit.

Photo of Rodney wins UK parliamentary photography competition

Prima Facie

The Prime Minister has become a law lecturer and informs us that “A prima facie case is not evidence of anything that will stand up in court.”

Grant from NZ Pundit, who is a lawyer, skewers the Prime legal expert by giving the definition from Butterworths Law Dictionary.

Prima facie case A litigating party is said to have a prima facie case when the evidence in his or her favour is sufficiently strong for his or her opponent to be called on to answer it. A prima facie case, then, is one which is established by sufficient evidence, and can be overthrown only by rebutting evidence adduced on the other side.

The NZ Herald also has some definitions.

New Minister of Energy

Fun at my expense

NBR on Friday had the usual fun at my expense:

Who are they, the whiz-kid high flyers whose dotcom innovations are set to become the object of a frenzied bidding war as the country’s media giants look to supplement their operations with new platforms? In the wake of this month’s bombshell sale of one online auction site, In Tray spotlights the top contenders for the corporate chequebook.

David P Farrar, 19, who started the hugely successful kiwiblog.co.nz two years ago from his Wellington garden shed, and today draws in as many as 820,000 unique visitors each hour according to independent auditors McFarrar & Sons, could now command as much as $1.4 billion in an all-out bidding war between Australasian media leaders. In addition to his regularly updated views on life in the political heartland, analysts point to the “tech-savvy” teenager’s runaway popularity with the younger generation who have all but given up reading conventional newspapers. Says David: “Everything I experience becomes fodder for Kiwiblog – like the other day when I asked why lattes are pronounced lat-TAYS. That got me 542 responses, including a lot of funny ones from my close friends from Parliament.” Could this be the magic bullet newspaper giant APN is looking for?

Heh. Also Generation XY has created an animated dancing DPF. It’s truly awful so don’t let kids near it.

David Parker

Firstly kudos to Hon David Parker for resigning as Attorney-General without delay and sparing us an awful Benson-Pope type saga where he attacks the accusers, denies he did it, then claims he can not remember and finally says it wasn’t that serious.

How-ever despite that laudable act, there are real questions remaining about whether he can remain a Minister at all. After all losing a portfolio is not exactly a major thing. The question is whether his admission (made far worse every time he gives more details on TV about it) that he falsified company documents means he can remain a Minister at all.

I think Clark will look very shabby if she tries the line that it is okay for Ministers to falsify company documents so long as they are not the Attorney-General. If Parker gives up his other portfolios he can be rehabilitated in due course.

His bigger concern may be keeping his seat in Parliament. If he is charged and convicted on the false returns then he stands to lose his seat as you are automatically expelled from Parliament if convicted of a crime with a maximum sentence of more than two years – even if the actual sentence is only a fine.

So if he is charged, then he may be expelled from Parliament. if he is not charged despite his admission, then it will just cement in the impression of a Government whose MPs are above the law.

UPDATE: Just announced that David Parker has resigned from all his portfolios. The PM in just 24 hours has gone from a position of there is no issue, to he must go as Attorney-General to he must resign all together as a Minister.

David Parker probably didn’t help his position with his interviews on this issue – especially last night on Campbell Live.

Commiserations to the staff on his office who are suddenly out of a job. Until a decision is made on whether a new Minister will be appointed and who gets what portfolios will be fairly miserable for them.

Paedophile gets $25,000 for loss if privacy

Police decide to warn the parents of local schools and kindies that a convicted paedophile had moved in, and they end up having to pay him $25,000.

He has a string of offending going back to 1982 so fair to be concerned that he may reoffend.

How nice we are that our laws protect paedohpiles rights for privacy but not parents rights to know a paedophile has moved next door to their school.

Sideswipe

Okay well my party invitations are going to dry up after my less than sober blog about The Penthouse party ended up exciting the NZ Herald. I was fairly incredulous when phoned by them that this was deemed newsworthy and suggested it was more a Sideswipe item if they were going to run it at all. So I can’t complain they have done exactly that and run it in Sideswipe! 🙂

Reflections in hindsight:

1) Yes singing Uptown Girl is in fact the more embarrassing revelation
2) As Rodney said to me on Sunday “David, do not blog when pissed” – is good advice
3) Yes grown-ups bragging about booze is puerile but to be fair I have never claimed to be totally grown-up!

Anyway commiserations to The Penthouse crew for me getting them sideswiped. And thanks again for the great night!

Jordan taking the moral high ground

Oh dear Jordan is upset and trying to take the moral high ground – always a shaky place to be. Let’s look at what he said yesterday.

First of all he calls on Tony Blair to resign as UK Prime Minister and Labour Leader due to UK Labour getting around funding laws by having secret loans made to the party.

Then without any realisation at the irony he attacks me for my outrage over NZ Labour getting off the hook for their flouting of the NZ election funding laws. In fact Jordan declares that everyone upset with Labour getting off the hook are myopic, irrelevant, petty, and hysterical. Plus for good measure we’re all men so obviously sexist or something.

The irony this is Jordan who rails against *National* wanting no funding limits and wanting to buy elections and he doesn’t even see the hypocrisy involved with his automatic defence of Labour on every issue. Hell how many times have I said National should have been charged over the GST yet Jordan still clings to the NZ Labour is never wrong line. And just imagine how outraged Jordan would be if it was National which had over-spent by $400,000.

Then finally Jordan gets outraged at Don Brash for criticising the Police over never ever charging a Government MP, but prosecuting National MPs for far less.

Okay so answer me this. Which party leader has done the following:

* Attacked and threatened the Police over their investigation of her for forgery
* Leaked false information to the media to force out the Police Commissioner
* Basically called The Police racist over the Steven Wallace shooting

But here Jordan is the heroic defender of the Police against all criticism. Well all criticism except from Helen.

The list gets bigger

Remember Helen promising new standards of behaviour when elected. Well certainly are new standards! To recap:

David Parker – resigned for false official returns
Lianne Dalziel – resigned for lying
Dover Samuels – stood down over personal issues
Marian Hobbs – stood down for claiming out of Wgtn accommodation
Ruth Dyson – resigned for drink driving
David Benson-Pope – stood down for bullying and lying allegations
Helen Clark – should have stood down for painting forgery
John Tamihere – resigned/sacked for various misdeeds

Have I missed any?

UPDATE: How could I forget Taito Philip Field!!

UPDATE2: Harry Duynhoven stood down as he was no longer an MP until they retrospectively re-elcted him by special law

PM on Parker allegations

I find it very interesting that the PM is resisting calls for any investigation into whether the Attorney-General has broken the law, on the basis of the story coming from Investigate Magazine, rather than any reliance on the actual facts of the case.

This is crude political behaviour where you attack the source of the allegations rather than the substance of them. The PM does this a lot such as over the leaky homes fiasco where she basically accused the NZ Herald of whipping up hysteria on the issue rather than admit there was a problem.

Now I will agree that some of Investigate’s stories in the past have been silly such as the one on the PM’s sexuality (which I felt was highly inappropriate) and one on associates of Clinton dying in mysterious circumstances.

But it would be unfair to not recognise that in recent times they have produced some very well substantiated stories. The Benson-Pope allegations were all backed up by pupils coming forward. The Tamihere interview was a stunner, and also their work on Peter Doone got material out there which had been ignored by others.

Allegations of misdeeds by Ministers should not be dismissed out of hand based on their source They should be judged on the veracity and facts of the case. The media should demand that Parker front up with his version of how a shareholder of one of his companies is disputing that consent was given as claimed in an official filing.

Of course as a few wags have joked, we could just all fast forward four months to the Police report concluding there was a prima facie infringement but they have decided not to prosecute 🙂

UPDATE: Parker has stood down according to a commenter. This is the correct thing to do. That was a very quick turn about from there being no issue.

UPDATE2: My goodness. According to NewstalkZB he has not just stood down but he has resigned all together. Sounds like he is keeping his other portfolios for now, which will be an issue for the House tomorrow.

Domain Name Disputes

With a little controversy over the Tasman with the closing of a fake John Howard website, it is timely to highlight that as at the 1st of June 2006 there will be a change on how disputes over .nz domain names are managed.

Previously the only recourse for disputes has been the High Court. From 1 June there will be the ability to have a dispute mediated and then if necessary adjudicated by an “expert”. The policy does not apply to all disputes. The one line summary is that it is for when one party had registered a domain in bad faith and with no rights to the name, and the other party can demonstrate some rights to the name. If both parties have a legitimate right to a domain then it doesn’t try to judge who has the “better” right.

As a final step towards the policy going live at 1 June, a panel of experts has just been appointed. There are four QCs, of which three are former Judges, on the panel.

I’ve been on the working party which has developed the policy for the last five years or so. Somewhat surreal that it has all finally been agreed upon, and will be operative in three months.

This won’t affect the vast majority of .nz registrants. If however you own xyz.com and have been trying to sell it to xyz ltd for $500,000 then you may have a problem!