Winnie is sulking

Online E-Democracy Forum

InternetNZ is hosting tonight an online election forum and webcast. It is focused on IT and Internet issues with the participants being:

* Hon David Cunliffe – Labour Party
* Hon Maurice Williamson – National Party
* Mikaere Curtis – Green Party

Paul Brislen (IDG / Computerworld) and Kate McLaughlin (NBR) will be asking the questions, but people will be able to propose questions through them to be asked:

It starts tonight at 7 pm sharp and the details are here. You can view the webcast, propose questions and discuss it in an IRC channel and also vote on a poll for how people went.

I’ll be in the chat channel so hopefully see some of you there. Not sure of the channel server and name yet so check back closer to the time.

Oh yeah the politicians will be in Auckland while we are having a physical audience in Wellington where we’ll be using access grid technology (think of video conferencing with multiple screens) to link up. We have a couple of spare seats in the Wellington audience, so let me know if you would like to attend and I can probably arrange a seat for you. We will be on Victoria Street.

UPDATE: IRC will be on irc.citylink.co.nz and use channels #forum and/or #debate.

The NZ First campaign

While the campaign is not over, unless something massive changes the NZ First campaign will go down in textbooks as what not to do.

A couple of months ago NZ First was surging, and I was considering scenarios where they may have up to 15%. But they have blown it. Some mistakes:

* The stunt with the cellphones which made it look like NZ First would hold country to ransom again
* Naming the wrong people as Saddam henchmen and refusing to apologise
* Refusing to give any hint of who they might support
* The awful campaign billboards which just confuse people at to what they mean
* Refusing to take part in minor party debates on the basis they are not a minor party

The Breakfast TV panel (I actually started this before they were on, so great minds think alike) also just rubbished their campaign.

Peters is now promising that he will make his position clear. Now don’t think this actually means he will make it clear. He could do anything from merely say they will not join a coalition, to saying they will (like UF) offer support initially to the largest party. I would be very surprised if he actually names Labour or National as his preference. If he does I still pick Labour on the grounds that with National threatening him in Tauranga he is not going to then say he’ll support them.

UPDATE: Just gets worse for Winston. The National Front has endorsed NZ First.

Bigger Treaty Settlements?

If Labour make it back to Government, they will probably need to do a deal with the Maori Party. And yesterday the Maori Party has called for larger treaty settlements.

Now people may not realise how devastating such a move would be. All treaty settlements to date have a relativity clause, and it is on that basis they are full and final – if future settlements are in proportion.

If the Maori Party’s policy is adopted by Labour (and let’s face it they are desperate to spend more money so there is none for tax cuts) then this will undo every single treaty settlement to date. Yes we will be back to first base, and with no end in sight.

If settlements are not full and final, then public support for them (and the public do support fair, full and final settlements) will disappear.

This is an appalling policy from the Maori Party as it undermines all the settlements to date .This may be the worst policy of this election.

Naked Internet use threat to morality

Typos

It’s inevitable that if typos get through the checking process, they will turn up in an education policy as happened with National yesterday. Worth noting they were typos rather than actual spelling errors (such as wrong version of principal/principle).

I recall in 2003 I was in charge of producing the education policy discussion document (around a 30 page publication). I was paranoid about even a single mistake in it, and literally checked it around six times myself plus had it reviewed by half a dozen other people around the office. Interestingly each person always finds something that no-one else did.

I actually borrowed from the parliamentary library the NZ style guide for written publications (used to be published by GP Print) and got so anal I was checking whether one should use % or percent or per cent (the latter is preferred), semi-colons vs commas, whether you use ten or 10 etc. We had an external reviewer also and when I commented to her that I had checked it against the NZ style guide, I remember her asking which edition as she then commented she used to be the editor of it. That reassured me that it was going to be pretty bullet-proof and we then had a geeky conversation about obscure grammar conventions.

Number Portability

That was fun

Around 300 people packed the Ilott Theatre last night for a Meet the Candidates Meeting and it was a marvellously fun evening.

A huge segment of the audience were Labour Party activists so Marian’s applause level was so loud the only thing louder was the heckles to the other candidates – and there were some good ones.

The nine candidates, in speaking order, were:

Sue Kedgley, Greens: Typical speech – listed 30 things the Greens want to do. Solid.

Stephen Hay, Anti-Capitalist Alliance: Unintentionally hilarious as he denounced the Labour Government, capitalism and all employers etc. Quoted from the little red book

Michael Appleby, Legalise Cannabis: No matter what the question was, Michael’s answer was the same – legalise cannabis. How to solve child poverty? Legalise cannabis so poor parents can grow their own rather than have to spend food money on buying cannabis.

David Somerset, Progressives: Somerset was the star of the night for me. With no disrespect he looked liked a humourless grumpy old man, but he killed the audience with his limericks. I can’t recall the full words but something to do with Brash and cash etc.

Stephen Franks, ACT: As usual Stephen was a good performer and didn’t mind being controversial such as when he said one should not need permission from a corrupt organisation like the UN to send troops overseas. The big revelation is that not only did Stephen use to belong to Labour, he even had joined a commune and gone to China.

Fiona McKenzie, United Future: Fiona got heckled even more than Blumsky by the Labour supporters, and in fact to a degree which was highly disrespectful. At least the Blumsky heckles were generally very funny, but Fiona was just being shouted at. When you consider that United Future have actually kept Labour in power this term, it was incredibly insulting and I think reflected the contempt the average Labour activist has for United Future. Anyway Fiona did fine, and spoke more confidently than up at Vic Uni.

Mark Blumsky, National: Mark handled all the heckles with good humour. His best line was about how Labour has given us a qualifications system where chemistry professors can not pass scholarship chemistry yet students can pass scholarship geography without even turning up to a single class. Next best line was how Annette King in 1998 called waiting lists of 100,000 criminal (they are now 120,000) so George Hawkins better make his first bust and arrest her.

Marian Hobbs, Labour: With a supportive audience Marian was in good form and delivered a strong speech. She (as all the candidates) enjoyed the night a lot. After Stephen revealed he had been in a commune, Marian revealed she had also been in a commune and then had been a member of the Communist Party for many years. Her reason for leaving was that they were not practical enough!

Kane O’Connell, Alliance: A very personable enthusiastic guy who normally may have looked radical but compared to the anti-capitalist alliance seemed pretty moderate.

All candidates spoke for five minutes, then over an hour of questions (which had to be to all nine candidates) and finally two minute closings from all. Every question, bar one I think, was hostile with such gems as:

* Can you explain your policy process and what role the Business Roundtable plays in it
* Do you support sending troops to fight George W Bush’s wars
* Don Brash said blah blah on child poverty, do you agree
* Do you support stopping foreign takeover of NZ etc

Anyway was a great fun night. What politics should be about.

TV3 Poll

The TV3 poll (normally the one which has National lowest) tonight has National back in the lead.

The poll was done from 25 to 30 August so most of it doesn’t take account of National’s Treaty policy released on Monday, which could move things even further.

On this poll a Labour/Green/Maori/Progressive coalition would only have 59 seats. National/NZ First would have 59 seats and United would have two. Who thinks United would choose a Labour/Green/Maori/Progressive option?

Regardless of who you support, isn’t it a fun campaign to have the lead swapping backwards and forwards so often. This is what campaigns should be about!

August Blog Stats

It’s the last day of the month, so it’s blog stats time.

If all those who want to be included can e-mail david at farrar dot com with their number of posts for August and if applicable their number of comments, I’ll do the usual summary tomorrow.

Blocked by Net Nanny

Heh. Rodney Hide just called me from the airport to say that he tried to catch up on the day’s events by reading my blog. But alas the computer would not let him through, warning him my site was blocked by Net Nanny for inappropriate content.

If I’m blocked, I presume G-Man must be also with his list of the 100 rudest place names in Britain.

Rodney was in an good mood, on the basis of the Epsom poll done by Capitol Research (Australia). I know nothing about that company or methodology so can’t express an opinion as to reliability. It will be interesting to see public polls in seats like Epsom and Tauranga.

Colin Espiner’s Blog

I am still underwhelmed by the party leader blogs on Stuff, but have just discovered that Press Political Editor Colin Espiner also has a blog.

Colin has caught onto blogging. It isn’t just about rehashing stories or press releases. He gives a first person, on the scene, perspective of the campaign trail.

Now if Fairfax could managed a dedicated RSS feed for their blogs, then I could get automatic updates for them.

Not even the Police believe the Police stats!

Frontline police have said they don’t believe their own statistics on the level of crime in New Zealand. Remarkable!

A Senior Constable in Christchurch said he had criminals in his car admit to carrying out 100 car break-ins in a night, but only three complaints arose and hence were recorded..

A man linked to 15 burglaries in Manurewa admitted to carrying out 60 burglaries – most had not been reported.

One officer said anecdotal evidence suggested victims who had not suffered a great trauma did not report the crime because they did not think it was worth the effort. This is why a focus on the violent crime statistics is useful because they are the ones most likely to always be reported.

A frontline Auckland officer said it was discouraging to hear people say there was no point ringing police to report a crime saying “All people see is traffic enforcing and you get a lot of decent people in the public getting tickets for minor infringements.” and “There’s no need for us to be standing out in the road in the middle of the day clocking someone who’s doing five or 10 kilometres over the speed limit. Those resources would be better solving crime.”

Most New Zealanders would agree with the officer. What a pity George Hawkins does not.

The best Cathy story yet

The great ACT auction

Act are fund-raising in an innovative way – they are auctioning off various memorabilia and goodies on Trade Me.

You can’t purchase their policies, but you can get the artwork for the policies. However the real highlight has to be a drive in the Alan Gibbs designed Aqua Car or Aquada.

Now thing if every party were to auction off goodies as fund-raisers. WHat could they auction off:

* Greens: A signed copy of Keith Locke’s essay supporting the Soviet invasion of Afghanistan and also to throw in a signed copy of his essay opposing the US liberation of Afghanistan

* NZ First: A copy of the parliamentary library issue card showing Winston Peters having borrowed Mein Kampf

* Labour: A Helen Clark signed painting

* National: A John Key designed tax calculator

* United Future: A St James bible signed by every MP except Marc Alexander

* Progressive: A 18 foot by 12 foot portrait of Jim Anderton

* Maori Party: A copy of the Treaty of Waitangi with the words “living partnership” added on in small tidy writing in the same font as the original.

Even MPs are human

A sad reminder that MPs can crack under the stress, like anyone else, with John Brogden trying to kill himself last night – obviously as a result of the scandal which forced him from the state leadership. Further allegations have come out also.

A more pleasant reminder of MPs being “normal” was the Holmes interview on Prime last night with Helen Clark and Peter Davis and Don and Je Lan Brash. I thought both couples came across well and talked very naturally about their relationships.

Back on the agenda

Sometimes a Labour MP is very honest. Take Russell Fairbrother:

” Redistribution of wealth had been off the political agenda for decades. Labour put it back on …”

The only problem Russell is Labour is now taking money from people on $45,000 and giving it to people who earn $120,000 if they happen to have kids.

The Public Address Gallery

After my gender confusion with Che Tibby of Public Address, David Slack has helpfully posted photos of all their bloggers.

My ratings are:

Russell Brown 9/10
Damien Christie 7/10
Jolisa Gracewood 9/10 (if I was gay)
David Slack 8/10
Fiona Rae 6/10
Che Tibby 9/10
Graham Reid 8/10
Tze Ming Mok 6/10
Keith Ng 7/10

How not to become Premier

You’re 36, leader of the opposition, and the long serving state premier has just retired. Pundits say you may be Premier before you are 40.

However you then go to a partyhosted by the Australian Hotels Association, and do the following things in ascending order of stupidity:

* Have a quick half dozen beers
* pinched Sunday Telegraph journalist Justine Ferrari on the bottom
* propositioned Sun-Herald journalist Angela Cuming.
* and finally referred to the wife of the former Premier as a “mail-order bride”

Helena Carr, wife of the popular Bob Carr, is Malaysian born and has lived in Australia since 1965. She has been married to Carr for 30 years and runs a division of a multi-national employing 1,000 people.

So it is no surprise that he has resigned. He keeps on digging blaming Alex Hawke, the national president of the Young Liberals for his downfall. No he didn’t make you act like a pillock.

ISP Survey

Stats NZ have done their first survey of ISPs in NZ. InternetNZ helped suggest questions. Some interesting results:

* 1.24 million customers of 66 ISPs with 80% of customers being residential.
* 65% of accounts are dialup (which suggests 81% of residential customers are still on dialup)
* 90% of ISPs offer spam filtering, with 77% doing it for free and 13% charging for it
* 86% offer virus filtering
* Only 36% offer content filtering
* The largest barriers to growth were the strength of competition followed by the telecommunications regulatory environment. Cost of international bandwidth also a big issue.

Tactical Voting

Che Tibby has a message for Labour supporters in Tauranga. To use her own words “give your candidate to the blue team, and your party vote to the red team”.

Her rationale “it’s bye bye Whinny while helping the commies get back into power”

She also notes “I hear from people back home that Clarkson is a top bloke. One who might actually do something for his electorate.”

I think it is highly likely NZ First will make 5% and be in Parliament. However if Peters lost Tauranga then they would have no safety net. And that would then give a huge incentive to actually behave responsibly and not hold the country to ransom if he does hold the balance of power. This is very much in New Zealand’s interest regardless of whether it is a National or Labour led Government.

UPDATE: Che is actually male. Read her as him.

Labour’s response

It has been one of those rare days – enjoying listening to National Radio.

It is clear that Labour is scared shitless about how to respond to the latest proposals from National. Clark refused to go on radio at all, and her only comment is that it is nothing new. This is of course wrong because there is new policy. Clark just desperately doesn’t want to be on the wrong side of public sentiment like she was after Orewa.

So instead they sent Mallard on, and you could almost hear the tears at National Radio when he agreed with much of what National proposed and said they also had concerns over some of these agencies and have been reviewing them also.

Maori Party

Many on the left, including Jordan Carter, have claimed for months that the Maori Party is “a party of the conservative right, which would be much more comfortable in coalition with parties … National and ACT – than it would be dealing with the progressive elements in National and with the bulk of the Labour Party.”

Now seeing the Maori Party’s Hone Harawira has just compared Don Brash to Adolf Hitler, would people like to revise their predictions?

Defending Orewa

We are all New Zealanders

National spelt out its view of New Zealand today being that the Treaty did not create a partnership but was the launching pad for the creation of one sovereign nation with many peoples.

Specific pledges are:
* Make membership of the Waitanagi Tribunal a full-time, not part-time, job so hearings can be acclerated
* Increase capacity of the Office of Treaty Settlements
* Appointing a number of specialist direct negotiators to work with claimant groups
* Removal of references to the “Principles of the Treaty of Waitangi” from 39 statutes with priority being the RMA and the Local Government Electoral Act
* Review the five specialist Maori agencies