Labour’s Candidates

Insolent Prick has done some good research and found out that apart from all the direct taxpayer money Labour is using for its campaign (how the hell can Margaret Wilson rule a re-election pledge card is legitimate expenditure I do not know) no less than 22 of their candidates are on the public or union payrolls.

Waiting for the apologies

The anti Greens and anti-Government leaflets have been identified as the work of the Exclusive Brethren.

Now unless one is a is paranoid enough to think there is a secret conspiracy between National and the Exclusive Brethren, then the pamphlets clearly have nothing to do with National, even though of course National, along with United Future, NZ First and ACT may benefit from them.

But this did not stop Clark, Cullen, Williams and Fitzsimons smearing National as the author, with comments bordering on defamatory. Let’s review them:

Cullen: “It seems pretty obvious a National Party front organisation is being used.”

Williams: “It’s clearly coming out of the National Party”

Clark: “The material in the leaflets was “absolutely consistent” with what the National Party was saying, with the same sort of graphics and typeface used”

Fitzsimons: “Given National’s history of smearing the Greens, a reticence on Dr Brash’s behalf would probably have to be interpreted as an admission of guilt.” and “The leaflets were reminiscent of past attacks on the Greens by the National Party.”

If Messrs Cullen and Williams and Mesdames Fitzsimons and Clark don’t want to apologise in person for their smearing of National, then I am happy for them to merely post their apologies on this thread.

I also look forward to the fearless media hounding the four individuals named above, until they have got them to apologise.

UPDATE: This is outraegous. Not only is Fitzsimons not apologising, she is all over the radio saying she is going to complain to the Electoral Office on the basis they are part of National’s campaign and should be included in their budget.

I am amazed the media give such claims airtime, without pointing out that the unions advocate on a massive scale in a way which helps Labour and also organisations like Greenpeace do advocacy which benefits the Greens.

This is desperate stuff.

Chief Justice Roberts

People stop it!

The big smear

Have just listened to the weekly politics chat with Linda Clark. On it they discussed the rumour that Labour is planning a big smear attack this weekend, as a make or break effort. The speculation was that something will be fed to the Sunday Star-Times (yes they who compared Don Brash to Pauline Hanson).

As an aside what was hilarious, was the comment by Linda Clark that she thought Helen Clark had already tried that last weekend in the SST with the desperate front page article alleging certain things were said at a debate two weeks earlier. When National Radio is laughing at the desperation of the attempt, you know you have problems.

Anyway I found the discussion of the rumour interesting because I had earlier in the week heard similar from sources, so it is obviously getting around town.

Let’s make this simple

I never fail to be amazed at the brazen attitude of Dr Cullen in that he can suddenly find billions of dollars for last minute spending bribes, yet then turns around and says tax cuts are not affordable.

Most online users are pretty intelligent people and don’t need to have spelt out for them what absolute crap Dr Cullen is spinning, but in case people need to convince some other people, here are some key facts:

* Treasury is projecting a $29 billion surplus over the next four years. Yes that is over $10,000 per family. Incidentally Treasury often under-project the surplus by around $2b a year so this could well turn out to be over $35b.

* National will spend around $9b extra over three years, based on an average $1.5b a year increase. This means in 2009 expenditure will be $4.5b a year higher than in 2006. This is not a cut unless you invent a new dictionary definition. I repeat National will increase spending by an average $1.b a year.

* The difference between National and Labour on spending is that Labour is claiming that spending has to increase at $1.9b a year and National is saying an extra $1.5b a year is sufficient. That $400m a year difference is less than 1% of government expenditure. Prior to Labour taking office expenditure the contingency for new expenditure was $600m a year so National is still allowing a contingency 2.5 times as large as the last National Government.

* The surplus under National will be around 2.5% of GDP. This is larger than what Labour averaged in its first four years, and is larger than most OECD countries. It will more than cover contributions to the superannuation fund. There is *no* requirement to borrow a single cent to cover expenditure.

* A small proportion of capital expenditure will be financed by debt. This is normal practice of almost every government and business in the world. The only exception I can think of is the near monopoly Microsoft which has such huge cash reserves. The extra borrowing to fund capital expenditure is only $3.5 billion over three years.

* Financing capital expenditure purely from the operating surplus is grossly inequitable. For example it means today’s 70 year old pensioner is paying the entire cost of a new motorway which will serve people for 40 years. No-one ever suggested that all capital expenditure should be funded from the operating surplus until around a year ago when Dr Cullen needed a reason to refuse tax cuts.

* Labour’s student loan bribe may well lead to a huge increase in borrowing, which would mean that in fact Labour will have to borrow billions for this additional capital expenditure.

Labour wonders why its scare-mongering is not working (see John Armstrong column). The answer is simple. Because they are bullshitting. They are trying to twist the facts in a way which lacks credibility, especially in view of their own spending pledges. You can not start drinking like an alcoholic in a brewery and then start issuing warnings against excessive alcohol consumption.

Housing Policy

Great to see National is going to deliver housing assistance to all low income New Zealanders, and gradually remove the discrimination against low income people who have a private sector landlord.

Labour’s policies have led to a huge 12,000 waiting list for state houses, as they deliver more assistance to you if the Government is your landlord.

Also pleasing to see incentives for state house tenants to buy their state homes. Labour calls this privatisation – helping state house tenants purchase the home they have lived in for years. And the money from any sales will go towards buying and more houses so the level stays fairly constant.

What will Winston do?

Useful article in the NZ Herald on the five options that Winston has, in announcing his plans tomorrow.

I tend to agree with the NZ Herald that the most likely position will be to begin talks for a confidence and supply agreement with the party with the largest votes.

Another e-mail

Another stolen email has surfaced, this time on One News last night. Incidentially this pretty much confirms they are in the possession of someone very hostile to National (not an insider) and media savvy as they are leaking them over a period of weeks to different media outlets.

What is very amusing is that beloved (and desperate) Helen has categorised Bryan Sinclair’s advice to “open up the cheque book as excruciating as this will feel” as “very nasty right-wing politics designed to turn kiwis against each other and buy an election”.

You see Bryan is obviously referring to extra spending on various initiatives (you know the sort Helen has been announcing), not tax cuts, because there is no way reducing taxes would cause excruciating pain to Dr Brash – quite the opposite.

So to follow Helen’s logic if pledging to spend more money on initiatives is “very nasty right-wing politics”, that must make Helen a very, very, very nasty right-wing politician.

$100 million for elective surgery

National has already announced it will target health funding, rather than provide universal subsidies for millionaires to visit their GPs etc.

Now it has announced it will use those savings to spend $100 million on elective surgery.

I certainly think it is a far higher priority that the hospital waiting lists are reduced, than millionaires get subsidised GP visits.

This of course is just another example of what Helen Clark now labels “very nasty right wing politics”.

I wonder if there is anything at all that Miss Clark does not label as “very nasty right wing politics”?

Your chance to see the Campaign movie

Anyone who follows politics should see the film “Campaign” at least once. It was produced by Tony Sutorius and is a documentary on the 1996 battle for Wellington Central.

It captures the comic chaos of six local candidates fighting for the seat in a race that went right down to the wire, with unexpected twists and skullduggery right til the bitter end.

Now you can get to see it on the 13th of September as pre-election stress relief. And no this is not a National fund-raiser but is raising funds for the Kids

Gobbling up its partners

There have been a lot of comments in recent times about how National is gobbling all its potential partners up (sounds like a black widow eh) and that somehow they should stop this.

Now I understand why some people are saying this, and I am known myself as being “ACT friendly” in that I certainly regard a National/ACT Government as an excellent outcome both in policy terms but also that I have high regards for ACT MPs like Rodney, Stephen and Heather who I think would contribute well as Ministers (as would most National MPs).

However I do not accept the way for this to be achieved is for National to not campaign for the party vote. There is a separate debate about tactical voting with the electorate vote, but I’ll post on that separately. This is about the party vote.

I want to have a look at the logic of this complaint about National by making a number of propositions. They are:

1) Every party campaigns for the party vote, and can never suggest a party vote goes elsewhere

No party can ever afford to suggest that voters should not cast their party vote for them. If you do that you are dead. National says party vote National, Labour says party vote Labour, ACT says party vote ACT etc. You can never be ambiguous on this message. If you are you get 21% of the vote not 46%.

2) Being the biggest party in Parliament is vital

It is vital that National is the biggest party in Parliament. United Future, and quite possibly NZ First, have said they will offer initial support to the biggest party. There is also an immense psychological advantage of being the biggest party.

3) Leading in the polls is important

The media don’t tend to report CR vs CL scenarios as their headlines. They report National vs Labour. And it is important to lead in the polls as they can be self-fulfilling prophecies. People like to back “winners”. If Labour is at 38%, one needs National at over 40%, not at 35% and with other CR parties at 8% between them.

One reason National got savaged last time is because it was so far behind Labour it was seen as irrelevant, even though in reality the CR vs CL margin was not great.

4) Parties do not control their voters

Parties can advise supporters, but they can not direct them. Parties can not unilaterally decide how people vote. And those voters can get quite feisty and independent.

5) Subtle messages are difficult

It is certainly true that it can be a bad idea to have large wasted vote from parties just under the threshold. I totally accept that if for example the Greens are at 4.9% then it is sensible for some Labour voters to vote Green to ensure that vote is not wasted.

However one can not simply say “We want every 20th Labour voter to vote Green”. Who votes Green and who stays with Labour? One could end up with Greens on 10% and Labour on 30%.

6) Wasted vote is not always bad

In 1996 the Christian Coalition had a wasted 4.3% of the vote. Many in National thought this was a good thing as they were seen as undesirable (something undeniable in hindsight with Capill). This election NZ First could get 4.6% (last poll result) wasted vote. However as he has not pledged that to either side, then why would one save him? And could you trust him even if he said he was supporting you?

7) The amount of wasted vote is important

Even if you have a party known to support you, and seen as dependable, the amount of wasted vote is important, especially looking at whether it will affect who gets to form a Government. If Labour has a 10% lead over National and the Greens are at 2% Helen Clark would say “so long suckers”. If Labour is 1% behind National and the Greens are at 4% then Helen might pose for a photo opportunity with Jeanette. She’ll never say vote Greens but she’ll send signals.

8) Many of these factors are not apparent until the final couple of days

Goes without saying.

So for my 2c worth National is doing exactly the right thing. A total fixation on the party vote, and getting a solid lead over Labour. This is vital.

As I said the electorate vote can be a bit more complicated and I’ll post on that later. I will not comment on a particular seat with that, but in generalities.

A sensible view on gay adoption

As I have commented before many try to portray Brash as a throwback to the 1900s or 1800s. But again it isn’t the case. Take gay adoption.

Pitt the Younger blogs how Don Brash was interviewed on Christian radio about this and his response was:

“He said two things. One was that he accepted the two parent family was best for kids, and that kids ought to be there if possible. Then he said that if that wasn’t possible, and gay adoption was a better option than what the kid had now, he supported it.”

As Pitt observes, he stuck by his principles regardless of the audience, just as he also told Grey Power he would not change the prostitution law or civil union law.

Brash is not a radical campaigner for social justice. However he is someone who can look at an issue logically and come down on the side of fair play as we see with his advocacy for Peter Ellis.

Tax Cuts cause hurricanes

Well not quite, but Frog Blog is linking tax cuts to the disaster in New Orleans.

This is obviously the same logic that linked a generator failure to privatisation, despite the lights being owend by an SOE.

Anyway that could be their campaign theme for the last 12 days – “If you vote for Don Brash and there is a hurricane, you will drown”

Labour and Tax

I got sent this article about an Australian Labor MP proposing significant tax cuts. This is not unusual. Left wing Governments around the world have cut tax rates when they have a significant surplus.

If Labour lose this election, they will only have their own greed to blame for it. If they had agreed to even a modest amount of tax cuts – say $1.5 billion annually or so, then they might be unassailable. The anger at their budget was immense.

NewstalkZB at 930 am

If anyone is interested, I’m going to be on (Wellington) NewstalkZB at around 930 am to talk about heckling!!

UPDATE: Was good fun. Justin (the host) is a big fan of public meetings where MPs and candidates face the public, and so am I. We shared some cynicism over Clark taking two weeks to remember that someone allegedly said something nasty to her.

I put a plug in for people to attend the Aro Valley Community Centre meeting on Tuesday evening if they want to experience a very active meeting. It starts at 7 pm but I advise going early to get a seat.

Aro Valley is the only area in NZ where the Green Party gets 400% more support than National. Yes last election they got 36% and National 8% so this is as hostile territory as it gets. Fist fights have occured some years and the aim for centre-right candidates is just to get out literally unscathed.

Not bad for their first term!

Labour talk all the time about how Clark and Cullen have been in Parliament for 48 years, both being in their eighth terms. They attack Brash as inexperienced, untrustworthy and having a “hidden agenda”, something John Armstrong points out is “a line of attack which has been rewarded by his preferred prime minister rating taking a leap upwards”.

But it is worth considering this issue. Indeed both Don Brash and John Key are first term MPs. Now your normal first term MP is given a portfolio such as Urban Affairs or Racing and told to just turn up to select committee, never ever agree to go on TV without permission, and just read out the Research Unit speech notes in Parliament. Oh yes and most importantly ask the questions that get assigned to you for question time.

It is amazing that both Brash and Key are fronting for a party which is leading in the polls, despite being in their first terms. I think it is a measure of the extraordinary abilities each MP has that they are very competitive with these 24 year veterans. Could you imagine Clark or Cullen in their first terms even being noticed by Sir Robert Muldoon?

Anyway my thought out loud is that if Brash and Key can do this well in their first terms in Parliament, just think what they’ll be able to achieve in their second terms? 🙂

What will Labour do?

It is now 12 days before the election and the polls have you 3% to 8% behind. You have two sets of choices before you.

The first choice is whether you hope the lead will fade, confident that your party’s policies and record will win through, or do you go for a “circuit-breaker”?

If you decide to go for a circuit-breaker, then you have a choice of a positive or a negative circuit breaker.

A positive circuit breaker is something like the student loans no interest pledge. However the pledge card has been printed, and a significant new policy at this stage would have a credibility issue and potentially undermine their fiscal costings.

So what does that leave? An inevitable conclusion that Labour is going to go very negative and very very dirty. On the brink of being kicked out of office, they will hold nothing back. Truth will not play a part in decision making.

And when will this happen? Well they need to influence the polls for the final week, so it will occur this week or at the latest do another exclusive with their friends on the Sunday papers to try and set the agenda for the last week.

This is confirmed by Labour in the The Press, saying “”It’s onslaught from now on”

More on debate heckles

For some reason I thought the TVNZ leaders debate was a week ago but in fact it was actually two weeks ago. This makes it even more extraordinary that Helen Clark suddenly starts mentioning alleged things shouted at her. I mean if they really had been shouted out, don’t you think she would have said something before now?

In the NZ Herald Clark claims her comments were not a ploy for sympathy. I’m sorry, but what bullshit. Why else do you bring it up two weeks after the debate? You do it because your internal polling tells you you are in the crap.

Talking of heckles, the Brooklyn meeting last night was great fun also with 13 candidates from Wellington Central and Rongotai – lots of funny interjections. My best was when Marian was talking about what Labour has done to reduce workplace stress and I interjected “not for Air NZ pilots”.

One News Colmar Brunton Poll

It is 13 days before the election and tonight’s One News Colmar Brunton Poll has confirmed the other recent polls that National now has a significant lead. It is 8% in this poll.

Worth nothing that it looks like some of this poll was still before last Monday’s treaty policy announcement and also most of it before Helen got an Air NZ pilot suspended.

The poll results are shown below, with the change from two weeks ago in brackets:

National 46% (+6)
Labour 38% (-5)
Maori 2% (+1)
ACT 1% (-1)
NZ First 5% (nc)
United Future 1% (nc)
Green 6% (-1)

Assuming that Turia, Dunne and Anderton hold their seats, the seat allocation in a Parliament based on this poll would be (change from current Prlt in brackets)

National 56 (+29)
Labour 46 (-5)
Maori 2 (+1)
ACT 0 (-9)
NZ First 6 (-7)
United Future 2 (-6)
Green 7 (-2)
Progressive 1 (-1)

A Labour led Government is all but impossible here. You would need a Labour-NZ First-Green-Progressive-Maori coalition.

If NZ First do not make it and they were just under 5% in the raw results, then the seat allocation would be”

Nat 59
United 2
Labour 49
Prog 1
Green 7
Maori 2

Again the only way Labour could form a Government is a Labour-Green-Maori-Progressive-United coalition.

Now there are still 13 days to go, and a lot can happen during this time. But when National were 8% behind Labour, Frog Blog said there must be full-scale panic within National. Taking Frog Blog’s own sayings, I presume there must be full-scale panic amongst Labour and the Greens.

And Jordan who has an uncanny ability to claim every poll ever published is good news for Labour has said this about the last week of polls:

“What a week in hell for National’s first week. And what a delicious one for Labour”

“So an interesting result. Once again, nothing to complain about”

“The fact that the combined Labour/Green vote only fell 1%, and the combined National/NZ First vote only rose 2, in the wake of the “king hit”, is wonderful news.”

“A very very good poll, all things considered.”

We look forward to seeing the spin on this poll.

Chief Justice Rehnquist has died

After 33 years on the US Supreme Court, including 19 years as Chief Justice, William Rehnquist has died rom cancer.

Will be fascinating to see who is nominated to replace him. I doubt it will be Scalia (pity) as then one would need a third confirmation hearing for his replacment also.

Respecting Religious Beliefs

I was somewhat amused to see in the paper a photo of the PM and Di Yates in Muslim headscarves entering a Mosque. They were entering through the door reserved for women.

Now I’m all for respecting religious beliefs, and if the PM thinks it is worth the extra votes, who am I to say no.

But what got me thinking was the contrast with respecting Christian beliefs. This is the same PM who refused to even allow grace to be said for the Head of the Church of England, and Head of State of NZ.

So a secular society means one can’t even say grace for the head of a Christian church but you can respect the customs of a local mosque.

Espiner on the Air NZ fiasco

Campaigning in Rongotai

Spent a few hours on Thursday campaigning in Rongotai with the votemobile bus. Was great fun. I ended up being the navigator as I grew up in the Rongotai electorate and went to school there. We started at Kilbrinie Pak & Save, moved onto the Lyall Bay Warehouse and then out to Miramar shops before going around the bays and descending on the good people of Island Bay.

bus2.JPG

A photo of the bus parked at Miramar.

bus1.JPG

Dunedin MP Katherine Rich, List Candidate Tim Groser and Rongotai Candidate Nicola Young in Miramar.

ODT Poll