Mediacow

Both the NBR and the Listener have in recent weeks printed confirmation that the much hunted MediaCow was David Young, so I am probably safe to mention it here for the few people who do not read either publication.

David’s ‘confession’ is in his latest business column for the Listener.

When MediaCow first emerged, there were furious hunts for his or her identity. I recall being asked by several MPs and journalists if it was me. My funniest memory was having my employer ask me not once but twice. After I denyed it was me initially, I got asked again a couple of days later along the lines of “I know I have already asked you if you were MediaCow and you denied it, but now it is really important that I know if it is you so can you own up, if it is, so we can work out to to handle this”.

Oh and as I have linked through to the Listener, can I also suggest people read the editorial as a seriously despressed, probably near suicidal Gordon Campbell, concedes the US election to Bush stating “In a year when almost anyone could have beaten Bush, the Democrats have succeeded in selecting one of the most unappealing candidates in living memory

Catch the Pulse

The Lower North Island region of the Young Nationals put out a regular newsletter called Pulse.

After I linked to a previous story about one of their number who went swimming in a tuxedo, they told me that this got them four times as many visits as normal, and what would it cost to have me link more often.

After careful consideration I set a price of one female virgin Young National to be sacrificed to me every month. The wise Regional Chairman accepted my terms.

Hence with great (anticipated) pleasure I encourage people to read Issue 14 of Pulse. The top ten reasons it will be a shame if Labour loses is a good read, and you can win $120 if you pick what states Bush and Kerry will win.

I am not sure if I am on a click through rate or a flat rate, but regardless I encourage people to go have a read šŸ™‚

Odds for who will be GG

Still need convincing?

Okay you don’y want to listen to the pyjama clad partisan wingnuts, and still think the memos are real. Well can I introduce Joseph Newcombe.

Joesph does not like George Bush but he does not like forgery either. And he knows a bit about digital typography, describing himself as “one of the pioneers of electronic typesetting”. He has been involved in many aspects of computer typography, has personally created computer fonts, helped create programs that created computer fonts, was a certified Adobe PostScript developer and has written about Microsoft Windows font technology in a book he co-authored, and taught courses in it.

One can agree I think with his assertion he is a qualified expert in computer typography.

You can read at the link his full analysis. A couple of highlights:

The probability that any technology in existence in 1972 would be capable of producing a document that is nearly pixel-compatible with Microsoft

Mallard must be worried

Mallard will be very worried that Alison Annan has got her old job back, at least for now. After demonising her and pushing her out of her job, it would be a major blow yp him if she remains reinstated.

I understand from well informed sources that Annan has or is about to apply for an injunction of the Augusta Wallace report on the grounds of natural justice – namely that she was never even interviewed for it.

If she suceeds, it will be even more of a red face for Mallard.

A sensible proposal

I quite like the proposal by Judith Collins regarding parental notification for under age abortions, even though the NZMA disagrees. It seems to strike a good balance between the two extremes of parents having no rights at all, and parents being able to actually veto or refuse consent for an abortion (as they can do for most other medical procedures).

They two key aspects of the proposal are:

1) Parents only have a right to notification, not a right to veto or refuse consent.

2) If an under 16 year old has genuine concerns about parental notification (as I am sure will often occur in deeply religious families), then they can have this waived by a Family Court Judge.

The judicial involvement sounds very legalistic and off putting in the story (talking about appeals) but on Breakfast TV Judith Collins described it as basically a facility where a doctor can make an appointment that day with a duty Judge, the patient goes along to meet the Judge, it is held in chambers with no lawyers involved, and if the Judge is convinced he or she signs a notification form on behalf of the parents.

Yes there is of course some risk that it may encourage illegal abortions, but one has to weigh up that risk against the profound risks to the family of having a kid go through the trauma of an abortion without the parents knowing what is wrong and unable to help. I suspect many girls in that situation would actually appreciate compulsory notification, as they want to tell their parents, but don’t want to make the decision themselves.

Coments from all are welcome, as long as they are not “men are not allowed to have a view on this issue”.

$300K for part-time work

Courts Minister Rick Barker has almost tripled the pay for the chairman of the Human Rights Review Tribunal (the one which recently gave a prisoner $1200 compensation for hurt feelings), ignoring the advice of his officials which said the post should be paid $600 a day.

Instead Mr Barker is giving away our taxes at the rate of $1,600 a day. Now I am not against paying a good rate for a role, but surely even Rick can see that having the part-time Chair of a quasi-judicial body earning more money ($299,000) than a full-time Court of Appeal Judge ($292,000) is simply daft. The Tribunal Chair is three levels lower in the judicial hierarchy, yet gets paid more.

At last!

Parliament is getting its own TV channel. I wonder if it will get more viewers than Maori TV?

More seriously this is very welcome. Opening up Parliament to anyone with a TV is good for a democracy. It will also be very useful for groups that want to follow specific issues, especially as they plan to include select committee meetings.

What an idiot

Readers will know that I am no fan of Destiny Church. However in this article in The Press, my sympathies go out to them for having to tolerate the idiot called Tony Tucker.

Tucker, by his own admission, was liquored up. He went along to outside a Destiny meeting, and again by his own admission shouted “nasty” comments at elderly women. He even chased one women to her car, and as she backed away, he blocked the car. He then complains that she didn’t stop the car. Good on her – I would have sped up considering they were banging on her bonnet and whacking her windows.

If anyone should be charged, it should be Tucker. No matter how obnoxious Brian Tamaki is, there is no excuse to have a group of young men intimidate and harrass an elderely parishioner as she leaves a meeting.

Great summary of forgery debate

Hugh Hewitt provides an excellent summary of the forgery debate. He states (as I do) that it is possible the documents are legitimate, but consider:

* Lt Col Killian didn’t type;
*Lt Col Killian’s family says he did not maintain such records;
*Guard regulations prohibited the maintenance of such records;
*General Bobby Hodges didn’t vouch for the docs as CBS said he would;
*Colonel Buck Staudt –cited in the memos as pushing Killian to “sugarcoat” a Bush evaluation– had retired more than a year before the meo was allegedly written;
*Bloggers have been overwhelmed with e-mails from active duty and retire dmilitary who scoff at the form of the memos;
*Typewriters with proportional spacing were rare in ’72/3;
*Typewriters with superscripting capabilites were rare in ’72/3;
*Typewriters with perfect centering ability were non-existent ’72/3;
*Typewriters with the “kerning” function didn’t exist in ’72/3;
*Most experts range from certain to almost certain in their conclusions that the docs are not legit;
*CBS doesn’t have the “originals” and didn’t reveal that fact until pressure mounted;
*The fake docs are easily and exactly reproduced on modern word-processing equipment, underscoring the ease with which the bad forgery could have been produced contrasted with the near impossibility of Lt Colonel Killian’s producing them in 72/3;
*Lt Col Killian lacked motive to write and maintain such records;
*Despite intense media interest in the president’s TANG career that extends back at least four years, someone sat on these docs until seven weeks before the 2004 election and after the RNC convention;
*CBS has a history of obtaining docs damaging to the Bush Adminsitration which in all likelihood came from Democratic partisans;
*CBS won’t reveal its source;

I doubt even No Right Turn can go through that list and say that even on balance of probabilities (let alone beyond reasonable doubt) the document are legitimate.

September One News Poll

Only minor changes this month. It shows

National 42% (+2)
Labour 42% (-2)
NZ First 5% (+1)
Green 4% (+0)
ACT 3% (+1)
Maori 2% (-1)
United Future 2% (-1)

Assuming Peters, Dunne, Tariana and Anderton hold their seats, the allocation of seats would be:

National 54 seats
Labour 54 seats
NZ First 6 seats
United Future 3 seats
Maori 3 seats
Progressive 1 seat

Labour/Maori/Progressive would be 58 seats. They would need United Future and/or NZ First to form a Government which would not be very stable.

Partisan Wingnuts

No Right Turn, commenting on the forgery debate, has said he would rather listen to “actual forensic document experts than obviously partisan wingnuts”.

Putting aside the irony of the fact that by his own description he is also a partisan wingnut, I wonder if he realises that to date not a single foresnic document expert has been willing to say the documents are genuine?

CBS is claiming they have not been “proven false”, but I suggest they have the burden of proof the wrong way around.

At present I would say they are not proven to be genuine or false. But it looks much much more likely they are false. To prove they are genuine CBS really needs to demonstrate that the US Air Force had a machine that could produce the memo, and/or explain where it came from.

No Right Turn also seems very upset that the blogosphere have challenged the credibility of the papers as it has distracted attention from the contents. Well pardon me but I think whether they are fake or not is the more important issue, and the massive preponderance of evidence to date (not just technical, but by family and ex colleagues) is that they are not.

The perfect minority candidate

When discussing the need for a diverse range of candidates for a party, the standard joke is one needs a young, vegetarian, disabled lesbian.

Well the Australian Democrats have actually found the perfect candidate, and have ranked at the top of their ticket for Victoria Jess Healy who was described as a “19-year-old, one-legged lesbian“. Healy points out she is bisexual not lesbian.

Having just done a Google, I’m pleased to say that Jess has her own blog. Good to see candidates blogging, so good luck Jess.

The forgery debate continues

The CBS forgery debate is fascinating. For every claim and then rebuttal, there are further claims.

I read the response from CBS and it seemed pretty strong. They claim that it is possible (probable is another issue) a typewriter could have produced the memos.

They also claimed that the alleged author’s superior, General Hodges, backed the memos.

However Instapundit puts this in a very different light, with the ABC story:

Retired Maj. General Hodges, Killian’s supervisor at the Grd, tells ABC News that he feels CBS misled him about the documents they uncovered. According to Hodges, CBS told him the documents were “handwritten” and after CBS read him excerpts he said, “well if he wrote them that’s what he felt.”

Hodges also said he did not see the documents in the 70’s and he cannot authenticate the documents or the contents. His personal belief is that the documents have been “computer generated” and are a “fraud”.

The Powerline also points out that the officer alleged to have been exerting pressure to sugarcoat Bush’s records, had retired 18 months before the memo was dated.

If it is eventually proven the documents are fake, this will in years to come almost be seen as the blogosphere’s graduation from puberty to adolescence – no longer a child to be ignored.

Damn I hate that

Sigh, I just finished a huge post on the role of the blogosphere in the US election, and I brushed a key which took my browser back a page, and I lost my entire post.

It is too painful to try and retype it all now. I may try again later. What a waste of 90 minutes!

UPDATE: NZ Pundit (hopefully back for good now) has been covering the issue with multiple posts. Have a look at him to get a good update. I wasn’t focusing just on the fake memos but also comparing the way the Kerry campaign and the Bush campaigns have dealt with these issues. It was not at all pretty for the Democrats. Sigh I really don’t want to rewrite it.

Vote for the ugliest kid

September the 11th

Well I am 37 today. Yes I have a very easy to remember birth date.

Despite being a silly age (after 30 one should only celebrate every five years I reckon), I have used it as an excuse for celebrations.

Last night I had drinks at the Backbencher with what I call my political mates. It was also the ten year anniversary of an event leading to a particular Backbencher display, so the location was apt.

Tonight I am catching up with some of what I call my “normal” friends. For some reason my political friends object to my clasifications of friends as normal and political šŸ™‚

Sunday will be a family lunch. So not too bad to get three days worth of activity out of a silly birthday.

Not many (other) famous people were born on September 11. Thew new Syrian dictator, Bashar al-Assad, was born a year before me, and singer Harry Connick, Jr. on the same day.

A few anniversaries on this day, apart from the obvious one. It is the day Australia invaded New Britain, the day US troops crossed into Germany in 1944, the day of the Pinochet coup in Chile, and the day the Starr Report was sent to the US Congress.

What great timing

For some months Winston Peters has been asking when TVNZ will be returning to appear before the select committee, to face further questioning over credit card expenditure.

When he got suspended from Parliament for a week on Wednesday, I actually joked to a Government staffer that someone should tell (committee chair) Mark Peck to schedule TVNZ to appear asap.

To my great amusement, I see they appeared yesterday. I am sure this was a coincidence!

In terms of the story itself, I find lines such as “Mr Ralston racked up $21,751 on his credit card in the financial year to June. The spending was in addition to his $299,000 salary.” fairly unhelpful as it suggests that expenditure charged to a credit card is of personal benefit, and I know from experience this is often not the case.

Some credit card expenditure such as entertainment does clearly have some personal benefit, but paying for taxis and airfares is just getting you to a place so you can do your job.

The lunatic fringe

Most will have seen the story about a group of Tuhoe activists claiming that they not only own the sea for 44 miles out, but they also claimed “absolute sovereignty over all air space to the heavens above“.

Now the last part is interesting, because as you know the Earth rotates on both its axis, and around the sun. This means that at various times many far flung planets will be seen to occupy Tuhoe air space. They will be most surprised to get a bill from Tuhoe, asking them to pay rent.

More seriously, this is one of the reasons why it was so invaluable that Don Brash made his Orewa speech. You see the debate previously had been going in one direction only – towards the extremes. Every year more and more radical propositions were promoted about sovereignty, and while they may not be accepted, they kept shifting the debate to the extreme.

Thanks to Brash we are now debating as a country, the serious, not lunatic, issues. We can now laugh at these claims, because we know the real debate is about more core issues like should one have treaty clauses in legislation, should one retain special seats for Maori, should one fund on race or need, and how does one tell them apart etc?

To be fair to Tuhoe, the details of the submission were not an official position of Tuhoe, with the trust board chair saying that claiming the air space was going a little bit too far. Only a little bit?

What a surprise

Wow – what a surprise – the Reserve Bank put interest rates up today.

Of course Dr Cullen beat Dr Bollard by accidentially announcing it yesterday.

Cullen is rather fortunate that the chaneg in interest rates was so widely expected. If he had let slip something which was unexpected, it would at the minimum require him to tender his resignation. These things are taken very seriously, and Roger Douglas tendered hsi resignation in the 1980s over a budget leak.

I hate doing this

I hate having to say the words that should never pass my lips, but Winston may be right on the Edwrads case.

Unlike most Winston scandals which exist in his imagination only, it is obvious Winston has one or more sources from within the Police who are obviously appalled at the lack of prosecution of Edwards for the Shaw burglary. And I know from first hand experience that Police National HQ do interfere in sensitive cases, and over-ride what the local officer in charge wishes to do.

Peters also has some substance when he talks about why Edwards got off with manslaughter. The panic attack defence was one I thought was bullshit anyway, and if it is true that Edwards had known for McNee for over three years, this should have been used by the Police at trial.

Peters is off base in accusing Hawkins of a cover up (Hawkins couldn’t cover up a wet spot let alone a conspiracy), but he has posed some legitimate questions, which to my mind still need answering. The media should be pressuring the Police for answers, not just reporting on Peters’ antics in Parliament.

Majority verdicts

I have been a long time supporter of majority verdicts. However I am reconsidering somewhat after reading this account in the NZ Herald of a jury trial.

Of course Mr Ansley’s point of view, may not be objective. And I also note that the defendent was found guilty in the retrial, so perhaps not a problem after all.

Ackbar at NZ Pundit has some concerns also. Of course as a lawyer Ackbar is only concerned about what will be best for his clients, not about justice šŸ™‚

I’m confused

If sole parents on the DPB do not name the other parent (the father) they stand to have the level of their benefit docked by $22 a week.

The Government has announced that there will be an increase in the level of reduction – to $28 a week, after three months of refusing to name the father.

Now unless I am missing something, this is a sensible thing to do. It is important that fathers do not get away with no responsibility for their children, and that the taxpayer is left with paying all the costs of raising a child, just because the mother wishes to protect the father from having to pay.

So what I am confused about if why Muriel Newman is attacking the increase. She claims that “there would be an increase in the number of men who knew they could father a child and walk away with no consequences”, when it appears to be quite the opposite.

Perhaps she is complaining about the risk of violence being an exemption to naming without penalty, but I presume this is the situation at the moment.

Anyone know more details about this?

A fallen idol

People may have seen the NZ Herald story on Tuesday, about the song by NZ Idol runner-up Michael Murphy, being a cover, not an original.

Murphy’s manager, Paul Ellis, seems to believe in shooting the messenger and described the person Robyn who discovered the other song as “a person who commits fraud everyday by downloading songs” and further “This guy Robyn obviously went to Kazaa or LimeWire purposely to download the song”.

As it happens I have met (once) the Robyn in question, who is Robyn Gallagher of Secret Passage fame (her blog is one of the very first I started reading years ago).

Now one can not be 100% sure about anything nowadays with the famous Georginas and Miriams out there, but I am almost definite that Robyn is female, not male.

Robyn on the NZ Idol blog points out in a letter to the NZ Herald (which refuses to publish it) that she does not and did not do illegal music downloads, and the song was available free of charge from the band’s website.

So it appears that Paul Ellis owes Robyn a rather big apology. He shot from the hip, he was wrong, and the longer he leaves it the less credibility he has.

Rachel, who created the popular idolblog site, has a summary of the story posted on her personal blog.

Peters named and suspended

On the motion of the Speaker, the House named and suspended Winston Peters today. The vote was 115 – 13 in favour with only NZ First against.

I think Hunt called this one correctly. In fact if anything he should have done it earlier. Peters is notorious for making numerous points of order which wouldn’t know a standing order if it got run over by one. He just uses them to relitigate his original questions.

Now all MPs do this to some degree, but Peters is by at least a magnitude the worst offender. And Hunt has often been reluctant to crack down, because he knows Peters will attack him personally if he does. And true to form Peters threatened to move a no confidence motion in Hunt, if he was named.

Both question times so far this week have gone for almost two hours, instead of the scheduled 60 minutes due to mainly Peters. And considering Helen called a snap election in 2002 on the basis of an average seven minutes a day being wasted on points of order, this might have given her an opportunity to try that same trick again!

The suspension only lasts 24 hours if it is the first naming for this session, which I think it is. The second time is for seven days and the third time on is for 28 days. During the suspension the MP not only can not enter the House, but can not vote, serve on a committee or lodge questions.

UPDATE: Having done further research, I have ascertained that Peters is suspended for the entire week, as it is his second naming this session.