Well done George

Saturday’s Herald had a long interview with George Hawkins, and in it they touch on the his stroke in the 1990s and in relation to performing in the House, George says “I don’t think people should make allowances for disabilities”. Well said.

Helen Clark’s defence of Hawkins on the basis he once had a stroke and that is why he is targeted must have been the most embarassing and patronising thing he had to endure. He doesn’t think it should give him a free pass, but she does. She really goes to the bottom of the barrel when under pressure.

I can relate a wee bit to the situation Hawkins is in. I have not had a stroke but as an infant I had something ‘wrong’ and was unable to speak at all. It took over ten years of speech therapy from two until fifteen to overcome my ‘disability’ and even today I still can have problems with certain words, or in certain situations.

But let me tell you if I was ever a Minister under fire for not performing in the House, and my leader leapt to my defence on the basis of having a speech defect, I would be so furious against them I would have to be physically restrained from doing them injury. It would just be the most awful embarrassing thing to endure.

Normal transmission will resume shortly

I am flying out to Kyoto, Japan in a few hours to attend the 2005 Asia-Pacific Regional Internet Conference on Operational Technologies (APRICOT).

I get back to NZ Sunday week. I expect that there will be fairly good Internet connectivity at the conference, so blogging should continue, but not until tomorrow.

APRICOT is in fact not just one meeting but almost a dozen meetings all held under the one banner. I am attending meetings of APCAUCE (anti-spam), APTLD (domain names), APNIC (IP addresses) as well as general workshop and conference sessions on issues ranging from DNSSEC to IPv6 to E-Govt to Computer Emergency Response Teams (CERTs).

If I wasn’t at Kyoto I would have been plotting world domination at the Conservative Political Action Conference in Washington hoping to get a date with Jenna Bush šŸ™‚

And talking of politics, an interesting cost/benefit analysis of the Kyoto Protocol is here. The cost to date has been $1.32 billion and potential temperature saving by 2050 is 0.000013717

St Molesworth on NCEA

Stolen from St Molesworth:Top 10 signs the qualifications system is failing :-

1. The NZQA introduces unit standards for understanding how the NCEA works.

2. The economics exam is set by leading business investor Jim Anderton.

3. The French exam requires you to translate the Treaty of Waitangi into German.

4. Even Asian kids can’t understand the maths exam.

5. The English exam has the following question: “Molesworth and Featherston write a ‘satirical’ diary of Don Brash which is neither original nor funny. Discuss the implications for the future of political satire in New Zealand.”

6. Trevor Mallard lets Associate Minister David Benson-Pope take all the “media opportunities” over the NCEA crisis.

7. Trevor Mallard’s latest media release is “New Pukerua Bay cycleway a bonus for Push Play”.

8. As an employer, you find it easier to calculate your employees’ holiday pay, GST, PAYE and student loan payments than it is to navigate your way through job applicants’ NCEA report cards.

9. For the first time in your life you’re glad you sat School Cert.

10. People call for George Hawkins to be the new Minister of Education.

Olivia’s inappropriate feelings for me

Over on Dog Biting Men, I was startled to read that my mystery stalker has in fact been Olivia Kember.

Olivia confesses to having inappropriate feelings toward me and stalking me dressed as a schoolgirl.

I’m flattered Olivia, and if I lived in Auckland would definitely be happy to be inappropriate, but alas that would breach my new year’s resolutions so it just is not meant to be.

However the Whig is single, has lots of time now he has stopped blogging, and is known to like the school girl fetish. Perhaps you could set up a double date with Ben?

Lots of love

David P Farrar

(And no the P is not Priapus, but a secret so closely guarded that the Otago University Orientation Magazine in 1987 ran a full page competition for readers to guess what it stood for.)

Bloggers dropping like flies

Ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha ha

A good candidate

National’s Otaki Candidate, Nathan Guy, hosted a function with Katherine Rich in Paraparaumu last night. Normally these sort of things get a dozen or so people, so I was surprised to see 40 – 50 people turn up to the wonderful Wave Cafe (Roti Chicken Rolls – yum) at Paraparaumu Beach.

Otaki 001.jpg

Nathan has only been the candidate since late last year but has made a real impact, as the montage of media stories shows. He led the charge on saving the local rescue helicopter service.

Further photos from the function below.
Continue reading »

When did the Minister know?

All the evidence to date on the NCEA fiasco has been that the Ministers tried to keep the public from realising how bad the problems are.

Trevor Mallard claims that he did not know of variability in subject pass rates until the 25th of January, despite his office being told on the 17th of January.

So we are expected to believe that neither the staff in his office, or David Benson Pope’s office, thought to mention to the Ministers that certain subjects had a pass rate of below 1%?

Yeah Right!

Bishop Brian

Having Destiny Chirch promote Brian Tamaki to a Bishop, reminds me of Sitiveni Rabuka promoting himself to a General after his Fijian coup.

The man owns the Destiny franchise and controls the entire church, so portraying it as the Church promoting him, instead of a self-promotion is just ridiculous.

How long until he promotes himself to Arch-Bishop? I give it a year.

It just gets worse

There is a growing tsunami of claims about how Te Wananga o Aotearoa has rorted the system. Today we have the CEO’s fiance selling a course to the institution for millions of dollars and students with previous qualifications, staff and tutors had all been enrolled in this literacy and numeracy course.

I just can not believe that as funding skyrocketed in five years from $8 million to $239 million, the Minister did not take any action until last year to investigate the situation, or tighten the policy. Instead they are letting the Opposition do their work for them.

And to really put the boot in, Stuff reports that despite the course having not yet been assessed, the Government had already paid out $4.5 million for it.

Do not forge

For the second time this month someone has been forging identities. First we had an Xtra user prtending to be Katherine Rich and Russell Brown and now we have an Ihug user pretending to be Conor Roberts.

I report all impersonations to the ISP of the IP address my logs show as having made the post.

I do not wish to bring in a registration system as certain backbench Labour MPs might get discouraged from posting as anonymous šŸ™‚

If you wish to “have a go” at someone, do not do it by impersonating them. Doing a parody is fine such as when zteve started parodying ztev. It was obviously a different person. But in this case many people thought that was Conor posting and that is just slimey.

And the count is ….

The official counting of the corks happened last night.

First we laid them all out on the floor.

corks2.jpg

And the count was 392, just one less than the previous year!

Pundito got it spot on from the online guesses at 392. Well done. Just one place off amongst the non-cyber entries was Chris on 393 who actually supplied and drank most of the wine.

corks3.jpg

And here we have Stats Girl with too much time on her hands, carefully placing the corks back one by one in a neat stack. We found one could fit an extra 25 or so corks in that way but it would make it too easy to guess in future.

Teacher’s ethics code

I always thought hell would freeze over before I agreed with Ivan Snook on any education issue. However I can only commend an excellent article by him in the NZ Herald.

The bottom line is that a draft code of ethics for teachers was excellent having specific “wills” and “will nots” such as teachers will protect students from harassment and teachers will not bonk their students.

The NZEI and PPTA could not handle there being an explicit list of things teachers may not do as this might actually lead to you know a teacher being held accountable against it. So they got the following clauses dropped:

Teachers will not expose students to embarrassment or disparagement.

* Teachers will not punish a student unnecessarily, harshly or unfairly.
* Teachers will not use information gained to disparage any family.
* Teachers will not invade a student’s privacy without good cause
* Teachers will not deceive parents regarding the abilities or progress of their children.
* Teachers will not accentuate or promote in their teaching the interests of any particular group in society.

Parents should be very worried about the extent to which the teacher unions have a strangehood on the education system, and are so obviously concerned only with protecting their union members, and not at all about protecting students or parents.

Treasure Island

Blog outage yesterday

Police resources

All the Hawkins defenders (a small but brave tribe) say George is not to blame on how the Police Commissioner assigns staff, as this is an operational decision.

Not so.

In 2002 the Police got 375 extra staff. George ring-fenced them so that 285 (76%) were for traffic duties only, 33 for counter-terrorism and 27 for youth aid.

The Commissioner actually complained “The task-specific nature of these allocations has been eroding the flexibility historically available to me and to district commanders to distribute resources across emerging problem areas in a timely or responsive manner.”

This of course did not stop George telling porkies, such as “that it is up to the commissioner how extra resources for police are used”.

Liar, liar, pants on fire.

Even Professors fail NCEA

A former chemistry professor has labelled a level three NCEA chemistry exam a “disaster for students” after failing to complete the test himself.

Professor Packer said he supported achievement-based assessment but could not believe the Government could introduce a national exam system “devoid of marks, any form of scaling to deal with inter-subject comparability, mistakes in papers, or papers proving too long or too difficult”.

Thank you Trevor.

350 cars

I was staggered to listen to the House and hear that Te Wananga has over 350 staff cars (link to Rodney). They even get groomed at our cost every fortnight.

Prebble asked Mallard whether this would not be more staff cars than the rest of the education sector combined. He agreed that it would definitely be more than the rest of the tertiary sector.

Let’s be blunt – this is a rort. Just like $15 million CD and the radio sing-a-longs were rorts. Their only aim is to enrich a few people at taxpayer expense.

The total cost of these rorts is staggering. It is in the hundreds of millions from what I can tell. The amounts involved are almost up to the magnitude of the UN Oil for Food scandal and at least they had some oil to show for it.

There is a job here for a hard working investigative journalist to go through the last five years of tertiary and community funding and do a comprehensive article on how much has gone on scams.

Labour let this happen on their watch. It has been growing in size for the last five years and they have done next to nothing until English and others exposed this. For this alone they deserve to lose office.

NSW Road Safety

Gay penguins hold out

The buck stops where?

Assorted flunkes have defended Hawkins over the 111 stuff ups on the grounds that as Minister he can not be held accountable for every mistake staff make.

Thst is correct. But he can be held accountable for if they have enough resources to cope with 111 calls. And the Dominion Post writes about how Auckland Police said they needed 100 more staff to cope with emergencies and George only gave them 32.

Te Wananga o Aotearoa

In just five years, Labour has increased funding for Te Wananga o Aotearoa from $8 million to $239 million. One should recall this when we are told no money for tax cuts.

I reported yesterday that some of this money was spent on sending NZ students to Queensland to do a security guard course. I was wrong – in fact they were offering to pay fees, flights, accommodation, apparel and for passports for Queensland students to come to NZ!!

The wananga offered free laptop computers for one course and expensive tracksuits and backpacks to other students. No wonder they have such a surge in enrolments when you can get a free laptop by enrolling etc.

This is just another version of the Christchurch Polytechnic $15 million CD scam. It proves that Government policy in this area has been fatally flawed. Over the last five years it is quite possible the amount of money gone into courses of dubious value is over one billion dollars.

But hey it is our money, not theirs, so why worry.

NCEA blame game

The NCEA blame game has started and the Government seems to have selected the NZQA Chief Executive. This of course may not be unreasonable.

A document has emerged showing the scholarship problems were raised at the Secondary Principals and Leaders Forum last August. If these made their way to the Minister, and were ignored, it will not be pretty for the Minister.

Audrey Young also has a good article on the issue, pointing out:

When they [Mallard and Benson-Pope] were alerted to a great variation in pass rates between subjects, their response was to invent two new sets of awards – like giving a patient candy to cure concussion.

It was a knee-jerk action and was evidence that they had no confidence in the outcome of the exam.

Helen wants more tax rises

Dear Helen is not content with overtaxing New Zealanders by $7 billion a year with her increases in income tax and around (at last count) 21 other taxes and levies.

A Swedish newspaper quotes the Swedish PM on his discussions with Helen. The page is in Swedish but according to Ruth on NZ Political Comments it roughly translates to “Clark’s explained that the reason NZ tax rates are not as high as Sweden’s is historical, the social democrats have not been in power long enough yet”.

Now I do not speak Swedish, so it is possible the newspaper actually said “Clark explained that she wants to sack Hawkins but Goff won’t let me” and Ruth is having fun scaring us. However an online translator tool tends to agree with her version.

So what is this Swedish model that Helen would like to implement if re-elected. It is:

Income tax rates from 46% to 60%
A house tax of 1.2%
Death Tax
VAT (GST) of up to 25%
Payroll Tax of 33%

So perhaps a brave journalist could ask Helen at her press conference which tax she will be increasing or introducing if re-elected, as she told her mate the Swedish PM.

Arab Civilisation

I wish the other embassies would put on guest speakers of the calibre the US Embassy does. I, for one, certainly appreciate the US taxpayer spending money to fly various speakers over here to do public lectures. It makes up for the lack of back-pay for my work on their behalf šŸ™‚

Yesterday David Pryce-Jones spoke at the US Embassy on the Arab world and Islam, and the so called clash of civilisations.

I did not take notes so can not summarise his speech, but there were several parts of interest I recall.

He refuted the notion that most Muslims simply hate the USA, pointing out that if the USA abolished green cards and opened its borders there would be more Muslims living there than in the rest of the world. And he is right. They hate certain aspects of the US, but would still choose to live there if they could.

Quite a bit of time was spent how Islam does teach infidels are inferior to believers and women inferior to men, and that much resentment of the west does draw from the way women in western societies are portrayed as being a threat to their values. There was discussion on how much one respects local customs (ie women not speaking on maraes) and when does it become a human right issue.

He mentioned the case of the Saudi TV presenter who had her face fractured in 13 places by her husband. Her crime was to answer the telephone without permission. She went on TV to show the beating and was reviled by many in her country for doing this.

I queried whether Islam could modernise with no central authority or hierarchy to provide leadership. Dr P-J said that in fact in most Arab countries the religion is controlled by the state and used by it as a political tool, so one can get change through Governments. He pointed out that the supreme council in Saudi Arabia has put out over 1,000 statements and not one of them has ever been critical of the Saud royal family.

Also discussion on the Palestinian issue, and how in fact many Arabs revile the Palestinians, and only provide lip service to their issue. He suggested, as many did, that the US is not hated because of Israel but in fact it is more Israel being hated because of the US.

On the issue of hatred, he said one of the great catalysts for hatred of the US by many Muslims is what people like Michael Moore and Sean Penn say. If Michael Moore writes books and movies pronouncing that the US is run by a bunch of criminals, who rigged elections, kill off dissidents ect, then why on earth would Muslims not believe this, and think it is true. Robert Fisk tells them every week the US is evil, so why would they think otherwise.

Many will not agree with Dr Pryce-Jones but he is no arm-chair academic. He has spent much time over many decades in the Middle East and speaks from first hand experiences.

He actually praises the Arab family structure being superior in some ways than the West. They have no rest homes as families look after their elderly. He also speaks of Arab civilisation over the centruries as one of the world’s greatest.

However his conclusion was that Arab culture and civilisation is not modernising to face the world today, and if it does not do so, then it may be the only great civilisation in history to simply become irrelevant.